|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
Conceived and designed the experiments: MOP HL NC GK VS CQ EB. Performed the experiments: MOP HL. Analyzed the data: MOP HL. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: GK. Wrote the paper: MOP HL NC CQ VS EB.
The molecular chaperone Hsp90 is essential in eukaryotes, in which it facilitates the folding of developmental regulators and signal transduction proteins known as Hsp90 clients. In contrast, Hsp90 is not essential in bacteria, and a broad characterization of its molecular and organismal function is lacking. To enable such characterization, we used a genome-scale phylogenetic analysis to identify genes that co-evolve with bacterial Hsp90. We find that genes whose gain and loss were coordinated with Hsp90 throughout bacterial evolution tended to function in flagellar assembly, chemotaxis, and bacterial secretion, suggesting that Hsp90 may aid assembly of protein complexes. To add to the limited set of known bacterial Hsp90 clients, we further developed a statistical method to predict putative clients. We validated our predictions by demonstrating that the flagellar protein FliN and the chemotaxis kinase CheA behaved as Hsp90 clients in Escherichia coli, confirming the predicted role of Hsp90 in chemotaxis and flagellar assembly. Furthermore, normal Hsp90 function is important for wild-type motility and/or chemotaxis in E. coli. This novel function of bacterial Hsp90 agreed with our subsequent finding that Hsp90 is associated with a preference for multiple habitats and may therefore face a complex selection regime. Taken together, our results reveal previously unknown functions of bacterial Hsp90 and open avenues for future experimental exploration by implicating Hsp90 in the assembly of membrane protein complexes and adaptation to novel environments.
Hsp90 is a chaperone protein that aids the folding of many other proteins (clients), which tend to be signal transduction proteins. Hsp90 is particularly important when organisms are under environmental or mutational stress (e.g. in cancerous cells). Although Hsp90 is well-studied in eukaryotic species from yeast to humans, little is known about its counterpart in bacteria. To address this challenge, we analyzed the presence and absence of thousands of genes across numerous bacterial species and identified genes that co-evolved with Hsp90. These genes provide insights into potential functions of Hsp90 in bacteria. We found that Hsp90 co-evolves with membrane-associated protein complexes such as the flagellum and that Hsp90 is associated with a preference for inhabiting multiple habitats. We extended our analysis to identify genes that exhibit evolutionary dynamics characteristic of Hsp90 clients. Many of the putative clients were involved in flagellar assembly, suggesting a crucial role of Hsp90 in the regulation of bacterial motility. We experimentally confirmed that E. coli Hsp90 interacts with selected candidates and demonstrated Hsp90's role in flagellar motility and chemotaxis. The computational approach described here, identifying novel functions and specific clients of bacterial Hsp90, further provides exciting starting points for research in bacterial chaperone biology.
In eukaryotes, the universally conserved and essential chaperone Hsp90 aids the folding of key proteins in development and responses to environmental stimuli –. In yeast, up to 10% of all proteins are estimated to be Hsp90 clients under standard culture conditions . Hsp90 function is even more important under stressful conditions that challenge protein folding, such as increased temperature . The activity of eukaryotic Hsp90 is further modulated by various co-chaperones, which confer substrate specificity and alter protein folding kinetics , . Depletion of eukaryotic Hsp90 in vivo increases phenotypic variation, reveals ‘cryptic’ heritable variation, and increases penetrance of mutations –. Accordingly, eukaryotic Hsp90 enables organisms to maintain a stable phenotype in the face of environmental and genetic perturbation and to correctly interpret environmental stimuli.
In stark contrast, in prokarya, Hsp90 is not essential  and many bacterial genomes lack Hsp90 altogether . Among Archaea, only very few species contain Hsp90, and those are thought to have gained Hsp90 horizontally from bacteria , . This fragmented phylogenetic pattern likely results from multiple independent gains and losses, though phylogenetic reconstructions are confused by ancient Hsp90 paralogy , . At the amino acid level, the Escherichia coli Hsp90 (High-temperature protein G or HtpG) is 42% identical to its human homolog, suggesting strong stabilizing selection consistent with functional conservation . Indeed, E. coli Hsp90 appears to retain generic protein chaperone activity  and homologous Hsp90 mutations cause chaperone defects in both the prokaryotic E. coli and eukaryotic yeast . However, there are no identified obligate Hsp90 co-chaperones in bacteria, adding to the uncertainty regarding the extent of its client spectrum and specificity.
To date, only three proteins have been implicated as Hsp90 clients in bacteria, with non-overlapping functions in ribosome assembly, the assembly of light-harvesting complexes, and the CRISPR/Cas immunity system –. Several other proteins have been shown to physically interact with the chaperone , . Together with our knowledge of eukaryotic Hsp90 function, these data have given rise to the speculation that Hsp90 may facilitate the assembly of oligomeric protein complexes in bacteria, much like it does in eukaryotes . Unlike in eukaryotes, however, further exploration of Hsp90's functional role in bacteria has proven challenging because there are no pleiotropic Hsp90-dependent phenotypes.
To address this challenge, we used a genome-scale co-evolutionary ‘guilt-by-association’ approach ,  to explore the spectrum of conserved Hsp90-associated genes, functions, and organismal traits. Hsp90-associated genes tended to function in flagellar assembly, chemotaxis, and secretion. Consistent with these functions, Hsp90-associated organismal traits included the ability to inhabit multiple environments. To add to the sparse list of known bacterial Hsp90 clients, we further developed a statistical method to predict putative Hsp90 clients, which included flagellar, ribosomal, and chaperone proteins. We validated our predictions experimentally, focusing on two candidates functioning in motility and chemotaxis. Indeed, both the flagellar protein FliN and the kinase CheA were found to be Hsp90 clients in vivo. Our findings demonstrate the power of co-evolutionary inference to correctly identify substrates and functions of conserved genes like bacterial Hsp90.
