|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
Selection and physiological production of protective natural antibodies (NAbs) have been associated with exposure to endogenous antigens. The extent to which this association depends on germline NAb sequence is uncertain. Here we show that alterations in germline DH sequence can sever the association between the production of self-reactive NAbs and NAbs that afford protection against a pathogen. In unmanipulated hosts, the availability of the evolutionarily conserved DFL16.1 gene segment sequence profoundly affected the serum levels of NAbs against bacterial phosphorylcholine but not oxidized low-density lipoprotein. Mice with partially altered DFL16.1 sequence could use N nucleotides to recreate the amino acid sequence associated with the classical protective T15 idiotype–positive NAbs, whereas those without DFL16.1 could not. DFL16.1 gene–deficient mice proved more susceptible to challenge with live Streptococcus pneumoniae. Our findings indicate that although production of self-reactive NAbs can be independent of germline DH sequence, their capacity to provide protection against pathogens cannot. The potential relevance of these findings for the rational design of vaccines is discussed.
Igs present in the sera of normal individuals in the absence of exogenous antigenic stimulation are termed natural antibodies (NAbs). The repertoire and reactivity pattern of NAbs are conserved both within and between species (Avrameas, 1991) and are remarkably stable. IgM is the dominant NAb isotype, and most, if not all, NAbs appear to be the products of B-1 B cells (Hayakawa et al., 1984, 1986a; Sidman et al., 1986; Haas et al., 2005; Baumgarth, 2011; Choi et al., 2012). The Igs produced by these lymphocytes often demonstrate decreased or absent N-region addition at the V-D and D-J junctions, emphasizing the major contribution of germline-encoded sequence to their specificity (Feeney, 1991; Tornberg and Holmberg, 1995; Kantor et al., 1997; Vale et al., 2010). NAbs are considered to constitute an innate component of the adaptive immune response, as they provide one of the first lines of defense against invading pathogens (Briles et al., 1981; Benedict and Kearney, 1999; Ochsenbein et al., 1999).
In mice, NAbs are present at equivalent levels in specific pathogen–, germ-, and even exogenous antigen–free animals, suggesting a role for endogenous ligands in the selection of the NAb repertoire (Bos et al., 1989; Haury et al., 1997). Accordingly, elegant experiments have shown that naturally generated B-1 B cells secreting antithymocyte NAb required the presence of the cognate endogenous antigen (Thy-1/CD90) for B cell expansion and serum autoantibody secretion (Hayakawa et al., 1999). Some NAbs also appear to play a role in normal cellular homeostasis, helping rid the body of cellular and molecular debris (Aprahamian et al., 2004; Binder and Silverman, 2005; Kaveri et al., 2012). One classical example in mice of the dual role of NAbs involves the NAb response to endogenous oxidation-specific epitopes on oxidized low-density lipoprotein (LDL [OxLDL]) and apoptotic cells (Shaw et al., 2000; Binder et al., 2003; Binder and Silverman, 2005; Chen et al., 2009; Chou et al., 2009). In response to OxLDL, there appears to be selection and expansion of NAbs bearing the germline-encoded T15 idiotype (T15-Id) in the peripheral B cell repertoire (Shaw et al., 2000; Kearney, 2005). T15-Id+ NAbs also bind to phosphorylcholine (PC) present on the cell wall of Streptococcus pneumoniae (Potter and Leon, 1968; Briles et al., 1981), constituting 60–80% of the natural anti-PC response (Gearhart et al., 1975; Sigal et al., 1975; Lévy, 1984; Feeney et al., 1988). Although many antibodies can bind PC, those containing the germline canonical T15-Id confer optimal protection against lethal S. pneumoniae bacteremia (McDaniel et al., 1984) and fatal sepsis (Briles et al., 1982) in mice, and low levels of IgM antibodies to PC have been recently associated with a higher risk of cardiovascular disease in humans (de Faire et al., 2010).
Although the key roles played by NAbs in host homeostasis and defense are increasingly appreciated, a major remaining question is the nature of the forces that shape the composition of the NAb repertoire. One thesis, which we may refer to as the natural selection hypothesis, holds that the germline composition of the NAb repertoire is critical for its dual function as a protector against both endogenous and exogenous antigens and thus has been naturally selected during evolution. The antithesis, which we may refer to as the self-antigen–driven or somatic selection hypothesis, proposes that exposure to self-antigen drives the production of dual-function NAbs irrespective of germline sequence.
The T15-Id is conserved across multiple mouse strains and is tightly associated with the use of a specific VH (VHS107.1) and a specific VL (Vκ22; Crews et al., 1981). Disruption of the VHS107.1 gene results in an inability to mount a protective immune response to S. pneumoniae (Mi et al., 2000). In common with many other B-1a Igs, canonical anti-PC T15 CDR-H3s lack N-region addition and use their DH, in this case DFL16.1, in only one of six potential reading frames, RF1 (Feeney, 1991). These findings raised the possibility that the complete germline sequence of DFL16.1 in general, and of RF1 in particular, would be critical for NAb protection against S. pneumoniae, with N addition playing a deleterious role (Benedict and Kearney, 1999). However, this presumed centrality of naturally selected DFL16.1 germline sequence, either partial or in its entirety, in promoting production of NAb induced by endogenous OxLDL and in preventing potentially atherogenic uptake of this lipid has not been experimentally verified.
In this work, we report the use of a panel of BALB/c mice with altered DH alleles (Schelonka et al., 2005, 2008; Ippolito et al., 2006; Zemlin et al., 2008) to both qualitatively and quantitatively test the relative roles of germline versus somatic selection of CDR-H3 sequence in the generation and function of the anti-OxLDL, anti-PC, and T15-Id+ NAb repertoires. We present data that support the moderating concept that natural selection of conserved D (diversity) sequence and self-antigen–driven somatic selection operate in concert to create a protective, functional NAb repertoire reactive with a bacterial cell wall component. In remarkable contrast, NAb reactivity and function in the case of an endogenous antigen representative of molecular debris do not show this dependence on evolutionarily conserved DH sequences.
