Search tips
Search criteria 


Logo of materialsLink to Publisher's site
Materials (Basel). 2016 May; 9(5): 380.
Published online 2016 May 17. doi:  10.3390/ma9050380
PMCID: PMC5503073

Effects of Laser Power Level on Microstructural Properties and Phase Composition of Laser-Clad Fluorapatite/Zirconia Composite Coatings on Ti6Al4V Substrates

Jonathan Phillips, Academic Editor


Hydroxyapatite (HA) is one of the most commonly used materials for the coating of bioceramic titanium (Ti) alloys. However, HA has poor mechanical properties and a low bonding strength. Accordingly, the present study replaces HA with a composite coating material consisting of fluorapatite (FA) and 20 wt % yttria (3 mol %) stabilized zirconia (ZrO2, 3Y-TZP). The FA/ZrO2 coatings are deposited on Ti6Al4V substrates using a Nd:YAG laser cladding system with laser powers and travel speeds of 400 W/200 mm/min, 800 W/400 mm/min, and 1200 W/600 mm/min, respectively. The experimental results show that a significant inter-diffusion of the alloying elements occurs between the coating layer (CL) and the transition layer (TL). Consequently, a strong metallurgical bond is formed between them. During the cladding process, the ZrO2 is completely decomposed, while the FA is partially decomposed. As a result, the CLs of all the specimens consist mainly of FA, Ca4(PO4)2O (TTCP), CaF2, CaZrO3, CaTiO3 and monoclinic phase ZrO2 (m-ZrO2), together with a small amount of θ-Al2O3. As the laser power is increased, CaO, CaCO3 and trace amounts of tetragonal phase ZrO2 (t-ZrO2) also appear. As the laser power increases from 400 to 800 W, the CL hardness also increases as a result of microstructural refinement and densification. However, at the highest laser power of 1200 W, the CL hardness reduces significantly due to the formation of large amounts of relatively soft CaO and CaCO3 phase.

Keywords: fluorapatite, zirconia, laser cladding, laser power, composite coating

1. Introduction

Biomedical implants typically comprise a thin bioceramic coating deposited on a titanium (Ti) alloy substrate [1,2,3]. Of the various coating materials available, hydroxyapatite (Ca10(PO4)6(OH)2; HA) is one of the most commonly used since it has the same chemical composition and crystallographic structure as the apatite of living bones, and hence promotes early bonding between the implant and surrounding tissue [4,5,6,7]. HA coatings are generally deposited using a plasma spraying technique due to its short operation time, high accumulation rate, low processing cost, and low heat input. However, HA is intrinsically brittle, and hence the as-sprayed HA coatings generally have poor adhesion with the Ti substrate [8]. Moreover, under high temperature plasma spraying, the HA decomposes into impurities and low-crystallinity phases (e.g., tricalcium phosphate (Ca3(PO4)2), tetracalcium phosphate (Ca4(PO4)2O), and calcium oxide (CaO)). These phases cause the coating to delaminate or flake, and can therefore lead to various medical disorders [9]. Furthermore, the HA coating and Ti substrate have very different thermal expansion coefficients. Consequently, significant residual stress is formed at the interface between the coating and the substrate during the spraying process [9]. This residual stress prompts premature coating degradation and can lead to implant failure after long-term imbedding in the human body. As a result, the need for alternative coating materials with improved structural stability under high temperature conditions has emerged as a pressing concern in recent decades.

Fluorapatite (Ca10(PO4)6(F)2; FA) has a similar level of biological activity and biocompatibility in the human body as HA. However, FA has better thermal and chemical stability, and therefore reduces the risk of pyrolysis [10,11,12,13]. Furthermore, FA has a slow bio-resorption rate, and thus promotes bone fixing and bone ingrowth [14,15]. As a result, FA has attracted significant interest as a possible substitute for HA in biomedical implant applications [16,17,18]. Many studies have shown that the mechanical properties and biological performance of biomedical coating materials can be enhanced through the addition of secondary phases such as zirconia (ZrO2) or alumina (Al2O3) [19,20,21,22,23,24,25,26]. Among these phases, ZrO2 is a particularly attractive choice due to its relatively high mechanical strength and fracture toughness [23,24,25,26].

The excellent mechanical, electrical, thermal and optical properties of zirconia ceramics render them useful for many structural and functional applications [27,28,29,30]. In the biomedical field, yttria-stabilized tetragonal zirconia (Y-TZP) is widely used for dental restoration work due to its high biological safety and good hydrothermal stability [31]. Various studies have shown that 3 mol % yttria (3Y-TZP) provides an ideal stabilizing effect for zirconia [27,32]. However, even though FA is known to be more thermally and chemically stable than HA, the literature contains little information regarding the mechanical and biological properties of FA coatings mixed with ZrO2 [4,23,24,31]. Moreover, of those studies which have been performed, the coatings are generally prepared using sintering or plasma spraying techniques. In contrast to such methods, laser beams have high coherence and directionality, and thus have the potential to generate strong metallurgical bonds between the bioceramic coating layer and the substrate [33,34,35,36,37]. Consequently, the present study investigates the microstructural properties and phase composition of composite FA coatings containing 20 wt % yttria (3 mol %) stabilized zirconia (ZrO2, 3Y-TZP) deposited on Ti6Al4V substrates using a laser-cladding technique. As in previous studies by the present group [38,39,40], the laser cladding process is performed using an Nd:YAG laser system.

In laser cladding processes, the microstructural properties and phase composition of the coatings are significantly affected by three experimental parameters, namely the specific energy (Es = P/(V × D), P: power; V: travel speed; D: laser beam diameter), the laser power density (LPD = P/(πD2/4)) and the interaction time (t = D/V)). In the present study, the cladding process is performed using three different settings of the laser power and travel speed, namely 400 W/200 mm/min, 800 W/400 mm/min, and 1200 W/600 mm/min, respectively. In other words, the laser-power/travel-speed (P/V) ratio is equal to 2:1 in all of the cladding trials. Moreover, the laser spot diameter is equal to 3 mm (approximately) in every case. Consequently, the specific energy is a constant in the present study. By contrast, the laser power density increases as the laser power is increased from 400 W to 1200 W. Finally, the interaction time reduces as the travel speed increases.