Our method for inferring the function of bacterial Hsp90 is based on the analysis of its distribution across the bacterial phylogeny. However, this analysis is complicated by the existence of multiple ancient Hsp90 paralogs in bacteria. These paralogs may be older than existing phyla in bacteria , , and may have evolved distinct functions on this enormous time scale. To address this issue and to identify each paralog, we first clustered bacterial Hsp90s by sequence identity. We identified 897 bacterial Hsp90 protein sequences in the KEGG database  and built a neighbor-joining gene tree of bacterial Hsp90s (Figure S1A–B). We observed two well-supported long-branching clades as well as several less confident divisions in the tree (Figure S1B). These two long-branching clades contain sequences corresponding to the ‘hsp90B’ and ‘hsp90C’ paralogs that were described previously , . All other branches correspond to ‘hsp90A’ , which is the largest of the Hsp90 families in bacteria (Figure S1C, Text S1). Notably, hsp90A is the lineage out of which all eukaryotic Hsp90s (excluding mitochondrial and chloroplast Hsp90s) are derived. Moreover, the E. coli gene htpG belongs to the hsp90A family, and its gene product is the best-studied bacterial Hsp90 protein. For these reasons, we restricted our analysis to hsp90A.
We set out to identify orthologous groups whose presence and absence profiles across bacterial species are associated with the presence and absence profile of hsp90A. To avoid spurious associations, any such comparative analysis must go beyond a naïve comparison of presence/absence patterns across genomes and incorporate phylogenetic information . To this end, we used BayesTraits –, a computational framework for phylogenetic analysis of character evolution. Given the states (e.g., presence/absence) of two characters across some set of species and a phylogenetic tree relating these species, BayesTraits evaluates the likelihood of various evolutionary models throughout the tree. This approach can be utilized, for example, to determine whether these two characters evolve in a mutually dependent vs. an independent fashion.
We used BayesTraits to detect associations between hsp90A and 4646 other orthologous groups in bacteria (which hereafter we shall refer to as ‘genes’ for simplicity). We used the tree constructed by Ciccarelli et al.  as a model phylogeny (Figure 1). In this initial analysis, we tested for any kind of dependency between hsp90A and other genes, and did not make specific assumptions about the nature of the relationship between hsp90A and the genes in question . Specifically, we compared a model in which the rate of gain and loss of a given gene is independent of the rate of gain and loss of hsp90A (independent evolution) vs. a model in which the rate of gain and loss of this gene is affected by the presence or absence of hsp90A or vice-versa (co-evolution).
In total, we found 327 genes that co-evolve with hsp90A (Dataset S1). We will refer to this set as hsp90A-associated genes. These hsp90A-associated genes were significantly enriched for annotations related to the flagellum and to bacterial secretion systems (Table 1). Moreover, out of the 16 hsp90A-associated bacterial secretion genes, 10 were part of the non-flagellar Type III secretion system, suggesting that hsp90A is associated specifically with this system rather than with secretion systems in general. Using a different and markedly more extensive phylogeny  provided similar results (see Text S1, Table S1), as did a pruned Ciccarelli tree without the species containing the hsp90B or hsp90C (see Text S1).
The associations of hsp90A with other genes identified above are agnostic to the specific nature of the dependency between hsp90A and the gene in question. For example, our initial analysis could not distinguish between a positive association (i.e. genes tend to be gained and lost together) and a negative association (i.e. genes tend not to co-occur in genomes). Similarly, this analysis did not distinguish between genes whose gains and losses are affected by the presence of hsp90A (but that do not themselves affect hsp90A evolution) and genes that exhibit mutually dependent dynamics with hsp90A. Without a quantitative estimate of the effects that hsp90A and its co-evolving partners have upon one another, inference of Hsp90A function and its relationship with other genes is challenging.
To characterize the specific nature of the dependency between hsp90A and hsp90A-associated genes, we therefore examined rates of gain and loss inferred by BayesTraits. We focused on the two major non-overlapping hsp90A-associated functional categories, flagellar assembly and bacterial secretion. Considering, for example, fliI, a representative flagellar gene, we found that its gain and loss was strongly affected by the presence of hsp90A. Specifically, in the presence of hsp90A, fliI was often gained and rarely lost, whereas it was rarely gained and often lost when hsp90A is absent (Figure 2A). This pattern was common to all hsp90A-associated flagellar genes (Figures 2C, S2), suggesting a positive association between hsp90A and flagellar genes throughout evolution. In contrast, the co-evolutionary relationship between hsp90A and yscN, a representative nonflagellar type III secretion system gene, was markedly different, with yscN presence strongly affecting the gain and loss of hsp90A (Figure 2B). Specifically, the presence of yscN was associated with a large increase in the rates of gain and (even more dramatically) loss of hsp90A relative to these rates in its absence. Again, this pattern was common to all hsp90A-associated bacterial secretion genes (Figures 2D, S3, S4), suggesting a negative association between hsp90A and nonflagellar secretion genes throughout evolution.
