|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
Clinical cases of neonatal listeriosis are associated with brain disease and fetal loss due to complications in early or late pregnancy, which suggests that microglial function is altered. This is believed to be the first study to link microglial apoptosis with neonatal listeriosis and listeriosis-associated brain disease, and to propose a new nanovaccine formulation that reverses all effects of listeriosis and confers Listeria monocytogenes (LM)-specific immunity. We examined clinical cases of neonatal listeriosis in 2013–2015 and defined two useful prognostic immune biomarkers to design listeriosis vaccines: high anti-GAPDH1-22 titres and tumor necrosis factor (TNF)/interleukin (IL)-6 ratios. Therefore, we developed a nanovaccine with gold glyco-nanoparticles conjugated to LM peptide 1-22 of GAPDH (Lmo2459), GNP-GAPDH1-22 nanovaccinesformulated with a pro-inflammatory Toll-like receptor 2/4-targeted adjuvant. Neonates born to non-vaccinated pregnant mice with listeriosis, showed brain and vascular diseases and significant microglial dysfunction by induction of TNF-α-mediated apoptosis. This programmed TNF-mediated suicide explains LM dissemination in brains and livers and blocks production of early pro-inflammatory cytokines such as IL-1β and interferon-α/β. In contrast, neonates born to GNP-GAPDH1–22-vaccinated mothers before LM infection, did not develop listeriosis or brain diseases and had functional microglia. In nanovaccinated mothers, immune responses shifted towards Th1/IL-12 pro-inflammatory cytokine profiles and high production of anti-GAPDH1–22 antibodies, suggesting good induction of LM-specific memory.
Cerebral listeriosis caused by the human pathogen Listeria monocytogenes (LM) constitutes a severe disease in infants and elderly people, with a mortality rate of 30% . LM targets the central nervous system (CNS) and foetus, and the most common listeriosis-related diseases are meningitis, meningoencephalitis, brain abscesses, foetal malformations and septicaemia [2–4]. Since 2008, the cases of listeriosis have increased in the European Union, but especially in Spain, where listeriosis cases reported between 2008 and 2014 are 1.15 cases per 100,000 inhabitants [5–7]. However, the landscape can be worse as listeriosis has only been listed as a notifiable disease in Spain since March 2015 , and therefore, annual incidences may be higher. Despite the amassing epidemiological data on listeriosis, immunological biomarkers were not investigated till recently . Moreover, a vaccine that prevents neonatal listeriosis and avoid or at least diminish brain diseases and foetal injury is not yet available but necessary. Our group has been preparing vaccines for systemic listeriosis in experimental models with good success. Dendritic cells (DCs) loaded with two LM immunodominant peptides, peptide 91-99 of listeriolysin O virulence factor, LLO91-99 and peptide 1-22 of glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (Lmo2459), GAPDH1-22 [10–12] or phagosomes obtained from macrophages and containing live wild type LM (LMWT) , prevented systemic listeriosis in mice. However, none of these vaccine vectors appeared suitable for neonatal listeriosis, because phagosomes containing live LMWT, supposed a risk for pregnant mothers, as they may develop listeriosis. Moreover, DCs poorly crossed the placenta and blood-brain barriers as a putative strategy to avoid injuring the foetus or causing neuroinflammation [14, 15].
Microglia (MG) are resident macrophages that survey the brain parenchyma to repair any damage, control pathogen invasion and prevent neuron injury. Therefore, they are responsible for controlling LM infection and potential target cells to combat listeriosis in the brain of humans, mice or ruminants [16–19].
Similar to macrophages, MG are divided into M1 and M2 subsets depending on their pro- or anti-inflammatory cytokine pattern and similar to macrophages [20–24]. In this regard, pro-inflammatory M1 macrophages or MG are microbicidal phagocytes and antigen-presenting cells (APC) that produce soluble and neurotoxic inflammatory mediators such as tumour-necrosis factor (TNF)-α, IL-1β, IL-12, NO or type I interferon (IFN-α/β) . However, continuous activation of M1 subset of MG might disrupt the delicate balance in the CNS and have a negative effect on neuronal survival [20, 24]. Upon microbial infection, M1 macrophages also induce programmed cell death, such as necrotic-programmed cell death, TNF-mediated apoptosis or pyroptosis [25–28]. In fact, apoptosis may be understood as a host mechanism to control infection  or a virulence process to spread the pathogen . M2 subset of MG parallel the alternative activation pattern of macrophages and showed high levels of IL-6 and IL-10; activation of pro-inflammatory negative regulators such as suppressor of cytokine signalling (Socs3); low phagocytic functions; promotion of immunoregulation and neuroprotection; and presented low production of reactive oxygen species [22–24].
The aims of this study were as follows. (1) To examine clinical cases of listeriosis to search for immune biomarkers to prepare safe nanovaccines. (2) To establish a neonatal cerebral listeriosis model in mice to investigate brain disease, biomarkers detected in human listeriosis cases, microglia function and apoptosis and bacterial virulence factors. (3) To test gold glyconanoparticle (GNP) vaccine formulations with adjuvants, that help to prevent listeriosis and brain-associated morbidities, including microglial dysfunction.