2. Experiments

The cladding trials were performed using Ti6Al4V alloy plates with dimensions of 100 mm × 60 mm × 3.8 mm and the chemical composition shown in Table 1. The FA was prepared using Ca3(PO4)2 (β-TCP, β-tricalcium phosphate) and CaF2 (Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, MO, USA) powders in accordance with the solid state reaction 3Ca3(PO4)2 + CaF2 → Ca10(PO4)6F2 [41]. Briefly, the powders were mixed in a stoichiometric molar ratio of 3:1 and milled with ZrO2 balls in ethanol for 48 h. After drying, the powder was compacted and heated at 1000 °C for 3 h in air to form solid FA cylinders. The cylinders were then ground into powder and reinforced with 20 wt % commercial ZrO2 powder (3 mol % Y2O3, EE-TEC Inc., Zhongli, Taiwan). Prior to the reinforcement process, the atomic structures of the FA (JCPDS 15-0876) and ZrO2 (3Y-TZP, JCPDS 49-1642) powders were examined using XRD (Figure 1). No separate yttria peak was detected (i.e., the XRD patterns of ZrO2 (3Y-TZP) and TZP (tetragonal ZrO2, t-ZrO2) are very similar). The FA/ZrO2 powder was mixed with a polyvinyl alcohol binder ((C2H4O)n) in a 3:1 ratio (wt %) and stirred until a slurry-like consistency was obtained. As shown in Figure 2, the Ti6Al4V substrates used in the present study were milled with two slots (each with a size of 52 mm × 44 mm × 0.8 mm). The FA/ZrO2 + binder slurry was placed in each slot and the excess quantity removed using a stainless steel scraper. The substrate was then dried in an oven at 100 °C for 30 min under atmospheric conditions. Finally, the specimens were laser clad using an Nd:YAG laser system (ROFIN CW025, 2500 W; Rofin Sinar Technologies Inc., Hamburg, Germany) operating in a continuous-wave mode. For each specimen, the cladding process was limited to a single laser line scan.

Figure 1
XRD patterns of coating powders: FA and ZrO2 (3 mol % yttria (3Y-TZP), partially stabilized with 3 mol % Y2O3).
Figure 2
Schematic illustration of Ti6Al4V substrate (unit: mm).
Table 1
Chemical composition (wt %) of Ti6Al4V substrates.

As stated above, the cladding trials were performed using laser powers (P) and travel speeds (V) of 400 W/200 mm/min, 800 W/400 mm/min, and 1200 W/600 mm/min. The laser spot diameter was equal to approximately 3 mm in every case. Consequently, the specific energy (Es = P/(D × V)) for each coating was equal to 40 J/mm2. Furthermore, the laser power densities (LPD = P/(πD2/4)) for the three cases were 5.66, 11.32 and 16.98 kW/cm2, respectively. Finally, the interaction times (t = D/V) were 0.9, 0.45 and 0.3 s, respectively. The laser beam was guided to the workstation by an optical fiber with a core diameter of 600 µm and a focal length of 120 mm. The cladding process was performed in an Ar-shielded atmosphere (Ar flow rate: 25 L/min) with a 5° laser incident angle and a 15 mm positive defocus length. The experimental setup is shown in Figure 3.

Figure 3
(a) Schematic illustration of Nd-YAG laser cladding system which was controlled by the computer numerical control (CNC); and (b) photograph of experimental setup.

The microstructures of the clad specimens were observed using SEM (JEOL JSM-6390LV, JEOL Ltd., Tokyo, Japan). In addition, the phase compositions were examined using SEM and EDS. Moreover, the various phases were identified using XRD (Cu Kα radiation, Rigaku D/Max Ш.V, Rigaku Ltd., Tokyo, Japan) with a 2θ scanning range of 20°~70° and a scanning rate of 2° min−1. Finally, the hardness of the coatings was determined using a micro-Vickers hardness tester under a maximum indentation load of 300 g.

3. Results and Discussion

3.1. Morphology and Microstructure of Weld Beads

Figure 4 presents cross-sectional optical microscope (OM) images of the coating layers (CLs) and transition layers (TLs) of the three laser-clad specimens. As shown, for a constant Es, the depth, width and depth/width ratio (i.e., aspect ratio) of the TL all increase with an increasing laser power (see also Table 2). In addition, cracks are evident within the TLs of the specimens prepared at higher laser powers of 800 W and 1200 W, respectively. The severity of the cracks increases with increasing power.

Figure 4
Optical microscope images of weld beads in fluorapatite (FA)/ZrO2 laser-clad specimens: (a) 400 W, 200 mm/min; (b) 800 W, 400 mm/min; and (c) 1200 W, 600 mm/min. (Note: CL denotes coating layer and TL denotes transition layer).
Table 2
Depth-to-width ratio of TL in FA/ZrO2 specimens prepared using different laser powers.

Given the same laser spot size and thermal diffusivity of the substrate, the size and shape of the weld fusion zone (i.e., weld bead) formed in the laser cladding process depends on the laser power density (LPD). For a low LPD, the weld fusion zone tends to be shallow and bowl-shaped. By contrast, for higher LPDs, the fusion zone is deeper and has a higher aspect ratio [42]. In the present study, even though the LPD increases with an increasing laser power, the specific energy, Es, is fixed. Thus, it seems reasonable to assume that the weld fusion zone should have a similar profile for all three specimens. However, in maintaining a constant Es, the laser travel speed is increased proportionally with increasing laser power. In practice, the laser speed also affects the shape of the weld bead. Thus, as shown in Figure 3, the weld bead profile changes with a changing LPD despite the constant Es in every case.

