|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
The association between dietary total antioxidant capacity (TAC) from different assays and serum C-reactive protein (CRP) has not been assessed in non-Western populations. We examined the association between dietary TAC and serum CRP concentration in young Japanese women using different four TAC assays.
The subjects were 443 young Japanese women aged 18–22years. Dietary TAC was assessed with a self-administered diet history questionnaire and the TAC value of each food using the following four assays: ferric reducing ability of plasma (FRAP); oxygen radical absorbance capacity (ORAC); Trolox equivalent antioxidant capacity (TEAC); and total radical-trapping antioxidant parameter (TRAP). Serum CRP concentrations were measured by highly sensitive nephelometry.
The major contributor to dietary TAC was green, barley, and oolong tea (FRAP: 53%, ORAC: 45%, TEAC: 36%, and TRAP: 44%). The prevalence of elevated CRP concentrations (≥ 1mg/L) was 5.6%. TAC from FRAP was inversely associated with serum CRP concentrations (adjusted odds ratio [OR] for elevated CRP concentration in high [compared with low] dietary TAC group: 0.39 [95% confidence interval (CI): 0.16-0.98]; P=0.04). TAC from ORAC was inversely associated with CRP, although the association was not significant (OR: 0.48 [95% CI: 0.20-1.14]; P=0.10). TAC from TEAC was inversely associated with CRP (OR: 0.32 [95% CI: 0.12-0.82]; P=0.02), as was TAC from TRAP (OR: 0.31 [95% CI: 0.12-0.81]; P=0.02).
Dietary TAC was inversely associated with serum CRP concentration in young Japanese women regardless of assay. Further studies are needed in other populations to confirm these results.
C-reactive protein (CRP) is produced by hepatocytes as part of the acute-phase response and represents a sensitive and non-specific marker of inflammation . CRP is associated with cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes mellitus, and cancer , and identification of the factors associated with serum CRP concentration is important to their prevention. Dietary factors represent one major modifiable factor related to CRP, and several previous studies have shown that increasing the intake of antioxidant nutrients (e.g., vitamin C and vitamin E) or foods (e.g., tea, fruits, and vegetables) is associated with decreased CRP concentrations [2-4]. In other studies, however, these single nutrients or foods were shown to have no effect [2,5-7]. Accumulating mechanistic and epidemiological data suggest that antioxidants act not only individually but also co-operatively, and in some cases synergistically . The effect of complex combinations of antioxidant nutrients and foods on CRP concentrations therefore warrants investigation.
Recently, the concept of dietary total antioxidant capacity (TAC) was proposed to assess the combined effect of multiple antioxidants . Previous observational studies [10-12] and an interventional study  showed that dietary TAC was inversely related to CRP among Italian, Spanish, and Greek populations. Given that dietary habits vary by country - vegetables commonly consumed in Japan differ from those consumed in Italy, for example [14,15] - the food source of dietary TAC at the intake level may also differ, and the association should therefore be evaluated in other countries, including Japan. Further, because CRP concentration tends to increase with age , maintaining concentrations as low as possible in younger age is an important preventive measure. Evaluation of the association between dietary TAC and CRP among young adult populations is therefore important.
Here, we estimated dietary TAC from different assays in young Japanese women and examined the association between dietary TAC and serum CRP concentration using these assays.
Details of the study population have been reported elsewhere . Briefly, the present study was based on a multi-center survey conducted from February to March 2006 among female dietetic students from 10 institutions in Japan. The study protocol was approved by the Ethics Committee of the National Institutes of Health and Nutrition, and written informed consent was obtained from each subject, and also from a parent for subjects aged less than 20years. A total of 474 women took part. We excluded subjects whose CRP concentrations had not been measured (n=22), those with CRP concentrations ≥10mg/L (n=2) on the basis that such high concentrations were likely caused by infection or an underlying medical problem not related to diet , and those aged <18 or ≥23years (n=7). The final sample thus comprised 443 women aged 18–22years. All women were free from diabetes, hypertension, and cardiovascular disease, and none reported extremely low (less than half the energy requirement for the lowest physical activity category (< 775 (1550×0.5) kcal/day)) or high (more than 1.5 times the energy requirement of the highest physical activity category (> 3450 (2300×1.5) kcal/day)) energy intake with reference to the Recommended Dietary Allowance for Japanese [5,18,19].
