Tigecycline resistance in
Klebsiella pneumoniae is on the increase, with reported cases in Greece (
9), India (
3), and Saudi Arabia (
1), and its effectiveness as a therapeutic agent is uncertain, with patients treated with tigecycline showing persistent bacteremia caused by
Escherichia coli,
Acinetobacter baumanii, and
K. pneumoniae (
2).
The AcrAB-TolC pump complex is a clinically relevant efflux system activated by several AraC-type transcriptional regulators such as MarA, SoxS, and RamA (
7). Genetic studies have shown that resistance to tigecycline is mediated by the increased expression of the
ramA gene, which subsequently results in the upregulation of the efflux pump
acrAB in
K. pneumoniae (
10,
11) and
Enterobacter cloacae (
6). It has been shown that the increased expression of the
ramA gene is linked to mutations within the cognate repressor,
ramR, that is divergently transcribed from the
romA-ramA genes (
10). However, in a recent study (
10), it was shown that high-level tigecycline resistance is exhibited in clinical strains of
K. pneumoniae that do not overexpress
ramA or
acrAB; hence, we hypothesized that alternative pathways to tigecycline resistance must exist in
K. pneumoniae. Accordingly, we searched the
Klebsiella genome for AraC-type transcriptional regulators that had a size similar to those of the other multidrug resistance regulators such as
marA,
soxS, and
ramA. The bioinformatic analyses of the genome of
Klebsiella MGH78578 (NC_09648) located an additional regulator, which we have termed
rarA (). In an
accompanying paper, we report the characterization of this novel multidrug-resistant (MDR) regulator (
13), which, when overexpressed, exhibits a MDR phenotype independently of
marA-soxS-rob and
ramA. In
K. pneumoniae and
Enterobacter spp., the chromosomally encoded
rarA regulator lies downstream of the efflux pump,
oqxAB (), which has been previously linked to decreased susceptibility to olaquindox, ciprofloxacin, and chloramphenicol (
5). Interestingly, in
E. coli, the gene locus encoding the efflux pump has been shown to be located on the pOLA52 plasmid in strains isolated from pig manure (
12), where the locus is flanked by two IS
26 insertion sequences, highly suggestive of its genetic mobility.
Our research issue was whether alternative pathways to tigecycline resistance exist in
K. pneumoniae. Accordingly, we used a genetically modified
Klebsiella pneumoniae Ecl8Δ
ramA strain, with a markerless deletion of the
ramA gene, in a tigecycline selection experiment. The markerless deletion of the
ramA gene was constructed as described previously (
8). Briefly, Ecl8Δ
ramA from an overnight culture was grown overnight at 37°C on agar plates containing tigecycline concentrations of 0.5 μg/ml, 1 μg/ml, 2 μg/ml, 4 μg/ml, and 8 μg/ml. The overnight culture was also diluted in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) and grown on LB plates without antibiotic to establish baseline growth levels. After overnight incubation, we picked three mutants (TGC1-3) from the plate with 4 μg/ml for further analyses. Accordingly, we found that the mutational frequency of Ecl8Δ
ramA with respect to tigecycline was 0.466 × 10
−6. MIC testing (performed in triplicate) of tigecycline, ciprofloxacin, norfloxacin, tetracycline, and olaquindox was undertaken as described in the British Society for Antimicrobial Chemotherapy (BSAC) guidelines (
4). Additionally, quantitative real-time PCR analyses were carried out to assess expression levels of genes
rarA,
oqxB,
acrA,
marA, and
soxS in the 3 mutant strains by the use of cDNA (generated by AffinityScript [Agilent]) and a Brilliant III kit (Agilent) for amplification. Experiments were conducted using a Stratagene Mx3005P system (Agilent) and analyzed using MxPro software (Agilent). MIC susceptibility testing demonstrated that all 3 clones exhibited reduced susceptibility to the antibiotics tested in comparison to the parental strain, Ecl8Δ
ramA (see ). We also found that the transcriptional levels of
rarA (4.59-fold, 17.15-fold, and 2.14-fold, respectively) and
marA (6.06-fold, 12.13-fold, and 5.28-fold) as well as those of the efflux operons
oqxAB (6.06-fold, 13.93-fold, and 3.03-fold) and
acrAB (55.72-fold, 103.97-fold, and 27.86-fold) were higher than the expression levels seen with the parental strain (Ecl8Δ
ramA) (see ). Of note,
soxS levels were found to be unaltered in comparison to those seen with the parental strain (Ecl8Δ
ramA).
| Table 1MIC and QPCR measurements of tigecycline mutants (TGC1, TGC3, and TGC5) |
Our work shows that tigecycline exposure to Ecl8ΔramA can generate mutants that exhibit low-level multidrug resistance. However, in order to pinpoint the individual contributions of rarA, marA, and oqxAB, individual gene deletions are essential. We surmise that both rarA and marA provide alternative pathways for the emergence of multidrug resistance in K. pneumoniae in the absence of the ramA gene. Additionally, we demonstrate that both the acrAB and the newly described oqxAB efflux pump can contribute to the MDR phenotype. From our findings, it is evident that a functioning ramA gene is not always needed to confer tigecycline resistance in K. pneumoniae.