To develop a clinical vaccine that prevented neonatal listeriosis, we explored cases of neonatal listeriosis in 2013-2015 to obtain information about common diseases and immune markers of poor prognosis in the two health institutions participating in this study, Hospital Universitario Donostia (HUD) and Hospital Universitario Marqués de Valdecilla (HUMV). From a total of 13 listeriosis cases in HUD, three cases corresponded to neonatal listeriosis due to complications during pregnancy, a case in the first trimester causing an abortion (HUD003 patient in Figure Figure1A)1A) and two cases at late gestational period, one neonate born with severe meningitis and treated for a month with ampicillin (HUD008 patient is the neonate of HUD007 patient) and a patient with caesarean of twins and first twin born healthy, while the second twin died (HUD004 patients). Therefore, neonatal listeriosis cases presented with a 50% mortality rate. While neonates with listeriosis presented severe brain diseases, mothers only presented small diarrhea or fever. In the same period, we also had an adult patient with listeriosis who died from lung adenocarcinoma and bacteraemia (HUD005), and served as a positive control for poor listeriosis prognosis (Figure (Figure1A).1A). High virulence of clinical isolates from listeriosis patients appeared to correlate with prognosis, as clinical isolates from mothers with neonatal listeriosis (HUD003, HUD004, HUD007 and HUD008) had 2-10 times higher virulence (LD50) than standard LM strains such as 10403S in C57BL/6 congenic mice; a model that is highly resistant to LM infection. A clinical isolate from the deceased patient (HUD005) had 200-fold higher LD50. Mice infected with standard 10403S LM strain served as controls of virulence (data in Figure legend). Other reported biomarkers of poor prognosis in sera of adult listeriosis patients  are: (1) low levels of antibodies against immunogenic LM virulence factors such as GAPDH (GAPDH1-22 epitope) or listeriolysin O (LLO189-201 epitope). Negative controls correspond to healthy donors where antibody titres were considered basal levels. (2) The imbalance in the cell populations among peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) or whole blood cells (Figure (Figure1B),1B), such as high percentage of granulocytes (CD66b+) and low percentage of monocytes (CD14+) or CD8+ or CD4+ T lymphocytes (patient HUD005, Figure Figure1B).1B). Patients with neonatal listeriosis presented with high titres of anti-GAPDH1-22 and undetectable anti-LLO189-201 antibodies, normal percentages of monocytes and CD8+ T cells, and higher numbers of mature and immature granulocytes as a result of bacterial infection (Figure (Figure1B).1B). A predominant Th2 cytokine profile with low Th1-Th17/IL-6 ratios, is also a biomarker of poor prognosis in adult listeriosis because it favours bacterial growth [1, 3, 4, 9]. We observed that neonatal listeriosis patients also presented low TNF-α/IL-6 ratios, indicating predominant Th2 immune responses (Figure (Figure1C).1C). Controls of cytokine measurements correspond to healthy donors (controls in Figure Figure1C).1C). Patients with neonatal listeriosis presented some biomarkers of poor prognosis, such as hypervirulent LM strains and low ratios of TNF-α/IL-6, as well as some biomarkers of better prognosis, such as high titres of anti-GAPDH1-22 antibodies and normal percentages of monocytes and CD8+ T cells. This indicates that efforts should be concentrated on shifting from Th2 to Th1 cytokine profiles to decrease the risk of listeriosis in pregnant women.
We developed a mouse model of neonatal listeriosis to evaluate brain disease and biomarkers detected in humans, exploring also putative bacterial virulence factors. Adult listeriosis has a 30% mortality rate, and in neonatal listeriosis, meningitis, encephalitis and cerebritis are the main brain diseases, which have higher mortality rates [9, 30–36]. We used five pregnant C57BL/6 female mice at 16 days of embryonic gestation (E16) (n = 5), as a model of neonatal listeriosis and challenged them intravenously (i.v) or not (not infected; NI) with 3000 CFU/mL of wild-type GFP-LMWT (LMWT), GFP-LMLLO (LMLLO) or GFP-LMActA (LMActA) mutants that encode LLO and ActA virulence factors, respectively. Both virulence factors are involved in microglial infection in vitro . At E20 we observed 3 ± 0.5 pups born to LMWT-infected mothers, 4 ± 0.5 pups born to LMActA-infected mothers, 8 ± 0.1 pups born to LMLLO-infected mothers and 9 ± 0.2 pups born to NI mothers (Figure (Figure2A,2A, images correspond to a representative experiment out of three independent ones, P ≤ 0.05). This indicated a 66% mortality rate, which was higher than in humans because we did not treat infected mice with antibiotics. Only two P4 neonates born to LMWT-infected mothers survived (Figure (Figure2B),2B), while all other pups born to either LMLLO- or LMActA-infected or NI mothers were alive (Figure (Figure2B).2B). We chose P4 neonates as they corresponded to age 1 month in human neonates; the period with antibiotic treatment in listeriosis and hair development in mice. These results suggest involvement of actA gene in foetal wastage as reported previously [30–32], which explains the lower number of neonates in mothers infected with LMActA mutants. The lack of skin pigmentation was noticed only in P4 neonates born to LMWT-infected mothers. We investigated all P4 neonates for clinical data, weight, length, coordination movement tests and general observations with a magnifying lens before they were killed. Clinical data were normal in P4 neonates born to NI or LMLLO- or LMActA-infected mothers (Figure (Figure2C),2C), although movement test performance was 30% reduced in the latter. P4 neonates born to LMWT-infected mothers showed 50% weight loss, no ability to move in the metric paper test, and a low number of black hair bulbs per millimeter of skin (0.1 ± 0.01) with a wrinkled skin appearance (Figure 2B, 2C). The lack of coordinated movements and melanoblast migration to hair bulbs in P4 neonates born to LMWT-infected mothers, confirmed severe CNS retardation after the E16 embryonic stage [33, 34]. We also detected cerebritis or enlarged heads in P4 neonates born to LMWT-infected mothers (Figure (Figure2B).2B). We noticed softer cranial covering, lack of brain integrity and a significant reduction of cerebral blood vessels in P4 neonates born to LMWT-infected mothers (Figure (Figure2D),2D), which might explain their difficulties in moving and developmental delay. Cell counts in the brain indicated a severe 44% loss of cellularity in P4 neonates born to LMWT-infected mothers, compared to normal cellularity in P4 neonates born to LMLLO- or LMActA-infected mothers (3.96 × 106 compared with 9 × 106 cells, Figure Figure2C).2C). We conclude that the main brain disease, cerebritis, reduction of cerebral blood vessels and cellularity, lack of brain integrity, and melanoblast migration to the hair bulbs seemed to depend on actA and hly genes.
