|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
Meningioma is the commonest primary intracranial tumour in adults. Excision is curative for low grade meningioma, whereas high-grade meningioma requires adjuvant therapy following surgery. Several studies have examined the association between peritumoural brain Edema — a common feature in meningioma — and histological grading with mixed results. The present study attempted to elucidate this association and if peritumoural brain Edema affects the intra-operative judgement of surgeons on the completeness of resection.
An observational study was conducted among those who underwent surgery for meningioma. Eighteen subjects were recruited each for low- and high-grades, respectively. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) prior to surgery was employed for interpreting the Edema index and MRI after surgery was used to determine residual tumour.
Median age was 50 years, male to female ratio was 1:3.5, 69.4% had peritumoural brain Edema and 75% had reported gross resection. Among the reported gross total resection cases, 40.7% had residual tumour. Analysis showed statistically significant association between peritumoural brain Edema (P = 0.027) and tumour volume (P = 0.001) with high-grade meningioma, however multivariate analysis did not present any association. No association was noted between judgement of tumour resection by surgeons and peritumoural brain Edema.
Odds ratio for peritumoural brain Edema remained high and the tumour volume exhibited marginal P-value marginal significance for prediction of high grade meningioma. These two factors may still contribute to the tumour grade and should be included in further studies on the prognosis of meningioma.
Meningiomas make up 33.8%–34.4% of the primary intracranial tumours observed in adults and are even more common than glial tumours, which comprise 31.1% of all primary intracranial tumours (1–2). Advancing age increases the risk of a diagnosis of meningioma, with the highest risk occurring between 60 and 70 years of age (2). Meningioma is assumed to arise from the arachnoid, particularly from the outer arachnoid layer and arachnoid villi, which are called the arachnoid cap cells and are diverse in their distribution throughout the central nervous system (3).
Meningiomas are distinguishable into three histological grades. Grade 1 meningioma occurs in almost 80% of cases, has a low proliferative potential, and is often cured through surgical resection. Grade 2 meningioma may infiltrate locally despite its low proliferative potential and also carries a probability of recurrence. Grade 3 meningioma generally reveals histological evidence of malignancy, including nuclear atypia and brisk mitotic activity (4).
Meningioma patients usually present with seizures, symptoms of raised intracranial pressure, and focal neurological deficits that are associated with the location of the tumour. These symptoms are exacerbated by peritumoural Edema and are occasionally visible when peritumoural Edema is present or increases (5–6).
Surgery alone is usually sufficient to treat grade 1 meningioma; despite complete excision, grade 2 meningioma has an eight-fold increased risk of recurrence (3). Grade 3 meningioma is considerably more aggressive, with an average survival period of two years or less (7). Despite some prior controversies, adjuvant radiotherapy continues to be recommended to treat grades 2 and 3 due to the locally invasive nature of the disease. Nevertheless, recent data regarding adjuvant therapy have shown promising results comparable with a second surgery for incomplete excision and recurrence (8–9).
The amount of peritumoural Edema is associated with the degree of blood-brain barrier breakdown; thus, if the tumour grade (malignancy) is higher, then the extent of the blood-brain barrier breach is greater. Therefore, tumours with a higher grade tend to produce more Edema (10).
Several studies have investigated the association between peritumoural brain Edema and the histopathological categorisation of the meningioma. While a few researchers have reported a significant connection (11–12), others have observed no such association (13–15). Thus, the connection between the histopathological grading of the meningioma and the presence of peritumoural brain Edema remains obscure.
Surgical intervention in intracranial meningioma patients aims for complete resection, which produces an improved long-term recurrence rate (6, 16). Attempts have been made to determine whether peritumoural Edema results from local infiltration and if the presence of vascular endothelial growth factor influences the totality of the resection of the intracranial meningioma (10, 17–18). This study examined the relationship between the presence of peritumoural Edema and the histological outcome of the meningioma. We also attempted to determine whether peritumoural Edema in any way affected the surgeons’ judgement regarding the completeness of the resection.