To further validate the fundamentally distinct co-evolutionary dynamics of these two groups of genes, we considered four different co-evolutionary models: (1) hsp90A and the gene in question are independent (null); (2) hsp90A and the gene in question are mutually dependent; (3) hsp90A is dependent on the gene in question but not vice versa, and (4) the gene in question is dependent upon hsp90A but not vice versa (Methods). We used the Akaike Information Criterion (AIC ) to determine which of these 4 models best fit the co-evolutionary dynamics of each hsp90A-associated gene. As expected, none of the hsp90A-associated genes fit the independent model. Of the 27 hsp90A-associated flagellar genes, 25 were classified as being dependent on hsp90A but not vice-versa (model 4). Of the 16 hsp90A-associated secretion system genes, 10 genes were classified as mutually dependent with hsp90A (model 2; 6 of which were Type III secretion system genes), whereas 6 were classified as affecting the evolution of hsp90A (model 3). Furthermore, considering all hsp90A-associated genes, we found that genes that best fit each of the evolutionary dependency models above (models 2, 3, and 4) were enriched for different functions (Table 1). Specifically, among genes dependent on hsp90A, flagellar motility was strongly enriched, whereas among genes mutually dependent on hsp90A, secretion system components were enriched. Taken together, these patterns suggest that flagellar genes and secretion system genes had markedly different regimes of co-evolution with hsp90A.
Although many genes exhibited distinct patterns of co-evolution with hsp90A, these patterns could be the result of indirect evolutionary relationships rather than the outcome of a direct interaction with Hsp90A. We therefore aimed to predict specific genes that encode putative hsp90A clients. Our method is based on the assumption that strong, conserved clients should be heavily dependent on Hsp90A, and thus should be found only rarely in the absence of hsp90A throughout evolution. To estimate the expected frequency of each hsp90A-associated gene with and without hsp90A, we used the inferred BayesTraits rates to calculate the steady-state probabilities of each of the 4 possible two-gene presence/absence states (Methods). These probabilities represent the proportion of the time that some arbitrary bacterial lineage will spend in each of the presence/absence states throughout evolution. From these probabilities we calculated a Putative Client Index (PCI) for each hsp90A-associated gene to evaluate how often it was present without hsp90A throughout evolution, compared to a null expectation (see Methods). This index is close to zero for genes that were infrequently present without hsp90A and were hence likely to be Hsp90A clients. We defined the genes with the lowest PCI values as putative clients (Table 2; see also Text S1).
Consistent with our prior analysis, several flagellar genes behaved as potential clients (Table 2). In particular, our set of putative clients included several genes (fliH, fliI, fliN) whose products had been previously shown to physically interact with Hsp90A in E. coli . The products of these genes are cytoplasmic components of the flagellar rotor and export apparatuses. In contrast, nonflagellar type III secretion genes were all absent from the list of potential clients. In fact, nonflagellar type III secretion system components were rated as some of the least likely clients by our index (Figure 3). This disparity in predicted client status mirrors the different evolutionary relationships of these complexes with hsp90A (Figure 2).
Chaperone/proteases (e.g. ClpA and PpiD) also ranked high in our list of potential clients. Hsp90A is known to collaborate with other chaperone systems such as DnaK ,  but to date no obligate co-chaperones have been described. The identified chaperone/proteases may represent such co-chaperones or collaborating chaperone systems, since our index cannot discriminate between Hsp90 clients and Hsp90 co-chaperones (or other collaborating proteins). Alternatively, these observed associations could simply indicate that components of the cytoplasmic stress response are dependent upon Hsp90A.
We also found several unexpected putative clients, such as the 3-hydroxybutyryl-CoA dehydrogenase PaaH and the transcription termination factor Rho, which we predict to be the two strongest clients. Further study will be necessary to understand these associations and the underlying cause of the co-evolutionary association between these genes and hsp90A.
Our putative clients and the predicted chaperone role of Hsp90A in flagellar assembly are consistent with previous observations. Specifically, the deletion of E. coli hsp90A, also known as htpG, resulted in reduced surface swarming movement . We also previously observed physical interactions between the HtpG protein and certain flagellar proteins . Yet, these observations lacked a clear demonstration of client status or mechanism, and E. coli swarming is a complex behavior that depends on numerous factors in addition to flagellar function . We therefore set out to test our hypothesis that Hsp90A is physiologically important for flagellar assembly and function and that flagellar components are indeed Hsp90A clients.
We examined the swimming motility phenotype of ΔhtpG E. coli strains on soft-agar plates (Methods). In contrast to surface swarming, swimming is a less complex behavior, in which bacteria use functional flagella and chemotaxis components to swim from an inoculation point through agar pores, following nutrient gradients that are created by nutrient depletion within the colony. The soft-agar assay is routinely used to assay bacterial swimming motility and chemotaxis. To enhance our ability to detect differences between wild-type and ΔhtpG cells, the assays were performed competitively. Competitive assays emphasize small differences between strains and reduce experimental error, thereby increasing the sensitivity of the assay. After mixing equal amounts of YFP-labeled WT and CFP-labeled ΔhtpG strains, this mixture was inoculated in the center of a soft-agar plate and incubated at 34°C for 8 hrs. We then counted cells of each strain in the plate center vs. the outer edge using fluorescence microscopy (Figure 4A). ΔhtpG mutants migrated less efficiently to the plate's outer edge relative to WT, confirming that they are partially deficient in their motility and/or chemotaxis (Figure 4B). This defect is apparently subtle, since little difference between WT and ΔhtpG cells was observed in a non-competitive assay (Figure S5), but it could be revealed due to strong selection for cells with optimal motility and chemotaxis at the outer edge of the spreading bacterial population.