We investigated LM target cells in the brains of our neonatal listeriosis model, establishing mixed microglial cultures from the hippocampus (95% neurons and 2% microglial cells) of P4 neonates born to LMWT-infected mothers. We confirmed a large amount of GFP-LMWT (green fluorescence) localized almost exclusively in microglial cells labelled with the macrophage marker F4/80 (red fluorescence), while neurons stained for α-tubulin were not infected (blue fluorescence in microglial mixed cultures; Figure Figure3A).3A). We verified LM viability in microglia of P4 neonates born to LMWT-infected mothers and detected 6200 CFU/mL, which was 20%-25% of total CFU of pregnant mothers (Table (Table1).1). We also followed listeriosis in pregnant mothers infected with LMWT and confirmed normal ability to clear LM infection. CFU/mg in the spleen were lower than in the liver and similar to those in non-pregnant female mice and LMWT-infected mothers (Table (Table1).1). In mice infected with 103-fold less virulent LMActA strain [31, 32], 3.5 CFU/mg were detected in microglial cells. We also detected significant numbers of bacteria in the liver of LMActA-infected mothers (340 CFU) and 10-fold fewer bacteria in the spleen (Table (Table1).1). Neonates born to LMLLO-infected mothers showed no detectable bacteria in microglia, liver or spleen, which suggested these mutants did not cross the placental or brain barriers, while LMActA mutants did (Table (Table1).1). Therefore, actA but not hly gene participated in microglial targeting.
LM infection of phagocytes induces different types of apoptosis or necrosis and significant cell surface remodeling [27–29]. We investigated cell surface changes in the microglia of P4 neonates born to LMWT-infected mothers and focused on apoptotic markers. We detected lower percentages of CD11b+ (8.2% of positive cells), CD14+ (3.9% positive cells), CD11c+ (6.3% positive cells), CD86+ (2% of positive cells) and MHC-I+ (from 67%-90% of positive cells), and normal percentages of MHC-II+ (43.1% of total positive cells) compared to microglia of neonates born to NI mothers (Table (Table2).2). To confirm that LMWT infection was responsible for the reduced expression of cell surface markers, we obtained microglia from NI mothers and infected them with LMWT, LMLLO or LMActA mutants at MOI of 10:1 (bacteria: cell) and analysed cell surface markers by flow cytometry (Figure (Figure3B).3B). We confirmed significant reductions in CD11b+ (12% of positive cells), CD14+ (10% of positive cells) and CD86+ (2%-4% of positive cells) cell surface markers after microglial infection with LMWT, LMLLO or LMActA mutants (Figure (Figure3B).3B). There were less prominent reductions in MHC-I+ after infection with LMWT or LMLLO and a greater reduction after infection with LMActA mutants (53% of positive cells). Confocal microscopy of purified microglia of P4 neonates born to NI mothers showed high staining of intracellular and membrane-bound CD11b (Figure (Figure3B).3B). However, cell surface staining of CD11b decreased significantly in microglia of P4 neonates born to LMWT-infected mothers, appearing mainly intracellular (white fluorescence) and co-localizing with GFP-LMWT (green fluorescence) and F4/80 marker (red fluorescence) (Figure (Figure3B).3B). Co-localization of the three markers (white, green and red fluorescence) appeared as light yellow fluorescence (Figure (Figure3B).3B). We confirmed that LMWT induced an apoptotic phenotype in microglia following the levels of the classical apoptotic marker, annexin V, by flow cytometry. Microglia of P4 neonates born to LMWT-infected mothers had 24.6% of cells with the apoptotic marker annexin V+, compared to only 2.1% in microglia of P4 neonates born to NI mothers (Table (Table2).2). To define the induction of apoptosis as early or late, we used a method that differentiates early and late apoptosis by fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS) as the double staining of cells with annexin V and 7-aminoactinomycin D (7-AAD) (late apoptosis) or single staining with annexin V (early apoptosis) in microglia of P4 neonates born to NI mothers and infected in vitro with different LM mutants. Microglial infection with LMLLO or LMWT induced early apoptosis in 9-12% of cells, annexin V+7-AAD−, (Figure (Figure3C).3C). LMActA infection of microglia failed to induce early apoptosis, since we only detected apoptosis in 1% of annexin V+7-AAD− cells, which was similar to 0.9% of annexin V+7-AAD− cells in control microglia (Figure (Figure3C).3C). We concluded that actA gene participated in LM induction of early apoptosis in microglia.