This cross-sectional observational study was conducted over a 5-year period on patients who had undergone a first-time tumour excision at Hospital Kuala Lumpur of a histologically confirmed meningioma. Institutional ethical approval was obtained from the Medical Research and Ethics Committee of the Ministry of Health in Malaysia.
Over a 5-year period, 168 cases of histologically confirmed intracranial meningioma were identified. Less than half of these cases (78 patients) were included in this study largely due to missing data or a delay in performing a follow-up magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scan post surgery.
Brain Edema is defined as an expansion of the brain volume due to increased water and sodium content (20). This condition is identified on MRI as a hyper-intense image on T2-weighted scans and as a hypo-intense one on T1-weighted scans (21).
In the current study, the tumour volume and Edema were measured using pre-operative contrast-enhanced MRI films. The sagittal and coronal diameters were determined from the axial images. The coronal images were used to measure the axial diameter (Figure 1). These measurements were employed to estimate the volume of reasonably regular shaped ellipsoid and concave objects by applying the formula abc/2, where a is the sagittal diameter, b is the coronal diameter and c is the axial diameter (22–26). This formula was used to measure peritumoural brain Edema by employing high signal intensity changes on T2-weighted images (Figure 2). The Edema index represents the degree of peritumoural Edema compared with tumour volume and is calculated by dividing the peritumoural brain Edema volume by the tumour volume. An Edema index of more than 1.0 signifies peritumoural brain Edema.
The World Health Organisation (WHO) classifies meningioma using three distinct grades. Grade 1 denotes a low proliferative potential that may be cured through surgical resection. Grade 2 lesions are locally infiltrative with a tendency to recur, despite their low proliferative index. Grade 3 lesions generally show histological evidence of malignancy (38–39). In terms of management, grades 2 and 3 require adjuvant therapy even after total tumour excision due to their tendency to recur and were thus classified as high grade in this study (42).
The extent of surgical resection of the meningioma has been reported to be correlated with recurrence and is distinguishable into five grades (16) (Table 1). To date, this is the most widely used and accepted grading system for meningioma resection. Generally, grades I–III denote complete macroscopic tumour excision.
The presence of a residual tumour was determined by post-operative MRI, which is routinely performed between 12 and 24 weeks after surgery. The MRI images were interpreted by the resident neuroradiologist based on the contrast uptake and signal intensity changes.
The surgeons were classified into three groups based on their number of years of experience after post-graduate training as follows: more than three years; between one and three years; and less than one year, which included the senior neurosurgery residents. This was a practical approach in our local setting because surgeons with less than one year of experience were still considered to be in training, while those with more than three years of experience were generally accepted as independent surgeons.
During the study period, 168 confirmed intracranial meningioma cases were recorded. The histopathological records of the 168 cases revealed that 147 had grade 1 (low grade) meningioma and 21 showed grades 2 and 3 (high grade) meningioma, which implied an approximately 12.5% incidence of high-grade meningioma.
After analysing the demographic data, no significant association was found for age, gender or racial profile with the histological grading of meningioma. The P-value was greater than 0.05 in all cases (Tables 2 and and33).
Tumour volume and peritumoural brain Edema had a significant association with high-grade meningioma upon univariate statistical analysis. Multivariate analysis using binary logistic regression was performed on these independent variables (Table 4). Peritumoural brain Edema had an odds ratio (OR) of 6 with a 95% confidence interval (CI) of 0.634–56.924, whereas the tumour volume had an OR of 1.022 with a 95% CI of 0.999–1.046 for the association with high-grade meningioma. The Nagelkerke R square was fairly representative at 0.439.
Multivariate analysis of the independent variables, including the presence of peritumoural brain Edema, tumour volume, histological grading (grades 2/3) and surgeons’ amount of experience compared with the presence of residual tumours on follow up reported as gross resection during surgery, was performed using binary logistic regression. The variables were found to be statistically insignificant (Table 5).
