|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
Conceived and designed the experiments: AMcF JS. Performed the experiments: AMcF GO NO MM TK MK JS. Analyzed the data: AMcF MK JS. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: TK JS. Wrote the paper: AMcF TK MK JS.
COMPcc forms a pentameric left-handed coiled coil that is known to bind hydrophilic signaling molecules such as vitamin D3, and vitamin A.
In an integrated approach we reveal the unique binding properties of COMPcc for saturated and unsaturated fatty acids. Our observations suggest that residues Met33 (gating pore), Thr40/Asn41 (water chamber) and Gln54 (electrostatic trap) are key elements for the binding of fatty acids by COMPcc. In addition, this work characterizes the binding of various fatty acids to COMPcc using fluorescence spectroscopy. Our findings reveal a binding trend within the hydrophobic channel of COMPcc, namely, that is driven by length of the methylene tail and incorporation of unsaturation.
The unique binding properties imply that COMPcc may be involved in signalling functions in which hydrophilic ligands are involved. The pentameric channel is a unique carrier for lipophilic compounds. This opens the exciting possibility that COMPcc could be developed as a targeted drug delivery system.
Cartilage oligomerization matrix protein (COMP) is a non-collagenous glycoprotein of the thrombospondin family that is found in cartilage , tendons , , and ligaments . It is a homopentamer consisting of five subunits held together by interchain disulfide bridges in the N-terminal coiled-coil domain (COMPcc) composed of residues 27–72 (Fig. 1A). The COMPcc chain fragment forms a parallel left-handed coiled-coil with an average length of 70 Å and an average outer diameter of about 30 Å. The axial pore of the pentamer is divided by the hydrophilic Gln54 ring system into two hydrophobic cavities that are exclusively lined with aliphatic side chains , . According to the heptad repeat pattern of left-handed coiled coils, residues in a positions of COMPcc form perpendicular knobs-into holes, whereas residues in d position are oriented in a parallel manner . The binding of a number of biologically relevant hydrophobic compounds to recombinantly expressed COMPcc has been shown, with crystal structures available for the COMPcc-vitamin D3 , COMPcc-all-trans retinol, and COMPcc-benzene complexes . The binding properties of the hydrophobic channel suggest the potential of COMPcc to be used as a storage and delivery system for hydrophobic compounds .
Fatty acids (FA's) have diverse and important biological functions in cells. They are involved in protein acylation, transcription regulation, apoptosis, energy production and storage, and membrane synthesis , . They are essential key components in numerous signaling cascades involving TLR and insulin signaling as well as inflammatory responses , . FA's comprise approximately 30–40% of total fatty acids in animal tissues, with the majority being palmitic acid (15–25%), followed by stearic acid (10–20%), myristic acid (0.5–1%), and lauric acid (<0.5%) . Natural receptors for FA's include family members of the albumin and fatty acid-binding protein (FABP) family . These proteins serve to increase the solubility of fatty acids and mediate their transport within cells. While there are many members of the FABP family with a great deal of variance in protein sequence, all members share a common ß-barrel structural motif . The 10-stranded antiparallel ß-barrel contains a hydrophobic core to which fatty acids bind. The core is capped on one end by an N-terminal helix-turn-helix motif. Inside the binding pocket, the carboxyl group is coordinated through electrostatic interactions with tyrosine and two arginine residues. The hydrocarbon tail is oriented with hydrophobic residues on one side and ordered water molecules on the other side . Multiple fatty acid binding sites have been shown for Human Serum Albumin revealing a combined contribution of electrostatic and hydrophobic forces to the binding interactions . Interestingly, the carboxylate head group of the bound fatty acids are more tightly bound than their methylene tail .
In the current work, we have solved the crystal structures of COMPcc in complex with myristic acid (C14:0), palmitic acid (C16:0), stearic acid (C18:0) and oleic acid (C18:1). In addition, the binding of these ligands to COMPcc in solution has also been studied with fluorescence spectroscopy. From the binding constants we have deciphered a trend in binding favorability that is determined by length of the aliphatic tail and geometry altered by introduction of a cis-configured double bond. A significant finding of this study is the observation that only fatty acids in an elongated configuration can pass the selectivity filter formed by the ring of five Met33 residues located at the entrance to the hydrophobic channel.
