|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
We recently reported the generation and initial characterization of the first direct model of human Fibrous Dysplasia (OMIM #174800), obtained through the constitutive systemic expression of one of the disease causing mutations, GsαR201C, in the mouse. To define the specific pathogenetic role(s) of individual cell types within the stromal/osteogenic system in FD, we generated mice expressing GsαR201C selectively in mature osteoblasts using the 2.3kb Col1a1 promoter. We show here that this results in a striking high bone mass phenotype, but not in a mimicry of human FD. The high bone mass phenotype involves specifically a deforming excess of cortical bone and prolonged and ectopic cortical bone remodeling. Expression of genes characteristic of late stages of bone cell differentiation/maturation is profoundly altered as a result of expression of GsαR201C in osteoblasts, and expression of the Wnt inhibitor, Sost, is reduced. While high bone mass is in fact a feature of some types/stages of FD lesions in humans, it is marrow fibrosis, localized loss of adipocytes and hematopoietic tissue, osteomalacia and osteolytic changes that together represent the characteristic pathological profile of FD, as well as the sources of specific morbidity. None of these features are reproduced in mice with osteoblast-specific expression of GsαR201C. We further show that hematopoietic progenitor/stem cells, as well as more mature cell compartments, and adipocyte development are normal in these mice. These data demonstrate that effects of Gsα mutations underpinning FD-defining tissue changes and morbidity do not reflect the effects of the mutations on osteoblasts proper.
Fibrous dysplasia of bone (FD, OMIM #174800) is a crippling disease with serious adverse consequences in its severe forms, including deformity, fracture, severe bone pain, confinement to a wheelchair and major sensorial damage (1). All clinical forms of the disease (monostotic, polyostotic, polyostotic with endocrinopathies/McCune-Albright syndrome, or mono-polyostotic associated with myxoma of muscle, otherwise known as Mazabraud’s syndrome) are caused by activating missense mutations in the GNAS locus, encoding the α subunit of the stimulatory G protein, Gs [(2,3), and reviewed in (1)]. Gsα-activating mutations induce a 30-fold reduction in the GTPase activity of Gsα, which as a consequence, remains in a prolonged state of activation, causing excess production of cAMP (4). In FD bone lesions, bone trabeculae are abnormal in architecture, structure, and mineral content, while the intertrabecular bone marrow space is depleted of both hematopoietic tissue and adipocytes, and filled with a fibrotic tissue (5–8). Over the past 20 years, studies focusing on skeletal stem/progenitor cells (also known as bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells), used either in vitro (9–11) or in in vivo transplantation assays (12,13), have been employed to reveal the pathogenic effects of these mutations on cells of the osteogenic lineage, and the contribution of the latter to the generation of tissue changes characteristic of FD and of the associated morbidity (1,14). We have recently shown that constitutive systemic expression of one of the FD-causing mutations (GsαR201C) generates an exact replica of the bone pathology seen in human FD, thus providing the long-missed mouse model of the disease (15). Such a model is necessary for improved understanding of crucial aspects of the natural history of the disease, and for direct testing of therapeutic strategies, whether existing or novel, pharmacological or based on more innovative approaches, such as cell or gene therapy. However, precise elucidation of the relative role of individual cells types in bone and bone marrow in vivo remains of crucial importance. The so-called stromal system (16) includes multiple lineages (chondrogenic, osteogenic, adipogenic) emanating from a common postnatal progenitor (17,18). Within the osteogenic lineage proper, definition of discrete differentiation steps has been elusive. Nonetheless, advances in that direction have included the identification of surface markers that are robustly expressed in early stromal progenitors and downregulated in mature bone cells [e.g., CD146 in humans (19)], as well as of transcription factors that are expressed and activated either across the osteogenic lineage, such as Runx2 (20), or in cell compartments that include mature osteoblasts and possibly committed progenitors thereof, such as Osx (21). The functional state of mature, bone-depositing osteoblasts is however precisely defined by the use of a specific Col1a1 promoter element, which is not activated either in progenitor cells or in other lineages within the stromal system (22,23), and represents a major tool for investigating the function of individual gene products in osteoblasts proper (24). As a natural next step towards the precise definition of the effects of Gsα in each of the members of the stromal/osteogenic system, we have therefore generated mice with osteoblast-specific expression of GsαR201C utilizing the 2.3kb Col1a1 promoter. We show here that, unlike mice with constitutive systemic expression of GsαR201C (15), Col1a1-GsαR201C expressing mice develop a striking skeletal phenotype characterized by deforming excess of bone. However, defining features of human FD that emanate from changes in the bone marrow are not reproduced in this model, which points to cells other than mature osteoblasts in the bone environment as being responsible for the generation of the FD phenotype.