We also tested the phenotype of the HtpG(E34A) mutant, which has reduced rates of ATP hydrolysis and is deficient in substrate refolding , . Since HtpG ATPase activity is necessary for release of clients, HtpG(E34A) is less efficient at releasing clients –. Indeed, this mutant showed stronger motility/chemotaxis defects than the ΔhtpG strain (Figure S5), presumably due to sequestration of its client proteins. We therefore employed the HtpG(E34A) mutant in all subsequent assays as a more sensitive test of HtpG involvement. Taken together, our observations suggest that the motility defect may be due to the improper function or sequestration of HtpG clients.
To further investigate the in vivo interaction of HtpG with flagellar components, we used htpG-yfp and htpG(E34A)-yfp constructs expressed in WT cells to perform acceptor photobleaching FRET between HtpG and FliN-CFP over an E. coli growth curve. Motility of E. coli is known to increase at the transition from the early exponential to post-exponential phase of growth , and this experimental design enabled us to examine the HtpG-FliN interaction in the context of the flagellar assembly process. If HtpG is indeed involved in the assembly process of these structures, the interaction of HtpG with FliN should correspond temporally to the timing of flagellar assembly. Indeed, we found that the interaction with FliN peaked at OD600=0.2 (Figure 5A) and correlated well with the onset of cell motility in wild-type cells (Figure 5B). Moreover, the interaction of HtpG(E34A) with FliN was stronger and delayed compared to the binding of wild-type HtpG. Correspondingly, the onset of motility was delayed in cells expressing HtpG(E34A) (Figure 5B). This is consistent with the delayed release of clients by HtpG(E34A), suggesting that HtpG's role in motility derives from a direct involvement in flagellar complex assembly.
Given that both bacterial and eukaryotic Hsp90s are known to collaborate with Hsp70 in refolding proteins , –, we considered the possibility that this was also the case for bacterial flagellar assembly. We previously showed that some flagellar motor components interact with DnaK, the E. coli Hsp70 homolog . Therefore, we repeated the FRET experiments testing for interactions between HtpG or HtpG(E34A) and FliN in a ΔcbpAΔdnaJ background. CbpA and DnaJ are DnaK co-chaperones and are essential for DnaK–dependent refolding activity . DnaK should not be able to pass substrates to HtpG in this mutant background. Indeed, we found that FRET interactions with FliN disappear for both HtpG proteins in this background (Figure S6A), suggesting that DnaK-dependent remodeling precedes HtpG action in flagellar complex assembly.
Since a recent high-throughput assay showed kinases to be overrepresented among eukaryotic Hsp90 clients , , we next examined whether the HtpG-dependent defects in chemotaxis may also be due to defective chemoreceptor kinase activity. Although no chemotaxis proteins were found in our list of the strongest putative clients, we did observe a significant enrichment of these components in the hsp90A-associated set (Table 1). We thus tested interactions between six chemoreceptor cluster components and HtpG(E34A) using, as before, acceptor photobleaching FRET (Table S4). We observed a strong interaction of HtpG(E34A) with the chemoreceptor kinase CheA. Our results suggest that the FliN/HtpG and CheA/HtpG interactions are direct and do not depend on other flagellar or chemotaxis proteins, since these interactions are robust to deletion of flhC, which ablates expression of all endogenous flagellar and chemotaxis genes (Table S4) . Moreover, the CheA dimerization domain was required for association with HtpG, supporting the hypothesis that HtpG aids oligomerization of its clients , . Testing HtpG interactions with other chemotaxis proteins of E. coli revealed an additional strong interaction with the dimeric phosphatase CheZ but not with other proteins (Table S4).
We again examined the temporal dynamics of these interactions. Due to the hierarchical order of flagellar and chemotaxis gene expression , , the assembly of chemoreceptor clusters is delayed compared to the assembly of flagellar motors as non-motile cells transition into motile cells. Indeed, the interaction of HtpG with CheA peaked at OD600=0.3, after the FliN peak (Figure 5A). Just as for FliN, the interaction of HtpG(E34A) with CheA was stronger and delayed compared to wild-type HtpG, and the HtpG-CheA interaction disappeared in a ΔcbpAΔdnaJ background (Figure S6B). Collectively, these findings suggest that HtpG plays an important role in the assembly of both the flagellar motor and chemoreceptor clusters through separate client interactions.
Given the role of HtpG in chaperoning proteins that mediate interactions with the environment, and the known role of eukaryotic Hsp90 in phenotypic robustness, we finally examined whether hsp90A directly co-evolved with certain bacterial organismal traits. We considered several organismal traits, including aerobism, thermophilicity, halophilicity, the ability to form endospores, pathogenicity, motility, and habitat preferences (see Methods). We used BayesTraits and the Ciccarelli tree to identify traits that co-evolve with hsp90A. Out of the 11 analyzed traits, 4 exhibited significant associations with hsp90A (p<0.05; Table S5), with the strongest association observed between hsp90A and the capacity to inhabit multiple habitats. Moreover, examining the gain and loss rates obtained, we found that hsp90A is gained and lost at significantly higher rates in organisms that inhabit multiple habitats (with no gains inferred in single habitat organisms), suggesting that a preference for multiple habitats imposes a different selection regime on hsp90A (Figure 6). We also tested whether the co-evolutionary dependency between hsp90A and multiple-habitat preferences was unidirectional, as we observed for some hsp90A-associated genes. Comparing the four co-evolutionary models described above and applying AIC to identify the best-fitting model, we found that hsp90A gain and loss depended on habitat preference, but not vice versa. This observation suggests that in organisms inhabiting multiple environments hsp90A is subjected to dynamically shifting selective pressures, potentially alternating between selection for and against hsp90A.