Dietary habits during the preceding month were assessed using a previously validated, self-administered comprehensive diet history questionnaire (DHQ) [20,21]. Responses to the DHQ as well as to an accompanying lifestyle questionnaire were checked at least twice for completeness, and reviewed with the subject when necessary to ensure the clarity of answers. Estimates of dietary intake for a total of 150 food items, energy, and n-3 polyunsaturated fatty acid (PUFA) were calculated using an ad hoc computer algorithm for the DHQ based on the Standard Tables of Food Composition in Japan . Although dietary supplement use was queried in the DHQ, intake from supplements was not included in analyses due to the lack of a reliable composition table of dietary supplements in Japan.
To calculate dietary TAC, a TAC value was assigned to each food item in the DHQ. Among the 150 food items in the DHQ, 54 foods were determined to contain no TAC value because they contained no or only trace amount of antioxidant nutrients such as carotenes, vitamin C, or vitamin E (e.g., animal foods and refined foods). We therefore searched for the analytical TAC value of the remaining 96 foods in the DHQ using the following four assays: ferric reducing ability of plasma (FRAP); oxygen radical absorbance capacity (ORAC); Trolox equivalent antioxidant capacity (TEAC); and total radical-trapping antioxidant parameter (TRAP).
Studies reporting the analytical TAC value of foods were identified by searching the PubMed database, which resulted in many TAC values for assignment to specific foods (about 70% of 96 foods). If we could not obtain a TAC value from PubMed, we searched the database of one journal, Food Chemistry, which was frequently referred to in the papers obtained from the PubMed search. The TAC values of four foods for ORAC and 11 foods for TEAC were obtained from this journal database only [23-28]. We therefore used papers in the literature reporting TAC values of food in analytical data for FRAP [15,29-34], ORAC [14,23,24,35-45], TEAC [15,25-28,33,46-49], and TRAP [15,33]. TAC values were expressed as mmol Fe2+/100g of food for FRAP or as mmol of Trolox equivalent (mmol TE)/100g of food for ORAC, TEAC, and TRAP.
When the analytical TAC value for a specific food could be obtained, the mean TAC value was calculated by weighting the number of foods analyzed in each study, and the mean value was assigned (analytical value; FRAP: n=40, ORAC: n=23, TEAC: n=22, and TRAP: n=21). When the analytical TAC value for a specific food could not be obtained, the mean value of similar foods or a different form of the same food was assigned (substituted value; FRAP: n=22, ORAC: n=20, TEAC: n=22, and TRAP: n=20). For fresh foods, if the TAC value of the food was obtained in dry matter only, the TAC value was calculated using the dry matter value and the proportion of water in the fresh food. For processed foods, if we obtained the TAC values of the ingredient foods, TAC values were calculated by the values of the ingredient foods and their proportion of the total food component. When we obtained a TAC value by these calculations, this value was assigned (calculated value; FRAP: n=18, ORAC: n=27, TEAC: n=29, and TRAP: n=17). The remaining foods were not assigned a TAC value because no value could be assigned using any of the above steps (FRAP: n=16, ORAC: n=26, TEAC: n=23, and TRAP: n=38). Of the 96 foods for which TAC values were sought, 12 could not be assigned a value by any of the four methods. Values for the remaining 84 food items used to calculate dietary TAC in this study are presented in Table 1. Dietary TAC was estimated based on intake and the TAC value of each food.
Peripheral blood samples were obtained from subjects after an overnight fast. Blood was collected in evacuated tubes containing no additives, allowed to clot, and centrifuged at 3000×g for 10min at room temperature to separate serum. Blood samples were transported at −20°C to a laboratory (SRL Inc, Tokyo, Japan). Serum CRP concentrations were measured by highly sensitive nephelometry at SRL Inc. In-house quality-control procedures were fulfilled at SRL Inc, and showed within- and between-assay coefficients of variation of 3.1% and 2.7%, respectively. The assay is sufficiently sensitive to detect 0.050mg/L. Undetectable CRP values were recorded as 0.025mg/L (n=81). Serum CRP concentrations ≥1mg/L were considered elevated for several reasons. First, previous studies have consistently shown that the median serum CRP concentration in Japanese (0.09-0.58mg/mL) was lower than those in Western populations (1.5-6.2mg/mL) [50,51]. Therefore to use cutoff value mainly based on Western population  might not be appropriate. Second, a higher serum CRP concentration is unfavorable for Japanese, although this value was not as high as those of other countries . Third, because CRP concentration tends to increase with age , maintaining CRP concentrations as low as possible in younger age is an important preventive measure. Fourth, some previous Japanese studies used 1mg/L of serum CRP concentration as cut off value [5,51].