A 2.3kb fragment of the mouse Col1a1 collagen promoter from the pJ251 vector (kind gift from B. de Crombrugghe, Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, TX, USA), was cloned into pBluescript SK+ (Stratagene, La Jolla, CA USA). The intermediate pKO-Col1a1-SV40 plasmid was generated by inserting the Col1a1 fragment into pKO-SV40, in which a 200 bpSV40 polyA fragment from the pKN185 plasmid was previously inserted. The final construct Col1a1-GsαR201C was assembled by insertion of a rat GsαR201CcDNA from the ATCC #63317 clone (GenBank M12673; ATCC, Manassas, VA) into the pKO-Col1a1-SV40 construct.
The Col1a1-GsαR201C vector was injected into the pronucleus of one-cell stage FVB embryos and these were subsequently implanted into pseudo-pregnant CD-1 mice (Harlan, Italy) (25). Founders were serially backcrossed with wild type FVB mice (Harlan) and two transgenic lines (D7 and E8) were selected for long-term maintenance and analysis. Animals were maintained under standard environmental conditions (temperature 22°C–25°C, humidity 40%–70%, 12:12 dark-light photoperiod), and food and water were provided ad libitum. All experiments involving animals were performed according to the relevant Italian laws and Institutional guidelines and all procedures were IACUC approved. All studies on the characterization of the skeletal phenotype of TG mice were conducted both in male and female mice.
Genotyping was performed on gDNA as described (15) by using the primers listed in Suppl. Table 1. RNA was extracted from frozen tissues and cell cultures with TRIzol (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA, USA) as per the manufacturer’s instructions and reverse transcribed as already described(26). Col1a1-GsαR201C transgene expression was analyzed by standard PCR reaction using the primers listed in Table 1. qPCR analysis on cultured cells was performed by Q-PCR using the TaqMan Gene Assays listed in Suppl. Table 2.
Osteogenic cultures were established from collagenase-treated bone fragments from calvariae or vertebrae and grown as described (15,27). Bone marrow stromal cell cultures (BMSCs, skeletal stem/progenitor cells) were established from mouse long bones and grown or induced to osteoblastic differentiation as described (26,28). Differentiated cultures were either stained with Von Kossa or harvested for RNA extraction.
cAMP was measured by using the cAMP Direct Biotrak™ EIA kit (GE Healthcare, Buckinghamshire, UK, Europe GmbH) according to the manufacturer’s instructions (29) in the presence of 3-isobutyl-1-methylxanthine (IBMX, Sigma, MO, USA).
Radiograms were taken using a Faxitron MX-20 Specimen Radiography System (Faxitron X-ray Corp., Wheeling, IL) at 25 kV for 8 sec. The images (1 to 5x projective magnification) were captured with Medical Imaging Film HM Plus (Ferrania USA, Inc., Woodbury, MN).
Samples were scanned at Queen Mary University of London by using the in-house designed “MuCat 2” X-ray microtomography scanner. This uses a time-delay integration readout CCD camera to provide high quality images, similar to the original scanner (30), but having a larger, fibre-optically coupled detector (6 cm2). The X-ray generator was set to 40 kV and 405 μA; beam hardening correction was applied to give an equivalent monochromatic energy of 25 keV (31). The voxel size was set to 12.5 μm and 951 projections were acquired over 360° rotation. 3D data sets were rendered using Drishti software (Australian National University, Canberra).