We set out to discover Hsp90 functions conserved throughout the bacterial tree of life. We found that hsp90A, the most common paralog of bacterial Hsp90, bore strong signatures of co-evolution with several hundred genes and with specific life history traits, shedding light on its function and impact on evolutionary history. Most notably, we found that hsp90A co-evolved with membrane protein complexes such as flagella and other Type III secretion (T3S) systems. Our results suggest that Hsp90's role in sensing and responding to environmental stimuli is conserved between bacteria and eukaryotes.
Similar to verified eukaryotic Hsp90 clients , our predicted putative Hsp90A clients were a diverse group of proteins (e.g. the flagella protein FliN, the chaperone ClpA, and the ribosomal protein RluB; see Table 2) that tended to belong to specific functional categories (e.g. flagellar proteins, chaperones, and ribosomal components). As our methods can only infer associations between genes that are frequently gained and lost, we may substantially underestimate the number of hsp90A-associated genes and clients. However, the non-essentiality and frequent loss of hsp90A throughout bacterial diversity argues that genes not captured in our analysis (since they are not frequently gained and lost) are unlikely to be strongly dependent on the chaperone throughout bacteria.
The subtlety of the bacterial Hsp90 mutant phenotypes that we (and others) report implies that Hsp90's role in cellular physiology has diverged between eukaryotes and prokaryotes , , . In other words, either essential pieces of cellular physiology changed, or Hsp90 function changed. We favor the first hypothesis, because Hsp90 is well-conserved among bacteria, archaea, and humans at the sequence level , and retains a similar quaternary structure  and biochemical activity , , . In contrast, bacterial and archaeal cells differ significantly from eukaryotic cells. Eukaryotic cells have higher cell compartmentalization, longer and multifunctional proteins with multiple domains , and increased protein interactome complexity . Together with the existence of many eukaryotic Hsp90 co-chaperones, all these features may contribute to the greater essentiality of Hsp90 in eukaryotes.
The dependence of HtpG-client interactions upon the DnaK chaperone system, as observed by us and by others , , argues that Hsp90A is well-integrated with other chaperone systems. Our putative clients included ClpA, the substrate adaptor for the ClpAP/ClpAXP chaperone/protease complexes, and PpiD, a periplasmic chaperone . Like HtpG, PpiD is necessary for optimal swarming motility , suggesting that it may participate in flagellar assembly. We speculate that these proteins act as Hsp90A co-chaperones in some bacteria; alternatively, their dependence on Hsp90A may represent an example of collaborating chaperone systems.
The best-characterized Hsp90 client in bacteria is the structural ribosomal protein L2 , , which is near-universally conserved throughout life (and hence not detectable by our method). In addition to L2, other ribosomal proteins were found to interact with HtpG in large-scale proteomics analyses. In agreement with these observations, we found the ribosomal proteins RlmE and RluB among the predicted hsp90A clients.
Although these chaperone and ribosomal proteins were predicted to be stronger clients than flagellar proteins, our experimental validation focused on the latter as their client status was suggested by previous observations , . We present four lines of evidence for HtpG client status for the flagellar protein FliN and the chemoreceptor kinase CheA, including direct interactions with HtpG, physiologically relevant timing of HtpG-FliN/CheA interactions, phenotypic consequences of reduced HtpG function in CheA/FliN-dependent traits, and dependence of CheA/FliN interactions with HtpG upon the Hsp40-Hsp70 pathway. The identification of FliN and CheA as HtpG clients is consistent with the hypothesis that bacterial Hsp90 facilitates the assembly of large membrane-associated protein complexes , .
Curiously, whereas the flagellar T3S system contained Hsp90A clients, the nonflagellar T3S system is predicted to have an antagonistic relationship with Hsp90A. Nonflagellar T3S systems and the flagellar T3S systems are closely related (NF-T3SS and F-T3SS) , . 9 NF-T3SS components are directly homologous to flagellar components, of which 8 were found to co-evolve with hsp90A in our analysis. Yet, these 8 genes are predicted to co-evolve antagonistically with hsp90A (Figure 3), whereas their flagellar homologs are mostly predicted to be clients (for instance, the fliI and yscN genes shown in Figure 2 are homologous). This result suggests that some relationship with Hsp90A is conserved between the two T3S systems, but with apparently opposite effects in each system. This result may reflect the fact that each of these systems is an adaptation to different ecological challenges. Specifically, we have shown that Hsp90A is important for flagellum-enabled motility and chemotaxis in E. coli. This mode of motility is strongly adaptive in certain physical environments , , , and thus Hsp90A is likely to be associated with fitness in these environments through flagellar assembly. The presence of NF-T3SS is likewise an adaptation to certain biotic environments , . Our observation that organisms inhabiting multiple habitats experience fluctuating selection for hsp90A is also consistent with competing selection pressures. Representative genes of these homologous T3S families were not significantly associated with habitat preferences, arguing that hsp90A's association with habitat preferences is not a byproduct of associations with T3S systems. Nonetheless, we suggest that these two T3S systems constitute a link between Hsp90A and phenotypic robustness across different environments.