The coiled-coil domain of rat COMPcc comprising residues 27–72 was prepared as described previously . Purified COMPcc was dialyzed against PBS pH 7.4 and concentrated to 10 mg/mL using an 10 kDa Amicon membrane (Millipore).
Crystallization experiments were performed at room temperature employing the vapour diffusion technique. Hanging droplets were made by mixing 2 µl protein solution (10 mg/ml) with 0.2 M sodium acetate, 0.1 M HEPES, pH 7.4 and 2 M ammonium sulfate. Individual fatty acids obtained from Sigma were soaked in an equimolar ratio into the crystals for 6 hours. Palmititc acid titration experiments were performed by adding molar excess and incubation overnight. The crystals belong to spacegroup P21 and contain one molecule of the pentameric COMPcc within the asymmetric unit. To analyze the influence of different effectors (pH, ions and organic solvents) four crystal structures performing different crystallization conditions were determined (data not shown). The high resolution data sets were collected at synchrotron CLS (PX-Beamline) on a MAR research imaging plate detector. Diffraction images were processed using program suite MOSFLM  and the structure factors were scaled and reduced using SCALA from the CCP4 package . Statistics of the merged data is given.
Molecular replacement was performed using the AMORE program of the CCP4 package . A Poly-serine model of native COMPcc structure (PDB-code:1MZ9) was used as search template. Positional refinement was performed with CNS using the maximum likelihood method . Five to ten percent of the reflections were excluded for use in a cross validation set. Refinement with CNS was alternated with manual electron density refitting of side-chains and terminal regions using MAIN. At this stage the individual fatty acid molecules have been fitted into a 3.0σ contoured Fo-Fc difference map. To determine the favoured axial orientation of the ligands within the pentameric channel a 2° stepwise refinement (conjugated gradient minimization together with individual B-factor refinement) along the five-fold local symmetry axis was performed . Interpretation of the electron density maps for each solution together with monitoring of the Rfree/Rvalue ratio revealed that no preferred orientation can be detected. In further refinement overall anisotropic B-factor and bulk solvent corrections were utilized. Simulated annealing omit maps confirmed the correctness of the protein and ligand structures. Water molecules were added chosen by distance criteria and hydrogen bonding geometry and were tested for position in spherical density, reasonable temperature factors, real space R-values, and improvement of the R-factors. The program CHARMM  and the effective energy function EEF  were employed for G determinations as described previously 
Steady-state fluorescence spectra were measured on a Fluorolog-3 Horiba Jobin Yvon spectrofluorometer (Edison, NJ). The sample was held in a 10×10 mm quartz cuvette equipped with a continuous stirrer. The data were analyzed with Sigmaplot (Point Richmond, CA) software. The reaction was thermostatically controlled at 25°C by a Jeio-Tech refrigerating bath circulator (Des Plaines, IL). All fluorescence data were collected in 1× PBS buffer, pH 7.4. From the fluorescence enhancement profile of CPA, the fraction of ligand bound protein (f) can be calculated using:
where F0 is the fluorescence of protein sample when no CPA has been added, F is the protein fluorescence at any given CPA concentration and F420 is the protein fluorescence in the presence of 3 µM of CPA. In the case of one ligand binding site, f follows a hyperbolic dependence upon ligand concentration given by:
where B is a constant, Kd is the dissociation constant and [L]free is the concentration of free ligand (in this case CPA). The data in Fig. 3B show a good hyperbolic correlation. Therefore, the binding of CPA to COMPcc is consistent with hyperbolic one site binding and the experimentally determined binding constant was 0.7±0.1 µM.