This study identified the incidence of high-grade meningioma to be 12.5%. This finding concurs with the incidence of high-grade meningioma (7.9%–35%) reported in other studies conducted after the introduction of the WHO 2000 classification scheme (27–29).
Grade 1 (low-grade) meningioma has a relatively good prognosis even with debulking; grades 2 and 3 (high-grade) meningiomas have a worse prognosis and necessitate adjuvant therapy (8–9). Physicians are often asked whether surgery is the end point of treatment or if adjuvant therapy will be required post-operatively. The ability to predict tumour grading will enable the physician to give a more accurate possibility of the treatment direction, instead of waiting for the formal and time-consuming histological diagnosis. Incomplete resection is linked to an increased need for vigilant surveillance necessitated by the residual tumour and also an increased likelihood for another surgery or adjuvant therapy.
Concurrent with the findings of other studies, the present study revealed women to be three times more likely to be diagnosed with meningioma than men. In contrast, men appeared to show a higher predisposition for high-grade meningioma (62.5%) than women (46.4%). Although this observation concurs with the indirect inference drawn by several other authors, it was statistically insignificant (31–32).
Ethnicity showed no predilection towards meningioma because the distribution based on racial composition almost mirrored the national racial composition, and this distribution pattern was observed in both the low- and high-grade tumour groups (30, 33).
Patients with a high-grade tumour reported a shorter duration of symptoms at presentation; however, this difference was statistically insignificant. To date, no studies have compared the growth rate of the different grades of meningioma. The differences in the clinical expansion rate between high- and low-grade meningiomas were often not very distinct (34). Further studies are necessary to predict local tumour aggressiveness and possible timing of surgery to facilitate the safe allocation of resources.
Forty per cent of patients with high-grade meningioma had seizures at presentation, as compared with only 22% of patients with low-grade meningioma. The OR that a patient with high-grade meningioma would experience seizures was 2.8 and was statistically insignificant, which was in line with an earlier report (35). However, the incidence of seizures among patients included in the current study was much higher when compared with the findings of a similar and more recent study by Hamasaki et al. (31).
High-grade meningioma exhibited a three-fold higher mean tumour volume than low-grade meningioma (96.67 cm3 versus 32.92 cm3, respectively), which was statistically significant in the univariate analysis. However, the lack of earlier published data for a comparison of this finding warrants further investigation. The percentage of low-grade meningioma patients with peritumoural brain Edema was 50.0%, while that of patients with high-grade meningioma and peritumoural brain Edema was 88.9%. This finding was statistically significant upon univariate analysis, had an OR of 8 and concurs with the results reported in prior studies (12, 19, 36), which suggested a positive correlation between peritumoural brain Edema and high-grade meningioma.
Among the 8 patients whose surgical procedure was performed by surgeons with less than 1 year of experience and were reported to have presented a gross total resection, 5 (62.5%) had a residual tumour. However, this rate was the lowest at 25% (3 out of 12 patients) among those patients who underwent surgery performed by surgeons with 1–3 years of experience. Nevertheless, the resection outcomes of the more senior surgeons (> 3 years of experience) were 3 out of 7 (42.9%) cases, in whom gross total resection was noted and the residual tumour was identified on the follow-up MRI. This finding suggests that younger surgeons have a tendency to overestimate their successes, while the more senior surgeons might encounter more technically challenging tumours. Of the 7 cases performed by the senior surgeons, 3 were petroclival, 1 each involved the falx, medial third sphenoid wing and olfactory groove, and there was also 1 suprasellar tumour. In contrast, 7 out of the 8 cases handled by surgeons with less than one year’s experience were convexity meningiomas. This theoretically will be easier to achieve complete resection.