Previous studies have shown that if the laser cladding parameters are not properly controlled, cracks are readily formed in the coating as a result of the thermal expansion mismatch between the coating and the substrate and relatively low toughness of the coating material [43]. As shown in Figure 4, cracks were not formed in any of the CLs. However, for the specimens prepared using laser powers of 800 W and 1200 W (i.e., a higher travel speed, heating rate and cooling rate), cracking occurred in the TL (see Figure 4b,c). The formation of these cracks is closely related to the residual stress generated during the cladding process [44]. Moreover, the stress increases with an increasing heating and cooling rate. The OM images in Figure 4b,c show that the cracks in the two specimens initiate within the TL, i.e., they do not spread from the CL. It is therefore concluded that the thermal expansion mismatch between the CL and the TL plays no role in prompting crack formation in the TL. In other words, crack initiation is dominated by the thermal stress generated by the rapid cooling rate of the substrate. More specifically, for a higher laser power (a higher laser travel speed), the cooling rate is increased. Consequently, the thermal shock within the TL is enhanced, and hence the crack severity increases. Furthermore, under a higher power level, the weld zone size also increases. As a result, a larger shrinkage stress is induced, and thus crack formation is further enhanced. Notably, however, the OM images in Figure 4 show that crack formation can be controlled through an appropriate setting of the laser power and travel speed parameters.

Figure 5 shows the surface microstructures of the CLs in the three laser-clad samples. It is seen that for all three samples, the coating has a fibrous-like morphology. Moreover, as the laser power increases, an increasing number of granular compounds are formed between the fibrous-like structures. The SEM images confirm the absence of microcracks in the CL. The lack of cracks is reasonable since the coefficients of thermal expansion (CTE) of FA and ZrO2 (3Y-TZP) (i.e., 9.1 × 10−6 K−1 [45] and 10~12 × 10−6 K−1 [46], respectively) are quite close to that of the Ti6Al4V substrate (8.8 × 10−6 K−1 [47]) in comparison to commonly used bioceramic coatings in the past, HA (15 × 10−6 K−1 [47]). Hence, only limited differential expansion between the CL and the TL occurs. The addition of ZrO2 particles with good mechanical strength and high fracture toughness further enhances the cohesive strength of the CL and suppresses microcrack formation. Therefore, the FA/ZrO2-substrate CTE mismatch is less than that for a HA/ZrO2-substrate system. Consequently, it can be inferred that the present FA/ZrO2 coatings have a better adhesive strength with the Ti6Al4V substrate than HA/ZrO2 coatings [8,29].

Figure 5
SEM metallographs of CL surface in FA/ZrO2 laser-clad specimens: (a) 400 W, 200 mm/min; (b) 800 W, 400 mm/min; and (c) 1200 W, 600 mm/min.

Figure 6 shows the interfacial microstructures of the CL and TL in the three specimens. The EDS analysis results (presented in Section 3.2) show that a significant diffusion of alloying elements occurs between the CL and TL. As a result, a strong metallurgical bond is formed between them [34]. The bonding strength of such an interface is greater than the mechanical bonding strength formed in general coating processes such as plasma spraying, sol-gel, and so on. Figure 7 presents SEM cross-sectional metallographs of the mid-section region of the CL in the various samples. Compared with the CL surface microstructures shown in Figure 5, the quantity of fibrous structures is reduced. However, a large number of spherical and irregularly-shaped particles are observed. For the sample prepared using a low laser power (400 W), the microstructure contains many flower-like structures. However, as the power increases, the flower-like structures are replaced with spherical-like particles. In general, the SEM images presented in Figure 6 and Figure 7 show that the higher cooling rate associated with an increased laser power results in significant microstructural refinement and densification of the CL.

Figure 6
SEM metallographs of CL/TL interface in FA/ZrO2 laser-clad specimens: (a) 400 W, 200 mm/min; (b) 800 W, 400 mm/min; and (c) 1200 W, 600 mm/min.
Figure 7
SEM metallographs of mid-section region of cross sectional CL in FA/ZrO2 laser-clad specimens: (a) 400 W, 200 mm/min; (b) 800 W, 400 mm/min; and (c) 1200 W, 600 mm/min.

3.2. Chemical Composition Analysis of Laser-Clad Coatings

Figure 8a presents an SEM image of the CL in the sample prepared using a laser power of 1200 W. Figure 8b,c shows the EDS analysis results for globular particles A and B in Figure 8a, respectively. As shown in Figure 8b, particle A consists mainly of Ti and P. The presence of TiP compounds (Ti phosphides) [48] suggests a partial thermal decomposition of the FA content in the CL during the high-temperature cladding process, accompanied by thermal-induced melting and diffusion of Ti from the substrate. As the laser power increases, the extent of FA decomposition and Ti melting/diffusion also increases, and hence Ti phosphides of a greater size are formed, as shown in Figure 7b,c. It is noted that the present results are consistent with those of Ye et al. [48], who showed that a large number of Ti phosphides (TixPy) were formed when sintering Ti/FA (1:1) composite powders under temperatures of 1100 °C or 1200 °C. In general, Ti phosphides can have a wide range of compositions, and it is thus difficult to reliably determine the exact composition of TixPy by XRD analysis alone [49]. Notably, the EDS results presented in Figure 8c, corresponding to particle B in Figure 8a, show that even under the maximum laser power of 1200 W, the CL matrix still contains a large amount of fluoride. In other words, the potential for FA residue or conversion to fluoride still exists even under high cladding temperatures, as discussed later in Section 3.3.

Figure 8
(a) SEM metallograph showing microstructure of CL in FA/ZrO2 specimen prepared using P = 1200 W and V = 600 mm/min; (b) EDS analysis results for particle A in (a); and (c) EDS analysis results for particle B in (a).

Figure 9 presents the EDS line scanning results for the individual alloying elements of the FA/ZrO2 cladding layer near the CL/TL interface in the specimen prepared using a laser power of 1200 W. It is seen that the Ca and F elements, i.e., the main decomposition components of FA, are confined almost entirely to the CL. Previous studies have shown that in the thermal decomposition of FA, F is either vaporized as HF gas or forms fluoride [24]. Thus, the F content in the CL layer most probably comes from the FA or fluoride, but requires further XRD analysis for confirmation (see Section 3.3). The P and O ions in the coating material have the ability to diffuse rapidly from the CL to the TL due to their small radii and low activation energy. Nonetheless, as shown in Figure 9, some ions still remain within the CL. It is noted, however, that some of the P ions produced in the FA decomposition process simply vaporize in the high-temperature cladding process [37,38,39,40]. Observing the results presented in Figure 9, it is seen that the distributions of Zr in the CL and TL, respectively, are roughly the same. In other words, given an addition of 20 wt % ZrO2 to the FA cladding material, a certain amount of Zr remains within the CL despite the high temperature diffusion effect. Furthermore, the TL retains a very high Ti content; with only a small amount of Ti diffusing to the CL. Overall, the EDS results reveal that while significant diffusion of the alloying elements occurs between the TL and the CL, the alloying elements in the TL are basically similar to the composition of the substrate, while those in the CL are similar to that of the coating material.

