Chromatin has the potential to influence all genetic processes that act on the underlying DNA. The application of genomic technologies to study chromatin organization has revealed a striking alignment with respect to transcribed genes consisting of a nucleosome depleted region upstream of the transcriptional start site (TSS) followed typically by an array of nucleosomes who’s positioning decays with progression into the coding region (1
). This organization appears to be a conserved feature of the organization of eukaryotic genomes and an assortment of factors have been proposed to contribute to its establishment (2
Prime candidates are remodeling enzymes related to the yeast Snf2 protein that have been shown to be capable of repositioning nucleosomes (4
). Of these enzymes, ISWI and Chd1 containing remodeling enzymes have been shown to be particularly effective in repositioning nucleosomes in vitro (5
). These enzymes share structural motifs that may adapt them for the purpose of nucleosome spacing (8
) exhibit sensitivity to an epitope in the N-terminal tail of histone H4 (9
) and have been shown to alter chromatin at specific loci in vivo (11
). This prompted us to investigate the extent to which deletion of any one of these proteins contributes to the overall organization of nucleosomes in vivo
. To do this we took advantage of recently published data for ISW1
) and ISW2
) and our own data for a strain in which the CHD1
gene had been deleted. Numerous alterations to chromatin structure are apparent in each strain. However, when the average chromatin structure with respect to TSS’s is aligned for all yeast genes, the individual deletions were observed to have relatively minor effects ().
Nucleosome organization is disrupted upon deletion of ISW1, and CHD1
The phenotypes associated with deleting individual ISW1
genes are relatively minor whereas deletion of all three genes results in synthetic phenotypes (6
). This led us to investigate chromatin organization in strains deleted for all combinations of these enzymes. MNase digestion of chromatin isolated from these strains indicated the presence of spaced nucleosomes except in the case of the isw1Δ
strains (Fig S1
). To characterize chromatin organization in these strains in more detail, nucleosomal DNA fragments were isolated and subject to paired end sequencing.
The locations of nucleosome dyads were estimated as the midpoint of each paired end read. A plot illustrating how the dyads map to a representative chromosomal locus (Chromosome I coordinates 100,000-120,000) is illustrated in Figure S2
. In the wild type strain a clear periodic enrichment of nucleosomal dyads is observed with a mean spacing of approximately 15 bp. In the isw1Δ
strains, many nucleosomes were observed to be less organized than in the wt strain. However, it is also notable that while many nucleosomes lose positioning relative to the TSS in the triple mutant, a subset of nucleosomes are retained. Alignment of nucleosomal dyads with the TSS reveals that nucleosome organization is grossly perturbed in these strains (). Especially prominent is a loss of nucleosome positioning through the coding regions while depletion of nucleosomes within the vicinity of the −1 nucleosome is unaffected. The loss of chromatin organization is observed in genes expressed at high and low levels (), but it is notable that nucleosome read depth increases within coding regions of highly transcribed genes following deletion of ISW1, ISW2
(). It’s possible that this reflects a role for spacing enzymes in the previously observed retrograde movement of nucleosomes counter to the direction of RNA polymerase (16
). In contrast to the dramatic effects on the organization of chromatin in the coding region, deletion of ISW1 ISW2
had relatively minor effects on chromatin organization in the vicinity of the 3′ ends of genes (). In concert these observations suggest that spacing enzymes play a major role in the organization of nucleosomes especially within coding regions.
Chromatin changes in the absence of remodeling enzymes do not directly correlate with transcription
Although it is difficult to prove a direct role for Chd1 and Isw1 in establishing nucleosome positioning the following evidence supports this. Firstly, these enzymes are especially proficient in nucleosome spacing in vitro (5
) and may contribute to the ATP dependent organization of chromatin recently observed in vitro (17
). Secondly Isw1 and Chd1 are found associated with the coding regions of highly transcribed genes consistent with functions related to elongation (Fig S3
). Thirdly, although there are alterations to the transcription of many genes following deletion of CHD1
(), alterations to chromatin structure do not correlate with these changes to transcription (Fig S4
In order to study how chromatin at individual genes is affected by deletion of spacing enzymes, hierarchical clustering analysis performed to identify groups of genes with similar nucleosome organization. Surprisingly, when clustering was performed based upon the distributions of nucleosome dyads in both the wild type and triple deletion mutant, a subset of nucleosomes that retain organization could be identified (). Interestingly, the location of these nucleosomes varies with respect to the transcriptional start site coinciding with the +1, +2, +3 and +4 positions within different groups of genes. These locations are also favored locations for in vitro nucleosome assembly () and show enrichment for the predicted affinity for nucleosomes (). This suggests that DNA sequence acts as a more important, though not necessarily sole determinant of nucleosome read depth at this subset of locations.
A subset of nucleosomes retain organization in the absence of Isw1, Isw2 and Chd1
An attractive explanation for our observations is that the nucleosome free region at the −1 region acts as a barrier for the establishment of the +1 nucleosome. It is notable that the depletion of nucleosomes in the −1 region is the feature of chromatin organization least affected by deletion of ISW1
. DNA sequence features and or the assortment of other factors known to act in this region may combine to maintain the depletion of nucleosomes in this region (18
). The +1 nucleosome is the most prominent nucleosome remaining in the absence of spacing enzymes () and it is attractive to speculate that its location may be set adjacent to the −1 region. Exclusion from the 147bp territory of the +1 nucleosome could to a limited extent direct positioning of the +2 nucleosome via mechanisms that have been discussed previously (22
). However, in the absence of spacing enzymes, the +2 nucleosome is far less prominent and subsequent nucleosomes barely discernable (). The majority of nucleosomes within the coding regions of genes are positioned in register with the +1 nucleosome as a result of the action of spacing enzymes that position successive nucleosomes within approximately 15 bp of their neighbor.
It is attractive to speculate that the action of Chd1 and Isw1 could be linked to transcription as the periodic nucleosomal pattern decays with increasing distance from the +1 nucleosome. There are also existing links between both Isw1 and Chd1 and transcription (11
). Following inactivation of RNA polymerase a shift in nucleosome positioning towards thermodynamically favored locations has been observed (16
). This loss of organization is not as severe as that observed following deletion of spacing enzymes, possibly because pol II was inactivated for up to 120 minutes and a substantial proportion of nucleosome positioning may be stable over this time frame.
Perturbation to chromatin structure even by a few base pairs can profoundly influence an assortment of genetic processes including transcription, and DNA replication. (15
). This makes it important to understand the principles underlying nucleosome positioning. Here we provide evidence that chromatin remodeling enzymes participate in this process. Previous studies have shown that increased intragenic transcription and histone H3 acetylation is observed following deletion of CHD1
). This may occur as a consequence of the presence of disorganized chromatin. Given the defects to chromatin and it is perhaps surprising that an Isw1, Chd1 delete strain survives reasonably well (6
). Our data indicate that substantial transcription is possible in the absence of correct nucleosome spacing (). Chromatin organization may have a more important role in tuning the sensitivity and kinetics of transcriptional responses (28
) rather than as an obligate requirement.