To establish whether LM induced pro- or anti-inflammatory apoptosis in microglia, we measured the pattern of cytokine release by microglia of neonates born to NI mothers, and infected them with LMWT, LMLLO or LMActA. Microglial infection with LMWT induced high levels of TNF-α and IL-6 and significant levels of IL-10, but low levels of IL-1 or IFN (Table (Table3).3). However, microglial infection with LMActA failed to produce significant levels of TNF-α IL-6 or IL-10 and induced low levels of IL-1 and IFN. Microglial infection with LMLLO only induced basal levels of most cytokines (Table (Table3).3). Similar cytokine patterns were observed in isolated microglia of P4 neonates born to LMWT-, LMActA- or LMLLO-infected mothers (Table (Table3).3). We concluded that actA gene was relevant for LMWT-induced apoptosis in microglia, presenting a predominant Th2 cytokine pattern but with high levels of TNF-α.
We characterized the early apoptotic transcriptional program induced by LMWT in microglia by differential expression of genes included on the Affymetrix GeneChip MOE430A2.0. We infected microglia in vitro with LMWT, LMLLO or LMActA for 20 min and normalized all values using levels of NI cells. Of the 162 genes in the first selection, we applied innate immunity functional clustering and identified 93 genes that were differentially expressed in LM-infected cells (Figure (Figure4A).4A). We reduced the innate immunity functional cluster to 32 genes that were exclusively regulated by TNF-α (Figure (Figure4B4B and Supplementary Table S1), which was the cytokine produced at highest levels after LMWT infection of microglia (Table (Table3).3). LMWT-infected microglia presented two early expression programs regulated by actA gene: induction of a TNF-α death-regulated program, and repression of a pro-inflammatory expression pattern involved in macrophage activation and antigen processing. The TNF-α-induced death signature, included the TNF-α receptor-associated component genes, tnf, traf3, tnfaip1 or tnfrsf1b; the TLR-associated genes, tlr1, tlr2 and cd14; the NFKB signalling genes, nfkbia and nfkbiz; ant the mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) gene, mapk1 (Figures (Figures4C4C and Supplementary Table S2); the early immune response gene, ier3; and two genes involved in ubiquitination, uba2 and uba3. Other genes belonging to this signature were the early immune response gene, irg1, cytokine gene il1b, the chemokine genes ccl3 and ccl5, the ion-pump ATPase regulatory gene atp6v1e1, and cathepsin genes ctsb, ctsd and ctsk, but with less intensity. The repressed pro-inflammatory signature in LMWT-infected microglia included the pi3kcg gene; the MHC I and pro-inflammatory h2-k1 gene implicated in antigen presentation; the lysosomal acid sphingomyelinase genes, smpd1 and scarb2, belonging to pro-inflammatory apoptotic and antigen-degradation routes; and the small GTPase component of cross-presentation signalling pathways, rab14 gene (Figures (Figures4C4C and Supplementary Figure S1). Other genes belonging to this repressed pro-inflammatory profile but with less intensity were the autophagy and inflammasome component, atg4b, and the SNARE component syntaxin 3, stx3. These results suggest a marked effect of LMWT infection in the transcriptome of microglia and the induction of TNF-α-mediated death signalling controlled by actA gene, which was different from the transcriptional pattern that LMwt induced in macrophages (Figure (Figure4A4A).
Efficient vaccine vectors in listeriosis are expected to control pathogen dissemination to the CNS and liver, and release protective cytokines such as IL-12p40, while showing basal levels of acute anti-inflammatory cytokines such as IL-6 [10–12, 37–39]. In addition, vaccine vectors might ideally prevent microglial apoptosis that appears linked to brain-associated morbidity. We formulated GNP-GAPDH1-22 nanovaccines with DIO-1 as adjuvant that signals through TLR2 and TLR4, and induces IL-12 without causing excessive inflammation or IL-10 production . Our purpose was to improve the spectrum of previous nanovaccine formulations with another adjuvant, Advax [39, 41] to prevent microglial dysfunction and brain disease in neonatal listeriosis. We vaccinated five pregnant mice at day 9 of gestation (E9), followed by challenge with LMWT on day 16 of gestation (E16) for 3 days. We observed a lack of viable CFU/mL in brains and only 20-25 viable CFU/mL in the liver of P4 neonates born to GNP-GAPDH1-22-vaccinated mothers, indicating high efficacy to block LMWT dissemination in neonates (Figure (Figure5A).5A). P4 neonates born to non-vaccinated (NV) mothers and infected with LMActA mutants (n = 5) showed 10-12 viable CFU/mL in brains but 3600 viable CFU/mL in the liver, indicating that these mutants disseminated in high numbers in the liver, severely crippled in their ability to invade the brain (Figure (Figure5A).5A). P4 neonates