Inferring function from evolutionary associations has some caveats. For instance, F-T3S systems can be found in genomes that lack hsp90A. If F-T3S systems include Hsp90A clients, then what may render Hsp90A-dependent stabilization dispensable in some bacteria? Experimental validation will be necessary to answer such questions, and to distinguish true client relationships from indirect co-evolutionary associations. As discussed before, our method is subject to gene set bias, in that only genes that are gained and/or lost frequently will have enough statistical power to reject the null hypothesis. Similarly, as our method assumes that relationships are maintained throughout the analyzed phylogeny, we cannot reliably detect genes that are associated with hsp90A in some organisms but not in others.
Although much work remains to articulate the precise mechanistic relationships between hsp90A and its co-evolving genes, our results highlight the tremendous potential of evolutionary inference for guiding experimental research. More generally, our study provides a successful example of how evolutionary perspectives and phylogenetic analyses can inform and advance the study of complex biological systems and the inference of elusive biological functions.
We downloaded all Hsp90 amino acid sequences (including all paralogs) for bacteria with full KEGG genome annotations from the KEGG database , . We aligned these sequences using ClustalO , and used the PHYLIP package  to construct neighbor-joining trees and assess their phylogenetic support through bootstrapping. We assigned Hsp90 families to branches according to bootstrap support for the branch and previous classifications , .
We acquired presence/absence patterns of genes across organisms from the KEGG database release 60.0 (in the form of KEGG Orthology/KO profiles) , and functional annotations from KEGG Class. Genes that were either present in fewer than five species or absent in fewer than five species in the tree of interest were dropped from our analysis, as these genes are unlikely to show meaningful signatures of co-evolution by this method.
We obtained the tree constructed by Ciccarelli et al. (Ciccarelli tree)  and pruned it to 148 bacterial species for which KEGG genome data was available. We also obtained the LTP104 version of the 16S/23S rRNA tree from the All-Species Living Tree Project (Yarza tree) , . We used ARB  to prune this tree to bacterial species for which KEGG genome data was available. We further pruned this tree to omit clades placed paraphyletically at the taxonomic levels of phylum, class, order, and family. This filtered tree included 797 bacterial species. As BayesTraits cannot process trees with zero-length branches, all branch lengths equal to zero were replaced with a negligible branch length (0.00001, approximately an order of magnitude smaller than the next smallest branch length in each tree).
We acquired organismal trait data from the NCBI Entrez genome project, November 2011 . We recoded all traits into presence/absence patterns for the trait in question. For instance, an organism found to be pathogenic towards any other organism was coded as ‘1’ for the trait of pathogenicity, whereas an annotated organism that was never found to be pathogenic was coded as ‘0’. Similarly, we coded both thermophilic and hyperthermophilic organisms as ‘1’ for the trait of thermophilicity, whereas all other annotated organisms were coded as ‘0’; anaerobic organisms were coded as ‘0’ for the trait of aerobicity, whereas all other annotated organisms were recoded as ‘1’. We define as inhabiting multiple habitats any organism that inhabits more than one of NCBI's habitat categories. For BayesTraits analysis, the tree was pruned to include only species annotated for the trait in question (each trait analysis was accordingly performed on a slightly different set of species; see Table S5 for details on species number for each analysis).
A complete description of the BayesTraits (v1.0) framework can be found elsewhere . Briefly, consider a character with 2 states, 0 and 1. If a species has 2 such distinct characters, it can occupy 4 possible states: 1:(0,0), 2:(0,1), 3:(1,0), and 4:(1,1). Specifically, if these 2 characters represent the presence or absence of two genes, hsp90A and gene X, these four states correspond to (hsp90A−, X−), (hsp90A+, X−), (hsp90A−, X+), and (hsp90A+, X+). Evolution is then the process by which these genes are gained and lost over time. Consider accordingly an evolutionary process where only one character can change state at a time. Such a process can then be described by 8 parameters for the rates of transition per unit time between these 4 states: Q=[q12, q13, q21, q31, q24, q34, q42, q43], where qxy is the rate of transition from state x to state y. BayesTraits implements this model of evolution as a continuous-time Markov process and estimates each of these rate parameters by maximum-likelihood (ML). We further validated that these ML-based rates are consistent with reversible-jump Markov chain Monte Carlo-derived estimates (Methods; Text S1). This estimation is based on a phylogeny and on the states of the two characters at the tips of the phylogeny. Having estimated these rates, BayesTraits additionally calculates the likelihood of the model based on the character states at the tips of the phylogeny.
We can further compare different models of evolution by forcing certain parameters to be equal. We specifically considered the following 4 models:
We used discrete from the BayesTraits package – to infer associations between hsp90A and other bacterial genes and between hsp90A and various organismal traits. We first tested for an evolutionary association with hsp90A by comparing model 1 to model 2 above with a likelihood ratio test (LRT), as previously described . In our likelihood-ratio tests, the 2Log(LR) approximates a χ2 test statistic for rejecting the independent model as a null hypothesis, and is calculated as twice the difference of the log-likelihoods of a co-evolutionary model and a model of evolutionary independence. The set of genes for which model 2 is preferred (i.e., model 1 is rejected as a null hypothesis) have an evolutionary association with hsp90A. Since different runs of the BayesTraits maximum likelihood method can potentially produce different parameter values, we repeated this procedure 100 times, each potentially resulting in a different gene set. We validated that these sets are similar and the choice of gene set does not substantially affect downstream analysis (Text S1). Any gene that was found to be associated with hsp90A in at least 90 runs was defined as hsp90A-associated gene. See Text S1 for more details.
