At this time, there are more than 23
Helicobacter species (
6,
14), and more species are being identified. Some of these non-
H. pylori species are found in clinical samples, and others colonize animals (
18). This diversity of
Helicobacter species creates a challenge for the detection of
H. pylori from environmental waters. The aim of this study was to develop a specific method for rapid detection of
H. pylori and to be able to selectively identify
H. pylori in mixed microbial communities.
The detection of
H. pylori is critical due to the high prevalence of this species, its worldwide distribution, and the large number of individuals carrying this species (
7,
10,
11,
16,
38,
41,
46). In addition,
H. pylori cells have the ability to form resistant, coccoid forms.
H. pylori cells in the coccoid stage cannot be cultured and can be detected only by culture-independent strategies (
5,
38).
H. pylori-specific probes that target the 16S rRNA, urease (
ureA), and phosphoglucosamine mutase (
glmM) (
4,
28) genes have been proposed. The 16S ribosomal DNA and
ureA primers did not detect all of the
Helicobacter spp. under the reaction conditions described (data not shown). Results with a wide spectrum of bacteria tested in this study showed that the primers for
glmM were selective for
Helicobacter spp. and did not amplify products from non-
Helicobacter spp.
In order to determine whether the assay was selective for
Helicobacter spp., DNA from other species of
Helicobacter and the closely related genus
Campylobacter was tested under the same conditions. Initial results showed that although the assay detected all
Helicobacter species,
Campylobacter species were also detected (data not shown). Reaction conditions were modified to develop a more stringent assay specific for
Helicobacter spp. as described in Materials and Methods. After this optimization, results showed that only
Helicobacter spp. were detected, and several environmental strains of the closely related genus
Campylobacter no longer yielded amplification products (Fig. ). The PCR-based method targeting
glmM was previously proposed by Lu et al. in 1999 (
28), but they did not report whether the PCR method was tested on any other
Helicobacter species. Bickley et al. (
4) found that this PCR test was specific to
H. pylori and did not yield any products when tested on five other species of
Helicobacter. We found that this PCR assay using the same primers yielded positive results for
H. pylori and some other
Helicobacter spp. tested.
To overcome this limitation, another set of PCR-based strategies was evaluated to identify H. pylori from cultures and water microcosms. The target for this PCR was a unique sequence flanking a 16S rRNA gene sequence in H. pylori.
The ISR between the 16S and the 23S rRNA genes has been the target for designing species- and even strain-specific molecular probes. This has been possible due to the high inter- and intraspecific variability (
8,
17,
33,
34,
40). The advantage of this region is that the flanking 16S and 23S rRNA genes at the 5′ and 3′ ends of the ISR contain highly conserved sequences (i.e., the 16S and 23S rRNA genes). Thus, conserved primers can be used for the selective amplification of ISR from bacterial species. However, in
H. pylori, a ribosomal 16S rRNA gene is not followed in the genome sequence by the 23S rRNA gene. The rRNA operon structure of
H. pylori has an atypical bacterial rRNA operon structure, as 16S rRNA sequences are physically removed from the 23S and 5S rRNA sequences and positioned on different DNA strands. There are two sets of rRNA genes in the genomes of
H. pylori strains. The 16S rRNA genes for strain J99 are located on the plus strand at positions 1188029 to 1189529 and 1463047 to 1464547, and the 16S rRNA genes for strain 26995 are located on the plus strand at positions 1207583 to 1209081 and 1511137 to 1512634. The associated primary transcript is synonymous with the minus strand. These regions lack the context of the typical hypervariable ISR of the rRNA operon found in other bacteria. The intervening region is poorly conserved. This pairing is specific for one of the copies of the 16S rRNA gene, and no suitably conserved region was identified for the other copy of the gene.
A nonstandard ISR is present in H. pylori. Nevertheless, a highly variable region, likely a remnant of its primitive ISR, is followed by a short conserved sequence which could be used for the design of a diagnostic probe for PCR amplification.
We designed a primer pair specific for H. pylori (Cluster2 and B199 primers) and evaluated its specificity in discriminating non-H. pylori species while uniquely identifying H. pylori. The first primer (B1J99) overlaps the 16S rRNA sequence and is synonymous with the primary transcript to avoid hybridization with 16S rRNA. The second (Cluster2) represents a sequence conserved between H. pylori J99 and H. pylori 26695, about 1,000 bases upstream on the opposite strand. We have sequenced and compared this conserved region from a number of H. pylori strains. The length of this region ranges from 992 to 1,548 bp, depending on the H. pylori strain.
Experimental testing of the PCR primer pair resulted in a high specificity for detecting
H. pylori strains. PCR amplification targeting this hypervariable region showed positive results for every
H. pylori strain tested and negative results for every
Helicobacter species (non-
H. pylori species) and other bacterial species tested. These results suggest that the proposed primer set resulted in a specific detection strategy for
H. pylori from cultures, clinical, and environmental samples. In addition, the proposed PCR detection strategy for
H. pylori using the 16S rRNA hypervariable region complements the results obtained by PCR amplification with
glmM-specific primers. While the use of
glmM-specific primers allows the detection of
Helicobacter species (both
H. pylori and other species of the genus), PCR amplifications based on the proposed primers specific for the region flanking the 16S rRNA gene of
H. pylori discriminate the non-
H. pylori species of this genus. Furthermore, sequence comparison using the proposed hypervariable region upstream of the 16S rRNA gene of
H. pylori can be an easy way to distinguish
H. pylori strains, since these sequences are highly specific for each
H. pylori strain. For this purpose, these sequences have been deposited in the GenBank DNA database (accession no.
AY505018 to
AY505034,
AY505037 to
AY505043, and
AY505045) and they are available for homology searches using BLAST (
3) in future applications and rapid identification methods.
In addition, PCR amplification using the proposed primers allows detection not only of
H. pylori but also of
H. pylori strains, as the amplified product can be used to differentiate strains of this species. Review of the literature has not revealed other published studies that used PCR amplification targeting the proposed hypervariable region upstream of the 16S rRNA gene in
H. pylori. The specificity and sensitivity of these primers, particularly the primers containing the region flanking the 16S rRNA gene, will significantly help to accurately and rapidly detect
H. pylori in environmental waters, including drinking water, well water, and river water. This is the first report proposing the use of this DNA sequence for the rapid detection and identification of
H. pylori in both helical and coccoid forms. Recent published data indicate that
H. pylori can be detected in different water samples (
5,
15,
20,
29,
32). Culturing techniques are not an option for most of these samples due to conversion of the bacterium to the nonculturable coccoid form. Although the PCR detection system does not distinguish viable from nonviable bacteria in any given sample, our combination PCR-based approach provides the effective presumptive assay for determining the presence of
H. pylori in cultures and in environmental water samples on the same day. Since the coccoid form of
H. pylori represents a persistent form which can exist in water for long periods of time, positive results obtained by using these probes could indicate the presence of such cells.