Body height was measured to the nearest 0.1cm with the subject standing without shoes. Body weight in light indoor clothes was measured to the nearest 0.1kg. Body mass index (BMI) was calculated as body weight (kilograms) divided by the square of body height (meters). In the lifestyle questionnaire, the subject reported her residential area, which was grouped into one of three regions (north, Kanto and Tohoku; central, Tokai and Hokuriku; or south, Kyushu and Chugoku) and also into three categories according to population size (city with population ≥1 million, city with population <1 million, or town and village). Current smoking status (yes or no) was self-reported in the lifestyle questionnaire. Alcohol drinking (yes or no) and dietary supplement use (yes or no) were assessed as part of the DHQ. Physical activity was computed as average metabolic equivalent-hours per day  on the basis of the frequency and duration of five different activities over the preceding month, as reported in the lifestyle questionnaire.
All statistical analyses were performed with SAS statistical software, version 9.2 (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA). All reported P values are two-tailed, with a P value of <0.05 considered statistically significant. Dietary TAC intakes were adjusted for energy by the residual method using a regression model . The percentage contribution of each individual food item to dietary TAC was calculated by dividing the TAC from each individual food item by the daily individual dietary TAC.
Significant differences between participants with normal and elevated CRP concentrations (cutoff 1.0mg/mL) were assessed using Mann–Whitney signed-rank test or chi-square test. We used the non-parametric test because the result of Shapiro-Wilk’s W test for normality showed that all continuous variables had non-normal distribution. Associations with elevated serum CRP concentration were examined for energy-adjusted dietary TAC. Participants were divided into two categories according to the median value of dietary TAC. Odds ratios (ORs) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) for elevated serum CRP concentrations were calculated after multivariate adjustment for potential confounding factors, including residential region, size of residential area, current smoking, alcohol drinking, dietary supplement use, physical activity (continuous), and BMI (continuous). Additionally, we adjusted for n-3 PUFA intake (energy-adjusted by residual method, continuous) because n-3 PUFA was the only dietary variable significantly associated with CRP; the following dietary variables were not associated with CRP: total fat, saturated fatty acids, monounsaturated fatty acids, polyunsaturated fatty acids, eicosapentaenoic acid+docosahexaenoic acid, alpha-linolenic acid, total dietary fiber, magnesium, vitamin C, fruit, vegetables, fish and shellfish, and dietary glycemic load . Spearman’s correlation coefficients of each TAC and n-3 PUFA were 0.17 for FRAP, 0.17 for ORAC, 0.14 for TEAC, and 0.12 for TRAP. In terms of trans fatty acid, one previous study has shown the positive association with CRP . We, however, did not investigate the association with CRP in the previous study. Nevertheless, while the major food contributors to trans fatty acid are fat and oil, bakery, confections, milk and milk products, and meat and meat products in young Japanese women (86%) , these foods seldom contributed to TAC as shown below (1-4%). Thus, it is unlikely that trans fatty acid and TAC are strongly correlated, neither does trans fatty acid confound or modify the association between TAC and CRP. We thus did not consider trans fatty acid in the present study.
Subject characteristics by normal and elevated CRP concentration are shown in Table 2. Median serum CRP concentration was 0.113mg/L, with a range of 0.025 to 7.100mg/L. The prevalence of elevated CRP concentration was 5.6%. Median dietary TAC was 10.61mmol Fe2+/d for FRAP, 16.78mmol TE/d for ORAC, 6.26mmol TE/d for TEAC, and 6.71mmol TE/d for TRAP. The range of Spearman’s correlation coefficients between each dietary TAC was 0.89-0.98 (data not shown). For the contribution of each food item to dietary TAC (Table 1), green, barley, and oolong tea was the major contributor (FRAP, 57%; ORAC, 47%; TEAC, 37%; and TRAP, 46%) and coffee was the second major contributor (FRAP, 3%; ORAC, 3%; TEAC, 6%; and TRAP, 10%) in all four assays. At food group level, non-alcoholic beverages, including green, barley, and oolong tea and coffee, was the major contributor in all food groups. Although vegetables was the second contributor in the food groups (FRAP, 8%; ORAC, 11%; TEAC, 9%; TRAP, 8%), it contributed less than single food item of green, barley, and oolong tea. The only significant difference between the elevated and normal CRP concentration groups was seen for dietary TAC (Table 2), with respective ratios for each dietary TAC of only 65-82% of those of the normal CRP concentration group.
