Mutations in topoisomerases genes are the main mechanism of fluoroquinolone resistance in many bacteria (
28). Previous studies have shown that this mechanism is involved in quinolone resistance of
P. aeruginosa in clinical practice (
2,
15,
19,
34). Herein, we screened for mutations in
gyrA,
gyrB, and
parC in 30 clinical ciprofloxacin-resistant
P. aeruginosa strains which were shown to be fully complemented by a plasmid carrying the wild-type
gyrA or
gyrB allele in a previous work (
2).
DNA sequencing of the
gyrA QRDR showed a high frequency of point mutations in codon 83 (27 of 30 strains), whereas only one strain had a point mutation in codon 87. These results are consistent with those reported in previous studies on clinical fluoroquinolone-resistant strains of
P. aeruginosa in which 13 of 22 strains (
19) and 10 of 18 strains (
32) harbored a single
gyrA mutation in codon 83 and 1 of 22 strains (
19) and 1 of 18 (
32) harbored only a single mutation in codon 87. We did not find any strain with a double mutation in codons 83 and 87 such as that described by Nakano et al. (
19). Strikingly, in our study as well as in others dealing with
P. aeruginosa (
15,
19,
32) or
Campylobacter jejuni (
27), the point mutation at position 83 always led to the substitution of an isoleucine for a threonine, despite several other possible amino acid substitutions encoded by a point mutation in an ACC codon (Pro, Ala, Ser, and Asn). This could not be attributed to a clonal relation between the strains of
P. aeruginosa studied, since these strains had different antibiotypes and serotypes (
4) and were isolated over a long period of time (3 years). In
E. coli, mutagenesis studies have shown that the mutation Ser-83 to Ala was responsible for a low level of ciprofloxacin resistance compared to the Ser-to-Leu or Ser-to-Trp mutations described in strains selected in vivo (
8,
33). Thus, we assume that the putative mutation Thr-83 to Ala in
gyrA would lead to a poor selective advantage in
P. aeruginosa in vivo, in contrast to the mutation Thr-83 to Ile. This point could be further investigated in a directed mutagenesis study.
We sequenced a 303-bp
gyrB fragment from
P. aeruginosa which included the QRDR. This fragment showed a high homology with the corresponding
gyrB fragment of
Pseudomonas putida (i.e., same genus) but also with that of other members of the family
Enterobacteriaceae such as
E. coli or
S. enterica serovar Typhimurium. Since some regions of the ParE subunit of topoisomerase IV are highly homologous to the GyrB subunit of DNA gyrase in
E. coli (
13), we compared our sequence to the ParE amino acid sequence of
E. coli. Amino acid identity was only 52% with ParE, in contrast to 92% identity with GyrB, suggesting that our DNA fragment corresponded to
gyrB and not to
parE.
We described the first mutation in the
gyrB gene of
P. aeruginosa, Ser-464 to Phe, located outside the
gyrB QRDR described in
E. coli (
30) and in
Staphylococcus aureus (
11). Similar mutations have been described in quinolone-resistant strains of
S. enterica serovar Typhimurium: TCC(Ser)-464 to TAC(Tyr) (
6,
7) and TCC(Ser)-464 to TTC(Phe) (GenBank accession no.
Y08383) (
14a). Considering the absence of mutations in codons 426 and 447 and the full complementation of these two strains by a wild-type
gyrB allele, we assume that the mutation found in codon 464 is responsible for quinolone resistance in
P. aeruginosa. The hydrophobicity and the bulkiness of the R group of phenylalanine in comparison to serine could modify the conformation of the B-subunit domain involved in quinolone interaction. Since there are now four strains belonging to two different genera (
S. enterica serovar Typhimurium and
P. aeruginosa) resistant to quinolones and harboring a mutation in codon 464 of the
gyrB gene, we propose to extend the QRDR in the B subunit of DNA gyrase to the domain of codons 426 to 464.
Analysis of the partial sequences of
gyrA and
gyrB showed a few silent base substitutions, resulting in a polymorphism of the sequences of the gyrase genes among
P. aeruginosa strains. Kureishi et al. mentioned the existence of silent nucleotide changes in
P. aeruginosa gyrA but did not provide a detailed description (
15). Wobble base changes were reported in
C. jejuni (
27) and
P. putida (
31). The polymorphism that we found in
P. aeruginosa gyrB is similar, for some codons, to that described in
P. putida (codons 406, AAG or AAA; codons 436, CGC or CGT; codons 456, GCA or GCG; codons 472, ACT or ACC). Yamamoto et al. proposed analysis of the
gyrB polymorphism as a tool for phylogenetic studies in
P. putida, since the base substitution frequency in
gyrB in this species turned out to be higher than that in 16S ribosomal DNA (
31).
