We observed more unique OTUs (3,234) than detected by Shepherd et al. [33
] (1,510 OTUs) despite our lower read depth (2,204 versus 28,458, respectively). This is likely because we had a greater number of horses (16 versus 2). However, our Chao1 index of bacterial richness (795.7) and Shannon Index of bacterial diversity (5.07) were lower than in the previous study (2,359 and 6.7, respectively) [33
]. There was significantly higher bacterial diversity as estimated from OTUs and the Chao1 index in the laminitis group compared to the control (P = 0.019, P = 0.020, respectively). The only other significant differences between the control and laminitis groups was the higher abundance of two undescribed genera of Clostridiales in the laminitis horses (P = 0.03 and P = 0.01, respectively). This suggests potential changes in bacterial communities that should be further explored.
Our lower bacterial richness and diversity relative to what was previously reported could be attributed to an insufficient number of reads to capture all of the diversity within each sample, particularly for the low abundance OTUs [33
]. This is supported by our OTU rarefaction plot that fails to plateau (Figure ). Future studies need to generate closer to the 5,000 reads per sample previously recommended [10
]. We targeted this level of depth; however, because one of our samples was over-represented (30,911) in the pooled multiplex of amplicons, it reduced the number of reads that were generated for the other samples. Therefore, greater attention needs to be given to DNA extraction, PCR amplification, and library construction so that each amplicon is equally represented.
We successfully assigned a greater number of reads to Phyla (98.42% versus < 62%) than several previous studies using 16S rRNA sequences [24
]. This is likely because they did not identify and exclude chimeras, which are known to inflate the number of unclassified OTUs [35
]. We detected the same number of Phyla (16) as in Shepherd et al.[33
], including 4 that were not previously observed in horses; MVP-15, Synergistetes, Chlamydiae, and Deferribacteres [10
]. The most abundant Phylum we observed in horses, Firmicutes, was also the major component of equine intestinal flora in previous studies that analyzed feces from two adult Arabian geldings [33
] and 6 healthy horses [10
], stomach contents from 9 hay-fed stabled horses [34
], and more traditional studies that used clone-based Sanger sequencing [24
]. Firmicutes are also common in the gut of other diverse taxa, from cats, dogs, and polar bears to cattle [38
]. In contrast, Bacteroidetes was the most abundant Phylum among horses that had colitis, supporting the hypothesis that Firmicutes play an important role in gut function [10
Verrucomicrobia, Bacteroidetes, and Proteobacteria represented the next largest components of the equine gut microbiome that we observed; a pattern similar to previous studies, although the Phyla were not always in the same Order [10
]. We detected higher levels of Verrucomicrobia than previously reported (21.78% versus < 5%) [10
]. The abundance of this Phylum in horses from central Texas suggests it plays a more important role in hindgut function than previously appreciated. Our second most abundant genus among all horses was an unknown type within the RFP12 Order of Verrucomicrobia. This is a good candidate for culturing in order to classify it and characterize this taxa’s metabolic function.
The cecum and colon of the horse are important for the breakdown of structural carbohydrates and production of volatile fatty acids [4
]. Therefore, we expected to detect bacteria known to play such a role, including Ruminococcus
spp., and Treponema
]. We indeed detected all of the above; Ruminococcus
had a mean of 1.03%, Fibrobacter
0.004%, and Treponema
2.18%. Our values were consistent with what has been previously observed (0.50% – 4.4%, 0.01% – 0.75%, 0.09%, 1.90% – 3.00%, respectively) [10
]. Interestingly, among the most abundant were unassigned genera of Ruminococcaceae that together composed 8.75% of all OTUs. These may represent important uncharacterized cellulytic bacteria and warrant further investigation.
A vast amount of individual variation was observed in horses at all taxonomic levels. A large portion of this likely came from environmental heterogeneity and differences in animal history, combined with lack of sequencing depth. However, similar individual variation in the equine gut microflora was previously observed. For example, in a study that had a mean of 4,712 reads per sample Bacteroidetes varied from 9.0% to 21.3% and Proteobacteria from 0.0% to 42.7% [10
]. Such large individual variation may be a natural trait of equine gut communities; however, the lack of detailed studies using a large number of horse samples limits the inferences that can be made from these patterns.
The genera previously found dominating the lower intestinal microflora in two Arabian geldings based on 16S rRNA pyrosequencing of fecal samples included Blautia
spp., Subdivision 5 Incertae sedis
spp., TM7 Incertae sedis
spp., and Ruminococcus
]. In contrast, fecal analysis of a more diverse group of horses found the primary genera Clostridium
spp., and Prevotella
]. A study that used intestinal samples detected many unassigned genera affiliated with Clostridium
spp., and Eubacterium
]. We detected all of the above except Coptotermes
spp., and Pseudomonas
. Among the 14 genera that we observed with > 1.0% abundance were Streptococcus
spp., and Oscillospira
spp., and 8 genera that could not be assigned to any described genus. This large proportion of unassigned genera among highly abundant OTUs highlights the need for more traditional studies characterizing bacteria and their phenotypic traits to better understand the function of the equine hindgut microflora.
Within abundant genera we found evidence suggesting additional diversity. The most diverse genus was Clostridium
, which exhibits a wide range of functions and contains both beneficial and pathogenic representatives [42
]. For example, C. botulinum
causes botulism as well as productivity problems and C. difficile
leads to severe diarrhea and colitis in both humans and livestock [43
]. Yet, many Clostridium
spp. are cellulytic and important for the digestion of plant material [45
]. We detected 33 species of Clostridium
, including C. botulinum
in one horse. The population dynamics of bacterial species and their interactions can influence normal gut function and the development of diseases [2
]. It is possible that some of the bacterial shifts that affect disease states such as laminitis occur at the species level.
There are numerous lines of evidence suggesting hindgut microflora play a role in the development of laminitis. Several studies have examined the bacterial response during various experimental laminitis models [12
]. An estimated 53% of acute laminitis cases occur after overconsumption of grain or grass rich with nonstructural carbohydrates (i.e., starch, fructans, or simple sugars) [20
], which is also associated with an explosive proliferation of Streptococcus
spp. and Lactobacillus
spp. in the cecum and a concurrent decrease in the intraluminal pH [1
]. Potentially, either of these may be a factor in laminitis. We found remarkable variation in Streptococcus
spp. among healthy horses (0.40% to 91.96% of all OTUs); therefore the absolute abundance of Streptococcus
spp. might not be important relative to other changes disrupting hindgut equilibrium.
In the carbohydrate overload model of laminitis, Garner et al. [23
] found that Lactobacillus
spp. increased in abundance by a factor of 105
. These changes led to decreased intraluminal pH through the production of lactic acid, which caused death and lysis of other bacterial species including Enterobacteriaceae
spp. and Bacilli
]. Garner hypothesized that these release endotoxins and cause mucosal damage, contributing to the development of laminitis. Endotoxins can escape into the bloodstream and cause immune system activation, inflammation, fever, low blood pressure, and high respiration rate; some of these symptoms appear during the early stages of laminitis [47
]. We found Lactobacillus
spp. represented a small portion of the bacterial communities in the horses we sampled (0.82% controls, 0.60% laminitis). However, we only obtained samples from horses that had a previous history of this condition and not immediately after a relapse of laminitis. Therefore we would not have detected any previous transient Lactobacillus
spp. proliferation. In addition, we sampled the microflora using feces, an approach which could potentially mask changes occurring in the stomach, cecum, and upper colon [32
]. The effects Lactobacillus
spp. and Streptococcus
spp. proliferation has on the equine gut microbiome following an increase in dietary nonstructural carbohydrates and relapse of chronic laminitis should be explored.
The composition of the hindgut microflora also has large impacts on feed digestibility and equine nutrition because the horse depends upon microbial fermentation to digest plant structural carbohydrates [4
]. Similar to previous studies we found that majority of the abundant bacterial genera were anaerobic fermenters, suggesting that the hindgut microflora are specialized for breaking down plant material. Alterations to bacterial communities may confer advantages to horses under certain dietary conditions [50
]. For example, gradual addition of grain into the diet increases the ratio of propionate to acetate, presumably by altering the bacterial microflora [51
]. Propionate can be directly converted to glucose and thus this shift is beneficial for horses with high energy needs [4
]. However, grain also has more simple sugars, which increase the risk of colic and laminitis [13
]. Future studies should explore how bacterial diversity and function can mediate adaptation to high-energy diets and reduce disease risks.