Recently, the use of the aureolic family of drugs has emerged in both cancer- and non-cancer-related disease therapies
[35],
[36]. For example, the new aureolic acid-type compounds, generated via combinatorial biosynthetic methods, were investigated for their application in cancer therapy and their effect on Sp binding to the c-src promoter region
[37]. The combination of betulinic acid and mithramycin results in a synergistic inhibitory effect on pancreatic cancer growth and has a therapeutic advantage over gemcitabine
[38],
[39]. In addition, Lahiri et al. indicated that Chro has potential for chelation therapy in Cu(II) accumulation
[40]. Divalent metal ions have been shown to be necessary for dimer formation of drugs of the aureolic family prior to the binding of these drugs to a GC-rich DNA duplex
[11],
[22]. Recently, we focused on the development of metal-derived complexes of the aureolic family of drugs and the exploration of their multifunctional anticancer activities, including DNA cleavage activity and topoisomerase I inhibition
[4],
[21],
[24],
[41]. In this study, the dimer form of Chro chelated with Fe(II), Co(II), and Ni(II) can be achieved when Fe(II), Co(II), and Ni(II) are in low-spin states with ionic radii of 75, 79, and 83 pm, respectively
[20]. It is believed that the rigid steric configuration of the bidentate Chro complex containing two neutral oxygen atoms on the chromophore causes a large ligand field splitting on the central metal ions and results in the low-spin states of the chelated divalent metal ions. In stark contrast to the formation of Fe(II)-containing dimeric Chro complexes that exhibited an inversion of the CD band at approximately 275 nm during complex formation, the formation of the Co(II)- and Ni(II)-containing dimeric Chro complexes caused the negative peak at 290 nm. The divalent metal ion-dependent difference in the CD spectra of Chro was ascribed to different structures of the dimeric Chro complexes chelated with various divalent metal ions, specifically the coordination geometry. When metalloantibiotics are used in a clinical trial, their structural integrity must be maintained. Recently, our CD spectral analyses showed that the more stable dimeric complexes of Chro chelated with Fe(II), Co(II), and Ni(II) exhibited strong structural integrity against destruction by heat at 60°C.
Previous studies have shown that metal ions play a crucial role in determining the DNA reactivity of several synthetic and natural metalloantibiotics
[10]. To explore the effects of various divalent metal ions, including Fe(II), Co(II), and Ni(II), on the efficacy of dimeric Chro complexes in the nucleus of cancer cells, we further characterized the DNA reactivity of these complexes. According to SPR assays, the analysis of the kinetic parameters reveals marked differences among Co
II(Chro)
2, Fe
II(Chro)
2, and Ni
II(Chro)
2 interacting with a DNA duplex containing regions of 4-bp G-tracts. Ni
II(Chro)
2 exhibits a faster association rate for binding to DNA than do the other complexes, whereas the dissociation rates of Co
II(Chro)
2, Fe
II(Chro)
2, and Ni
II(Chro)
2 from the DNA were essentially the same. This result suggests that a suitable minor groove in the DNA duplex allows easier access to the minor groove for Ni
II(Chro)
2 than for other complexes. Moreover, the binding affinity of the dimeric Chro complexes for the DNA duplex follows the order Ni
II(Chro)
2>Co
II(Chro)
2>Fe
II(Chro)
2. The thermal stability of the dimeric-Chro-M DNA duplexes increases considerably (Δ
Tm
=

2.89–10.04°C) depending on the metal ion compared to the stability of the complexes without metal ions. Consistent with the above SPR results, the most dramatic increases in the
Tm, Δ
G and Δ
H values of the DNA duplex were observed upon Ni
II(Chro)
2 binding relative to the other complexes. Moreover, this study provides evidence that Co
II(Chro)
2, Fe
II(Chro)
2, and Ni
II(Chro)
2 can generate damaging hydroxyl radicals that cause DNA stand breaks via a Fenton-type reaction and can kill cancer cells. Interestingly, the Fe
II(Chro)
2-induced DNA cleavage rate was 12 and 3.1 times lower than those of Co
II(Chro)
2 and Ni
II(Chro)
2, respectively. Although Co
II(Chro)
2, Fe
II(Chro)
2, and Ni
II(Chro)
2 exhibited different DNA reactivities, the CD spectra of Fe(II)-, Co(II)-, and Ni(II)-containing dimeric Chro complexes bound to DNA were essentially identical to that of a Mg
II(Chro)
2 complex in the presence of a DNA duplex, exhibiting induced CD intensities at 287 and 275 nm (UV region). The results also suggest that these complexes have similar binding modes toward DNA.