We selected 10 genes at random from the hsp90A-associated set and used the BayesTraits implementation of reversible-jump Markov chain Monte Carlo to estimate the rate parameters for their gain and loss in concert with hsp90A . For each of these 10 genes, we used an exponential rate prior with mean and variance equal to 30, and ran the chain for 150 million iterations while sampling every 100 iterations. We discarded the first 75 million iterations as burn-in and used the remaining iterations as a posterior distribution of rate parameter estimates. We used Tracer v1.5  and previously described criteria to evaluate chain convergence in this remaining sample . For each rate, we used the median of its posterior distribution in this sample as a point estimate.
To provide an accurate description of the co-evolutionary dynamics of hsp90A-associated genes, we further applied BayesTraits to these genes, estimating the likelihood of each of the four models described above. We identified the best fit model for each gene using the Akaike Information Criterion (AIC) , taking into account both the likelihood score and the number of parameters in each model. We again repeated this procedure 100 times and classified a gene into a specific co-evolutionary model only if it fit this same model in at least 90 runs (see Text S1 for more details). This two stage scheme, first identifying associated genes and then selecting a model that best describes their evolutionary relationship with hsp90A, provides a more stringent test of co-evolution and supports a simple approach for multiple testing correction.
We used BayesTraits-derived evolutionary transition rates under the fully unrestricted model to estimate residence times in specific states (for instance, the proportion of time spent by bacteria in a state where both hsp90A and some other gene are present, vs. the time when only the other gene is present) under steady state dynamics. For a given gene, the probability of being in one of the four states, A: (hsp90A absent, Gene absent), B: (hsp90A present, Gene absent), C: (hsp90A absent, Gene present), D: (hsp90A present, Gene present) at a very small increment of time Δt after time t is given by:
We can differentiate this to obtain the instantaneous change in each probability:
At steady state dA/dt = 0, dB/dt = 0, etc., and therefore:
This set of linear equations can be solved for A, B, C, and D, with the requirement that A+B+C+D=1. We replaced 0 rates with the smallest nonzero rate in the model multiplied by 0.001 to allow transitions between all states. The positive nonzero solution for A, B, C, and D can then be conceived as the expected residence times along some arbitrary bacterial lineage. We used these residence times to estimate a Putative Client Index, PCI, denoting the normalized residence time in state C:
Notably, if Hsp90A and the gene's product have no client relationship, the proportion of time spent in state C is expected to be equal to (C+D)(A+C), so a PCI close to 1 indicates that the observation does not differ from the expectation. Smaller values of PCI therefore indicate that a gene is observed less frequently than expected without hsp90A, and is thus more likely to be a client. Since no obvious threshold value can be defined, we considered the 20 genes with the lowest PCI values as putative clients (Figure 3 and Table 2; Methods). To account for variation in rates between BayesTraits runs we repeated this procedure 100 times and defined as putative clients those that were identified as clients in at least 90 of these runs (see Text S1). PCI scores shown in Table 2 and Figure 3 are averages across all runs.
We used a hypergeometric test to assess whether each KEGG Class functional annotation is overrepresented in the various Hsp90-associated gene sets. As a background set in each case we used the entire set of genes analyzed. Any annotation present in less than 4 copies in the background set was not considered. We accepted enrichments at a 5% FDR.
Escherichia coli K-12 strains and plasmids used in this study are listed in Table S2. Cells were grown in tryptone broth (TB; 1% tryptone and 0.5% NaCl) and when necessary supplemented with ampicillin, chloramphenicol and/or kanamycin at final concentrations of 100, 35 and 50 µg/ml, respectively. Overnight cultures, grown at 30°C, were diluted 1100 and grown at 34°C for about 4 h, to an OD600 of 0.45–0.5. All expression constructs for YFP and CFP fusions were constructed as described previously , , . Induction levels for protein expression were 1 µM IPTG (pHL24, pHL35, pVS129 and pVS132), 20 µM IPTG (pVS64 and pVS99), 25 µM IPTG (pDK36, pDK90 and pDK91), 50 µM IPTG (pDK19 and pVS18), 0.005% arabinose (pHL13, pVS108 and pVS109) and 0.01% arabinose (pHL52, pHL70, pDK14, pDK29, pDK30 and pDK49). Cells were harvested by centrifugation (4,000 rpm, 5 min), washed once with tethering buffer (10 mM potassium phosphate, 0.1 mM EDTA, 1 mM L-methionine, 67 mM sodium chloride, 10 mM sodium lactate, pH 7) and resuspended in 10 mL tethering buffer prior to FRET measurements.
TB soft agar plates were prepared by supplementing TB with 0.3% agar (Applichem) and when necessary with 100 g/mL ampicillin and 1 µM IPTG. Equal amounts of cells from different overnight cultures, adjusted depending on their optical density to the equivalent of 2.5 µl of culture with OD600 of 2.0, were inoculated and allowed to spread at indicated temperatures for indicated times. Following incubation, photographs of plates were taken with a Canon EOS 300D (DS6041) camera. Images were analyzed with ImageJ (Wayne Rasband, NIH, http://rsb.info.nih.gov/ij/) to determine the diameter of the rings of spreading colonies.
For analysis of motility at different growth stages (indicated by OD600 value), percentages of motile cells were estimated from the microscopy movies of swimming cells. The experiment was performed with the RP437 strain, which is non-motile above 37°C. Cells were grown overnight in TB medium at 37°C to completely inhibit their motility. After dilution in fresh TB medium to OD600 0.01, cells were grown at 34°C for measurements.
