|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
Conceived and designed the experiments: MV VT. Performed the experiments: MV AS SN. Analyzed the data: MV AS SN RK VT. Wrote the paper: MV SN VT. Critically reviewed the paper: RK. Performed initial aggregation scoring for Htt and het-s: AKB.
Small molecules with antioxidative properties have been implicated in amyloid disorders. Curcumin is the active ingredient present in turmeric and known for several biological and medicinal effects. Adequate evidence substantiates the importance of curcumin in Alzheimer's disease and recent evidence suggests its role in Prion and Parkinson's disease. However, contradictory effects have been suggested for Huntington's disease. This difference provided a compelling reason to investigate the effect of curcumin on glutamine-rich (Q-rich) and non-glutamine-rich (non Q-rich) amyloid aggregates in the well established yeast model system. Curcumin significantly inhibited the formation of htt72Q-GFP (a Q-rich) and Het-s-GFP (a non Q-rich) aggregates in yeast. We show that curcumin prevents htt72Q-GFP aggregation by down regulating Vps36, a component of the ESCRT-II (Endosomal sorting complex required for transport). Moreover, curcumin disrupted the htt72Q-GFP aggregates that were pre-formed in yeast and cured the yeast prion, [PSI+].
Amyloidosis is a group of protein misfolding disorders, characterized by abnormal accumulation of insoluble fibrous protein aggregates . Broadly, these amyloid proteins can be categorized as glutamine-rich (Q-rich) and non glutamine-rich (non Q-rich). Huntington's disease (HD) and Spinocerebellar ataxia  have been associated with expansion of Q-rich repeats. Other amyloid proteins including human prion protein (PrP), Aβ (Alzheimer disease), α-synuclein (Parkinson's disease) and Transthyretin (Transthyretin amyloidosis) lack these Q-rich regions. These amyloid proteins exhibit little or no sequence homology and are associated with a distinct clinical picture, but they share a common cross-β structure  suggesting a common cellular mechanism underlying the pathology of amyloid disorders.
Yeast has been well established as a successful model to decipher the molecular basis of amyloid disorders including Parkinson's disease, Alzheimer's disease, and Huntington's disease –. Interestingly, yeast has glutamine/asparagine (Q/N)-rich endogenous prion proteins  and was also shown to propagate Het-s, a non Q-rich fungal prion protein from Podospora anserina . While a surfeit of research is focusing on uncovering the molecular mechanism of pathogenesis related to amyloidosis, several studies are now concentrating on therapeutic developments. Recently, both research and pharmaceutical industries are putting forth a huge effort to evaluate small molecules from natural products for their medicinal properties. Yeast is being exploited to screen for small molecule inhibitors with therapeutic potential for amyloid disorders , . Furthermore, the ease of genetic manipulation and available tools in yeast allows dissection of the molecular pathways targeted by small molecules.
Curcumin, a polyphenol present in the spice turmeric, is known to have broad biological and medicinal effects including efficient anti-oxidant, anti-inflammatory and anti-proliferative activities. Overwhelming evidence now suggest that curcumin can be exploited for potential drug development for prevention and treatment of several disorders including cancer, obesity, aging, and neurodegenerative diseases. The neuroprotective effect of curcumin has been extensively studied in Aβ amyloid pathology. It binds and inhibits formation of Aβ fibrils in vitro  and reverses amyloid pathology in transgenic Alzheimer's disease (AD) animal models , . In addition, curcumin has an inhibitory effect on the aggregation of α-synuclein ,  and in vitro conversion of prion protein (PrP) together with the inhibition of protease-resistant PrP formation in cell culture . Hence, it appeared very likely that curcumin could inhibit aggregation of expanded polyglutamine repeats in the huntingtin protein. Instead, it has previously been shown to promote aggregation of expanded polyglutamine in exon 1 of the huntingtin protein . Thus, the therapeutic effect of curcumin in Huntington's disease is still questionable. In the present study, we sought to evaluate the anti-aggregation potential of curcumin for both Q-rich and non Q-rich amyloid proteins using established yeast models. Here, we find that curcumin acts through VPS36, which is a component of the ESCRT-II complex and prevents aggregation of exon 1 of the huntingtin protein with expanded glutamine repeats.
