We demonstrate here through reductions in the acute insulin and C-peptide responses to glucose and arginine that a low islet β-cell mass relative to the naive state is the principal cause of the impaired glucose tolerance observed following intrahepatic islet transplantation. Furthermore, rapamycin monotherapy is not associated with insulin resistance in the early posttransplant period. Finally, our results demonstrate that the improved glycemic control following engraftment of a suboptimal islet mass may be achieved, in part, through suppression of glucagon secretion.
The apparent reduction in islet function we observe in transplanted primates may be due to mechanisms other than reduced functional β-cell mass. Reductions in circulating insulin concentration could result from increased insulin extraction by the liver. This is not likely, however, as human recipients of intrahepatic islet transplant have been reported to have both normal insulin-mediated suppression of hepatic glucose production and hepatic insulin extraction (
20,
22), as well as our observations of reduced C-peptide levels, which is unaffected by liver extraction and not disproportionately different than insulin levels in this study. Our primates did have elevated systemic rapamycin levels (
12), possibly inhibiting islet function. Unfortunately, consistent rapamycin levels were difficult to maintain (
11) because of reluctance of the animals to take oral rapamycin and due to its gastrointestinal toxicities (
24). As orally administered rapamycin results in a 1.65-fold higher drug concentration in portal relative to peripheral vein blood, islets infused into the portal vein are exposed to slightly higher sirolimus concentrations (
5). Supratherapeutic sirolimus concentrations have been shown to have a deleterious effect on rat and human islets in vitro (
1), and on rat islet function in vivo (
19). On the other hand, the improved insulin secretion shown in minipigs treated with sirolimus in vivo, as well as the extremely low incidence of diabetes reported in human nonislet transplant recipients treated with sirolimus in the absence of glucocorticoids, both suggest that sirolimus may not cause significant islet functional impairment (
15,
21).
Islet functional assays may also be limited by a relative lack of vascular supply of the transplanted islets. Revascularization of islets in primates may take between 7 and 30 days following transplant (
10) and within 10–14 days in rodents (
3,
23). It is possible, therefore, that our studies were performed at a time when revascularization has occurred. If this is not the case, it is still likely, however, that despite improvements in islet function following full vascularization, that suboptimal islet β-cell insulin secretion would be observed due to the relatively low mass of islets transplanted. It is less likely that ongoing rejection contributed to the abridged islet function, as we did not observe lymphocyte infiltration surrounding or penetrating the transplanted islets (
12).
We assessed insulin sensitivity by the minimal model of glucose kinetics to calculate the S
I, a mathematical index of insulin sensitivity that has been extensively validated in rodents and multiple large animal models, including nonhuman primates (
2,
4). The S
I data obtained from the IVGTT suggest that while islet mass is reduced, insulin sensitivity remains unchanged between the naive and transplanted animals and so is unaffected by rapamycin treatment. Nonetheless, the FFA and glycerol responses observed during the IVGTT provide further insight into islet function postislet transplantation. Insulin's well-described antilipolytic effects inhibit triglyceride breakdown to its products, FFA, and glycerol. In naive primates, we observed a rapid decline in FFA and glycerol levels soon after insulin concentrations rise during the IVGTT. In fact, FFA and glycerol levels remain near their minimum as glucose increases above basal levels. Only after insulin concentrations begin to fall do the FFA and glycerol levels rise. In contrast, neither the FFA nor the glycerol levels decline below basal levels in the transplant group. Therefore, it is possible that the islets of transplanted primates produce just enough insulin to control blood glucose but insufficient insulin to inhibit lipolysis in peripheral tissues. These findings are in contrast to those observed in human islet transplant recipients, who demonstrate the expected insulin-mediated suppression of FFAs (
9,
27). These distinct differences may potentially suggest that nonhuman primates exhibit a greater impairment in insulin-mediated inhibition of lipolysis over that of glucose disposal in the setting of impaired insulin secretion. On the other hand, these effects may be related to rapamycin therapy, as rapamycin has been shown to increase lipolysis and FFA release in 3T3-L1 adipocytes (
31) and lead to increased triglyceride concentrations in human nonislet transplant recipients following conversion from calcineurin inhibitors to rapamycin for immunosuppression (
33).
We demonstrate reductions in arginine-stimulated glucagon secretion that suggest the improved glycemic control following islet transplantation may be related in part to lowering of ambient circulating glucagon levels. The factors influencing glucagon secretion and maintenance of α-cell mass are quite complex. Our group recently showed a surprising reduction in α-cell mass following autoimmune mediated β-cell destruction (
26). Many groups have reported that hypoinsulinemic diabetic patients manifest a paradoxical rise in glucagon secretion induced by secretagogues such as arginine; and that optimal insulin administration normalizes such abnormalities (
17). Further, patients with insulinopenic diabetes but who also lack glucagon (e.g., postpancreatectomy) are less prone to ketoacidosis, despite the insulin deficiency (
7). In addition, genetic mouse models lacking the insulin receptor in α-cells exhibit elevated and inappropriate glucagon secretion and subsequent hyperglycemia (
16). Therefore, it is possible that transplantation of functional islets with a complement of all endocrine cell types through secretion of insulin, or other factors, restores or potentially enhances intraislet signaling within the endogenous islets of the recipient, leading to a reduction in α-cell glucagon secretion. Recent evidence has also shown that inhibition of the mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR) pathway with rapamycin can reduce proliferation of α-cells (
18). It is possible that in a setting of rapamycin monotherapy, the supratherapeutic rapamycin concentrations used in our studies, may have led to reductions in both α-cell mass and function. It is also possible that the mechanisms of reduced β-cell function following islet transplantation, such as revascularization and denervation of transplanted islets, may lead to impaired glucagon secretion.
In summary, we assessed several metabolic parameters using the nonhuman primate islet transplant model. These data suggest that although insulin independent, the imperfect glycemic control observed in islet transplant recipients is secondary to limited functional islet β-cell mass. We demonstrate no evidence of insulin resistance during rapamycin monotherapy in the early posttransplant period. Further, we suggest that the suppression of an inappropriate glucagon response to stimuli observed in T1DM patients and β-cell-deficient primates may play an important role in achieving improved glycemic control.