We had previously used techniques of cre-loxP–based gene targeting on a BALB/c embryonic stem cell line to delete 12 of the 13 DH gene segments in the DH locus, retaining only the single DFL16.1 segment (ΔD-DFL mice). We then generated a panel of DH-altered mice by replacing the single DFL16.1 segment with a twice-frameshifted DFL16.1 gene segment (ΔD-DµFS) or an inverted DSP2.2 gene segment (ΔD-iD; Schelonka et al., 2005, 2008; Ippolito et al., 2006; Zemlin et al., 2008; Schroeder et al., 2010).
To gain insight into the role played by germline DH sequence in the antigen specificity of the NAb repertoire, we performed a semiquantitative immunoblot assay that enables an en bloc analysis of the self-reactivity of IgM present in the serum of unmanipulated WT and the DH-altered mutant mice (Nobrega et al., 1993; Haury et al., 1994; Mouthon et al., 1995). Sera were tested for reactivity to self-proteins isolated from brain, muscle, heart, and liver (Fig. S1 A and not depicted). The serum IgM self-reactivity pattern (actual repertoire) was remarkably well-conserved in mice that generate very different primary CDR-H3 repertoires at multiple stages and subsets of B cell development, including the B-1 compartments (unpublished data). To test whether the self-reactivity pattern observed in serum is also conserved at the cellular level (available repertoire), we sorted and cultured peritoneal cavity (PerC) B-1a, B-1b, and B-2 cells under mitogen stimulation to induce polyclonal IgM secretion and tested the supernatants using the immunoblot assay. Whereas the self-reactivity profiles from B-1a culture supernatants were highly conserved among the different mouse strains, reflecting those observed in the serum, there was less conservation in B-1b and still less in the B-2 cell culture supernatants (Fig. S1 B). These results suggest that the self-reactivity profile of the serum NAb repertoire is conserved and is essentially independent of germline DH sequence.
The remarkable conservation of NAb self-reactivities observed in the en bloc immunoblot assay could also suggest conservation of function. To test both the reactivity and function of the NAb produced by these gene-altered mice, we turned to the well-defined T15 system. Essentially two CDR-H3 T15 prototypes are generated by the IgH allele of BALB/c WT mice, the dominant one entirely encoded by the germline VH, JH, and DH DFL16.1 RF1 gene segment sequence (Fig. 1 A, top; Feeney, 1991). Our panel of mice provided us with a suitable range of alternative DH sequences to study the relationship between naturally selected, germline DH amino acid sequence, both for self-reactivity and for protection against a common exogenous pathogen (for further details see Fig. 1 A and Materials and methods).
In unmanipulated mice, we found that consistent with our en bloc analysis, the physiological levels of anti-OxLDL NAbs were indistinguishable among the different strains, irrespective of the availability of evolutionarily conserved DFL16.1 gene segment sequence (Fig. 1 B). To test the antiatherogenic potential of anti-OxLDL NAbs generated under varying levels of DFL16.1 availability, we then used immunoenzymatic (Fig. 1 C), flow cytometry (Fig. 1 D), and confocal microscopy (Fig. 1 E) assays to evaluate the capacity of sera from each mouse strain to inhibit binding/uptake of OxLDL to macrophages. In each case, we found that pooled serum from each DH-altered mouse strain was equally efficacious to WT in blocking binding of OxLDL to macrophages. Collectively, these results suggested that both anti-OxLDL NAb serum levels and functionality had apparently been both qualitatively and quantitatively unaffected by the enhancement, alteration, or complete elimination of germline DFL16.1 gene segment sequence usage.
We then tested whether the production of anti-PC NAbs had been influenced by altering DH. We first measured the levels of anti-PC antibodies in the serum of naive mice (Fig. 2 A). To perform quantitative calculations for this analysis, we used a parameter that we term R value (Table 1; for further details see Materials and methods), which is an expression of the likelihood of the use of the DFL16.1 RF1 sequence. We related the R value to the prevalence of anti-PC antibodies bearing the T15-Id. Among the seven homozygous and heterozygous genotypes of mice examined (Table 1), the titer of anti-PC NAbs was lowest in the complete absence of DFL16.1 (homozygous ΔD-iD mice, P < 0.001 and P < 0.001 versus both WT and ΔD-DFL, respectively), followed by the heterozygous WT/ΔD-iD (Fig. 2 A). Anti-PC production in both heterozygous and homozygous ΔD-DµFS mice, which retained the DFL16.1 core sequence, was lower than WT but not significantly so. However, anti-PC production proved highest in the heterozygous ΔD-DFL/WT mice, followed by the homozygous ΔD-DFL mice (P < 0.001 and P < 0.01, respectively, when compared with WT). Evaluation of the anti-PC titer as a potential function of the use of DFL16.1 in RF1 relative to the WT (R value) revealed a strong, positive correlation (r = 0.82; P = 0.02; Fig. 2 A, inset). Competition assays showed that the binding of serum IgM from each of the mouse strains to PC-BSA was significantly inhibited by PC-KLH (at least 60%), indicating that most of the natural IgM bound specifically to PC and not to the carrier link (Fig. 2 B). These data suggested that, contrary to what was observed for anti-OxLDL NAbs, the availability of B cells incorporating germline-encoded DFL16.1 RF1 sequence into their Ig H chains might directly influence the physiological production of anti-PC NAbs.
We next tested whether these serum NAb alterations reflected differences in the frequency of anti-PC B cell clones, focusing on the PerC B-1a population. We observed that the germline composition of the DH locus had little, if any, effect in determining the frequency of B-1a cells in the PerC-bearing BCRs with anti-PC reactivity (Fig. 2 C), as analyzed by flow cytometry. To further confirm our finding that PC-specific B cell frequencies were unaffected by DFL16.1 sequence alteration or loss, we tested the capacity of individual B cells to secrete anti-PC antibody in vitro. Limiting dilution analysis (LDA) showed no significant correlation between R and the frequency of B-1a clones secreting anti-PC IgM, confirming the results of flow cytometric analysis (Fig. 2 D). Thus, in contrast to the DH sequence–associated variation in the serum levels of the anti-PC NAbs (actual anti-PC repertoire), the prevalence of PerC B-1a cells with the potential to secrete anti-PC antibodies (available anti-PC repertoire) did not appear to be affected by changes in or loss of DFL16.1 germline sequence content.