born to NV mothers and infected with LMWT (n = 5) showed 7000 viable CFU/mL in the brain and 5800 viable CFU/mL in the liver, indicating high dissemination of bacteria in both organs (Figure (Figure5A).5A). The high efficiency of GNP-GAPDH1-22 nanovaccines to prevent dissemination in the brain and liver prompted us to focus on these vaccine vectors to prevent other listeriosis-associated morbidity. P4 neonates born to GNP-GAPDH1-22-vaccinated mothers and challenged with LMWT showed normal ability to move (movement test), normal numbers of hair follicles (skin test), as well as normal weight and length compared to control neonates (Figure (Figure5B).5B). All these parameters were impaired in P4 neonates born to NV mothers and infected with LMWT (Figure (Figure5B).5B). Isolated microglia of P4 neonates born to GNP-GAPDH1-22-vaccinated mothers also prevented early and late microglial apoptosis (Figure (Figure5B)5B) and shifted microglial cytokine production towards a Th1 pattern with high levels of IL-12p40 and high ratios of TNF-α/IL-6 (Table (Table4).4). We also detected high titres of anti-GAPDH1-22 antibodies in sera of GNP-GAPDH1-22-vaccinated mothers (GNP-GAPDH1-22 + LMWT) (Table (Table4),4), which is another indicator of vaccine efficiency in listeriosis [10, 39]. Microglia of P4 neonates born to NV and LMWT-infected mothers presented high levels of IL-6, IL-10 and TNF-α and lacked production of IL-12p40 (Table (Table4);4); a Th2 pattern similar to the cytokine profile reported in meningitis and encephalitic cases of listeriosis [4, 33, 35]. We also detected low titres of anti-GAPDH1-22 antibodies in sera of NV mothers and infected with LMWT or LMActA, suggesting low induction of specific immune responses (Table (Table4).4). Similarly, microglia of P4 neonates born to LMActA-infected mothers failed to produce IL-12p40 (Table (Table4).4). GNP-GAPDH1-22 nanovaccination during pregnancy also prevented other manifestations of severe forms of listeriosis such as stillbirth or brain disease, since vaccinated mothers challenged with LMWT gave birth to 8 ± 0.1 pups, similar to NV and NI mothers (Figure (Figure5C)5C) and showed normal cerebral cellularity and vascularization (Figure (Figure5C).5C). Histological examination and anti-CD31 immunostaining of P4 neonates born to GNP-GAPDH1-22-vaccinated mothers challenged with LMWT; indicated normal skin and mature lungs, spleen and stomach (Figure (Figure5C)5C) and corrected vascularization of these organs, indicating prevention of development retardation. GNP-GAPDH1-22 formulated with Advax, while showing listeriosis protection in brains (2-3 CFU/mL), failed to reduce liver LMWT (400 CFU/ml) and produced anti-GAPDH1-22 antibodies, while produced high IL-10 levels (Table (Table44).
Brain morbidities reported in neonatal listeriosis implied meningitis, brain abscesses, diffused skin lesions and rash, fever or lethargy [2, 9, 33–36]. We found that neonatal listeriosis in our health institutions, HUMV and HUD, represented 28% of all listeriosis cases but with high mortality rates of 50%, urging the development of safe vaccines to protect pregnant women at high risk of listeriosis and to prevent neonatal brain illness. The major morbidities we observed in our neonatal listeriosis cases were foetal death (patient HUD003 and second twin of patient HUD004) and severe meningitis in a premature neonate that was treated successfully with ampicillin (neonate HUD008 of patient HUD007) . The incidence of listeriosis has increased in Europe since 2008 and especially in Northern Spain with two outbreaks, and current incidence rates of 1.71-1.86 cases per 100,000 inhabitants compared to 0.56 incidence rates before 2008 [1, 5, 9].
Therefore, vaccines can decrease incidence of listeriosis and increase immunocompetency in pregnant women. To prepare effective vaccines, we must identify immune biomarkers of good prognosis and the cells and mechanisms responsible for brain disease. Two immune biomarkers seem to be relevant in listeriosis, high titres of anti-GAPDH1-22 antibodies that indicate the ability of mothers with neonatal listeriosis to elicit potent LM-specific immune responses, and high Th1/Th2 ratios that prevent bacterial dissemination . In this regard, all our patients developing neonatal listeriosis, had high titres of anti-GAPDH1-22 antibodies but low TNF-α/IL-6 ratios, confirming our efforts to formulate vaccines that increase Th1/Th2 ratios. Synthetic nanovaccines formulated with GNPs coupled to LM epitopes such as GNP-LLO91-99 or GNP-GAPDH1-22 have been tested successfully in systemic experimental listeriosis in adults [39, 41]. Since patients with listeriosis have failed to produce anti-LLO antibodies , we focused on GNP-GAPDH1-22 nanovaccines, selecting the adjuvant DIO-1 for the vaccine formulation, because it induces IL-12p40 and fails to produce IL-10 , avoiding disproportionate inflammation in the brain.