Figure 9Figure 9
EDS line scan results for Ca, P, O, Ti, F and Zr contents of CL and TL in FA/ZrO2 specimen prepared using P = 1200 W and V = 600 mm/min.

3.3. XRD Patterns of CL Surface

Figure 10 shows the XRD patterns of the CL surfaces in the three specimens. For the 400 W sample, the CL consists mainly of FA, TTCP (tetracalcium phosphate, Ca4(PO4)2O (JCPDS 25-1137), CaF2 (JCPDS 35-0816), CaZrO3 (JCPDS 35-0790), CaTiO3 (JCPDS 22-0153), m-ZrO2 (monoclinic phase ZrO2, JCPDS 88-2390) and a small amount of θ-Al2O3 (JCPDS 23-1009). For the 800 W specimen, the CL additionally contains CaO (JCPDS 37-1497), CaCO3 (JCPDS 47-1743) and a trace amount of t-ZrO2 (tetragonal phase ZrO2, JCPDS 80-0965). For the 1200 W specimen, the CL contains large quantities of CaO, CaCO3 and TTCP, but a lesser amount of CaTiO3. Furthermore, the quantity of t-ZrO2 increases, while that of m-ZrO2 and CaZrO3 decreases. Notably, the XRD pattern also indicates the presence of trace amounts of several unknown compounds in the CL. In general, the XRD results indicate a greater tendency toward compound phase formation in the CL as the laser power is increased.

Figure 10
XRD analysis results for CLs of FA/ZrO2 specimens prepared using different laser powers.

The FA powder used in the present study was prepared via a solid state reaction of Ca3(PO4)2 (TCP) and CaF2 at 1000 °C for 3 h. However, in the cladding process, the FA reverts to Ca3(PO4)2 and CaF2 in accordance with Reaction (1) if the temperature remains sufficiently high for a sufficiently long period of time [23,31]. For example, Nasiri-Tabrizi and Fahami [23] reported that a partial decomposition of FA to Ca3(PO4)2 and CaF2 occurs at 900 °C for 1 h in the presence of zirconia. However, at higher temperatures (i.e., greater than 1100 °C), CaF2 transforms to CaO through hydrolysis, as shown in Reaction (2) [50]. Thus, the high CaO content in the CL of the present specimen prepared using a high laser power of 1200 W is most likely the result of the thermally-induced hydrolysis of CaF2.

Ca10(PO4)6F2 → 3Ca3(PO4)2(TCP) + CaF2

CaF2 + H2O(g) → CaO + 2HF(g)

In high temperature processes, the decomposition of FA powder without oxide addition can be described by Reaction (3). (Note that Reaction (3) is equivalent to Reaction (1) + Reaction (2)). In other words, in high temperature processes, FA decomposes as TCP and CaO [24,50]. In the present study, ZrO2 is also added to the coating. The additional reactions which therefore take place under high density laser power irradiation are described by Reaction (4) below.

Ca10(PO4)6F2(s) + H2O(g) → 3Ca3(PO4)2(s) (TCP) + CaO(s) + 2HF(g)

Ca3(PO4)2(s) (TCP) + 2CaO(s) + ZrO2(s) → Ca4(PO4)2O (TTCP) + CaZrO3

Ben and Bouaziz [24] examined the decomposition of FA doped with ZrO2, and showed that given sufficient time and temperature, the decomposed TCP and CaO react with the ZrO2 to produce TTCP and CaZrO3. In addition, many researchers have analyzed the reaction between ZrO2 and CaO in accordance with Reaction (5) [4,24,29,51].

CaO(S) + ZrO2(S) → CaZrO3(S)

In the XRD patterns in Figure 10, a peak corresponding to the original ZrO2 powder (3Y-TZP, XRD pattern similar to t-ZrO2) is absent for the 400 W specimen. Moreover, only small quantities of ZrO2 are detected in the 800 W and 1200 W samples. In other words, most of the ZrO2 particles melt and undergo phase transformation during the laser cladding process. However, FA is still present in all three samples. Thus, it is inferred that even though the original FA powder melts completely during the laser-cladding process, the high thermal stability of the FA powder and the short residence time of the powder at high temperature result in only a partial decomposition of the FA to TTCP and CaO. However, as the laser power increases, the extent of FA decomposition also increases. Thus, for the specimens prepared using higher laser powers of 800 W and 1200 W, respectively, the intensity of the TTCP and CaO peaks in the XRD patterns increases.

Under the high temperatures produced during the laser cladding process, the ZrO2 particles reside in a molten state and the diffusion of Ca ions into the ZrO2 particles is enhanced. Consequently, CaZrO3 is formed during cooling in accordance with Reaction (5) above. Furthermore, CaO is unstable and reacts with CO2 to form calcium carbonate (CaCO3) in air [31]. As the temperature increases, more of the original FA powder decomposes as CaO, and hence the quantity of CaCO3 increases. In addition, Al2O3 is produced via the reaction between Al atoms diffused from the substrate and the coating material atoms or environmental O atoms. Finally, CaTiO3 is produced through a reaction between the decomposed or melted FA and the Ti6Al4V substrate.