In BALB/c WT mice, 60–80% of anti-PC antibodies have been reported to be T15-Id+ (Sigal et al., 1977; Feeney et al., 1988). We thus postulated that the decrease in the serum levels of anti-PC NAbs observed in mice either lacking DFL16.1 entirely or possessing an altered DFL16.1 sequence would be accompanied by a decrease in serum T15-Id+ NAb levels. Using the T15 clone–specific antibody (AB1.2), we found that the titer of T15-Id+ antibodies in the homozygous ΔD-iD mice was at least one log lower than that of the other six genotypes (P < 0.05 for both the WT and ΔD-DFL mice; Fig. 3 A). When compared with homozygous ΔD-DFL mice, T15-Id+ antibodies were also less common in both heterozygous WT/ΔD-iD mice (P < 0.05) and homozygous ΔD-DμFS mice (P < 0.05). As observed in the total anti-PC serum levels, there was a strong positive correlation between T15-Id+ levels and the R value (r = 0.80; P = 0.03; Fig. 3 A, inset). To independently estimate the levels of antibodies that express VH-T15 (VHS107.1) and VL-T15 (Vκ22), we used two additional antibodies, designated TC68 and TC139, respectively. Although the serum levels of antibodies using the VHS107.1 heavy chain gene were significantly lower in the mice using the ΔD-iD allele when compared with WT or mice using the ΔD-DFL allele, we did not observe a positive correlation with R (Fig. 3 B). In contrast, the prevalence of Vκ22 light chain–containing serum antibodies in the seven genotypes roughly followed the same pattern observed in anti-PC antibody reactivity (Fig. 3 C), with a high degree of correlation between Vκ22 prevalence and R (r = 0.78; P < 0.04; Fig. 3 C, inset). A competition assay using AB1.2 as a competitor showed 55%, 70%, and 80% inhibition of IgM binding to PC-BSA in ΔD-DµFS, WT, and ΔD-DFL homozygous mice, respectively. No significant inhibition was observed in pooled ΔD-iD sera, suggesting that the low level of T15-Id+ reactivity in these mice reflected binding to noncanonical T15-VH– and/or T15-VL–containing antibodies, perhaps caused by weakly cross-reactive determinants (Fig. 3 D). These data suggest that the availability of germline-encoded DFL16.1 gene segment sequence quantitatively determines the physiological production of anti-PC antibodies through the control of T15-Id+ expression.
By FACS and LDA, we then analyzed the frequency of B-1a cells in the PerC bearing anti-PC T15-Id+ IgM. Contrary to the relatively stable numbers of B-1a cells bearing anti-PC BCRs, the frequency of T15-Id+ B-1a cells directly correlated with the R value, thus reflecting the availability of germline DFL16.1 gene segment sequence in RF1 (Fig. 3, E and F). These data support the view that the potential to secrete T15-Id+ antibodies is also qualitatively dependent on the germline sequence of the DH locus.
We next examined at the amino acid level the actual composition of the PC-specific Ig heavy chain repertoire in B-1a cells from mice with varying access to DFL16.1 RF1 sequence. From the PerC of homozygous DH-altered and WT mice, we sorted PC-DEX+ AB1.2+ B-1a cells and sequenced their CDR-H3 (Fig. 4 A). The classical T15 CDR-H3 amino acid sequence was found only in the B-1a cell population that stained highly for PC-DEX and AB1.2 (Fig. 4 A and Table S1). This is consistent with observations by Dizon and Kearney, showing by flow cytometry that only the PC-DEXhi B cell population is inhibitable using PC-BSA as a blocking reagent (unpublished data). Indeed, we found that the T15 heavy chain prototype was found only in B-1a cells derived from mice that carry the DFL16.1 gene segment sequence in proportions dependent on its availability for usage, i.e., 70%, 25%, and ~4% in ΔD-DFL, WT, and ΔD-DµFS mice, respectively (Fig. 4 B). Strikingly, both the prevalence of N addition and the diversity of VH/JH usage increased as the complete sequence of DFL16.1 in RF1 became less available to the DH-altered mice (Fig. 4 B and Table S1).
Detailed analysis of the CDR-H3 sequence in transcripts from B-1a cells revealed that junctional diversity, including N-region addition and nucleotide nibbling, can rescue the canonical VH-T15 sequences in mice forced to use the frameshifted DFL16.1 gene segment (ΔD-DµFS), which preferentially encodes hydrophobic sequences in place of the neutral T15 amino acid sequence. Extensive nucleotide nibbling at the 3′ end of the DH segment eliminated the D/J microhomology that otherwise would have helped guide D→J rearrangement into the frameshifted RF2 as well as the stop codon near the 3′ terminus of RF1 created by the DµFS frameshift (Fig. 4 C). N addition at both the V-D and D-J junctions then created a complete, canonical CDR-H3 T15 amino acid sequence. Although in this case the data suggest that somatic selection, perhaps driven by endogenous antigen, can rescue and expand rare TdT-dependent T15 B cell clones, the low frequency observed suggests that the power of N addition to create the T15-Id is limited and dependent on the availability of at least partial DFL16.1 germline RF1 sequence because we were unable to detect the presence of such N nucleotide–generated T15 B cell clones in the ΔD-iD mice.
