In the present work, an expression metagenomic library was used to identify β-glucosidases in the DNA fragments from uncultured microorganisms populating the cow rumen. We detected four β-glucosidases that have been subcloned, expressed, purified and characterised; these enzymes were likely derived from representatives of the genus
Prevotella ruminicola (Bacteroidetes phylum) known to be abundant in the ruminal environment [
25].
β-Glucosidases could be employed in combination with low dosages of commercial cellulase enzymes, in applications such as bio-ethanol production [
14,
16], which requires efficient enzyme cocktails to achieve a high degree of conversion of lignocellulose [
9,
10,
29-
31]. Bioconversion of lignocellulose into bio-ethanol consists of four major steps: pre-treatment, hydrolysis, fermentation, and product separation/distillation [
32]. Cellulases and hemicellulases act synergistically in the second step of enzymatic hydrolysis. In this study, LAB25g2 β-glucosidase showed synergistic effects with Celluclast, one of the most common enzymatic cocktails actually produced (Novozymes A/S, Bagsvaerd, Denmark), which can release fermentable sugars from oligosaccharides obtained during the breakdown of lignocellulose by endo-hydrolases. Such synergistic effect is of a special interest as it is known that cellulose is difficult to be hydrolysed even after pre-treatment [
2,
3]. Although the enzyme LAB25g2 did not show appreciable activity towards filter paper where the cellulose is mostly crystalline, it would promote the hydrolysis of short- to medium-sized cello-oligosaccharides (Table ) that are likely produced by endo- and exo-glucanases present in the commercial cocktail. The final concentration of glucose after 96 h of treatment was 234.8 ± 6.4 g glucose kg
-1 dry biomass which is approximately equal to 20% increase in the glucan hydrolysis yield. More interestingly, the enzyme was also able to contribute to the complete hydrolysis of cellobiose in the slurry (containing 20% dry biomass) after 96 h hydrolysis. This result seems to be highly valuable, since
Saccharomyces strains are commonly used for fermentation of ethanol and they utilize glucose more efficiently than cellobiose, because they have no β-glucosidases [
7]. Also, LAB25g2 displayed a high stability under experimental conditions (t
1/2 > 5 days at 50°C and pH 5.2; Figure C) likely similar to those required for the industrial bio-ethanol production.
To understand the reasons of the high performance of LAB25g2 in supplementation assays, a detailed comparison of the properties and kinetic studies of about hundred β-glucosidases from various sources, in which affinity constants (
Km), maximal specific activity (V
max), catalytic rate constant (
kcat), catalytic efficiency (
kcat/
Km) and/or specific activities (units mg
-1) reported for assays using
pNPβG,
pNPβC and cello-oligosaccharides ranging from cellobiose to cellohexaose, was undertaken (data provided in Additional file
2: Table S). They include those from known bacteria, archaea, yeasts, fungi, plants and insects, as well as from unknown and uncultured microbial resources. The β-glucosidase properties from
Aspergillus niger, generally used to complement the cellulolytic cocktail of
Trichoderma reseei[
13] actually used in hydrolysis tests and commercial preparations, were also included. Compared with reported or commercially available β-glucosidases (
Km: 0.004-68 mM for
pNPβG; 4.8-17.6 mM for
pNPβC; and 0.31-66 mM for cellobiose) our enzymes exhibit similar affinity towards synthetic
pNPβG (from 0.034 to 1.73 mM) and
pNPβC (from 0.48 to 1.47) as well as for cellobiose (from 4.88 to 25.51 mM). The
kcat values (≤ 0.88 s
-1) were in the same range or lower than those reported (from 0.022 to 87400 s
-1 for
pNPβG, 18.2-17500 s
-1 for
pNPβC and 4.5-699 s
-1 for cellobiose). However, the enzyme kinetic parameters from previous studies demonstrated significant differences in their hydrolytic capacity against natural cello-oligosaccharides, with notably better values for the β-glucosidases reported in present study. Thus, for the enzyme LAB25g2, the specific activity for cellobiose (1537.2 units mg
-1 when used as pure protein or 231.5 units mg
-1 as crude
E. coli BL21 (DE3) cell extracts expressing β-glucosidase) was up to 38000 fold higher, as compared with the reported or commercially available β-glucosidases (see Additional file
2: TableS ); only the β-glucosidase from the fungus
Penicillium funiculosum NCL1 (1796 units mg
-1) had a close activity, followed at much lower extent, by that of
Aspergillus oryzae (938 units mg
-1). Additionally, it is noteworthy that LAB25g2 did show 27–1166 fold higher specific activity towards cellotriose-cellopentaose (up to 2682.6 ± 0.01 units mg
-1), as compared to known β-glucosidase, with that of
Aspergillus oryzae (512 units mg
-1), being the most-active among enzymes and commercial preparations reported so far. Compared with Novozymes 188, a β-glucosidase derived from
Aspergillus niger and one of the most commonly used β-glucosidases in lignocellulose conversion [
15], we found that crude extract and pure preparations of LAB25g2 were 7 and 46 fold, respectively, more active towards cellobiose (see Additional file
2: Table S). Accordingly, to the best of our knowledge, LAB25g2 has the highest activity reported for short-chain cello-oligosaccharides. This finding is of a special significance, as the activity towards cello-oligosaccharides has only been reported for a limited number for β-glucosidases.
