Myeloid leukemias are a group of disorders arising in marrow and often involving blood which are characterized by overproduction of immature leukocytes or terminally differentiated cells as in chronic myelogenous leukemia (CML). In this review, we will focus on acute leukemias where impairment of differentiation is found. Most therapies available to treat acute myelogenous leukemia target leukemia blast cells which are in general a later progenitor/precursor cell no longer capable of self-renewal and multipotential differentiation. Only about 0.01% of normal marrow cells are hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs), and what the actual leukemia stem cell (LSC) number is at a typical new diagnosis of acute myeloid leukemia (AML) is not known. Also, it is not known if mutations which are associated with AML arise in normal stem cells or in more differentiated cell types which then acquire stem-like features (
Misaghian et al., 2009). Leukemia stem cells are defined functionally as cells which are able to engraft in immunocompromised mice, but it is possible that xenotransplantation underestimates the numbers and types of stem cells due to the presence of a foreign microenvironment (
Adams and Strasser, 2008). The concept that a LSC which is a counterpart to a normal HSC exists has been considered for many decades, but thus far the implications that such a cell has in the manifestation and therapy of acute myelogenous leukemia have remained controversial.
The cellular origin of AML remains unclear, with ongoing controversy as to whether it arises from a transformed true HSC with multipotential self-renewal capacity or in a more mature progenitor cell. Most AML cells do not possess the properties of self-renewal and multipotency. This has led to the concept of stem cell heterogeneity (
Nguyen et al., 2012;
Walter et al., 2012). Some leukemias may arise at the level of pluripotent CD33
- precursors, some may have an initial mutation in a pluripotent HSC with a collaborating mutation such as a core binding factor mutation occurring later, or some may arise at the level of a committed myeloid precursor as is the case in acute promyelocytic leukemia. Both the mutation(s) leading to a leukemic state and the cell of origin of the mutation are thought to have prognostic bearing (
Walter et al., 2012). The LSC may not always be a rare population of quiescent cells. The phenotype, frequency, and functional properties of these cells may also change during disease progression (
Mather, 2012;
Nguyen et al., 2012).
Bonnet and Dick (1997) found that only leukemic blasts with the immature cell-surface phenotype characterized by CD34 expression with lack of CD38 expression were capable of transferring AML to immunodeficient mice; severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) mice. This seemed consistent with a cancer stem cell (CSC) hypothesis which suggests that tumors are maintained by a small population of stem cell-like cancer cells which have the capability for indefinite self-renewal (
Lapidot et al., 1994). Subsequently, some leukemia-initiating cells (L-ICs) have been found in the CD34 negative marrow fractions (
Taussig et al., 2010). Also, LSCs have a hierarchy defined by length of repopulating potential in serial immune deficient mice transplantations defined as short- and long-term potential (
Sarry et al., 2011). Those with long-term potential are thought to be quiescent (outside of active cell cycle) and express high levels of the multi-drug resistance phenotype, MDR-1, indicating ability to efflux cytotoxic drugs (
Krause and van Etten, 2007). There is also evidence that pathways involved in proliferation of primitive cells such as Hox, hedgehog, notch, and Wnt are all involved in the maintenance and proliferation of the LSC (reviewed in
Krause and van Etten, 2007).
While the CD34
+CD38
- cells are clonal as based on cytogenetics, fluorescence
in situ hybridization (FISH), and reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) in some cases, normal CD34
+CD38
- cells are also capable of engrafting NOD/SCID mice and must be distinguished from their leukemic counterparts in the course of functional assays. If a multipotential CD34
+CD38
- stem cell is the cell of origin for acute leukemia, it is not known why the lymphoid phenotype is suppressed after transformation.
Satoh and Ogata (2006) have postulated that myeloid HSCs with minimal lymphopoietic potential may be the site of transformation in AML and could be a target to eliminate the LSC in many cases.
The LSC is best defined functionally by its ability to recapitulate leukemia faithfully in immunocompromised mice. This requires not only homing and engraftment potential to the murine microenvironment but ability to express the phenotype of the original AML in terms of surface phenotype and of clonal markers such as chromosome translocations or deletions or of other abnormal molecular markers such as nucleophosmin-1, Flt3–ITD expression, or Ras mutations. Unfortunately, only about 50% of AML cases have clonal chromosome markers to allow easy distinction, but other aberrant leukemic cell phenotypes can sometimes allow the distinction of normal vs. leukemia human CD45
+ cells to be made by flow cytometry or by mutation analysis by PCR or sequencing. Detecting the presence of human CD45
+ cells is not sufficient as normal HSCs are also able to engraft immunodeficient mice, so documentation of the leukemic nature of the engrafting cells is required.
In vivo L-IC and HSC assays are important to measure functional stem cell capability and to measure effectiveness of therapies against L-ICs as has been determined with a compound kinetin riboside which has potential therapeutic efficacy and preferential effects against LSCs as compared with normal HSCs (
McDermott et al., 2012). Some AML do not engraft immune deficient mice, and it is thought that murine engraftment could represent proliferative potential of the leukemic cells or could simply reflect ability to interact with the murine microenvironment (
Risueno et al., 2011). Targeting LSCs is thought to be of importance since the burden of LSCs at diagnosis has prognostic significance. Patients whose blasts at diagnosis fail to engraft NOD/SCID mice at high cell doses have superior long-term survival (
Pearce et al., 2006).
Knowing which “stem cell” to target therapeutically in AML is difficult, however, since relapse may occur in a founder clone, a recurring subclone, or in a novel stem cell clone (
Walter et al., 2012). Not only do controversies exist about how to identify a LSC but also about whether such a stem cell must be eliminated in order to effectively treat the leukemia (
Kelly et al., 2007;
Majeti, 2011). The possibility that stem cell-like components of tumors may change phenotype rapidly and reversibly also makes study of these cells difficult (
Mather, 2012). Because of the heterogeneity in the phenotype of LSCs, surface antigen phenotype is inadequate as a means of isolation. High expression of aldehyde dehydrogenase (ALDH) activity in conjunction with CD34 has been found to delineate an L-IC (
Ran et al., 2012). The frequency of aldehyde bright cells in the marrow at time of initial diagnosis is an independent prognostic factor predicting overall survival (
Ran et al., 2012). It has also been shown that in a majority of AML cases, two subsets with progenitor immunophenotype coexist, and both have LSC activity and are hierarchically patterned (
Goarden et al., 2011).
That the stem cell model has clinical significance in AML is suggested by studies such as one which showed that the percentage of CD34
+CD38
- LSCs at the time of diagnosis correlated with the duration of relapse-free survival in 92 patients (
van Rhenen et al., 2005). Those with >3.5% AML LSCs had a median relapse-free survival of 5.6 months vs. those with <3.5% who had a median relapse-free survival of 16 months. The presence of a CD34
+CD38
- ALDH intermediate population has been shown to correlate with minimal residual disease (MRD) and subsequent relapse and to be able to distinguish LSCs from normal stem cells which are aldehyde high expressors (
Gerber et al., 2012). Overall, LSC frequency is thought to be an important component of MRD (
Buccisano et al., 2012).