To gain insight into the quality of serum anti-PC antibodies from mice with varying access to DFL16.1 RF1 sequence, we determined the levels of NAb cross-reactivity to OxLDL and PC-BSA, as well as to binding by anti–T15-Id antibodies. Competition immunoassay studies indicated that the binding of natural serum IgM to OxLDL was inhibited by PC-BSA in a manner that was proportional to the relative use of the DFL16.1 RF1 sequence (Fig. 5 A). In particular, PC-BSA completely failed to inhibit the binding of IgM from the pooled sera of ΔD-iD mice to OxLDL (Fig. 5 A). The T15-Id–specific antibody, AB1.2, was able to inhibit only a fraction of IgM binding to OxLDL in serum from ΔD-DFL and WT mice (Fig. 5 B). These findings were also replicated using OxLDL as a competitive inhibitor of binding to PC-BSA (Fig. 5 C). These data are in agreement with the observation that a major fraction of anti-PC antibodies, a significant proportion of which are T15-Id+, can be physiologically generated in the presence of germline-encoded DFL16.1 sequence and cross-react with the endogenous antigen OxLDL (Shaw et al., 2000). However, our data go beyond these previous studies to strongly suggest that although anti-PC NAbs are still generated in the absence of germline DFL16.1 sequence (e.g., in the ΔD-iD homozygous mice), these NAbs do not cross-react with the phospholipid-related epitope on OxLDL. Collectively, these results indicate that the elimination of germline DFL16.1 sequence has severed the relationship between self-antigen–driven, antiatherogenic OxLDL NAb and anti-PC NAb production.
Although the levels and quality of the anti-PC NAb were significantly affected by the availability of DFL16.1 gene segment sequence, the frequencies of PerC B-1a anti-PC clones were not. We thus tested the ability of the DH-altered mice to produce anti-PC antibodies after exogenous stimulation. The levels of anti-PC and the T15 components (T15-Id, VHS107.1, and Vκ22) in the sera of each mouse strain were measured 7 d after immunization with heat-inactivated S. pneumoniae. Differing from the pattern observed in naive mice, anti-PC production in immunized homozygous ΔD-iD mice proved similar to that observed in WT and ΔD-DFL mice (Fig. 6 A). Thus, the link between R and anti-PC titers had also been severed (Fig. 6 A, inset).
Importantly, the production of anti-PC antibodies was similar among six of the seven genotypes, but the production of T15-Id+ antibodies proved to be strongly influenced by the composition of the DH locus (Fig. 6 B). A strong correlation between R and the T15-Id titer was observed (r = 0.82; P = 0.02; Fig. 6 B, inset). In particular, homozygous ΔD-iD mice demonstrated significant difficulty generating T15-Id+ antibodies (P < 0.05 vs. WT and homozygous ΔD-DFL) even after antigen challenge. The levels of IgM antibodies using the VHS107.1 were similar among homozygous ΔD-iD, WT, and ΔD-DFL mice after immunization (Fig. 6 C), and the correlation between R and the use of VHS107.1 was extremely weak at best (r = 0.75; P = 0.068; Fig. 6 C, inset). However, as was the case in naive mice, the prevalence of serum antibodies containing the Vκ22 light chain in the seven genotypes was comparable with that observed in antibodies with anti-PC reactivity (Fig. 2, A and D; and Fig. 6, A and D). The production of Vκ22-bearing antibodies was significantly higher than WT in both ΔD-iD (P < 0.001) and ΔD-DFL homozygous mice (P < 0.001) and significantly lower in heterozygous ΔD-iD mice (P < 0.001). Caused in part by the markedly higher titer of IgM antibodies containing Vκ22 light chain in homozygous ΔD-iD mice, there was no correlation between R and Vκ22 usage (r = 0.23; P = 0.62; Fig. 6 D, inset). These data show that immunization promotes a serum anti-PC response even when germline-encoded DFL16.1 gene sequence is not available, further confirming that the potential to secrete anti-PC antibodies is intact in all DH-altered mouse strains, as was also observed after polyclonal stimulation in the LDA (Fig. 2 D).
The serum level of anti-PC antibodies in ΔD-iD mice after immunization with heat-inactivated bacteria proved indistinguishable from WT (Fig. 6 A), raising the question of whether the anti-PC antibody repertoire created in the complete absence of DFL16.1 RF1 sequence (see Fig. 5 B), but with full access to VHS107.1, JH1, Vκ22, and Jκ5, would be able to protect against experimental infection with live S pneumoniae. We thus challenged cohorts of homo- and heterozygous ΔD-iD and WT mice with live S. pneumoniae. 7 d after challenge, survival of the WT (15 of 21) and heterozygous ΔD-iD mice (15 of 21) was significantly greater than that of the homozygous ΔD-iD mice (5 of 21; P < 0.001; Fig. 7 A). To assess whether the ΔD-iD mice that survived challenge with live S. pneumoniae had managed to produce levels of anti-PC and the protective T15 antibodies equivalent to WT or heterozygous control, the serum concentration of PC-binding antibodies and the titers of antibodies in the sera that expressed the T15-Id, VHS107.1, or Vκ22 markers were then measured in blood samples obtained from the survivor mice (Fig. 7 B).
Although the majority of ΔD-iD mice died from the infection, anti-PC production in the surviving homozygous ΔD-iD mice matched that observed in surviving WT or heterozygous ΔD-iD mice. However, the variance was pronounced within the homozygous ΔD-iD serum samples (Fig. 7 B), and a correlation between R and anti-PC serum levels was not observed (r = 0.95; P = 0.20; Fig. 7 B, inset). Serum levels of antibodies bearing the T15-Id in the surviving homozygous ΔD-iD mice remained at baseline and were significantly decreased when compared with WT or heterozygous ΔD-iD littermate survivors (P < 0.001; Fig. 7 C). The correlation between R value and T15 serum concentration did not achieve statistical significance (r = 0.99; P = 0.06; Fig. 7 C, inset). The prevalence of antibodies using VHS107.1 was the same among all the survivors irrespective of genotype (Fig. 7 D), and no significant correlation between R and VHS107.1 prevalence (r = 0.83; P = 0.38; Fig. 7 D, inset) was observed. The prevalence of antibodies using Vκ22 was again the same among all the survivors irrespective of genotype (Fig. 7 E), and again no correlation between R and Vκ22 prevalence (r = 0.98; P = 0.13; Fig. 7 E, inset) was observed.