Results further indicated that LAB25g2 crude extract preparation was more effective that two commercial β-glucosidases (selected on the basis of their high β-glucosidase activity as compared to other commercially available preparations) for the saccharification of pre-treated corn stover, as they both produced similar results as the control tests without supplement. This may be described to the activity characteristics differences. Thus, using
pNPβG as substrates both enzymes were 28 (from almond) and 79000 (from
Agrobacterium sp.) times more active than crude extract preparation of LAB25g2; however, using cellobiose, almond and
Agrobacterium sp. preparations were 100–798 less active that LAB25g2 preparation. Additionally, whereas almond β-glucosidase did show low activity at 50°C and pH 5.0 that from
Agrobacterium sp. was quite stable (Additional file
3: Figure S), indicating that both activity and stability features accounted for the LAB25g2 performance. It has been also reported that Novozymes 188 decreased the remaining cellulose concentration in supplementation assays using
T. reesei cellulase by 10.1% (dry matter content of 10%; 37°C, 120 h) at low dosage (3.76 units g
-1 dry biomass, using
pNPβG as substrate) [
15]; this factor is about half of that produced by LAB25g2, although it should be taken into consideration that in our experiments 8.3-fold higher β-glucosidase supplemented activity was used. Under similar dosage conditions β-glucosidase Novo-188 (Novozymes A/S) was found to consume all cellobiose in our experimental conditions after 24 h (not shown), whereas LAB25g2 required several days. Other characteristics of LAB25g2 β-glucosidase (i.e., optimum temperature, 50°C; pH 4.5-5.5, and high stability under supplementation assay conditions (50°C, pH 5.2)) suggest this enzyme has an outstanding position among the reported β-glucosidases isolated from different sources. Most likely, the high performance of LAB25g2 towards oligosaccharides occurring during the breakdown of lignocellulose by exo- and endo-hydrolases, together with its thermostability, seem to be major factors contributing to the biomass hydrolysis improvement when used in combination with the β-glucosidase-deficient commercial cocktail Celluclast (Novozymes A/S).
The discovery of a high performance novel β-glucosidase for the saccharification of lignocellulose under industrial operational conditions is a clear example of the utility of function-centred enzyme discovery in complex microbial communities. The natural selection by the great polymeric substrate diversity imposed on a complex microbial community is likely a key factor driving the evolution of family 3 β-glucosidases, which has been recognized to represent about 19% of the total carbohydrate hydrolases in the bovine rumen [
25]. Taking into account that many proteins of this family share a significant degree of homology with enzyme LAB25g2 reported here, we suggest that the enzymatic potential of the microorganisms populating animal gastrointestinal tracts remains underestimated and underexploited and that animal digestomes may be a potent bio-resource for novel lignocellulases for bio-ethanol production. Although, the yield improvements reported here are far from being scaled up at the industrial level (and are lower than that reported for Novo-188 [
15], one of the most commonly used β-glucosidases in lignocellulose conversion), the present study highlights the need for more extensive experimental work to accurately identify enzymes potentially applicable for bio-fuel production [
33]. That might also result in the production of efficient setups or
a-la-carte cocktails mixed in-house by own technological facilities upon demand and upon the choice of the feedstock.