To explore the cells and mechanisms responsible for brain disease, we established a neonatal experimental listeriosis model by inoculating pregnant mice with pathogenic LMWT at late pregnancy (E16). While not exactly similar, this experimental model of neonatal listeriosis mimics several human clinical symptoms of listeriosis [5, 9, 33–36, 42–44] and appears to retard normal foetal development (this study). In this regard, the threefold reduction in the number of neonates born to LMWT-infected mothers resembled spontaneous abortion (patient HUD003) or stillbirth (second born twin of patient HUD004), which were the most severe morbidities of neonatal listeriosis. Similarly, the enlarged heads, softer cranial covering and low number of neuronal bodies, are related with brain dysfunction and explained the lacked of coordinated movements, resembling severe brain diseases reported in neonates not treated with antibiotics [1, 2, 33]. Moreover, the lack of melanoblasts in the hair bulbs and a thinner epidermis with a delicate stratum corneum, are justified with a retard in the embryonic development at E16 stage induced by LM infection. At E16 stage, normally neural crest derivatives such as neurons, glial cells or melanoblasts start migration from the neural tube to brains or skin, respectively . It is possible that LM infection causes impairment of melanoblast migration at this stage, since LM targets to melanocytes and induces apoptosis . Moreover, other immature features, such as non-distended stomach, collapsed lung and reduction of blood vessels in the lungs and brain, are consistent with arterial ischaemic stroke and foetal bradycardia in early postnatal death [3, 36, 44]. These immaturities, together with the lack of spleen, retarded cerebellar formation and melanocyte migration to the skin in experimental neonatal listeriosis, which suggests severe delayed development, but also reduction of innate immune responses. Reduced innate immune responses explain dissemination of the pathogen in the liver and brain. Patients with neonatal listeriosis frequently presented with bacteraemia (HUD004 and HUD003), suggesting penetration of the blood-brain barrier and LM replication in the subarachnoid space, causing meningitis (patient HUD008) and cerebritis . Neonatal meningitis caused by group B Streptococcus is associated with recruitment of microglia and induction of non-classical apoptosis [22, 25]. Similarly, microglia are the target cells in brains of mice with neonatal listeriosis, inducing a TNF-α-mediated transcriptional program of cell suicide that up-regulates early macrophage signaling via tlr1, tlr2, tnf-α, nfkB, cd14 and mapk1 genes with low induction of ccl3 and ccl5 chemokine genes, which suggests poor recruitment of monocytes to the brain compared to during systemic listeriosis . This transcriptional program also down-regulates pro-inflammatory genes involved in macrophage activation and antigen presentation, such as pi3kcg, h2-k1, smpd1, scarb2 and rab14 genes. This transcriptional program is consistent with the cell surface apoptotic phenotype of microglia, CD11blowMHC-IlowCD40lowF4/80highMHC-IIhighAnnVhighCD86−  that appears to be regulated by the bacterial actA gene and not the classical hly gene that induces apoptosis in most phagocytes [27, 28]. This TNF-α-mediated apoptotic transcriptional program appears to be a mechanism to limit over-activation of innate immune responses, common to other bacteria inducing meningitis [22, 25] and consistent with high production of Th2 anti-inflammatory cytokines, IL-6 and IL-10, but low levels of Th1 cytokines such as IL-1β and IFN. Therefore, we consider this apoptotic pattern in neonatal mice as a TNF-IL-6 producing MG. The high numbers of CFUs detected in microglia of P4 neonates born to LMWT-infected mothers, verified the failure of microglial microbicidal mechanisms previously suggested in vitro , and therefore, microglial dysfunction. Microglial dysfunction in neonatal listeriosis explains brain disease such as motor impairment or lethargy.
Evaluation of two vaccine formulations, GNP-GAPDH1-22/DIO-1 and GNP-GAPDH1-22/Advax, in pregnant female mice before infection with LM, highlighted that DIO-1 adjuvant was superior to prevent neonatal listeriosis and avoid dissemination of the pathogen to the brain or liver, but also to avert brain disease associated with microglial failure. Neonates born to GNP-GAPDH1-22 nanovaccinated mothers showed normal numbers at birth with healthy conditions, coordinated movements, normal brain cellularity and vascularization, and no induction of apoptosis in microglia that produced high levels of IL-12p40 and TNF-α. These nanovaccines formulated with DIO-1, also induced high titres of anti-GAPDH1-22 antibodies in sera of vaccinated mothers, inducing LM-specific immunity and memory. We explained this broadened action of nanovaccines formulated with DIO-1 by implementing TLR2 signalling in different innate immune cells that elicit listeriosis-protective Th1 immune responses [40, 47–49]. The low production of anti-inflammatory cytokines IL-10 and IL-6 using DIO-1 as adjuvant prevented bacterial dissemination and induction of acute responses in the brain, preserving its integrity. Vaccine formulations with Advax or LMActA mutants failed to produce anti-GAPDH1-22 antibodies, reduced CFUs in the liver and induced IL-10 production, confirming GNP-GAPDH1-22 nanovaccine formulations with DIO-1 were superior. Nevertheless, Advax-formulated nanovaccines conferred significant listeriosis protection, while LMActA mutants did not.
We conclude that GNP-GAPDH1-22 nanovaccines formulated with a TLR2/4 targeted adjuvant, DIO-1, can be administered during pregnancy as they elicit Th1 protective immune responses and strong innate and specific immune responses. Their nanoscale formulation allows them to cross the placental barrier and induce a Th1 response in neonates that prevents brain and liver dissemination of the pathogen and establishment of listeriosis-associated diseases.
We used L. monocytogenes strains EGD (ATCC) and 10403S (LMWT) and LMLLO and LMActA mutants derived from 10403S strain (D.A. Portnoy, Berkley University, CA, USA), GFP-LMWT and GFP-LMActA derived from EGD strain (M. Lecuit, Pasteur Institute, Paris, France) , and GFP-LMLLO derived from 10403S strain (D.E. Higgins, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA). LLO189-201 and GAPDH1-22 peptides were synthesized at Centro Nacional de Biotecnología (CSIC, Madrid, Spain) followed by HPLC and mass spectrometry using a MALDI-TOF Reflex IV spectrometer. Peptide purity was ≥95% after HPLC.
We used C57BL/6 mice from our animal facilities at the University of Cantabria at 8-12 weeks old. Three female and one male mice were mated and assessed for the appearance of vaginal plugs denoting first embryonic day of pregnancy.
Listeriosis was confirmed in the foetus or stillborn or newborn infant according to the Commission Decision of 28/IV/2008 and classified as listeriosis at the Microbiology Department of Hospital Universitario Donostia (San Sebastian, Spain) during 2013-2015. In total, 13 human listeriosis episodes were detected in Gipuzkoa, which has an annual incidence of 1.86 cases per 100,000 inhabitants. Bacteria were recovered from blood in all cases. Description of patients and clinical manifestations is shown in Suuplementary Table S2. All patients participated in the study voluntarily and they gave signed informed consent at the time of physician consultation and received an information document about the study. Patients could revoke the informed consent at any time.