Using genetically manipulated mice, we have previously shown the importance of conserved DH gene sequence content in delimiting the composition of the CDR-H3 repertoire (Schroeder et al., 2010). However, constraints in the CDR-H3 repertoire were also observed in unmanipulated WT mice (Ivanov et al., 2005; Schelonka et al., 2007; Vale et al., 2010), suggesting a role for naturally selected DH genes in defining the composition of the NAb repertoire and, by doing so, potentially regulating NAb functions. The key roles played by NAbs in host defense have been extensively documented (Briles et al., 1981; Benedict and Kearney, 1999; Ochsenbein et al., 1999; Zhou et al., 2007; Rapaka et al., 2010), and more recently their roles in tissue homeostasis have become increasingly appreciated (Shaw et al., 2000; Binder et al., 2003; Chen et al., 2009; Kyaw et al., 2011; Kaveri et al., 2012). Nevertheless, major questions regarding the forces that shape the NAb repertoire remain unanswered. In this study we tested two, in many ways competing, hypotheses: first, that the germline composition of the NAb repertoire is critical for its dual function as a protector against both endogenous and exogenous antigens and, second, that exposure to self-antigen drives the production of these functional NAbs irrespective of germline sequence. Although these hypotheses are not mutually exclusive, they imply major differences regarding the forces that underlie the generation of the NAb repertoire, and the predominance of one upon the other would have distinct functional consequences.
We found that serum IgM NAb from DH-altered mice have reactivity patterns that are predominantly focused on the same self-antigens that dominate the NAb repertoire in WT animals (Fig. S1 A). These data not only reinforce the view that self-antigens drive the production of NAb reactivities, as previously shown by Hayakawa et al. (1999), but also suggest that this property of NAb elicitation is preferentially driven by a delimited subset of the self-antigens (Mouthon et al., 1995).
It is well established that antigen-binding specificity does not always correlate with antibody function (Bachmann et al., 1997); therefore, the study of the well-defined T15 system as an exemplar of the role of NAbs in protection against both endogenous and exogenous deleterious antigens was instrumental to test our competing hypothesis. In the absence of evolutionary conserved DH sequence, we find that somatic selection continues to elicit a set of NAbs capable of preventing the uptake of OxLDL by macrophages (Fig. 1). To the extent that this activity reflects the ability of these NAbs to function in normal cellular homeostasis, these data support the view that production of these NAbs is driven by self-antigen and somatic selection. Furthermore, the data suggest that access to conserved germline DH sequence is not required to generate a fully functional physiological repertoire against self-antigens of this type.
In the case of the exogenous antigen, however, the answer proved quite different. Normal mice challenged with S. pneumonia produce high levels of protective anti-PC T15-Id+ antibodies, mainly derived from B-1a cells (Briles et al., 1981; Kearney et al., 1981). The PC epitopes recognized by T15-Id+ antibodies are found both on OxLDL as well on the bacteria cell wall. Accordingly, it has been suggested that the T15 clonotype has been conserved during evolution because of its value both for protection against host damage by oxidatively modified self-structures and for defense against infection with PC-bearing pathogens (Silverman et al., 2000). However, the severing of the relationship between the production of NAbs against OxLDL and NAbs against PC in our DH-altered mice indicates that the concordance between these activities requires access to conserved germline DH sequence content.
A recent study showed that deletion of the conserved VHS107.1 gene, which is dominant among anti-PC antibodies, led to changes in epitope recognition on apoptotic cells (Chen et al., 2009). In light of our data, we suggest that the NAb repertoire produced in the absence of DFL16.1 sequence no longer recognizes PC as the major phospholipid-related epitope on OxLDL, being hierarchically replaced, possibly by an alternative epitope such as malondialdehyde (Chen et al., 2009). We propose that a large assortment of redundant anti-self NAbs reactive with alternative epitopes are available and able to play a role in tissue homeostasis, irrespective of the presence of evolutionary conserved gene segments. This suggests that major NAb clones, T15 in particular, have been fixed and predominant across evolution through natural selection for both homeostasis and host defense against common pathogens.
The serum concentration and quality of anti-PC antibodies in naive mice proved dependent on the availability of DFL16.1 sequence. The analysis of the actual composition of the PC-specific heavy chain repertoire in B-1a cells from the DH-altered mice revealed that, when there is forced reduction of availability to DFL16.1 RF1 sequence, a compensatory increase in the frequencies of alternative VH and JH genes occurs that otherwise would be biased toward VHS107.1/JH1 gene usage (Crews et al., 1981). In mice forced to preferentially use charged CDR-H3s (ΔD-iD), we observed extensive exonucleolytic nibbling among the B-1a anti-PC transcripts to the extent that 30% of the anti-PC CDR-H3 sequences did not contain an identifiable iD sequence. We also observed a higher frequency of N-region additions compared with the non–anti-PC transcripts from B-1a cells (unpublished data). These findings reveal the existence of robust somatic selection operative on DH-altered B cells and support the concept that the unusual CDR-H3 imposed by the iD transgene might inhibit the physiological humoral immune response to PC. Strikingly, we observed an increase in clonal diversity within the anti-PC B-1a cells as the DFL16.1 gene segment became less available for use. Our findings therefore show that limiting the availability of an evolutionary conserved DH element encoding a major B cell clonotype generates a whole new set of diversified B cell clones to fill the gap left by the missing clone. Thus, contrasting with the original nomenclature, the limitation/alteration of the DH gene, defined as “D” for “diversity” (Cohn, 2008), which a priori would reduce the diversity of B cell precursors, led surprisingly to a more polyclonal and diversified response than the otherwise oligoclonal anti-PC immune response observed in WT animals (Cosenza and Köhler, 1972; Sher and Cohn, 1972; Gearhart et al., 1975; Crews et al., 1981).
Several mechanisms have been proposed to explain the T15 immunodominance in BALB/c mice, which is established early in ontogeny (Claflin and Berry, 1988; Feeney, 1991, 1992). This includes microhomology between the ends of the VH and JH gene segments and the ends of the DH gene segments that, in the absence of N addition, drives rearrangement site preferences (Feeney, 1991). As a result, the prototypic T15 V-D and D-J junctions are the most common junctional sequences among VHS107.1-DHDFL16.1-JH1 genes in neonatal B cells (Feeney, 1991). Likely because of both the high affinity of the T15 antibodies (Feeney and Thuerauf, 1989) and to the self-replenishing nature of the B-1a cells that produce them (Hayakawa et al., 1986b; Wemhoff and Quintans, 1987; Masmoudi et al., 1990; Kantor et al., 1995), it has been suggested that these characteristics would be sufficient to establish the T15 dominance for life (Kenny et al., 1992). As previously suggested, these limitations in the neonatal repertoire may have evolved to reproducibly provide certain specificities that are essentials for the survival of the species, supporting the idea of a layered immune system (Herzenberg and Herzenberg, 1989).