DNA sequencing of the
parC QRDR showed the higher frequency of point mutations at codon 80 (nine strains), which is homologous to codon 83 in
gyrA, than in codon 84 (one strain), which is homologous to codon 87 in
gyrA. Nakano et al. recently reported mutations in codon 80 (Ser to Leu) of
P. aeruginosa parC for eight clinical strains and in codon 84 (Glu to Lys) for only two strains (
19). In the present study, we found a novel substitution of tryptophan for serine encoded by codon 80 for two strains. The mutations Ser to Leu and Ser to Trp which are frequent at position 83 in
E. coli GyrA are known to be involved in quinolone resistance (
33). Since the A subunit of gyrase and the ParC subunit of topoisomerase IV are highly homologous (
13), our results emphasize the key role of the serine at position 83 (or at position corresponding to) in both DNA gyrase and topoisomerase IV for determining quinolone resistance.
Only 10
P. aeruginosa strains had a mutation in
parC, whereas all of the strains had a mutation in
gyrA or
gyrB. Overall, the strains with a double
gyrA-parC mutation were three to four times more resistant to ciprofloxacin and sparfloxacin than the strains with a single mutation in
gyrA or in
gyrB. We thus hypothesize that in
P. aeruginosa, mutations in
parC occur at a second step in strains already harboring mutations in
gyrA or
gyrB and lead to a fourfold increase in their fluoroquinolone resistance level. All of the strains with a double
gyrA-parC mutation were fully complemented by the wild-type
gyrA gene, as already reported for
E. coli (
9). These findings support the hypothesis that in
P. aeruginosa, as in
E. coli, DNA gyrase is the primary target for quinolones (
9) and that topoisomerase IV is a secondary target.
There was a large overlap in the distribution of fluoroquinolone MICs within both strains with a double
gyrA-parC mutation and those with a single mutation in
gyrA or
gyrB (Table ). An additional mechanism(s) of resistance could be implicated in some strains, particularly in those with a single mutation and for which the ciprofloxacin MIC was above 8 μg/ml. Mutations in
parE can be one of these mechanisms, since
E. coli strains with double mutations in
gyrA and
parE are fully complemented by a plasmid carrying the wild-type
gyrA allele (
1,
22). Unfortunately, we have not yet succeeded in amplifying the
parE gene of
P. aeruginosa.
| TABLE 2Distribution of P. aeruginosa strains by susceptibility to ciprofloxacin and imipenem and number of mutations in topoisomerase genes |
Twenty of the 30
P. aeruginosa strains studied were coresistant to imipenem and fluoroquinolones (ciprofloxacin and sparfloxacin). We have previously demonstrated that in those strains, imipenem resistance was related to the lack of OprD (
2), and we demonstrated in the present work that quinolone resistance was related to mutations in DNA topoisomerase genes. For strains having a single mutation in
gyrA or
gyrB, not associated with a mutation in
parC, the level of resistance to ciprofloxacin, but not that to sparfloxacin, was slightly but not significantly higher in Imi
r than in Imi
s strains. Multidrug efflux systems were described in clinical fluoroquinolone-resistant isolates (
5,
12,
14), and some of them, such as MexEF-OprN corresponding to the phenotype NfxC, lead to coresistance to quinolones and imipenem (
5,
17). The hypothesis that some of the Imi
r strains used in this study overexpress this efflux system is unlikely, since
gyrA-nfxC double mutants are known to be partially complemented with a plasmid carrying a wild-type
gyrA gene (
5) in contrast to our strains which were all fully complemented as previously shown. For the strains with a double
gyrA-parC mutation, the fluoroquinolone MICs were not higher in Imi
r than in Imi
s strains. Thus, despite the limited number of strains studied, we assume that the imipenem resistance mechanism has no effect at all on ciprofloxacin resistance when two mutations in topoisomerase genes are present. Taken together, the results of the present work support the hypothesis that the main mechanisms of quinolone resistance in clinical strains of
P. aeruginosa are mutations in DNA gyrase or topoisomerase IV genes and that the mechanisms conferring quinolone resistance and those conferring imipenem resistance are independent of each other.