The probe CPA can also be used to characterize the binding of other fatty acids to COMPcc. The addition of fatty acids (FA) to the CPA-COMPcc complex will displace CPA leading to a decrease in fluorescence. If the concentrations of COMPcc and CPA are kept significantly lower than the Kd value, the following dissociation constants can be defined for the CPA-COMPcc and FA-COMPcc complexes:
In these experiments, the concentration of COMPcc is kept low, both relative to KdCPA and relative to CPA and the concentration of CPA is also kept significantly lower than KdCPA (the initial concentration of COMPcc is ~0.1 µM and CPA is equal to 0.4 µM). In the case where there is no FA added the concentrations are [COMPcc]=[COMPcc]0 and [CPA]≈[CPA]0=0.4 µM. In this case the concentration of the CPA-COMPcc complex will be equal to:
At ,the concentration of the COMPcc-CPA complex is equal to one half the initial:
Writing a mass balance for COMPcc we obtain:
The dissociation constant can be calculated using the value of [FA]1/2 (the amount of fatty acid that reduces the CPA fluorescence to half its original value.
The coiled-coil domain of COMP comprising residues 20–72 was obtained by recombinant expression in E. coli as described previously (see also Materials and Methods and ). The individual crystal structures of the COMPcc-fatty acid complexes were solved by molecular replacement using the apo-COMPcc version (PDB code:1MZ9) as a search template (Fig. 1; see also Table 1). In the individual COMPcc-fatty acid complex structures, one molecule of the respective fatty acid is bound inside the N-terminal hydrophobic compartment in a linear, elongated conformation. The longitudinal axis of the fatty acids are parallel to the five-fold channel symmetry (Fig. 1B). Diffusion of the lipophilic ligands into the channel likely occurs through the N-terminus. Additional electron density in the crystal structure of palmitic acid (C16:0) supports this assumption (see below and Fig. 2B). The fatty acids are retained in the binding pocket through (i) the electrostatic interaction between the electronegative carboxylate head group and the elaborate hydrogen bonding network formed by the Gln54 ring and (ii) the hydrophobic interaction existing between the aliphatic tail of the fatty acids and the hydrophobic cavities that exists between Leu37 and Leu51 residues of COMPcc (Figs. 1B and and2A).2A). These hydrophobic cavities can accommodate fatty acids of different lengths within the channel by mediating interactions with the aliphatic side chains. All amino acid residues in positions a and d of the heptad repeat pattern contribute to van der Waals contacts with the alkyl chain of the bound fatty acids. The terminal methyl groups are held in a fixed position by Thr40 (for C14:0), Leu37-Thr40 (for C16:0) and Leu37 (for C18:0). This interaction is elicited by the longitudinal extension of the fully saturated elongated fatty acids. The C20:0 fatty acid complex is well ordered up to Leu37 after which point the aliphatic tail becomes disordered (data not shown). Based upon this observation we propose that the region Leu37 to Leu51 form the core hydrophobic fatty acid binding region.
A significant structural difference was observed in the binary COMPcc-oleic acid complex. Oleic acid (C18:1), whose aliphatic tail has a single cis-double bond, is held fixed to Leu44 at the cis-double bond kink, while the rest of the aliphatic tail remains highly disordered. The opening of the unligated COMPcc channel has been determined to be of maximal width (~6 Å) at position Val47. This region, therefore, serves to accommodate the cis-configured double bond of oleic acid (Fig. 1A) . The sp2-hybridized double bond between C9-C10 of oleic acid is thus tightly fitted into a hydrophobic ring of the β-branched side chains of Val47, which is a d residue in the heptad repeat pattern of COMPcc. Oleic acids C11 methylene, that immediately follows the double bond, forms van der Waals contacts with three of the five Leu44 side chains in its vicinity.
The structural studies on palmitic acid (C16:0) in complex with COMPcc reveal the presence of two ligand molecules at separate sites (Figure 2). The fatty acid inside the COMPcc channel adopts a linear, elongated conformation with a total length of ~19 Å (Figure 2A). With its terminal methylene groups, C15–C16, the palmitic acid reaches into the cavity between Leu37 (position a in the heptad repeat pattern) and Thr40 (position d). Polar interactions of the carboxylate head group with the proposed dipole of the Gln54 ring system stabilize the ligand inside the channel. The overall shape of the electron density map suggests that the ligand molecule is rotating freely inside the channel. This is supported by the fact that a preferred lateral orientation in a stepwise refinement protocol could not be detected (see Materials and Methods). The second palmitic acid molecule is located outside the COMPcc channel and revealed a curved conformation with a kink at position C4–C6 (Fig. 2B). Interestingly, the bent methylene tail is surrounded by a water cloud, and the carboxylate head group is oriented towards a five-membered thioether ring system formed by the Met33 side chains.