However, our findings reported here reopen this discussion and raise alternative interpretations. The ΔD-DµFS allele contains a single DFL16.1 gene segment that has been doubly frameshifted to enable microhomology-driven rearrangement to preferentially access valine-enriched RF2 sequence in place of tyrosine-enriched RF1. Although access to the RF1 core is still possible, albeit at one-third the frequency, a termination codon was introduced into the third codon from the 3′ end of this RF, thereby destroying a part of the sequence used for the canonical T15 CDR-H. Thus, the rearrangement limitations of the neonatal B cell repertoire that normally ensure the conservation of the T15 clonotype have been subverted in ΔD-DµFS mice and require significant somatic modification to be allowed to contribute to the formation of classical T15 CDR-H3 amino acid sequence. Our finding of the T15 heavy chain prototype sequence among the ΔD-DµFS transcripts thus means that at least three of the mechanisms that normally limit the neonatal repertoire were subverted: (1) the aforementioned role of microhomology between V-D and D-J junctions, which would otherwise generate the hydrophobic-enriched RF2; (2) extensive exonucleolytic nibbling to eliminate the termination codon; and (3) addition of N nucleotides in the germline-enriched B-1a compartment to recreate the full DFL16.1 RF1 amino acid sequence. Indeed, we found additions of a “C” nucleotide at the V-D junction and “TC” nucleotides at the D-J junction, which completely abrogate the microhomology sites at both ends of the DH, concomitantly recreating the T15 amino acid sequence. These observations suggest that there may be a sufficient imperative to create certain clonotypes within the NAb repertoire such that somatic selection can overcome germline limitations to recapitulate the lost “normal” repertoire. More importantly, these mechanisms of endogenous antigen-driven selection proved to be at work during immune homeostasis and powerful enough to be effective without any intentional immunization in the ΔD-DμFS mouse. However, this somatic drive clearly has limits because the ΔD-iD mouse, which completely lacks DFL16.1 RF1 sequence, was unable to recreate this sequence, at least at the limits of our ability to detect it by flow cytometry and sequencing.
Unlike in the VHS107.1 deficiency model (Mi et al., 2000), all immunized DH-altered mice mounted a similar anti-PC response compared with the WT. More importantly, the anti-PC levels were indistinguishable between homozygous ΔD-iD and ΔD-DFL mice after immunization, even though the T15 response was not recovered in mice lacking the DFL16.1 RF1 sequence altogether. Thus, the availability of DFL16.1 core sequence proved to be necessary only to create a robust T15 response. The serum level of TC139+ antibodies, reflecting the use of the Vκ22 light chain, was slightly increased in ΔD-iD mice compared with the other mouse strains, suggesting a compensatory expansion of clones using the prototypic T15 light chain combined with heavy chains other than the canonical T15 VHS107.1. The ΔD-DµFS mice, which can encode the VH-T15 at the amino acid level, had serum levels of both anti-PC and T15-Id+ antibodies comparable with WT after immunization. However, the variance in the T15-Id+ antibody levels observed among the different ΔD-DµFS samples provides evidence for the difficulty in recapitulating the T15 clonotype in this mouse strain, possibly reflecting the low frequency of anti-PC T15-Id+ B-1a cells, as illustrated in Fig. 3 (E and F) and at the sequence level in Fig. 4 C.
Our earlier experiments pointed out the importance of the NAb CDR-H3 in its germline configuration to provide immune protection against S. pneumoniae (Benedict and Kearney, 1999). Here we also tested the effects of the absence of DFL16.1 gene segment on survival after challenge with live S. pneumoniae. The infected mice were able to produce abundant anti-PC antibodies, and both VHS107.1 and Vκ22 sequences were used. Although, our analysis limits conclusions about the antibody response of the initial cohort of mice, we found that 7 d after challenge with live bacteria, only the homozygous ΔD-iD mice were unable to produce T15-Id+ antibodies. However, the anti-PC antibodies produced by these mice were less protective with significantly higher mortality observed in homozygous ΔD-iD compared with both heterozygous ΔD-iD and WT mice. Thus, naturally selected DFL16.1 germline sequence content is essential for the production of T15-Id+ antibodies and is vital for mounting a successful defense against S. pneumonia.
Our findings provide the first evidence, to our knowledge, that the composition of the germline DH locus, in concert with endogenous antigen-driven selection, can both qualitatively and quantitatively regulate the antigen-binding site features of the NAb repertoire and, by so doing, can control the ability of the host to protect against bacterial infection. However, the structural and chemical composition of the NAb paratope repertoire clearly differs, as demonstrated by our sequence analysis. One consequence of this divergence is the severing of the relationship between self-antigen recognition and protection against common pathogens, as illustrated by the T15 anti-PC response.
Collectively, these data may have important implications for the rational design of vaccines against hard-to-defend pathogens such as HIV. The first scenario, in which the protective B cell clones are not available, may help explain why classical vaccine intervention may not be able to easily create a protective immune response without requiring extensive somatic hypermutation (Mouquet et al., 2010; Scheid et al., 2011). Instead, classical vaccine protocols may be more likely to induce a polyclonal expansion of vaccine-specific B cells able to produce a diverse, albeit nonprotective and perhaps deleterious, antibody response (Nicoletti et al., 1993; Limpanasithikul et al., 1995; Putterman et al., 1996). In a second scenario in which the potentially protective B cell clones are available but at low frequencies or in nonchallenged B cell compartments, it is possible that vaccine protocols could be modified to elicit the desired responses at the levels needed to provide protection against future infections. In general, immunogen design will need to address the germline sequence–dependent likelihood of encountering or promoting high-affinity antibodies bearing antigen-binding sites that properly engage critical epitopes on the microorganism. Our DH-altered mouse model provides one approach to testing these hypotheses and thus working out how essential aspects of B cell development and selection of the natural available repertoire influence vaccine responses and thus contribute to the likely success of rational vaccine strategies.