VL2, a [psi−][pin−] and a weak [PSI+] [pin−] strain in 74-D694 background (ade1-14, ura3-52, leu2-3, 112 trp1-289, his3-200) was a gift from Susan Liebman. Yeast deletion strains and BY4741 were purchased from Invitrogen. The TAP (Tandem Affinity Purification)-tagged strains for VPS36 (Cat# YSC1178-7501934) and VPS4 (Cat# YSC1178-7503327). were procured from Open Biosystems. Deletion of VPS36 was created in the VL2 strain by short flanking homology primers . The sequences of primers used for deletion are:
The exon 1 of human HTT gene cloned in the p426-GAL1 vector with expanded polyglutamine (htt72Q-GFP) was a gift from Susan Lindquist. The C-terminal prion domain of the Het-s gene fused with GFP is cloned under a galactose promoter in a 2 micron vector . The plasmids were transformed into yeast by standard Lithium Acetate protocol .
Curcumin (Cat# C1386) , morin hydrate (Cat# M4008) and ascorbic acid (Cat# A4403) were all procured from Sigma. α-Tocopherol was procured from INTAS Pharmaceuticals. Curcumin and α-tocopherol were dissolved in Dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), morin was dissolved in methanol and ascorbic acid in sterile water.
The 50% inhibitory concentration (IC50) of the chemical compounds was calculated by adding different concentrations of molecules to yeast culture in early log phase (0.2 OD). The treatment was done for 14 hours at 30°C and OD600 was taken. The IC50 (curcuminIC50=62.5 µM, morinIC50=475 µM, α-tocopherolIC50=650 µM, ascorbic acidIC50=5 mM) was determined by plotting percentage survival versus concentration. The concentrations below IC50 for each compound were used in all the experiments.
A [psi−][pin−] strain transformed with htt72Q-GFP or Het-s-GFP was grown in Synthetic media lacking uracil and tryptophan, respectively. Cells were then re-inoculated in Synthetic Raffinose +2% Galactose (SRaf+Gal) and grown till early log phase. Cells were transiently treated (8 hours) with different concentrations of compounds. Cell growth becomes slow during this period but the cells are then replenished with fresh inducing media and incubated for 16 hours at 30°C. After replenishment, there was no difference in growth in the treated and untreated cultures. Cells with aggregates were analyzed using a Nikon Ti-E inverted fluorescent microscope and manually counted. The percentage of cells with aggregates was calculated by counting more than 300 cells for each treatment per transformant.
To calculate the percentage of cells with htt72Q-GFP aggregates in deletion strains and BY4741 (wild type, WT), cells were grown for 48 hours in inducing media (SRaf+Gal) at 30°C and analyzed under the fluorescent microscope.
In the sedimentation assay, yeast cells with htt72Q-GFP aggregates were harvested and lysed using 1× lysis buffer (50 mM TrisCl, 50 mM KCl, 10 mM MgCl2, 5% glycerol). 150 µl of cell lysate normalized for total protein was loaded on 20% to 70% sucrose step-gradient and centrifuged for one hour at 14000 rpm. 150 µl of different fractions were carefully taken out, boiled at 95°C and run on 12% SDS-PAGE. The blot was probed with anti-GFP antibody (Cat # G6795, Sigma).
In the centrifugation assay, cell lysate normalized for total protein was centrifuged at 17,500 rpm for 1 hour at 4°C. Supernatant fraction was aspirated and the pellet was resuspended in the same volume of 1× lysis buffer. The total, supernatant and pellet fractions were resolved on 12% SDS-PAGE and analyzed by immunoblotting using anti-GFP antibody. β-actin, a housekeeping protein was used as loading control.
For protein levels, TAP tagged yeast strains for VPS36 and VPS4 were grown in rich media, re-inoculated in Synthetic complete media. Cells were treated with 20 µM and 40 µM of curcumin at 0.2 OD and incubated for 16 hours at 30°C. Protein was isolated, normalized, immunoblotted and probed with anti-TAP antibody. β-actin was used as loading control. Anti-Tap antibody was from Open Biosystems.
For mRNA levels, [psi−][pin−] cells were treated with 20 µM and 40 µM of curcumin and incubated for 16 hours at 30°C. Cells were lysed by lyticase and RNA was isolated by the Guanidinium thiocynate-phenol-chloroform extraction protocol (TRIzol method) using TRI reagent from Sigma (Cat#T9424) . cDNA was prepared using High Capacity cDNA kit (Applied Biosystems) and real time PCR was carried out using SYBR Green (Fast SYBR from Applied Biosystems). ACT1 was used as an endogenous control.
Yeast cells contain an endogenous prion protein, Sup35, a translational termination factor. When Sup35 is functional (non-prion form), it terminates at the premature stop codon on the ade1-14 allele. This inhibits adenine biosynthesis and results in accumulation of red pigment in the cell which gives red color to yeast cells on rich media. When Sup35 is non-functional (prion form), it no longer terminates at the stop codon on the ade1-14 allele, adenine biosynthesis takes place and cells appear pink (weak [PSI+]) to white in color (strong [PSI+]) on rich media .
Log phase culture of a weak [PSI+] strain was grown in YPD broth and uniformly spread on YPD plates. Plates were allowed to air dry for 30 minutes and sterile filter paper discs soaked with different concentrations of curcumin were placed on it. A sterile filter soaked with DMSO and 10 mM guanidine hydrochloride was used as negative and positive controls, respectively. These plates were incubated for 2 days at 30°C and then kept at 4°C for 2–3 days. Curing of weak [PSI+] was monitored by change in coloration of the colonies.
The inhibitory effect of curcumin has been well established for non Q-rich amyloid proteins including Alzheimer's  but has been shown to promote aggregation of mutant huntingtin . The difference in action of curcumin on two different types of amyloid proteins prompted us to re-examine the effect of curcumin on existing yeast models for both Q-rich and non Q-rich amyloid proteins. The effect of curcumin was analyzed on htt72Q-GFP and Het-s-GFP aggregation by fluorescent microscopy in a [psi−][pin−] strain (Figure S1). More than 2-fold decrease at 20 µM and >3-fold decrease at 40 µM of curcumin were consistently observed for cells with htt72Q-GFP aggregates (Figure 1A). In case of Het-s-GFP aggregates, 1.7-fold inhibition at 20 µM and ~2-fold at 40 µM was observed (Figure 1B). Thus, we observed a significant dose-dependent inhibitory effect on both htt72Q-GFP and Het-s-GFP aggregates.
The inhibitory effect of curcumin treatment on htt72Q-GFP aggregation was validated by sedimentation profile of htt72Q-GFP aggregates on sucrose step-gradient. Cells over expressing htt72Q-GFP were transiently (8 hours) treated with curcumin, lysed and loaded on sucrose gradient. In absence of curcumin, higher molecular weight htt72Q-GFP aggregates penetrated deeper into the higher fractions of sucrose gradient. In cells treated with 20 µM curcumin, higher molecular weight aggregates decreased significantly (fractions 4–6) and lower molecular weight aggregates increased (fractions 2 and 3) (Figure 1C). Centrifugation assay also showed a clear decrease in the pellet fraction, which again validates the inhibition of aggregation after curcumin treatment (Figure 1D).
We also analyzed the effect of three other known antioxidants on htt72Q-GFP and Het-s- GFP aggregation. Morin showed a significant dose-dependent decrease (2-fold at 150 µM and 4-fold at 300 µM) and α-tocopherol showed ~2-fold decrease but at much higher dosage (400 µM) in htt72Q-GFP aggregates. Ascorbic acid did not show any effect on htt72Q-GFP aggregates (Figure 1A). No significant effect of morin, α-tocopherol and ascorbic acid on Het-s aggregation was observed (Figure 1B).
As curcumin exhibited an appreciable inhibition of appearance of both Q-rich and non Q-rich aggregates, we were curious to decipher the mechanism of action of curcumin. To identify the cellular target of curcumin, we utilized the information provided by the chemogenomics profiling fitness database (http://fitdb.stanford.edu/fitdb.cgi) that lists heterozygous or homozygous deletion mutants with increased sensitivity to compounds . We examined htt72Q-GFP aggregation in eight homozygous yeast deletion strains (cc2Δ, ypk1Δ, atx1Δ, vps36Δ, sip3Δ, pho86Δ, vam7Δ and fet3Δ) shown to exhibit the maximum growth defect in the presence of curcumin. The growth defect in these deletion strains was confirmed in the presence of curcumin (data not shown). Out of eight, seven strains showed aggregation similar to BY4741. The vps36Δ strain showed a significant decrease in the percentage of cells with htt72Q-GFP aggregates (Figure 2A). We confirmed that this decrease in aggregation is not due to growth inhibition as no appreciable decrease in growth rate was observed between BY4741 and vps36Δ. To analyze the effect of Vps36 on htt72Q-GFP aggregation in another yeast strain background, deletion of VPS36 was recreated in the VL2 strain and confirmed by PCR (data not shown). A similar decrease in aggregation was observed in this strain and validated by a shift towards lower fractions on sucrose density gradient (Figure 2B) and a significant decrease in pellet fraction (Figure 2C).
VPS36 is a component of the ESCRT-II complex and encodes Vacuolar Protein Sorting protein 36. To validate if the inhibiton of aggregation after curcumin treatment is through Vps36, the effect of curcumin on expression levels of Vps36 was analyzed. A dose and time-dependent decrease in mRNA levels of Vps36 was observed by real time PCR. VL2 strain was treated with curcumin for 16 hours, a 1.5-fold and >4-fold decrease in levels of Vps36 mRNA was observed for 20 µM and 40 µM, respectively (Figure 3A). The time-dependent effect was monitored at 20 µM curcumin after 17, 24 and 40 hours of treatment. A significant decrease in Vps36 mRNA levels at 17 hours and further decrease at 24 hours was observed. However, after 40 hours, the levels of Vps36 mRNA increased a little compared to the untreated sample (Figure 3B). A moderate decrease in the protein levels of Vps36 was also observed after curcumin treatment (Figure 3C) by probing for TAP-tagged Vps36 in BY4741 strain background. The levels of Vps4, which is involved in disassembly of ESCRT–III complex, showed no change after curcumin treatment (Figure 3A and 3D). Deletion of vps4 did not show any change in percentage of cells with aggregation compared to BY4741 (Figure 2A). Hence, curcumin significantly downregulates Vps36 levels in yeast.
As curcumin is known to destabilize pre-formed Aβ fibrils , we asked if curcumin also acts on pre-formed htt72Q-GFP aggregates. Cells with htt72Q-GFP were grown in inducing media for 48 hours, analyzed for aggregates and lysed. Cell lysate containing the pre-formed aggregates was treated in vitro with 100 µM curcumin at 37°C for 16 hours and analyzed by sedimentation profiling. The aggregates from untreated lysate penetrated into higher fractions of sucrose gradient, which diminished considerably after treatment (Figure 4A). The aggregates appeared more concentrated in supernatant and lower fractions of sucrose gradient. This shows that curcumin destabilizes htt72Q-GFP aggregates that are pre-formed in yeast.
The effect of curcumin was also analyzed on the endogenous yeast prion. A dose-dependent effect of curcumin on weak [PSI+] was observed on rich media plates as an increase in red coloration of colonies around the discs soaked with increasing concentration of curcumin (Figure 4B). These red colonies were picked and restreaked on rich media lacking curcumin, which propagated as red color [psi−] colonies as shown in figure 4B. The control discs soaked in DMSO did not cause any color change. No effect of curcumin was visible on strong [PSI+] strain (data not shown).
Emerging evidence suggest a neuroprotective role of curcumin in Alzheimer's disease and several clinical trials have been initiated to examine the effect of curcumin in AD patients. Contrary to this, curcumin has been shown to increase the aggregation of mutant huntingtin and also enhance toxicity associated in PC12 cells by augmenting the proteasomal dysfunction . Impairment of proteasomal machinery is implicated in other amyloid disorders including AD and HD –, therefore, if curcumin enhances a proteasomal defect, a similar increase in aggregation is expected on treatment for other amyloid proteins. Though Aβ peptide and mutant huntingtin protein form similar cross β-sheet structures, the major difference lies in their sequence. While Aβ lacks glutamine repeats, huntingtin protein is glutamine rich. This intrigued us and we investigated aggregation of mutant huntingtin with expanded glutamine repeats and Het-s, a non Q-rich fungal prion protein, after curcumin treatment in yeast. In accordance with a protective effect of curcumin for neurodegenerative disorders, we demonstrate an inhibitory effect of curcumin on both Q-rich and non Q-rich protein aggregation in yeast and describe the likely mechanisms of inhibition.
The molecular mechanism of action of curcumin is complex and multiple molecular targets have been proposed by several independent studies . Curcumin has been shown to have a therapeutic effect on AD by reducing oxidative damage , decreasing β-amyloid formation by inhibiting GSK-3β-mediated presenilin-1 levels  and Wnt/β-catenin signaling pathway activation  and also inhibiting trafficking and maturation of Amyloid Precursor Protein (APP) into Aβ peptide . We scored aggregation in eight homozygous deletion strains hypersensitive to curcumin and only deletion of VPS36 caused significant inhibition of formation of aggregates of mutant huntingtin. Vps36, a component of the ESCRT-II complex, appeared to be a functional target of curcumin as it was downregulated in a dose and time-dependent manner. Vps36 is involved in trafficking soluble and integral membrane proteins from the trans-golgi network to the perivacuolar region and finally to the vacuole . As misfolded proteins including mutant huntingtin are known to localize in the perivacuolar region , we propose that in vivo deletion or downregulation of Vps36 caused by curcumin treatment prevents recruitment of misfolded protein to the perivacuolar compartment and thus inhibits formation of visible large aggregates. The importance of protein trafficking pathways in aggregation of amyloid proteins has been demonstrated previously. Several genes from endocytic pathway and vacuolar protein sorting are known to affect aggregation of amyloid proteins including mutant huntingtin  and prion proteins . In compliance with previous work, our work further strengthens that protein trafficking pathways can be exploited for developing small molecule inhibitors of amyloid disorders.
Curcumin has been shown to destabilize Aβ fibrils but disassembly of mutant huntingtin by curcumin has not been described earlier. In vitro, disruption or remodelling of mutant huntingtin aggregates pre-formed in yeast clearly supports anti-aggregation potential of curcumin. Furthermore, our findings are supported by a very recent report that shows a clear decrease in number of aggregates in the striatum of knock-in HD mouse model . Curcumin is known to cross the blood-brain barrier but bioavailibity is still poor. Hence, analogs of curcumin or combination of small molecules that increase the bioavailability of the active molecule need to be evaluated.
Morin, a polyphenol, present in red wine, has been suggested to have potential for developing therapies for AD and tauopathies by inhibiting GSK-3β , . Recently, it has been reported to inhibit amyloid formation of Islet Amyloid Polypeptide (IAPP) . We show that morin is an effective inhibitor of mutant huntingtin aggregates. Morin treatment also led to slight inhibition of non-Q rich aggregates. Further work is required to understand the mechanism of action of morin.
The key findings of our study are that curcumin is a more potent inhibitor of both Q-rich and non Q-rich aggregates than morin and α-tocopherol. Furthermore, it inhibits mutant huntingtin aggregation by acting through protein trafficking pathways and also destabilizes pre-formed aggregates. Based on our data and previous studies, curcumin is a promising compound for development of preventives and therapeutics for both Q-rich and non Q-rich amyloid disorders.
Microscopic image of cells showing the effect of curcumin on htt72Q-GFP aggregates in yeast.
We thank Prof. Susan Liebman, Dr. Rakesh Sharma and Dr. Veronique Dinand for carefully evaluating our work and giving useful suggestions and Kavita for helpful comments on the manuscript. We thank Prof. Nirmal Kumar Ganguly for the support and encouragement during this study.
Innovative Young Biotechnology Award, Department of Biotechnology, Government of India, India. VT acknowledges fellowship from Innovative Young Biotechnologist Award, Department of Biotechnology, India. MV acknowledges senior research fellowship from Indian Council of Medical Research. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.