For microscopy, cells were taken from the soft-agar plates and applied to a thin agarose pad (1% agarose in tethering buffer). Fluorescence imaging was performed on a Zeiss AxioImager microscope equipped with an ORCA AG CCD camera (Hamamatsu), a 100× NA 1.45 objective, and HE YFP (Excitation BP 500/25; Emission BP 535/30) and HE CFP (Excitation BP 436/25; Emission BP 480/40) filter sets. Each imaging experiment was performed in duplicate on independent cultures. All images were acquired under identical conditions. Images were subsequently analysed using ImageJ software.
FRET measurements by acceptor photobleaching were performed on a custom-modified Zeiss Axiovert 200 microscope as described before . Briefly, cells expressing YFP and CFP fusions of interest were concentrated about tenfold by centrifugation, resuspended in tethering buffer and applied to a thin agarose pad (1% agarose in tethering buffer). Excitation light from a 75 XBO lamp, attenuated by a ND60 (0.2) neutral-density filter, passed through a band-pass (BP) 436/20 filter and a 495DCSP dichroic mirror and was reflected on the specimen by a Z440/532 dual-band beamsplitter (transmission 465–500 and 550–640 nm; reflection 425–445 and 532 nm). Bleaching of YFP was accomplished by a 20 sec illumination with a 532 nm diode laser (Rapp OptoElectronic), reflected by the 495DCSP dichroic mirror into the light path. Emission from the field of view, which was narrowed with a diaphragm to the area bleached by the laser, passed through a BP 485/40 filter onto a H7421-40 photon counter (Hamamatsu). For each measurement point, photons were counted over 0.5 s using a counter function of the PCI-6034E board, controlled by a custom-written LabView 7.1 program (both from National Instruments). CFP emission was recorded before and after bleaching of YFP, and FRET was calculated as the CFP signal increase divided by the total signal after bleaching. ΔflhC strains were used to define direct interactions between HtpG and flagellar and chemotaxis components. In this background expression of endogenous flagellar and chemotaxis genes is inhibited, thus eliminating indirect interactions that may result from concomitant binding of HtpG and tested protein to a third flagellar or chemotaxis protein.
hsp90A-associated genes and relevant information.
Phylogenetic clustering of bacterial hsp90 paralogs. (A) Neighbor-joining phylogeny of 897 bacterial Hsp90 amino acid sequences. Groups Hsp90A, Hsp90B, and Hsp90C as defined by Chen et al.  are illustrated. (B) Consensus neighbor-joining tree for 100 bootstraps with clades collapsed to highlight deep branch structure. Bootstrap support for each branch is displayed and is also reflected by the branch lengths. One species (ZIN, representing Hsp90 from the organism Candidatus Zinderia insecticola CARI), never grouped within the other divisions shown, and was excluded from our analysis. The branch separating Hsp90B and Hsp90C from the Hsp90A clades is present in 99/100 bootstrap trees. (C) Hsp90A, B, and C presence/absence patterns mapped onto a 16S/23S rRNA phylogeny of 797 bacterial species  (see Text S1). Branch lengths are ignored for ease of display.
Co-evolutionary gain and loss rates of all hsp90A-associated flagellar genes. The layout of each diagram is similar to that used in Figure 2.
Co-evolutionary gain and loss rates of all hsp90A-associated secretion genes. The layout of each diagram is similar to that used in Figure 2.
Box plots of the rates of gain and loss of all hsp90A-associated secretion genes (n=16). See also Figure 2D.
The htpG(E34A) mutant strain shows decreased motility/chemotaxis. (A) Plates were inoculated with the same amount of wild-type MG1655 (top), the ΔhtpG mutant (bottom left) and the htpG(E34A) mutant (bottom right) cells and incubated at indicated temperatures for 6 hr. (B) Relative motility of ΔhtpG and htpG(E34A) mutants, compared to wild type, at indicated temperatures, quantified by the diameter of the outer rings of spreading colonies. Error bars indicate standard errors from two replicates.
HtpG interactions with FliN and CheA are dependent on the DnaJ/CbpA/DnaK chaperone system. Acceptor photobleaching FRET was measured between HtpG and FliN (A) or CheA (B). In each panel, HtpG(E34A) (top row) and wild-type HtpG (bottom row) were assayed, and experiments were performed in both WT (left column) and ΔdnaJΔcbpA (right column) backgrounds. Y-axes are normalized in each case to the mean CFP signal before bleaching (first 45 s). Photobleaching begins at ~50 s and lasts for 20 s (indicated by black bar). FRET interaction is indicated by a post-photobleaching increase in CFP signal above pre-photobleaching CFP signal (as observed in all experiments in the WT background).
Comparable results in Ciccarelli and Yarza trees across FDR thresholds.
E. coli strains and plasmids used in this study.
Spreading of wild-type and ΔhtpG cells in soft-agar assays at 34°C and 42°C.
Acceptor photobleaching FRET interactions of chemotaxis components with HtpG(E34A).
hsp90A presence and absence is associated with organismal traits in bacteria.
Additional details on Hsp90 paralog distribution, consistency of BayesTraits runs, and robustness of co-evolutionary associations to choice of phylogeny.
We thank Joe Felsenstein for methodological guidance. We thank Aviv Regev for valuable discussions and advice at the initiation of this work. We thank Matthias Mayer for providing strains and for valuable discussions. We thank Evgeni Sokurenko, Willie Swanson, Olivier Genest, and members of the Queitsch, Sourjik, and Borenstein laboratories for helpful discussions. We thank Andrew Meade and Mark Pagel for help with the BayesTraits software.