The panel of DH-altered ΔD-DFL (Schelonka et al., 2005), ΔD-DμFS (Schelonka et al., 2008; Zemlin et al., 2008), or ΔD-iD (Ippolito et al., 2006) backcrossed to BALB/c for 22 generations and WT BALB/c littermates were bred in our mouse colony at the University of Alabama at Birmingham (UAB). Animal care was conducted in accordance with established guidelines and protocols approved by the UAB Animal Care and Use Committee. Each mouse strain carries its unique DH-altered allele as follows. The ΔD-DFL allele provides access to only the germline DFL16.1 gene segment, increasing its contribution from 20% of the developing repertoire to 100%. The ΔD-DµFS allele contains a single DFL16.1 gene segment that has been doubly frameshifted to promote the use of valine-enriched RF2. Access to the RF1 sequence remains but at one-third the frequency and with the frameshift insertion of a termination codon at the third position from the 3′ terminus. In the ΔD-iD allele, the sequence of inverted DSP2.2 has been embedded within DFL16.1. The ΔD-iD allele lacks the DFL16.1 sequence altogether. Together, this panel of DH-altered mice presents varying levels of availability of germline DFL16.1 sequence (0–100%).
In WT BALB/c mice, the major T15 prototype uses germline DFL16.1 RF1 sequence without N-region addition (Feeney, 1991). To perform quantitative calculations relating the likelihood of the use of DFL16.1 RF1 sequence to the prevalence of antibodies bearing the T15-Id, we developed a parameter we term R value (Table 1), which reports the expected frequency of mature B cells using the DFL16.1 in RF1 in our DH-altered mice relative to WT. The calculation of R value takes into account the observed proportion of mature, recirculating IgM+ IgD+ B cells in the bone marrow relative to WT (R1), the expected frequency of use of the DFL16.1 gene segment relative to WT (R2), and the frequency of use of DFL16.1 in RF1 (R3), whether the mouse strain in question is homozygous or heterozygous for the mutant DH allele. The R values for each genotype are represented in the Table 1 and were calculated based on previous published data (for ΔD-DµFS mice see Schelonka et al.  and Zemlin et al. , and for ΔD-iD mice see Ippolito et al. ), according to the following formula:
The en bloc analysis of serum IgM reactivities was performed using a semiquantitative immunoblot assay. The method has been previously described (Nobrega et al., 1993; Haury et al., 1994, 1997). Specific antibody titers to OxLDL were determined by ELISA as previously described (Närvänen et al., 2001; Smook et al., 2008), using native LDL (Nat-LDL) and OxLDL (MyBioSource). Quantitative ELISA assays to determine the serum levels of anti-PC and T15-Id+ antibodies were performed as previously described (Kearney et al., 1981; Desaymard et al., 1984). The following reagents were used: PC-BSA (high loaded PC-BSA), the monoclonal AB1.2 anti-idiotypic antibody against T15 (Kearney et al., 1981), the monoclonal antibody TC68 against VHS107.1, and the monoclonal antibody TC139 against Vκ22 (Desaymard et al., 1984). The levels of IgM antibodies in each mouse strain are shown as an equivalent titer to the BALB/c IgM anti-PC–producing hybridoma BH8 (Kearney et al., 1981). The standard curve was used to calculate the equivalent titer of antibodies in each sample.
Binding/uptake of OxLDL to macrophages was assessed by three different approaches, immunoenzymatic, flow cytometry analysis, and confocal microscopy, based on several previous studies (Hörkkö et al., 1999; Binder et al., 2003; Miller et al., 2003; Xu et al., 2010). A murine macrophage cell line, RAW 264.7 (American Type Culture Collection), was used for all assays described, and the cells were cultured according to Xu et al. (2010). Immunoenzymatic assay was performed to assess the inhibition of binding of biotinylated-OxLDL (Biot-OxLDL) to 105 RAW macrophages plated in microtiter wells. To detect the 2 µg/ml Biot-OxLDL bound to RAW macrophages, we used streptavidin coupled with alkaline phosphatase, and the binding is expressed as OxLDL bound to macrophages in optical density at 405 nm. A flow cytometric approach was used to determine the inhibition of binding of 5 µg/ml Biot-OxLDL to 5 × 105 RAW macrophages. The intensity of fluorescence (streptavidin-PE) was indicative of Biot-OxLDL binding to macrophages. The inhibition of binding is depicted in the histogram graphs expressing the intensity of fluorescence, and the statistical analyses were performed using the mean fluorescence intensity of each sample, according to Xu et al. (2010). Confocal microscopy was used to determine the inhibition of binding/uptake of DiI-OxLDL by RAW macrophages. For nucleus staining, the cells were incubated for 10 min with 10 µg/ml DAPI (Sigma-Aldrich) and washed. The cells were then placed for confocal microscopy (LSM710; Carl Zeiss). For all three approaches, the binding/uptake of OxLDL to RAW macrophages was determined in the absence or presence of diluted pooled sera from each mouse strain. The specificity of the binding/uptake of OxLDL (either Biot- or DiI-OxLDL) was determined in the absence and presence of 50-fold unconjugated OxLDL or Nat-LDL as competitors.
The specificity of IgM antibodies binding to PC and/or OxLDL was determined by competition immunoassays as described previously (Binder et al., 2003; Chou et al., 2009). In brief, sera from each mouse strain was pooled, diluted to 1:100, and incubated overnight at 4°C in the presence or absence of increasing concentrations of competitors. Samples were then centrifuged at 15,800 g for 45 min at 4°C, and supernatants were analyzed for binding to the respective antigen by ELISA.
Single-cell suspensions prepared from PerC and spleen were stained with the following fluorochrome-conjugated antibodies purchased from BD or eBioscience: anti-B220 PB (RA 3.6B2), anti-CD5 PE (53-7.3), anti–Mac-1 FITC (M1/70), and anti-CD138 PE (281-2). For anti-PC analysis, we used PC-DEX FITC (provided by J. Kenny, National Institute on Aging, National Institutes of Health, Baltimore, MD) and anti–T15-Id AB1.2 APC (Kearney et al., 1981). Analysis and sorting were then performed on an LSR II (BD) and MoFlo instrument (Dako), respectively. For B cell cultures, the cells were collected directly in sterile tubes containing RPMI medium and for mRNA purification the cells were collected directly in RLT lysis buffer (RNeasy mini-kit; QIAGEN).
Cultures of sorted B cell, stimulated with LPS, were performed as described previously (Vale et al., 2012). Sorted B cells were cultured at variable numbers in 24 replicates for each cell concentration, as follows: 18, 6, 2, and 0.66 B cells per well, to determine the frequency of IgM-secreting clones by ELISA according to Poisson’s distribution and 10,000, 3,333, 1,111, 370, 123, 41, and 14 B cells per well to estimate the clonal frequencies of antigen-specific (PC) and/or idiotype-positive B cells (T15-Id+) using ELISA. Culture supernatants were harvested usually on the ninth day of culture and analyzed by ELISA.
For each mouse strain, B-1a cells PC-DEX+/AB1.2+ diagonal high and low (see Fig. 4 A) were sorted directly into RLT lysis buffer. Cells were sorted from at least five mice per group and then pooled to achieve sufficient numbers of cells to allow for RNA extraction and sequencing. RNA isolation, RT-PCR amplification, and sequencing analysis were performed as previously described (Ivanov et al., 2005), except for the VH primer. To screen for anti-PC Cµ transcripts without missing the true dimension of the repertoire, we intentionally used a VH primer that biases toward the VHS107 family but also allows the amplification of other VH family members (Feeney, 1990). In the present work, we used S107-1 primer 5′-GGTGAAGCTTGTGGAATCTGGAGGA-3′, as previously described by Feeney (1990). We used One-step RT-PCR kits (QIAGEN) for amplification. RT-PCR conditions were 50°C for 30 min, 95°C for 15 min, and then 95°C for 1 min, 55°C for 1 min, and 72°C for 1 min for 35 cycles, and then 72°C for 10 min. PCR products were cloned into TOPO-TA vector and transformed into TOP10 competent bacteria (Invitrogen). QIAprep Miniprep kits (QIAGEN) were used to isolate plasmid DNA from colonies. Plasmid DNAs were sequenced at the DNA Sequencing and Analysis Core at the UAB.
A heat-inactivated preparation of strain R36A of S. pneumoniae was used. 8–12 wk-old WT, as well as ΔD-DFL/ΔD-DFL, ΔD-DFL/WT, ΔD-DμFS/ΔD-DμFS, ΔD-DμFS/WT, ΔD-iD/ΔD-iD, and ΔD-iD/WT mice, were immunized i.v. with 108 heat-inactivated/100 µl, pepsin-treated S. pneumoniae (strain R36A) as previously described (Briles et al., 1982). The number of mice in each group is given with the results. Blood was collected retroorbitally before and 7 d after infection. Mice were euthanized 7 d after immunization.
Live S. pneumoniae strain A66.1 was prepared according to Briles et al. (1981). 8–12 wk-old WT, homozygous ΔD-iD, and heterozygous ΔD-iD/WT mice were inoculated in the tail vein with 9,120–9,750 CFU/200 µl S. pneumoniae (strain A66.1). Blood was collected retroorbitally before and 7 d after infection. Mice were closely monitored for mortality until all surviving mice showed no signs of morbidity (hunched back, poor grooming, irritability, or unresponsiveness to touch), which occurred at 7 d after infection. Surviving mice were monitored daily for 21 d, at which time they were euthanized by CO2 narcosis, followed by cervical dislocation.
Data were analyzed using SigmaPlot version 11 (SYSTAT Software, Inc). One-way ANOVA was performed if data in multiple groups were normally distributed with equal variance. The Kruskal-Wallis one-way ANOVA on ranks was used if three or more groups were compared and the data were not normally distributed with equal variance. If these tests indicated that the groups were significantly different, we used an All Pairwise Multiple Comparison Procedure, Holm-Sidak, or Dunn method, respectively, to determine which of the groups were significantly different from the others. Pearson’s correlation coefficient r was calculated to evaluate relations. The Gehan-Breslow test was used to analyze survival after infection with live bacteria. Rejecting the null hypothesis at α = 0.05 with a p-value < 0.05 was interpreted to indicate a significant difference.
Fig. S1 shows the immunoblot patterns of reactivity against self-antigens (brain extract) using IgM from sera and supernatants of B cell cultures from WT, ΔD-DFL, and ΔD-iD mice. Table S1, included as a separate Excel file, provides the CDR-H3 nucleotide sequences from VDJCµ transcripts cloned from PC-DEXlo/AB1.2lo and PC-DEXhi/AB1.2hi B-1a cells from each of the mouse strains; each of these CDR-H3 sequences is compared with the T15 prototype. Online supplemental material is available at http://www.jem.org/cgi/content/full/jem.20121861/DC1.
We thank members of the H.W. Schroeder Jr. laboratory for thoughtful discussion. We thank Dr. B. Dizon for invaluable advice and support. We are grateful to Y. Zhuang for expert technical assistance. We also thank J. King and members of the D.E. Briles laboratory for assistance challenging with live bacteria. We thank S.L. Dong for advice with the experiments involving macrophage uptake and microscopy. We are grateful for the aid of the Comprehensive Flow Cytometry Core (AR43311) and the DNA Sequencing and Analysis Core (CA13148) at the University of Alabama at Birmingham.
This work was supported in part by National Institutes of Health grants NIH-AI048115 (to H.W. Schroeder Jr.), AI088498 (to H.W. Schroeder Jr.), AI090742 (to H.W. Schroeder Jr.), AI021458 (to D.E. Briles), AI14782 (to J.F. Kearney), and AI100076-01 (to P.D. Burrows). M. Zemlin was supported in part by the German Research Council, Transregio 22, project A17. A. Nobrega was partially supported by Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (CNPq)/Brazil, Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado do Rio de Janeiro, and Financiadora de Estudos e Projetos. A.M. Vale was supported in part by a fellowship from Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior/Brazil and by an exchange-training fellowship from CNPq.
The authors have no conflicting financial interests.