Tissue samples were processed as described (7,15). Paraffin sections were used for hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) staining, Sirius red staining, Giemsa staining for transmitted light and fluorescence microscopy (32) and immunohistochemistry. Three-micron-thick sections were cut from GMA and PMMA embedded tissues and used for histomorphometry following von Kossa/methylene blue staining (7). Enzyme cytochemical reaction for alkaline phosphatase (Alp) and tartrate resistant acid phosphatase (Trap) were performed on undecalcified GMA embedded tissues as described (33). Immunolocalization of Sp7/Osterix was performed using the rabbit anti mouse Sp7/Osterix antiserum (#ab22552, ABCAM, Cambridge, UK), applied at 1:200 dilution, overnight at 4°C. A standard immunoperoxidase (DAB) reaction was used to reveal binding sites. Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) and Quantitative Back-Scattered Electrom (qBSE) imaging were performed as described (34,35,36–38).
Blood samples were collected from the jugular vein. The serum Fgf-23 levels were measured using a mouse Fgf-23 (C-Term) ELISA Kit (Immutopics Inc, San Clemente, CA) according to the manufacturer’s instructions.
Femora and tibiae were isolated from 6 month old mice and flushed with Hanks’ Balanced Salt Solution containing 1% FBS. The marrow cell suspension was then stained and analyzed by flow cytometry. The following antibodies were used: anti-CD43-PE (BD Pharmingen, San Jose, CA), anti-c-Kit-APCCy7 (BD Pharmingen), anti-Sca-1-FITC (BD Pharmingen), anti-B220-FITC (BD Pharmingen), anti-IL-7rα PECy7 (eBioscience, San Diego, CA, USA), anti-CD19-APCCy7 (BD Pharmingen), anti-IgM-APC (BD Pharmingen), anti-CD34-APC (BD Pharmingen). To analyze Lin− cells, total bone marrow cells were stained with a biotinylated Lin+ antibody cocktail of anti-CD4, anti-CD8, anti-NK1.1, anti-CD3, anti-CD11c, anti-B220, anti-CD19, anti-Gr1, anti-CD11b and anti-Ter119 (BD Pharmingen), followed by streptavidin-Pacific Blue (BD Pharmingen). FACS analyses were performed on a FACS Canto II running with the FACSDiva software (Becton Dickinson, Franklin Lakes, NJ, USA). In all analyses, propidium iodide was used to exclude dead cells. FACS analysis was done using the FlowJo (Treestar Inc., Ashland, OR, USA) software.
Two-tailed t-test with Welch’s correction for unpaired samples was performed using GraphPad Prism 5. Comparisons were deemed statistically significant when P <0.05.
Mice with osteoblast-specific expression of GsαR201C exhibited normal viability and fertility. Expression of the transgene was restricted to bone (Fig. 1A), uniform across the skeleton (Fig. 1B), and sustained throughout life. Excess production of cAMP was easily demonstrated in cultures of mature osteogenic cells derived either from calvariae or from trabecular bone (spine and tail vertebrae) (Fig. 1C). Expression of the transgene was not observed in cultures of BMSCs unless they were induced to differentiate into osteoblasts (Fig. 1D), confirming specific targeting of GsαR201C expression to mature cells within the osteogenic lineage. Transgenic mice were born free of skeletal abnormalities detectable by X-ray or histological analyses. However, a prominent skeletal phenotype developed in the postnatal life. The phenotype was identical in every respect in male and female mice. The earliest signs of a skeletal phenotype became obvious at around 3 weeks as an increased radiographic density in tail vertebrae, which progressed over time to a deforming excess of bone mass, radiographically detectable at 6 weeks (Fig. 1E). At 3 months, deformity of tail vertebrae was grossly apparent (“bumpy tail” phenotype, Fig. 1F) and the excess of bone was obvious in all skeletal segments (Fig. 1G), but with variable severity, symmetry and uniformity in individual mice (Suppl. Fig. 1).
