Despite some similarities between AMD and myopic CNV, including macular CNV, subretinal location of the CNV outgrowth, and some degree of atrophy, no genetic variants have been previously reported to be associated with myopic CNV among Caucasians. In this study, we evaluated several AMD genetic variants that could also be involved in myopic CNV development. Following a candidate gene approach, this case-control study identified one SNP in the CFI gene significantly associated with myopic CNV even after adjusting for confounding factors and multiple testing. Other SNPs that showed suggestive evidence for association are worthy of further exploration as well.
The T allele of rs10033900, which is located 2781 bp upstream of the 3′ untranslated region of the complement factor I gene (
CFI), has been associated with increased risk of exudative AMD in Caucasians.
44,47 Both complement factors I and H are complement regulatory proteins.
CFH encodes factor H, the most important alternative pathway discriminator that binds C3b and prevents the formation of C3 convertase and acts as a cofactor of factor I to cleave C3b in iC3b.
49
CFI is expressed by hepatocytes, macrophages, lymphocytes, endothelial cells, and fibroblasts and encodes factor I, a regulator protein of the three complement pathways.
50 By cleaving of C3b and C4b, factor I reduces the formation of the C3 and C5 convertase enzymes.
50 Other genes in the complement cascade pathway are associated with exudative AMD, including
CFH, C2, CFB, and
C3.
34–36,39–43 Interestingly,
CFH (rs1061170,
P = 0.04) and
CFI (rs10033900,
P = 0.0023) appeared to be related to myopic CNV in this study after adjustment for age, sex, and degree of myopia, and
CFI remained significant after adjustment for multiple testing. The possible difference in effect of
CFI compared with
CFH on myopic CNV risk may be related to the fact that factor I is involved in the classic, lectin and alternative pathways, while factor H is only involved in the regulation of the alternative pathway.
55 It is interesting to note that the gene on chromosome 10,
ARMS2/HTRA1, was not related to myopic CNV in this study even though this gene is more strongly associated with CNV compared with geographic atrophy in AMD
47,56 and also more strongly associated with all AMD subtypes when compared with the CFH at-risk common variant.
57 It is also noteworthy that the SNPs in the VEGF gene were not related to myopic CNV, given that
VEGF rs4711751 is related to advanced dry and exudative AMD.
47The intronic SNP rs669676 in the
COL8A1 gene was associated with myopic CNV after adjustment for age, sex, and degree of myopia (
P = 0.0076). This gene encodes one of the two alpha chains of type VIII collagen, a major component of basement membranes of Bruch's membrane and choroidal stroma.
58 The intronic SNP rs13095226 in this gene is associated with advanced AMD in our previous studies.
45,47 The SNP rs669676 of
COL8A1 might lead to direct or indirect structural alterations of the Bruch's membrane as frequently observed during high myopia (), which is a risk factor for myopic CNV.
59The association between the E4
APOE haplotype and a reduced risk of AMD has been described in two independent case-control studies,
32,33 and supported by other studies or in meta-analyses.
60–62 The lipid component of soft drusen observed in AMD and the genotypic correlations between
APOE and macular pigment
63 could possibly support the hypothesis of a genetic association between this gene and CNV due to high myopia or AMD. However, associations between AMD and
APOE are not consistent
48 and the
APOE gene is known to be linked to human longevity.
64 In a murine model, apoE4 mice showed a more severe AMD-like pathological phenotype and also developed marked CNV, a hallmark of exudative AMD.
65 In this study, although we did not find significant evidence supporting the association between E2, E3, and E4
APOE haplotypes and myopic CNV (see Supplementary Material and Supplementary Table S1,
http://www.iovs.org/content/53/8/5004/suppl/DC1), we found suggestive evidence of association between myopic CNV and another SNP (rs769455), which is a rare variant of the
APOE gene previously implicated with type III hyperlipoproteinemia.
51 This was not significant after correction for multiple testing, however. Additional studies are required to replicate this result and elucidate the roles of this gene in myopic CNV etiology.
A limitation of this study is the relatively small sample size, especially for cases with myopic CNV; however, the study is strengthened by at least two factors. First, all participants came from a similar ethnic background, which reduced the chances of heterogeneity in different populations. Second, both the cases and controls were high myopic patients with high myopic genetic profile, which enhanced the ability to detect susceptible loci for myopic CNV. In contrast, comparing myopic CNV patients with nonmyopic controls may be confounded by the genetic and environmental factors influencing the risk of myopia.
To our knowledge, this study is the first to explore specific genetic effects influencing risk of CNV in high myopic patients compared with controls who are also highly myopic. This study suggests that the inflammatory pathway may be associated with myopic CNV, a vision-threatening complication of high myopia, through CFI. Larger studies are needed to analyze this gene and other candidate loci for this important vision-threatening complication of high myopia.