For the 400 W sample, the XRD pattern indicates the presence of both m-ZrO2 and CaZrO3 compounds. For the sample prepared with a higher power of 800 W, the intensity of the m-ZrO2 and CaZrO3 peaks increases and a trace amount of t-ZrO2 emerges. However, for the sample prepared using the highest power of 1200 W, the intensity of the t-ZrO2 peak increases, but that of the m-ZrO2 and CaZrO3 peaks decreases. In other words, the original ZrO2 (3Y-TZP) powder melts more completely under high-energy laser irradiation. During the cooling and solidification phase, an allotropic transformation of the ZrO2 compound takes place from the cubic phase (c-ZrO2 2370–2680 °C (melting point)) to the tetragonal phase (t-ZrO2, 1170 °C–2370 °C), and finally to the monoclinic phase (m-ZrO2, room temperature–1170 °C) [32]. For laser cladding at 400 W, the t-ZrO2 phase has sufficient time to transform to m-ZrO2 due to the lower cooling rate (i.e., the lower travel speed). As a result, the ZrO2 exists almost entirely in the monoclinic phase. However, for higher laser powers of 800 W and 1200 W, respectively, insufficient time exists for t-ZrO2 transformationto m-ZrO2 and consequently the quantity of t-ZrO2 increases while that of m-ZrO2 decreases. Notably, no c-ZrO2 is observed in any of the XRD patterns in Figure 10. This finding suggests that the temperature required for c-ZrO2 formation is not maintained for a sufficient length of time during the cooling process, and hence the quantity of c-ZrO2 formed is too low to be detected via XRD analysis.

Ramachandra Rao and Kannan [26] and Nagarajan and Rao [51] showed that the CaO released during the sintering of HA/ZrO2 at temperatures of 1150 °C and above stabilizes the m-ZrO2 via a solid solution reaction, and prompts the formation of t-ZrO2. However, with the release of excess CaO through the further decomposition of FA, the solubility of Ca in ZrO2 exceeds the maximum solid solution range and hence CaZrO3 is formed in preference to t-ZrO2 [52,53]. Heimann and Vu [52] showed that when CaO is added to HA/ZrO2 composite sintered samples, the surplus CaO is effectively fixed by the ZrO2, which acts as a sink for the Ca2+ ions. Consequently, either t-ZrO2 or CaZrO3 is formed. Furthermore, according to the ZrO2-CaZrO3 phase diagram [54], the formation of CaZrO3 depends on the extent of CaO diffusion into ZrO2. Hence, a fuller decomposition of FA promotes the production of CaZrO3. However, in the present study, although the quantity of CaO increases significantly with an increasing laser power, that of t-ZrO2 increases only slightly. Furthermore, the quantity of CaZrO3 reduces under the highest laser power of 1200 W. By contrast, the quantity of CaCO3 increases significantly with an increasing laser power. This feature suggests that given a sufficiently high laser energy, the tendency of CaO and CO2 to react and form CaCO3 is higher than that of CaO and ZrO2 reacting to form CaZrO3. However, further investigation is required to confirm this inference and to clarify the related underlying mechanisms.

3.4. Micro-Hardness Evaluation

Figure 11 shows the cross-sectional hardness profiles of the various specimens from the CL (thickness approximately 0.2–0.3 mm) through the TL and into the substrate. For all three samples, the TL has a higher hardness than the CL, which in turn has a greater hardness than the substrate. Comparing the CL hardness values of the three samples, it is seen that the hardness increases from 1100 HV0.3 to 1300 HV0.3 as the laser-cladding power is increased from 400 W to 800 W, but then reduces to around 800 HV0.3 as the laser-cladding power is further increased to 1200 W. From inspection, the CL hardness of the three specimens is around 2~3 times higher than that of the Ti6Al4V substrate.

Figure 11
Cross-sectional hardness profiles of FA/ZrO2 specimens prepared using different laser powers.

The hardness of laser-clad coatings is related to both their microstructural characteristics (e.g., porosity and density) and their phase constituents [41,43,55]. For the present samples, the CL microstructure exhibits a greater refinement and densification effect as the laser power (travel speed) increases (see Figure 6). Consequently, the hardness increases. The phase constituents of the CL can be ranked in order of decreasing hardness as ZrO2 > CaF2 > CaO > CaCO3 [56]. As shown in the XRD patterns in Figure 10, the sample prepared using a laser power of 1200 W has a high CaO and CaCO3 (low hardness) content. Thus, the microstructure-induced hardness enhancement is outweighed by the softening effect of the CaO and CaCO3 phases, and consequently a reduction in the CL hardness occurs.

Chien et al. [57] showed that the average hardness of the CL formed in the laser cladding of pure FA on Ti6Al4V substrates was equal to 617 HV0.3 for a laser power of 740 W and 750 HV0.3 for a laser power of 1150 W. It is noted that these hardness values are significantly lower than those obtained in the present study. The laser source and laser cladding parameters are similar in both cases. Hence, it is inferred that the higher CL hardness of the present specimens is due to the addition of ZrO2 to the FA matrix. Kim et al. [41] prepared sintered FA samples containing 20 and 40 vol % ZrO2 powder, respectively, and found that the hardness increased with an increasing ZrO2 content. Ouyang et al. [43] used a laser-cladding process to deposit yttria partially stabilized ZrO2 (7 wt %) ceramic coatings doped with 2.5 wt % TiO2 on aluminum alloy substrates. The cladding layer was found to have a hardness of 1415~1575 HV0.1. This value is greater than that observed for the present coatings. Kim et al. [41] conducted sintering trials using HA and FA powders doped with 20 vol % ZrO2. The results showed that the FA-ZrO2 composites had a greater hardness (~8 GPa) than the HA-ZrO2 samples (~1 GPa). Various studies have attributed the greater hardness of laser-clad ZrO2 or ZrO2 composite coatings to the absence of porosity and a fine-grained structure [41,43]. However, the present results suggest that the hardness is actually determined by a competition process between the microstructural hardening effects and the phase composition softening effects.

4. Conclusions

The present study has deposited composite coatings consisting of fluorapatite (FA) and 20 wt % yttria (3 mol %) stabilized zirconia (ZrO2, 3Y-TZP) on Ti6Al4V substrates using a laser cladding process with laser powers and travel speeds of 400 W/200 mm/min, 800 W/400 mm/min, and 1200 W/600 mm/min, respectively. The experimental findings support the following main conclusions.

  1. The depth, width and depth/width ratio of the TL increase with an increasing laser power (travel speed). For the 800 W and 1200 W specimens, cracks are formed in the TL due to the greater cooling rate and larger weld zone (i.e., greater shrinkage stress). However, no cracks are formed in the CL due to the addition of ZrO2 to the FA powder and the relatively small CTE mismatch between the FA/ZrO2 powders and the substrate.
  2. A significant diffusion of alloying elements occurs between the CL and the TL. As a result, a good metallurgical bond is formed between them. Overall, the alloying elements of the TL are close to the composition of the substrate, while the alloying elements of the CL are close to the composition of the coating material.
  3. The CL of the 400 W specimen consists mainly of FA, TTCP, CaF2, CaZrO3, CaTiO3, m-ZrO2 and a small amount of θ-Al2O3. For the 800 W specimen, the CL also contains CaO, CaCO3 and trace amounts of t-ZrO2. For the highest laser power of 1200 W, the CaO, CaCO3 and TTCP contents of the CL increase significantly. The t-ZrO2 content also increases. However, that of m-ZrO2 and CaZrO3 reduces. In general, the tendency to form composite phases increases as the laser power increases.
  4. For all of the specimens, the TL has a greater hardness than the CL. Moreover, the CL hardness is around 2~3 times higher than that of the Ti6Al4V substrate. As the laser power increases from 400 W to 800 W, the CL hardness increases due to a microstructural refinement and densification effect. However, under the highest laser power of 1200 W, the hardness reduces significantly due to the formation of CaO and CaCO3 phases with relatively low hardness.


The authors gratefully acknowledge the financial support provided to this research by the Chi Mei Foundation Hospital, China (Taiwan), under Grant Number 110990223 and the Ministry of Science and Technology of China (Taiwan) under Grant Number NSC 101-2221-E-218-017.

Author Contributions

Author Contributions

Chi-Sheng Chien, Cheng-Wei Liu and Tsung-Yuan Kuo conceived and designed the experiments; Chi-Sheng Chien and Cheng-Wei Liu performed the experiments; Chi-Sheng Chien, Cheng-Wei Liu and Tsung-Yuan Kuo analyzed the data and discussed the experiment; Chi-Sheng Chien and Tsung-Yuan Kuo wrote the paper. The manuscript was reviewed by all authors.

Conflicts of Interest

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.


1. Zhao Y.T., Zhang Z., Dai Q.X., Lin D.Y., Li S.M. Microstructure and bond strength of HA(+ZrO2 + Y2O3)/Ti6Al4V composite coatings fabricated by RF magnetron sputtering. Surf. Coat. Technol. 2006;200:5354–5363. doi: 10.1016/j.surfcoat.2005.06.010. [Cross Ref]
2. Wang B.C., Chang E., Yang C.Y., Tu D. A histomorphometric study on osteoconduction and osseointegration of titanium alloy with and without plasma-sprayed hydroxyapatite coating using back-scattered electron images. J. Mater. Sci. Mater. Med. 1993;4:394–403. doi: 10.1007/BF00122198. [Cross Ref]
3. Savarino L., Fini M., Ciapetti G., Cenni E., Granchi D., Baldini N., Greco M., Rizzi G., Giardino R., Giunti A. Biologic effects of surface roughness and fluorhydroxyapatite coating on osteointegration in external fixation systems: An in vivo experimental study. J. Biomed. Mater. Res. A. 2003;66:652–661. doi: 10.1002/jbm.a.10018. [PubMed] [Cross Ref]
4. Khor K.A., Fu L., Lim V.J.P., Cheang P. The effects of ZrO2 on the phase compositions of plasma sprayed HA/YSZ composite coatings. Mater. Sci. Eng. A. 2000;276:160–166. doi: 10.1016/S0921-5093(99)00495-5. [Cross Ref]
5. De Bruijn J.D., van Blitterswijk C.A., Davies J.E. Initial bone matrix formation at the hydroxyapatite interface in vivo. J. Biomed. Mater. Res. 1995;29:89–99. doi: 10.1002/jbm.820290113. [PubMed] [Cross Ref]
6. Oonishi H., Iwaki Y., Kin N., Kushitani S., Murata N., Wakitani S., Imoto K. Hydroxyapatite in revision of total hip replacements with massive acetabular defects. J. Bone Jt. Surg. 1997;79B:87–92. doi: 10.1302/0301-620X.79B1.1290. [PubMed] [Cross Ref]
7. Sun L., Berndt C.C., Gross K.A., Kucuk A. Material fundamentals and clinical performance of plasma-sprayed hydroxyapatite coatings: A review. J. Biomed. Mater. Res. 2001;58:570–592. doi: 10.1002/jbm.1056. [PubMed] [Cross Ref]
8. Li H., Li Z.X., Li H., Wu Y.Z., Wei Q. Characterization of plasma sprayed hydroxyapatite/ZrO2 graded coating. Mater. Des. 2009;30:3920–3924. doi: 10.1016/j.matdes.2009.02.002. [Cross Ref]
9. Wang G., Zreiqat H. Review—Functional coatings or films for hard-tissue applications. Materials. 2010;3:3994–4050. doi: 10.3390/ma3073994. [Cross Ref]
10. Chen Y., Miao X. Thermal and chemical stability of fluorohydroxyapatite ceramics with different fluorine contents. Biomaterials. 2005;26:1205–1210. doi: 10.1016/j.biomaterials.2004.04.027. [PubMed] [Cross Ref]
11. Rawls H.R., Zimmerman B.F. Fluoride-exchanging resins for caries for caries protection. Caries Res. 1983;17:32–43. doi: 10.1159/000260646. [PubMed] [Cross Ref]
12. Bhadang K.A., Gross K.A. Influence of fluorapatite on the properties of thermally sprayed hydroxyapatite coatings. Biomaterials. 2004;25:4935–4945. doi: 10.1016/j.biomaterials.2004.02.043. [PubMed] [Cross Ref]
13. Weng J., Liu X., Zhang X., Ji X. Thermal decomposition of hydroxyapatite structure induced by titanium and its dioxide. J. Mater. Sci. Lett. 1994;13:159–161. doi: 10.1007/BF00278148. [Cross Ref]
14. Moreno E.C., Kresak M., Zahradnik R.T. Fluoridated hydroxyapatite solubility and caries formation. Nature. 1974;247:64–65. doi: 10.1038/247064a0. [PubMed] [Cross Ref]
15. Ingram G.S., Nash P.F. Mechanism for the anticaries action of fluoride. Caries Res. 1980;14:298–303. doi: 10.1159/000260467. [PubMed] [Cross Ref]
16. Al-Noaman A., Karpukhina N., Rawlinson S.C.F., Hill R.G. Effect of FA on bioactivity of bioactive glass coating for titanium dental implant. Part I: Composite powder. J. Non-Cryst. Solids. 2013;364:92–98. doi: 10.1016/j.jnoncrysol.2012.11.051. [Cross Ref]
17. Dhert W.J., Klein C.P., Jansen J.A., van der Velde E.A., Vriesde R.C., Rozing P.M., de Groot K. A histological and histomorphometrical investigation of fluorapatite, magnesiumwhitlockite, and hydroxylapatite plasma-sprayed coatings in goats. J. Biomed. Mater. Res. 1993;27:127–138. doi: 10.1002/jbm.820270116. [PubMed] [Cross Ref]
18. Wei M., Evans J.H., Bostrom T., Grøndahl L. Synthesis and characterization of hydroxyapatite, fluoride-substituted hydroxyapatite and fluorapatite. J. Mater. Sci. Mater. Med. 2003;14:311–320. doi: 10.1023/A:1022975730730. [PubMed] [Cross Ref]
19. Viswanath B., Ravishankar N. Interfacial reactions in hydroxyapatite/alumina nanocomposites. Scr. Mater. 2006;55:863–866. doi: 10.1016/j.scriptamat.2006.07.049. [Cross Ref]
20. Suchanek W., Yoshimura M. Processing and properties of hydroxyapatite-based biomaterials for use as hard tissue replacement implants. J. Mater. Res. 1998;13:94–117. doi: 10.1557/JMR.1998.0015. [Cross Ref]
21. Gautier S., Champion E., Bernache-Assollant D. Processing, microstructure and toughness of Al2O3 platelet-reinforced hydroxyapatite. J. Eur. Ceram. Soc. 1997;17:1361–1369. doi: 10.1016/S0955-2219(97)89403-4. [Cross Ref]
22. Li J., Fartash B., Hermansson L. Hydroxyapatite-alumina composites and bone-bonding. Biomaterials. 1995;16:417–422. doi: 10.1016/0142-9612(95)98860-G. [PubMed] [Cross Ref]
23. Nasiri-Tabrizi B., Fahami A. Synthesis and characterization of fluorapatite-zirconia composite nanopowders. Ceram. Int. 2013;39:4329–4337. doi: 10.1016/j.ceramint.2012.11.016. [Cross Ref]
24. Ben Ayed F., Bouaziz J. Sintering of tricalcium phosphate-fluorapatite composites with zirconia. J. Eur. Ceram. Soc. 2008;28:1995–2002. doi: 10.1016/j.jeurceramsoc.2008.02.004. [Cross Ref]
25. Ramachandra Rao R., Kannan T.S. Synthesis and sintering of hydroxyapatite-zirconia composites. Mater. Sci. Eng. C. 2002;20:187–193. doi: 10.1016/S0928-4931(02)00031-0. [Cross Ref]
26. Sallemi I., Bouaziz J., Ben Ayed F. Elaboration and characterization of bioceramic based on tricalcium phosphate and zirconia. Int. J. Curr. Eng. Technol. 2013;3:1691–1700.
27. Song J.H., Lee J.H. Glycothermal synthesis and characterization of 3Y-TZP nanoparticles. Korean J. Mater. Res. 2009;19:412–416. doi: 10.3740/MRSK.2009.19.8.412. [Cross Ref]
28. Subbara E.C. In: Science and Technology of Zirconia. Heuer A.H., Hobbs A.H., editors. Volume 3. The American Society; Columbus, OH, USA: 1981. pp. 1–24.
29. Chou B.Y., Chang E., Yao S.Y., Chen J.M. Phase transformation during plasma spraying of hydroxyapatite—10-wt %-zirconia composite coating. J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 2002;85:661–669. doi: 10.1111/j.1151-2916.2002.tb00147.x. [Cross Ref]
30. Butler E.P. Transformation-toughened zirconia ceramics. Mater. Sci. Technol. 1985;1:417–432. doi: 10.1179/mst.1985.1.6.417. [Cross Ref]
31. Nasiri-Tabrizi B., Fahami A. Reaction mechanisms of synthesis and decomposition of fluorapatite-zirconia composite nanopowders. Ceram. Int. 2013;39:5125–5136. doi: 10.1016/j.ceramint.2012.12.008. [Cross Ref]
32. Piconi C., Maccauro G. Review—Zirconia as a ceramic biomaterial. Biomaterials. 1999;20:1–25. doi: 10.1016/S0142-9612(98)00010-6. [PubMed] [Cross Ref]
33. Tlotleng M., Akinlabi E., Shukla M., Pityana S. Microstructures, hardness and bioactivity of hydroxyapatite coatings deposited by direct laser melting process. Mater. Sci. Eng. C. 2014;43:189–198. doi: 10.1016/j.msec.2014.06.032. [PubMed] [Cross Ref]
34. Wang D.G., Chen C.Z., Ma J., Lei T.Q. Microstructure of yttric calcium phosphate bioceramic coatings synthesized by laser cladding. Appl. Surf. Sci. 2007;253:4016–4020. doi: 10.1016/j.apsusc.2006.08.036. [Cross Ref]
35. Cheng G.J., Pirzada D., Cai M., Mohanty P., Bandyopadhyay A. Bioceramic coating of hydroxyapatite on titanium substrate with Nd-YAG laser. Mater. Sci. Eng. C. 2005;25:541–547. doi: 10.1016/j.msec.2005.05.002. [Cross Ref]
36. Chien C.S., Hong T.F., Han T.J., Kuo T.Y., Liao T.Y. Effects of different binders on microstructure and phase composition of hydroxyapatite Nd-YAG laser clad coatings. Appl. Surf. Sci. 2011;257:2387–2393. doi: 10.1016/j.apsusc.2010.09.108. [Cross Ref]
37. Chien C.S., Liao T.Y., Hong T.F., Kuo T.Y., Chang C.H., Yeh M.L., Lee T.M. Surface microstructure and bioactivity of hydroxyapatite and fluorapatite coatings deposited on Ti-6Al-4V substrates using Nd-YAG laser. J. Med. Biol. Eng. 2014;34:109–115. doi: 10.5405/jmbe.1379. [Cross Ref]
38. Chien C.S., Ke Y.S., Kuo T.Y., Liao T.Y., Lee T.M., Hong T.F. Effect of TiO2 addition on surface microstructure and bioactivity of fluorapatite coatings deposited using Nd:YAG laser. Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng. H. 2014;228:379–387. doi: 10.1177/0954411914528307. [PubMed] [Cross Ref]
39. Chien C.S., Ke Y.S., Kuo T.Y., Liao T.Y., Lin H.C., Lee T.M. Surface properties and in vitro bioactivity of fluorapatite/TiO2 coatings deposited on Ti substrates by Nd:YAG laser cladding. J. Med. Biol. Eng. 2015;35:357–366. doi: 10.1007/s40846-015-0048-1. [Cross Ref]
40. Chien C.S., Liu C.W., Kuo T.Y., Wu C.C., Hong T.F. Bioactivity of fluorapatite/alumina composite coatings deposited on Ti6Al4V substrates by laser cladding. Appl. Phys. A. 2016;122 doi: 10.1007/s00339-016-9788-1. [Cross Ref]
41. Kim H.W., Kong Y.M., Koh Y.H., Kim H.E., Kim H.M., Ko J.S. Pressureless sintering and mechanical and biological properties of fluor-hydroxyapatite composites with zirconia. J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 2003;86:2019–2026. doi: 10.1111/j.1151-2916.2003.tb03602.x. [Cross Ref]
42. Kelkar G. Pulsed Laser Welding. WJM Technology; Cerritos, CA, USA: [(accessed on 29 July 2011)]. Available online:
43. Ouyang J.H., Nowotny S., Richter A., Beyer E. Laser cladding of yttria partially stabilized ZrO2 (YPSZ) ceramic coatings on aluminum alloys. Ceram. Int. 2001;27:15–24. doi: 10.1016/S0272-8842(00)00036-5. [Cross Ref]
44. Song W., Zhu P., Cui K. Effect of Ni content on cracking susceptibility and microstructure of laser-clad Fe-Cr-Ni-B-Si alloy. Surf. Coat. Technol. 1996;80:279–282.
45. Zhang S., Zeng X., Wang Y., Cheng K., Weng W. Adhesion strength of sol-gel derived fluoridated hydroxyapatite coatings. Surf. Coat. Technol. 2006;200:6350–6354. doi: 10.1016/j.surfcoat.2005.11.033. [Cross Ref]
46. Scardi P., Leoni M., Bertamini L. Residual stresses in plasma sprayed partially stabilized zirconia TBCs: Influence of the deposition temperature. Thin Solid Films. 1996;278:96–103. doi: 10.1016/0040-6090(95)08163-1. [Cross Ref]
47. Zheng X.B., Ding C.X. Characterization of plasma sprayed hydroxyapatite/TiO2 composite coatings. J. Therm. Spray Technol. 2000;9:520–525. doi: 10.1007/BF02608556. [Cross Ref]
48. Ye H., Liu X.Y., Hong H. Fabrication of titanium/fluorapatite composites and in vitro behavior in simulated body fluid. J. Mater. Sci. Technol. 2013;29:523–532. doi: 10.1016/j.jmst.2013.01.013. [Cross Ref]
49. Ninga C.Q., Zhoub Y. On the microstructure of biocomposites sintered from Ti, HA and bioactive glass. Biomaterials. 2004;25:3379–3387. doi: 10.1016/j.biomaterials.2003.10.017. [PubMed] [Cross Ref]
50. Ben Ayed F., Bouaziz J., Bouzouita K. Calcination and sintering of fluorapatite under argon atmosphere. J. Alloys Compd. 2001;322:238–245. doi: 10.1016/S0925-8388(01)01200-2. [Cross Ref]
51. Nagarajan V.S., Rao K.J. Structural, mechanical and biocompatibility studies of hydroxyapatite-derived composites toughened by zirconia addition. J. Mater. Chem. 1993;3:43–51. doi: 10.1039/jm9930300043. [Cross Ref]
52. Heimann R.B., Vu T.A. Effect of CaO on thermal decomposition during sintering of composite hydroxyapatite-zirconia mixtures for monolithic bioceramic implants. J. Mater. Sci. Lett. 1997;16:437–439. doi: 10.1023/A:1018591605388. [Cross Ref]
53. Wu J.M., Yeh T.S. Sintering of hydroxyapatite-zirconia composite materials. J. Mater. Sci. 1988;23:3771–3777. doi: 10.1007/BF00540526. [Cross Ref]
54. Stubican V.S., Ray S.P. Phase equilibria and ordering in the system ZrO2-CaO. J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 1977;60:534–537. doi: 10.1111/j.1151-2916.1977.tb14100.x. [Cross Ref]
55. Li J., Chen C. Effect of ZrO2 (YPSZ) on microstructure characteristic and wear resistance of theTi3Al/TiC laser-cladded ceramic layer on titanium alloy. Int. J. Appl. Ceram. Technol. 2012;9:947–952. doi: 10.1111/j.1744-7402.2011.02692.x. [Cross Ref]
56. Hardness of Minerals Va: Variation among Oxides and Oxysalts. [(accessed on 29 January 2008)]. Available online:
57. Chien C.S., Liao T.Y., Hong T.F., Kuo T.Y., Wu J.L., Lee T.M. Investigation into microstructural properties of fluorapatite Nd-YAG laser clad coatings with PVA and WG binders. Surf. Coat. Technol. 2011;205:3141–3146. doi: 10.1016/j.surfcoat.2010.11.028. [Cross Ref]

Articles from Materials are provided here courtesy of Multidisciplinary Digital Publishing Institute (MDPI)