Table 3 shows the association between dietary TAC and elevated serum CRP concentration. The percentages of participants with elevated CRP levels in the low dietary TAC group (7.7-8.6%) were about two to three times higher than those in the high dietary TAC group (2.7-3.6%). ORs for elevated serum CRP concentration in the high versus low dietary TAC group were 0.30-0.45 in the crude model, and were hardly changed after adjustment for possible confounders. TAC from FRAP was inversely associated with serum CRP concentration (adjusted OR for elevated CRP concentration in high versus low dietary TAC group: 0.39 [95% CI: 0.16-0.98]; P=0.04). With regard to TAC from ORAC, the inverse association between dietary TAC and serum CRP concentration was also observed with this method (adjusted OR: 0.48 [95% CI: 0.20-1.14]; P=0.10), although the association did not reach statistical significance. TAC from TEAC was inversely associated with serum CRP concentration (adjusted OR: 0.32 [95% CI: 0.12-0.82]; P=0.02). Additionally, TAC from TRAP was also inversely associated with serum CRP concentration (adjusted OR: 0.31 [95% CI: 0.12-0.81]; P=0.02).
In this study, we found that a higher dietary TAC was associated with a lower prevalence of elevated CRP concentration among young Japanese women. Dietary TAC from FRAP, TEAC, and TRAP were significantly inversely associated with serum CRP concentration. Dietary TAC from ORAC also showed an inverse association with serum CRP. The dietary TAC values of elevated serum CRP concentration group were significantly lower than those of normal CRP group. To our knowledge, this is the first study to examine the association between dietary TAC and elevated CRP concentration in a non-western population.
In the present study, dietary TAC was estimated using a DHQ for the four different assays of FRAP, ORAC, TEAC, and TRAP. The TRAP databases [15,33] contain the TAC values of only a limited number of foods, and those of 38 foods could not be obtained. In contrast, the FRAP databases [29-32] contain an extensive number of foods, and values could not be obtained for only 16 foods. Further, most foods in the FRAP assay were assigned an analytical rather than a substituted or calculated TAC value. These different results were probably due to the different antioxidant mechanisms derived from different substrates, reaction conditions, and quantification methods . Nevertheless, the major sources of dietary TAC were the same among the TAC assays and the TAC values of these food items were available in the literature (i.e., teas, coffee, and chocolate). Our study showed that dietary TAC from FRAP, TEAC, and TRAP were significantly inversely associated with serum CRP concentration. Dietary TAC from ORAC also showed an inverse association with serum CRP, albeit without statistical significance. Additionally, the correlation coefficients between respective dietary TAC values were high. These results may suggest that dietary TAC was inversely associated with serum CRP concentration regardless of assay.
Whereas previous western studies showed that the main contributors of dietary TAC were coffee, fruits, vegetables, and alcohol beverages [57-60], the major contributor in this present young Japanese population was green, barley, and oolong tea. Even the sum contributions of all vegetables or fruits were less than the contribution of single green, barley, and oolong tea. Additionally, vegetables commonly consumed in Japan differ from those in Italy [14,15], and fruit and vegetable items consumed by contemporary young Japanese women differ from those by young Spanish adults . Nevertheless, dietary TAC was inversely associated with CRP in our Japanese population, as with Italian and Spanish populations [10,12], suggesting that a high dietary TAC is important for a low prevalence of elevated CRP level regardless of the type or origin of food. The present finding of a significant association between dietary TAC and CRP contrasts with a previous study in the same population which found no association between single intakes of vitamin C, fruits, and vegetables and serum CRP . This difference in turn suggests that complex combinations of antioxidant nutrients and foods might be more strongly associated with CRP than any single nutrient or food alone.