RNA polymerase, which is necessary for constructing RNA chains using DNA genes as templates in essential cellular processes, is the target of many therapeutic agents
[42]. Various RNA polymerase inhibitors, such as actinomycin D, are presently used as drugs in cancer therapy
[43]. T7 RNA polymerase possesses all of the fundamental features of eukaryotic RNA polymerases and serves as an ideal model system in which to study the functional mechanisms of transcription
in vitro
[44],
[45]. Our study showed that Co
II(Chro)
2, Fe
II(Chro)
2, and Ni
II(Chro)
2 were able to interfere with the activity of T7 RNA polymerase via groove binding. The binding of a Chro-metal complex with DNA could prevent RNA and DNA polymerase from binding to the DNA, thus affecting the initiation of transcription. In addition, the drug can block the progression of RNA polymerase along the template DNA, prematurely terminating transcription. In this study, Ni
II(Chro)
2 possesses the highest inhibitory effect on RNA polymerase
in vitro compared to the other complexes because it exhibits the highest DNA-binding affinity.
Transcription factors, such as Sp1 bound to GC-rich sequences in promoter regions, are associated with cancer pathogenesis
[46]. Blocking the binding of transcription factors to DNA using DNA-binding drugs and, in turn, modulating the expression of oncogenes such as c-myc have become attractive issues in cancer therapy
[47]. Previous studies reported that the aureolic acid antibiotic Mith with GC-rich DNA sequences selectively inhibits c-myc gene transcription by interacting with the c-myc promoter to block the access of the Sp1 transcription factor
[48]. Our current RT-PCR and luciferase reporter studies have shown that Co
II(Chro)
2, Fe
II(Chro)
2, and Ni
II(Chro)
2 have the capacity to inhibit c-myc gene transcription regulated by the Sp1 transcription factor. As a consequence of our
in vitro transcription results, which showed the highest inhibitory effect on the RNA polymerase exhibited by Ni
II(Chro)
2, this Ni-containing drug complex has the pronounced capacity to inhibit c-myc transcription via binding to the c-myc promoter region.
In early studies, complexes of the structurally related DNA-binding anticancer antibiotics with metals have been tested to amplify their potential in cancer therapy
[49],
[50]. For example, doxorubicin, one of the best known anticancer drugs, has been tested regarding its mode of complexation with a number of metal ions, such as Pt(II), Fe(III) and Cu(II), to determine its effects on tumor cells
[10]. Here, we found that changes in the divalent metal ions in the dimeric Chro complexes have been correlated with improved anticancer profiles. By comparing the cytotoxicities of Co
II(Chro)
2, Fe
II(Chro)
2, and Ni
II(Chro)
2 toward several cancer cell lines, our studies concluded that Chro in the presence of Ni(II) exhibited more potential antitumor activities than did Co
II(Chro)
2 and Fe
II(Chro)
2, due to its higher DNA-acting efficacy. The availability of new metal derivatives of Chro with improved pharmacological profiles may introduce new possibilities for exploiting the unique properties of this class of compounds for therapeutic applications. In summary, our results may provide important insights into the properties of stable dimeric complexes containing Chro chelated by divalent metal ions that may be applied to cancer therapy in the future.