The presence of peritumoural brain Edema does not significantly alter the morphology of the arachnoid plane or therefore impair the surgeons’ judgement regarding the completeness of the resection. Among patients with residual brain tumours, follow-up MRIs indicated that 81.8% of them had peritumoural brain Edema, while 18.2% of patients did not. A similar observation was noted among those without residual tumours on follow-up MRIs (81.9% revealed peritumoural brain Edema, while 18.1% did not). In contrast, Vignes et al. reported a significant correlation between the presence of peritumoural brain Edema in meningioma and surgical difficulty during resection. They reported that 14 (46.7%) patients had a clear arachnoid plane, while 16 (53.3%) showed an ill-defined one. At the 1-year follow-up visit, mortality and nil recurrence were reported in 29 patients, while 8 patients had tumours present at the skull base (18).
High-grade tumours are linked to tumour infiltration into the adjacent tissue. Both grade 2 and grade 3 meningiomas have been reported to locally infiltrate (6). In fact, earlier studies have established a relationship between the presence of a high-grade tumour and its recurrence (37–39). However, in the literature review, no studies discussed the factors that produced inadvertent residual tumours in meningioma. We examined whether the histological grading influenced the totality of the resection and found that patients with high-grade meningioma had a 3.5-fold higher chance (OR: 3.49) of having a residual tumour, although this finding was not statistically significant.
Univariate analysis has indicated that the concurrent presence of peritumoural brain Edema and tumour volume has been associated with high-grade tumours (Table 4). Patients with peritumoural brain Edema were six times more likely to harbour a high-grade tumour when compared to those without it; this result was statistically significant, with a P-value of 0.118. Similarly, a comparison of the tumour volumes revealed an OR of 1.022 with a P-value of 0.061. This result could have significance because of the relatively small sample size, but it was not expected to reveal the relationship between the volume and tumour grade, which was beyond the scope of this work.
An earlier study reported significant difficulty in the surgical removal of the tumour in patients with peritumoural Edema preoperatively, which may have been due to arachnoid plane distortion (18). However, other studies have identified a positive association between the presence of peritumoural brain Edema and the recurrence of the meningioma, which could imply the presence of a residual tumour that might have been overlooked during the surgery (40–41). Contrary to the aforementioned hypothesis, no statistically significant differences were identified in this study between the various factors examined and the completeness of tumour resection, as perceived by the surgeons (Table 5).
This study would have been of greater value and significance had the population under study had been categorised based on tumour location. It is widely accepted that the location of the tumour probably influences the tumour’s respectability and perhaps also the presence of peritumoural brain Edema. However, such a categorisation will necessitate a much larger sample size, which in turn will increase the power of the study. A larger multicentre study is necessary, with one drawback of a multicentre study being the increased disparity of the surgeons’ skills at each institution.
Initially, there appeared to be a connection between the higher grades of meningioma and peritumoural brain Edema, which was backed by univariate statistical analysis and also had a higher probability of advanced grades of meningioma with a rise in the tumour volume, a fact that has not been previously reported. However, the statistical significance of both the parameters decreased upon multivariate analysis, while the OR remained reasonably high (OR = 6.0). It is evident that peritumoural brain Edema does not influence the intra-operative judgment of the surgeons on the entirety of the resection of a meningioma.
Although the factors studied generally had an insignificant effect upon the multivariate analysis, the influence of peritumoural brain Edema and tumour volume on the histological grading of meningioma cannot be disregarded. The scoring system for meningioma in the future must necessarily consider these two factors.
Conception and design: KP, MSMH
Analysis and interpretation of the data: KP, NRMZ
Drafting of the article: KP
Critical revision of the article for important intellectual content: KP, MSMH, NRMZ
Final approval of the article: KP, MSMH
Provision of study materials or patients: KP, MSMH
Statistical expertise: KP
Obtaining of funding: KP
Administrative, technical, or logistic support: KP
Collection and assembly of data: KP, NRMZ