To obtain GNPs carrying GAPDH peptide (GNP-GAPDH1-22), an aqueous solution of tetrachloroauric acid (Strem Chemicals, Newburyport, MA, USA) (0.025 M, 1 eq.) was added to a mixture of glucose (90%) and GAPDH peptide (10%) with thiol ending ligands (0.012 M, 6 eq.) in methanol/water/acetic acid (3:3:1). The detailed procedure has been reported previously . The size distribution of the GNPs was evaluated from several transmission electron micrographs (JEM-2100F; Jeol, Tokyo, Japan), with an average diameter and number of gold atoms of 2.1 ± 0.5 nm. The presence of glucose and peptide ligands was confirmed by 1H NMR and the amount of GAPDH peptide on the GNPs was determined by quantitative NMR in a Bruker AVANCE 500 MHz spectrometer (Bruker, Billerica, MA, USA). GNPs (0.234 mg) were dispersed in 99.9% D2O (200 μL) and 80 μl of this solution was added to 40 μl 0.05% 3-(trimethylsilyl)propionic-2,2,3,3-d4 acid sodium salt solution in D2O as an internal standard. Peptide loading was 10.6 μg/0.234 mg GNPs and GNP-GAPDH1-22 and their stability in dendritic cells has been described previously . DIO-1 is a TLR2/4 targeted molecule that can be used as an adjuvant  and Advax is an inulin formulated adjuvant .
C57BL/6 female mice were inoculated i.v. with 100 μL suspension of each clinical isolate in saline (5000 CFU/mice). At 72 h post-inoculation, mice were killed and spleens recovered and homogenized, and viable bacteria were determined on blood agar plates. Results are expressed as the mean ± SD of CFU/mL. All data were gathered in triplicate and we performed three independent experiments.
Pregnant C57BL/6 female mice (n = 5) were inoculated intravenously (i.v) at 16 days of gestation (E16) via the lateral tail vain with 100 μL of a GFP-LMWT, GFP-LMLLO, GFP-LMActA, LMWT, LMLLO or LMActA bacterial suspensions in saline (3000 CFU/mL) (LMWT, LMLLO or LMActA infected mothers) or inoculated with 100 μL of saline (non-infected (NI) mothers) (n = 5). All animals were examined daily. Three P4 neonates born to NI, LMLLO or LMActA mothers and the two P4 survivors born to LMWT infected mothers, were killed to obtain the cerebellum for preparation of mixed microglia and subsequent isolation of primary microglial cultures for CFU quantification, cell surface markers analysis by FACS, and cytokine quantification. LMWT-infected and NI mothers were bled for cytokine and anti-GAPDH1-22 antibody analysis and killed to obtain spleens and livers for CFU quantification and analysis of cell populations by FACS. Results were expressed as CFU/mL in spleens and livers and CFU/mL in microglial cultures ± SD of triplicates.
Clinical tests were performed at P4 on all pups born to mothers infected or not with different bacterial strains. Metric tests of health conditions and units were as follows: weight (milligrams × 10), length (mm), movement assay placing pups in a 10-cm metric paper and recording the movement after 5 min (cm) and skin test, counting the number of black bulbs under a magnifying glass in 1 mm of skin, and skin was observed for general appearance as wrinkled or flattered. All results are the mean ± SD of three different experiments.
Microglial cultures and detailed procedures for obtaining mixed microglial cultures and purified primary microglia have been reported previously .
Pregnant C57BL/6 female mice were vaccinated (n = 5) or not (n = 5) at day 9 of gestation (E9) via the lateral tail vain with GNP-GAPDH1-22 formulated with DIO-1 adjuvant (5 μg nanoparticles and 2 μg DIO-1). At 16 days of gestation (E16) all mice, were inoculated i.v with 100 μL of a LMWT or LMActA bacterial suspension in saline (1 × 104 CFU/mL) (NV-LMWT or NV-LMActA infected mothers). All animals were examined daily. At E20 we detected 3 ± 0.5 pups born to LMWT infected mothers, 4 ± 0.5 pups born to LMActA infected mothers and NV, while 8 ± 0.1 pups were born to control and GNP-GAPDH1-22 vaccinated mice, challenged or not with LMWT (or LMActA) (P ≤ 0.05). Results were the mean ± SD of three independent experiments. Four days after birth, P4 postnatal pups born to NV or GNP-GAPDH1-22-vaccinated and LMWT- (or LMActA)-infected mothers were killed to quantify viable CFU/mL in whole brains and livers. Other P4 neonates were used for preparation of microglial cultures and measurement of cytokines and viable CFU/mL in these cells.
Neonates were killed on day 4 after birth (P4) and were immersed in 4% formalin for cryopreservation of complete bodies. Most frequently affected organs (brain, skin, spleen, lungs and blood vessels) were resected, sectioned and fixed by immersion in 4% formaldehyde for 24 h. Organs were embedded in paraffin and cut at 3-μm thickness for histological analysis. Different sections (stained with hematoxylin and eosin; HE) of each organ were analysed by two independent pathologists. For immunohistochemical analysis, EnVision technology (Dako) was applied. Samples were boiled in target retrieval solution buffer as described previously . Sections were incubated with ready-to-use primary monoclonal antibody (Dako) against CD31 to explore vascularized endothelia in neonatal organs. Antigen was visualized using biotinylated antibody and streptavidin conjugated with horseradish peroxidase (EnVision Mouse HRP; Dako). Diaminobenzidine (Dako) was used as the chromogen.