Dietary TAC was significantly associated with some lipid biomarkers (e.g., oxidized low-density lipoprotein; ox-LDL) and plasma TAC was negatively correlated with ox-LDL concentrations . These results may suggest that high consumption of antioxidant-rich foods decrease oxidation in the low-density lipoprotein by increasing the plasma TAC availability. These favorable situations might relate to low serum CRP concentrations. CRP production in the liver is induced by interleukin-6 (IL-6) [1,62]. Adipocytes produce many inflammatory cytokines, including IL-6, and their transcription is regulated by the nuclear transcription factor-κB (NF-κB) [62,63]. Given previous findings that dietary TAC was inversely associated with CRP as well as with mRNA expression of NF-κB subunit-1 and IL-6 in young Spanish adults  and that ox-LDL is able to induce a pro-inflammatory status by the activation of NF-κB , the association between dietary TAC and CRP might accordingly relate to NF-κB-regulated pathways interacting ox-LDL. However, that study also showed that dietary TAC was not associated with serum IL-6 concentration . Meanwhile, another study reported that dietary TAC tended to show an inverse association with IL-6 level . These inconsistent results hamper any comprehensive understanding of the mechanism of the relationship between lower CRP concentrations and dietary TAC. Various antioxidants contribute to dietary TAC and these compounds regulate inflammation via multiple signaling pathways . The mechanism by which dietary TAC associates with serum CRP concentration is therefore likely complex. Further, the validity of TAC as a measure of functional efficacy of antioxidant defense in vivo was questioned. In fact, not only dietary phytochemicals, but also powerful enzymes in cells and tissues contribute to the prevention of oxidation. Additionally, antioxidant capacity of some molecules in foods may change into the uptake and metabolism . We should take into account the fact that dietary TAC may not necessarily reflect antioxidant level in vivo.
Several limitations of the present study should be mentioned. First, because TAC data on Japanese foods were available from only a single database , dietary TAC was estimated using databases developed in other countries. Additionally, many foods were assigned a substituted or calculated TAC value. Further, because a reliable TAC database for dietary supplements could not be obtained, we did not consider the intake of dietary supplements in calculating dietary TAC. Second, the DHQ was not specifically designed to measure dietary TAC. In assessing dietary TAC, we were unable to investigate the validity of the DHQ against the 16-day dietary records we previously used to investigate the validity of other dietary variables [20,21] because the dietary record contained an insufficient number of foods with information on TAC values (n=143–373). However, a previous validation study among 92 adult women reported Pearson correlation coefficients of 0.64 for β-carotene, 0.52 for vitamin C, and 0.47 for α-tocopherol , and Spearman correlation coefficients for food groups were 0.75 for coffee, 0.59 for green and oolong tea, 0.56 for total vegetables, and 0.40 for fruits . This satisfactory validity of the DHQ for a wide range of antioxidant nutrients and foods provides some reassurance. Third, participants of the present study were selected female dietetic students, not a random sample of Japanese women. In addition, because of our recruitment procedure, the exact response rate was unknown, which might have produced recruitment bias. Thus, our results cannot easily be extrapolated to the general Japanese population. Fourth, although we attempted to adjust for a wide range of potential confounding variables, we are unable to rule out residual confounding. Finally, the cross-sectional nature of the study hampers the drawing of any conclusions on causal inferences among dietary TAC and serum CRP concentration.
This study showed that dietary TAC was inversely associated with serum CRP concentration among young Japanese women regardless of assay. This result will provide valuable insights from a preventive perspective. Our result should be confirmed in other Asian and Japanese populations.
TAC: Total antioxidant capacity; CRP: C-reactive protein; DHQ: Diet history questionnaire; PUFA: Polyunsaturated fatty acid; FRAP: Ferric reducing ability of plasma; ORAC: Oxygen radical absorbance capacity; TEAC: Trolox equivalent antioxidant capacity; TRAP: Total radical-trapping antioxidant parameter; TE: Trolox equivalent; BMI: Body mass index; OR: Odds ratio; CI: Confidence interval; IL-6: Interleukin-6; NF-κB: Nuclear transcription factor-κB.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
SK formulated the hypothesis, analyzed and interpreted the data, and wrote the manuscript. KM contributed to the concept and design of the study, the study protocol, and data collection and management; coordinated the field work; interpreted the data; and contributed to the writing and editing of the manuscript. SS was responsible for the concept and design of the study, the study protocol, and data collection and management; and contributed to the writing and editing of the manuscript. KU contributed to the concept and design of the study, the study protocol, and data collection. MY, HH, TG, JO, KB, KO, TK, RW, and YS contributed to data collection. All authors contributed to the final version of the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
This study was supported by grants from the Ministry of Health, Labor, and Welfare of Japan.