X-ray and XMT analyses also demonstrated that the excess bone mass was not uniformly distributed in individual bones either, but affected or spared specific anatomical features, resulting in regular patterns of deformity in individual bones. In vertebrae (Fig. 2, top two rows), for example, endplates were normally configured and vestiges of the spinous and transverse processes were moderately affected, while zygapophyses were markedly deformed. In femora (Fig. 2, bottom row), femoral heads and condyles were neither misshapen nor deformed, and trochanters were only moderately affected. Over the extensor surface, overgrowth of bone spared the region in contact with the quadriceps muscle, resulting in the appearance of a groove. Most of the excess bone mass formed conspicuous lateral and posterior bulges in the subtrochanteric regions. Although an increase in bone mass was obvious in both cortical and cancellous regions, involvement of cortical bone was striking (Suppl. Movie 1, Suppl. Fig. 2). The excess cortical bone was permeated by a system of interconnected micropores, extending from the endosteal to the subperiosteal surface (Suppl. Movie 1). SEM and XMT analyses clearly demonstrated their connection to vascular and bone marrow spaces (Suppl. Movie 1, Suppl. Fig. 2)
The very shape of the massive bones of Col1a1-GsαR201C mice per se implied an excess of periosteal bone formation, which was easily confirmed by histological studies using different techniques (Fig. 3, Suppl. Fig. 3). In tail vertebrae from 2–6 month old mice, sites of neo-osteogenesis were localized to metaphyseal and subperiosteal, circumferential regions (Fig. 3A-ii and 3A-v, 3B, right). These regions extended up to the lateral aspect of the growth plates and endplates (a site equivalent, in tail vertebrae, to Ranvier’s grooves of long bones), where they formed “shoulders” of nascent periosteal bone, and included the complex system of metaphyseal apophyses characteristic of tail vertebrae (vestiges of transverse processes, zygapophyses). Nascent bone trabeculae were highly irregular in profile (Fig. 3A-iii) and woven in character (Fig 3A-vi, Suppl. Fig. 3D), and thus vaguely reminiscent of fibrous dysplastic bone in humans. However, the densely cellular osteogenic tissue giving rise to nascent bone (Suppl. 3B and C) did not include bona fide fibrotic tissue, as revealed by Sirius red-polarized light analysis (Fig. 3A-vi, Suppl. Fig. 3D) and its collagen content was limited to isolated fibers directly continuous with periosteal collagen. By quantitative backscattered electron (QBSE) microscopy, there was no overall reduction in bone mineral content in TG bone compared to WT (Fig. 3B). Lack of mineralized cartilage remnants in QBSE images (which would be seen as white) further denoted the non-endochondral origin of the nascent, excess cortical bone. Excess membranous ossification in the periosteum led to the generation of a system of nascent bone trabeculae, separated by a highly cellular tissue, directly continuous with the osteogenic periosteum (Fig. 3C, Suppl. Fig. 3B) and comprised of tightly packed cells with strong Alp activity at the plasma membrane (Fig. 3D) and expressing Osx (Fig. 3E) in the nucleus. Towards the mid-diaphysis, maturation of nascent bone into thicker and more interconnected bone trabeculae was noted. Not surprisingly, bone formation activity measured as ObS/BS % was significantly higher in TG mice compared to WT; dual calcein/alizarin red fluorescent labeling resulted in intense and ubiquitous labeling that could not be reliably measured as per standard histomorphometric techniques (not shown).
Consistent with an overtly abnormal osteoblast function in vivo, in vitro analysis of gene expression by differentiated BMSCs from TG and WT mice revealed a profound dysregulation of multiple markers and regulators of osteoblastic function (Fig. 4). Messenger RNA levels of Runx2, Osx, Alp and Col1a1 were normal in TG cells compared with WT cells. On the other hand, mRNA levels for Atf4 [a regulator of osteogenic genes (39)], and multiple markers of very late stages of osteogenic differentiation such as Ocn, Dmp-1, Phex and Sost were reduced in TG cells compared with WT. In contrast, mRNA levels for Fgf23, also thought to be predominantly expressed in late stages of osteogenic differentiation, were higher in TG osteoblastic cells compared with WT, and this finding was reflected in higher levels of total (C-term and intact) serum Fgf23 in TG mice compared with WT. Lastly, consistent with a reduced expression of the Wnt repressor, Sost, mRNA levels for the Wnt target gene, Lef-1, were increased in TG cells compared to WT, suggesting a functional link between the high bone mass phenotype and enhanced Wnt signaling in Col1a1-GsαR201Cmice.
Tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase staining of tail vertebrae from 3–6 months old TG mice demonstrated high osteoclastic resorption activity (Fig. 5A-i–iii), which grossly co-distributed with new bone formation activity as mapped by Alp staining (Suppl. Fig. 4, compare B and C). A wealth of mononuclear Trap-positive cells interspersed among the Alp-positive osteogenic cells documented high levels of osteoclastogenesis, in addition to obviously high numbers of osteoclasts. Interestingly, in spite of this, measurements of osteoclast numbers and surfaces per bone surface units failed to reveal differences between WT and TG mice (Fig. 5B). While counterintuitive, this finding was easily accounted for by the morphology of the thin, curvilinear bone trabeculae in TG mice, noted for a high surface complexity and as a result, surface length. Taken together, these data suggested that high bone formation activity was coupled with high resorption activity in cortical bone of TG mice. Serial X-ray analyses of individual mice at 3 and 6 months demonstrated that the deforming excess in bone mass peaked at 3 months and progressively declined thereafter (Fig. 5C), consistent with sustained levels of continued bone remodeling within the excess cortical bone. In the femur, the massive density seen in the distal half at 3 months was replaced, in the same individual bones, by patterns of cancellous bone and peculiar “bone-in-bone” (cortex-in-cortex) features (Fig. 5C, bottom panel). XMT analysis of femora dissected from 3 and 6 month old animals documented that these radiographic features arose from the replacement of previously massive cortical bone by cancellous bone; this ex-massive, newly cancellous bone merged directly, at the midshaft, with a system of lacunar spaces interspersed within massive cortical bone, and widely interconnected (Fig. 5D). SEM analysis of the walls delimiting such lacunar spaces directly documented the origin of such space from intracortical remodeling, by demonstrating a wealth of resorption bays over their surfaces (Suppl. Fig. 5A–D). Giemsa-stained sections (and QBSE images, not shown) demonstrated the aberrant presence of pseudo-Haversian systems [cortical bone does not normally include secondary osteonal Haversian systems in the mouse (Suppl. Fig. 6A)], further documenting the occurrence of extensive, protracted and ectopic intracortical bone remodeling in TG mice (Suppl. Fig. 6B–D).
In the femur, histological analysis demonstrated that the intracortical space, and spaces within the newly formed cancellous bone that, over time, replaced large portions of the massive cortical bone were, like the marrow cavity of long bones, occupied by hematopoietic (red) marrow (Fig. 6A and B). The aberrant, excessive, and ectopic remodeling of the cortical bone of Col1a1-GsαR201C mice (Fig. 6C) thus represented, in fact, the remodeling of bone into bone marrow space. Bone marrow tissue, however, was entirely free of fibrosis (Fig 6D), which characterizes fibrous dysplastic bone lesions in humans. All hematopoietic lineages were normally represented therein. Analysis of hematopoietic progenitor cell compartments in red marrow (from long bones of 6-months old Col1a1-GsαR201C mice) also failed to reveal changes. The HSC-containing fraction (Lin-/Sca-1+/c-kit+, LSK) was unchanged in frequency and absolute numbers. LSK/CD34− cells were also similar to wild-type mice. Numbers of CLP (Lin-/IL-7Ra+/Sca-1+/−/c-kit+/−), Pro-B (CD19+/CD43+/IgM-), Pre-B (CD19+/IgM-/CD43-) and immature B (CD19+/IgM+) cells were not significantly different from controls (Fig. 6E). Thus, while osteoblast-specific expression of GsαR201C did affect the gross distribution of hematopoietic bone marrow, it did not affect either its structure (lack of fibrosis) or its function, including the size of stem cell and progenitor compartments.