Cis-parinaric acid (CPA) was used as fluorescence probe to investigate the fatty acid binding properties of COMPcc (see also Material and Methods). The free probe has low fluorescence in aqueous solution, however, its fluorescence is increased significantly in the event of protein binding (Fig. 3A). The binding of CPA to the protein follows a simple hyperbolic curve, indicating that one ligand of CPA binds to one molecule of protein. The CPA probe can also be used to characterize the binding of fatty acids to COMPcc (Fig. 3B/C). Titration of fatty acids to the CPA-COMPcc complex will displace CPA leading to a decreased fluorescence. This reduction in the fluorescence signal follows a hyperbolic profile as shown by the correlation line depicted in Fig. 3C. The binding data are summarized in Table 2. The fatty acids all bind strongly to COMPcc, with binding constants in the sub-micromolar range. For elongated, saturated fatty acids, progressively increasing the chain length from C14 to C18 resulted in a decrease in the kd value, indicating stronger binding of the fatty acid to the channel. However, increasing the chain length further to C20 causes an abrupt increase in the kd value, indicating a reduction in binding affinity. The addition of a single double bond to stearic acid almost doubles the kd value, showing that the geometric kink at position C9 in oleic acid (C18:1) disrupts favourable interactions between COMPcc and oleic acid.
The N-terminal cavity of COMPcc is able to bind different single fatty acid molecules, with their charged carboxylate head group oriented towards the Gln54 ring system and the methylene tail oriented towards the N-terminus. The ability of COMPcc to bind various fatty acid molecules is directly related to its physicochemical properties. A key role in the electrostatic fixation of polarized ligands inside the aliphatic channel is played by the Gln54 ring system. The Gln54 residue belongs to a four amino acid motif (QVKE) that is conserved among the pentameric thrombospondins (TSP-3, TSP-4, and COMP) . Gln54 is situated at position d of the characteristic heptad repeat (a−g)n, which is unusual, since the a and d positions are normally occupied by hydrophobic residues. The hydrogen bonds of the Gln54 ring are arranged into a funnel-like manner, such that the partial positive charges on the amide nitrogens are oriented towards the bottom of the funnel and the partial negative charges on the carbonyl oxygens towards the top. This creates a dipole, which is parallel to the dipole moment of the α-helices. The positively-charged bottom of the funnel can act as a trap for negatively-charged ions, as demonstrated in the native structure of COMPcc where a chloride ion is bound . Interestingly, it was shown that the melting point of COMPcc was increased from 73°C to 104°C when Gln54 was mutated to a Leu residue . This implies an evolutionary advantage of the less thermostable wild type COMPcc over the Q54L mutant and suggests an additional function of the glutamine residues inside the pentameric channel. This decrease in thermal stability can be compensated by ligand binding: the midpoint transition temperature (Tm) of unfolding increased by 2°C with benzene or cyclohexane bound in the channel, by 8°C when vitamin D3 and by 10°C with 18:1 trans-9 elaidic acid .