Microglia purified from P4 neonates were cultured in vitro and cultured supernatants filtered and stored at −80°C before cytokine analysis using a CBA pro-inflammatory kit (BD Biosciences, NJ, USA) [10, 19]. Samples were analysed in triplicate and results are shown as the mean ± SD of three separate experiments.
Microglia were infected or not with different LM strains for 20 min (LMWT, LMLLO or LMActA). We isolated RNA and performed differential microarray analysis using the Affymetrix GeneChip MOE430A2.0 that evaluates 22,626 mouse genes . The results of microarray analysis were deposited in NCBI Gene Expression Omnibus and accessible through GEO Series accession number GSE32505 (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/geo/query/acc.cgi?acc=GSE32505). Results of the differential microarrays are expressed as signal log ratio (SLR). All final values were subtracted from basal controls values that corresponded to NI cells (detailed in Supplementary Information).
We obtained sera from NV LMWT-infected, NV LMActA-infected, NV NI, GNP-GAPDH1-22 vaccinated LMWT-infected and GNP-GAPDH1-22 vaccinated NI pregnant mice. Sera were also obtained from listeriosis patients. Peptide ELISA was performed as described previously [12, 39]. LLO189-201 and GAPDH1-22 peptides were prepared at 50 μg/mL in coating buffer (50 nM of Na2CO3 at pH 9.7) and used to coat Nunc MaxiSorp plates overnight at 4 °C. Plates were blocked with 1% BSA in PBS at room temperature for 30 min and mouse sera were diluted 1/200 in PBS/0.5% BSA and incubated for 1 h at room temperature. IgM was detected with a goat anti-mouse IgM conjugated with horseradish peroxidase or goat anti-juman IgM conjugated with horseradish peroxidase (0.8 μg/mL) and enzymatic reactions developed with tetramethyl benzidine in citric/acetate buffer and H2O2. Reactions were stopped with 50 μL H2SO4 (0.8 M) and absorbance was measured at 450 nm in the ELISA reader. Results were expressed as mean ± SD absorbance units from triplicate experiments.
For statistical analysis, the Student's t test was applied. P≤0.05 was considered significant using GraphPad for graphic presentation. ANOVA was used for cytokine analysis (BD Biosciences, San Jose, CA).
This study was carried out in strict accordance with the recommendations in the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals of the Spanish Ministry of Science, Research and Innovation. The Ethical Committee of Animal Experiments of the University of Cantabria approved this protocol (Permit Number: PI-01-17), which follows the Spanish legislation (RD 1201/2005). All surgery was performed under sodium pentobarbital anaesthesia and all efforts were made to minimize suffering. This study was also approved by the Ethical Committee of Clinical Research of Cantabria at Instituto de Investigación Marqués de Valdecilla (Santander, Spain), with the reference number 2014.228 (patients with listeriosis). All participants signed the Informed Consent documents and these documents are in the custody of physicians in accordance with Spanish Law (Ministry of Health).
We thank F. Madrazo-Toca (Unidad Microscopia Avanzada, IDIVAL, Santander, Spain) for providing help with confocal microscopy, M.L. Fanarraga (Department of Molecular Biology, Universidad de Cantabria, Santander, Spain) for assistance with microglia images, C. Santa Cruz (Unidad de Citometría, IDIVAL, Santander, Spain) for FACS analysis, and E. Ferrández-Fernandez (IDIVAL, Santander, Spain) for excellent technical assistance with cell cultures and mouse experiments. R. Calderon-Gonzalez is supported by grant numbers API13/14/SAF2012-34203 and INNVAL15/01. The salary of E. Frande-Cabanes is paid from grant number API12/SAF2009-08695 and that of H. Terán-Navarro by grant number INNVAL15/01. We also thank D. Fernandez (Progenika S.A, Bilbao, Spain) for gene expression analysis. We are indebted to R. Franco (Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, Universidad de Barcelona, Cataluña) for his encouragement, microglial expertise, advice and critical comments on the manuscript. This study is dedicated to the memory of F. Leyva-Cobian.
Authors’ contributionsR C-G, E F-C and H T-N performed the experiments and analysed the data; JF, performed the histochemical experiments, analysed the data and help to write the paper, A S-G, help with the microglia experiments; A C-S, helped with the experiments to establish the neonatal listeriosis model; JMM, MA and E P-T performed all laboratory diagnoses of listeriosis patients, compiled all clinical data and performed all genotyping of bacterial clinical isolates; J G-R, directed the histochemical experiments, analysed the data and helped to write the paper; IG, MM and SP synthesized nanovaccines and performed controls, S Y-D, helped with neonatal clinical tests, analysed the data and helped to write the paper, MCF, C G-R and FR provided listeriosis patients and helped with the discussion of results (HUMV), CP and MF, prepared the DIO-1 vaccine formulations; MF and JMM also helped with writing the paper; C A-D, directed the study, designed the experiments, analysed the data and wrote the paper.
CONFLICTS OF INTEREST
The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest with the contents of this article.
This study was supported by IDIVAL grants API2010/03/SAF2009-08695, AIP13/2014/SAF2012-34203 and INNVAL15/01 (to C. A-D and J.F), the Spanish Government through Plan Nacional (MINECO) (SAF2012-34203), FIPSE (ISCIII) (00-00002755-16) and CIBER-BNN (CIB16-NM009) (to C. A-D and I. G), RED RICET RD12/0018/0004 and BIOMID (ISCIII), SAF2013-42850-R (MINECO), HOMIN-317057-FP7-PEOPLE-2012-ITN (EU) (to M.F) and by the Spanish Government through Plan Nacional (MINECO) (CTQ2011-27268) (to S.P).