Different regions of the skeleton are normally occupied by either red (hematopoietically active) or yellow (adipose) marrow (40). While long bones including the femur are typical red marrow sites in the mouse, the tail vertebrae are typical sites of yellow (adipose) marrow, whose development begins postnatally and is completed within 3 weeks (data not shown). Just as continued remodeling of cortical bone expanded the space available for red marrow in long bones over time, continued remodeling in tail vertebrae gained space for yellow marrow (Fig. 7). While the excess bone formation impinged on bone marrow space in tail vertebrae, development of adipocytes from a local progenitor was not per se impaired. Development of adipocytes around sinusoids could actually be pinpointed in the inner parts of tail vertebrae at 3 months, and full-blown yellow marrow was clearly discernible at 6 months (Fig. 7A). Thus, in tail vertebrae, which are normally filled with yellow marrow, expression of the constitutively active GsαR201C did not impact on the type of marrow that formed. While osteoblasts and adipocytes have been claimed to represent positive (41) and negative (42) regulators of the hematopoietic stem cell niche and hematopoiesis, respectively, the change in their local balance in the tail vertebrae did not turn yellow marrow into red marrow; i.e., it did not establish ectopic hematopoietic activity in the tail at any time. Aside from the progressive increase in ectopic marrow space within cortical bone, no gross osteolysis was ever observed in TG mice of any age (Fig 7B). At any site, bone marrow tissue, whether red or yellow, whether located in the marrow cavity or in the newly established intracortical marrow space, did not show any signs of fibrosis (Fig. 7C). While marrow fibrosis, lack of adipocytes and local depletion of hematopoietic tissue are hallmark effects of Gsα activating mutations in human FD, none of these changes were reproduced by targeting GsαR201C expression to mouse osteoblasts.
We recently showed that constitutive, global expression of an FD-causing mutation results in a direct replica of human FD in the mouse (15), with gross, microscopic and even subtle features of FD pathology in humans. Data from this study demonstrate directly the effects of osteoblast-specific expression of GsαR201C. These effects, we have shown, fail to reproduce the defining features of human FD; i.e., marrow fibrosis, osteolysis, fracture, osteomalacia, and local disappearance of both marrow adipocytes and hematopoietic tissues from bone marrow. None of these effects, observed both in the human disease and in its recently developed mouse model (15), can thus be attributed to osteoblasts. As FD emanates from effects of the mutation on the osteogenic lineage, all of these effects must be attributed to cells in the stromal/osteogenic system distinct from the mature osteoblast, including osteogenic progenitors, as previously postulated based on in vivo models employing local transplantation of mutated human skeletal stem/osteoprogenitor cells (12). Of note, the characteristics of the human disease that are not reproduced by osteoblast-specific Gsα mutations in mice (notably, marrow fibrosis, local loss of hematopoietic tissue, local loss of adipocytes) are centered on the function of bone marrow stromal stem/progenitors rather than mature osteoblasts. Consistent with the lack of conspicuous structural or architectural changes in the bone marrow proper in our Col1a1-GsαR201C mice, we observed normal compartments of hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells, in the presence of normal skeletal progenitors and mutation-expressing osteoblasts. This is of specific interest in view of recent attention paid to osteoblasts as potential regulators of both the HSC niche (43–45) and B-lymphopoiesis (46), and of a putative role in this respect for Gsα expressed in osteoblasts proper (46). Our data, rather, lend support to the view that osteoprogenitors, but not mature osteoblasts, are the osteogenic cells more directly involved with hematopoietic progenitor regulation (47).
From our data, the sole effect of overactivity of Gsα in osteoblasts appears to be a marked increase in bone mass. This by default reflects in an altered shaping of marrow space during skeletal growth. The boundaries and relative volumes of bone and bone marrow do change as a result of osteoblast-specific expression of activating mutation of Gsα, but bone marrow structure and cellular composition do not. Furthermore, ectopic perivascular remodeling within cortical bone wins, over time, perivascular space for hematopoiesis, while the anatomical mapping of yellow and red bone marrow across the skeleton remain unchanged. Excess bone mass is a feature of FD of bone in humans, and specifically contributes to facial deformity, for example (1). However, excess bone mass is not an obligate feature of individual FD lesions, and never occurs in isolation in the context of FD (1). Interestingly, osteoblast-specific expression of GsαR201C, while failing to mimic the characteristic changes of FD and its overall pathology in the mouse, mimics human high bone mass phenotypes and disorders that are unrelated to Gsα and FD, such as sclerosteosis (48) and Van Buchem’s disease (49). These disorders represent the effects of loss-of-function mutations in SOST (50,51), a known Wnt inhibitor expressed in late stages of bone cell differentiation (52–55), which is otherwise known to be downregulated by agonists of the Gsα signaling pathway such as PTH (56–60). Consistent with these known effects of excess cAMP and with the excess of cAMP in osteoblastic cells of the Col1a1-GsαR201C mice, we observed a reduced expression of Sost and increased expression of the Wnt target gene, Lef1, in late stages of osteogenic cultures from Col1a1-GsαR201C mice. These results mirror precisely the opposite results obtained by using similar cultures from Gsα conditionally-deficient specifically in osteoblasts (46,61) and support the suggestion made by these authors that Gsα can act as a brake in late stages of osteoblastic differentiation via its effect on Wnt signaling (46). Likewise, the reduced expression of markers commonly regarded as “osteocytic” in our late stage cultures might mirror a delayed or disturbed osteoblast-to-osteocyte transition, even if in the context of an in vivo excess of woven bone, known to be enriched in osteocytes, but indeed, specifically in immature osteocytes. Overall, when in vitro data are matched to the overt in vivo phenotype of our mice, it is clear that these effects on very late stages of maturation of osteogenic cells are globally superseded by (and in fact contribute to), in vivo, a pronounced anabolic net effect of Gsα activity on bone formation and bone mass. A pronounced increase in bone mass was observed previously in other unrelated models in which excess Gsα signaling and cAMP production (in the presence of WT Gsα) take place, and can be predicted based on the nature of the transgene, residing upstream [a constitutively active PTH1R (41), and an engineered, overactive G protein coupled receptor (62)] or downstream [PKA (63)] of Gsα in the signaling pathway. A direct comparison of our model with mice of the same background (FVB/N) in which a constitutively active PTH1R was specifically expressed in osteoblasts by the same promoter we used (2.3kb Col1a1) (41) (Suppl. Fig. 7) reveals that the peculiar cortical bone phenotype induced by expressing an activating mutation of Gsα in osteoblasts is not mirrored by expression, in osteoblasts, of a constitutively active mutant of PTH1R, which predicts a similarly enhanced cAMP response (Suppl. Fig. 7). A divergent response of cortical and trabecular [actually, intramedullary (28)] bone in mice expressing a constitutively active PTH1R in osteoblasts had been noted previously (41). Our data now also reveal a divergent response of cortical bone itself to constitutively active Gsα vs. the Gsα-activating, constitutively active PTH1R and may suggest a specific, distinct, possibly PTH1R-independent role for Gsα in cortical bone.
Lastly, the deforming nature of the excess bone mass in our mice per se denotes a non-uniform effect of the transgene on cognate bone-forming cells existing at different anatomical sites (e.g., in tail vertebrae, endplates vs. main body; in femora, articular regions vs. midshaft). Specific regions undergo the most profound changes in individual bones in Col1a1-GsαR201Cmice, resulting in consistent patterns of deformity (bumpy tails, subtrochanteric bulges). Non-cell autonomous specifiers of the response of osteoblasts to the transgene may determine or contribute to these localized effects of the transgene. While PTH is commonly seen as the main agonist of the Gsα signaling pathway in bone, additional players such as β-adrenergic signals (known to operate in bone (64–69)) should not be overlooked. Elucidating further which ligands, in which physiological context, and through which downstream mediators [e.g., PKA-I and II, known to be differentially activated by different ligands and cognate receptors activating the cAMP pathway (70)] are the dominant triggers of activation of Gsα in different anatomical compartments of bone, in the osteogenic lineage, and in the stromal system thus appears to be an important step to undertake. This will improve our understanding of the physiology of Gsα signaling in the bone-bone marrow organ and of its derangements leading to development of FD lesions. These endeavors can be facilitated by the models that we have reported previously and herein.
This work was supported by grants from Telethon (Grant GGP09227), Fondazione Institut Pasteur-Cenci Bolognetti, MIUR, Ministry of Health, Sapienza University and EU (PluriMes consortium) to PB; Fondazione Roma to PB and MR; and by the DIR, NIDCR, of the IRP, NIH, DHHS (PGR, KH).
Authors’ contribution: CR, SM, KH, IS construct design and transgenesis; CR, ADC, SC, ES, BS, genotyping, mouse breeding, X-ray analysis, histology, cytochemistry, immunocytochemistry; CR, cell cultures, in vitro assays, QPCR; AB, SEM, QBSE, XMT; GD, XMT analysis; AC, bone marrow studies; CR, IS, AB, KH, PGR, MR, PB, experiment planning and data analysis and interpretation, writing and editing of manuscript; PB, project oversight.