Two additional core residues, all at the d position of the heptad repeat play a crucial role in the binding of diverse cargo elements (Fig. 4). Firstly, Met33 at the N-terminal opening of the COMPcc channel forms a gating pore with a diameter of 3.4 Å. The CH3-moieties face each other and establish strong van der Waals contact forces (Fig. 2B). In contrast the polarizable sulphur components of the thioether are oriented towards the inner core of the pentameric channel. Therefore, one can assume that in order for any ligand to enter the COMPcc channel, the gate has to open thereby permitting access. This assumption is underlined by changes within the helical backbone at the very N-terminus (data not shown). Secondly, Thr40, a subsequent residue in the next heptad repeat, forms interhelical hydrogen bonds between its β-hydroxyl group and the amide group of Asn41. Previous work has shown, that the side chains of the individual Thr40 residues undergo significant re-orientations during ligand binding . In addition to re-orientation, it has also been shown that between the concentric Thr40/Asn41 arrangement and Leu37, a water chamber is formed that contains up to five water molecules inside the pentameric channel (Fig. 4). Comparing wild type COMPcc (pdb-code 1VDF) with COMPcc in complex with vitamin D3 (pdb-code:1MZ9), myristic acid (pdb-code:3V2N), palmitic acid (pdb-code:3V2Q) and stearic acid (pdb-code:3V2P) reveals an interesting pattern (Fig. 4). Whereas apo-COMPcc has water molecules lined up along the full length of the channel, the complex structures only contain water in the water chamber (Fig. 4A). An interesting result is observed in the structure of the COMPcc-palmitic acid complex. In this case, the water chamber is empty and instead a cloud of water molecules is surrounding a second bent palmitic acid ligand that is located outside the entrance to the channel (Fig. 2B). This suggests that the release of channel waters plays a key role in facilitating the binding of fatty acids into the pentameric COMPcc channel. To summarize, our observations suggest that the core residues Met33 (gating pore), Thr40/Asn41 (water chamber) and Gln54 (electrostatic trap) are essential components for the binding of fatty acids by COMPcc.
The local environment of the aliphatic tail of the individual fatty acids is characterized by van der Waals contacts with β-branched side chains at a and d positions, pointing inside the channel of COMPcc (Figs. 1 and and2).2). The binding site is fully extended, providing space for fatty acids up to ~22 Å in length (equivalent to C20:0). A careful comparisons of the crystallographic B-factors for the aliphatic tail carbons (C3 to C15) showed that they are similar in magnitude to those of the adjacent side chains of COMPcc. Whereas the methylene tail reveals an averaged B-factor of ~41 Å2, amino acid residues Leu37, Thr40, Leu44, Val47 and Leu51 show an averaged individual B-factor for their side chains of ~38 Å2. These finding suggests nearly fully occupancy of the fatty acid ligands inside the pentameric channel. However, the crystallographic studies on C16:0 at 2.2 Å resolution show a flattened electron density map for the ligand, missing the expected fine contouring for the individual CH2-groups (Fig. 2A). This suggests that the ligand is rotating inside the channel. The role of hydrophobic interactions in the binding of nonpolar ligands to COMPcc can be assessed by analyzing how elongation of the fatty acid aliphatic chain affects the binding constant. For example, the binding data indicate that adding two carbons to myristic acid results in a decrease of ~0.26 kcal/mol in the binding energy (Table 2). This is only a fraction of ~0.8 kcal/mol, the free energy cost of hydrophobic solvation of the methyl group. A possible explanation for this smaller effect is that the binding of fatty acids to COMPcc is accompanied by a loss of conformational entropy in the aliphatic chain. In other words, when fatty acids bind to COMPcc, the aliphatic chain can not access all its conformational isomers, this entropic loss can partially cancel the gain in free energy due to the hydrophobic effect.
Because myristic acid has 14 carbon atoms, the contribution of the hydrophobic effect (this is equivalent to removing seven or eight pairs of carbon atoms) to the binding of myristic acid to COMPcc can be roughly estimated to be between 2.1 kcal/mol and 2.4 kcal/mol. From the Kd value, the free energy of binding of myristic acid to COMPcc can be estimated to be approximately 8.4 kcal/mol. This indicates that the hydrophobic effect contributes about a fourth of the interaction energy of the fatty acid binding.
It must also be emphasized that although COMPcc binding causes a loss of conformational entropy in the fatty acid ligands, the COMPcc binding pocket is still relatively flexible. This flexibility is shown by the fact that COMPcc can accommodate the unsaturated stearic, oleic and CPA molecules with only a modest change in the binding constant.
Coiled-coil proteins such as COMPcc are attractive candidates for the design of drug delivery systems , , , . In this work we have studied the hydrophobic binding pocket of COMPcc and have characterized the various interactions that play an important role in the binding of hydrophobic ligands to the protein. The following is a summary of our findings: