Previous studies of the effects of
MC1R genotype in postnatal life have documented fewer acquired melanocytic nevi in red-haired children and adults (
Duffy et al., 2004;
Dellavalle et al., 2005), and in individuals homozygous or compound heterozygous for R alleles at the
MC1R locus (
Duffy et al., 2004). In addition, genome-wide association studies have not found any association between
MC1R genotype and numbers of acquired melanocytic nevi (
Falchi et al., 2006;
Yeh and Bastian, 2009), and no association between
MC1R variants and higher numbers of acquired nevi in families with inherited melanoma (
Demenais et al., 2010). However, in the current study, we have identified associations between families with CMN-affected children and the red hair pigmentary phenotype, and associations between
MC1R variants and the presence of CMN, as well with more extensive CMN. Taken in the context of the effect on birth weight, this difference between congenital and acquired nevi may be due to the differential effects of MC1R during pre- and postnatal life, although other inherent genetic differences between congenital and acquired nevi could also be significant factors.
Our findings indicate that certain
MC1R variants function to promote the growth of CMN during embryogenesis, and possibly the growth of the fetus as a whole. The exact mechanism whereby
MC1R variants alter fetal growth and development are unknown, but might involve direct effects on the fetus and/or indirect effects through the presence of
MC1R on trophoblast cells of the placenta (
Thornwall et al., 1997). MC1R is expressed on a wide range of adult human cell types including adipocytes (
Hoch et al., 2007;
www.genecards.com;
Rebhan et al., 1997), supporting the increasing body of evidence that it has significant non-pigmentary roles (
Robinson and Healy, 2002;
Mogil et al., 2005;
Robinson et al., 2010); alpha-MSH is involved in metabolic pathways, but this is currently understood to be via the other melanocortin receptors. Melanocortin-1-receptor (
MC1R) genotype is known to interact with pigmentary and non-pigmentary pathways (
Robinson and Healy, 2002;
Cooper et al., 2005;
Robinson et al., 2010), for example, altering the penetrance of other genes in melanoma such as
p53 (
Patton et al., 2005;
Stefanaki et al., 2007;
Nan et al., 2008) and
CDKN2A (
Box et al., 2001;
Debniak et al., 2006). The latter effects are dependent not only on particular alleles but also on the number of variant alleles present (
Demenais et al., 2010). A similar interactive effect may be operating in individuals with CMN, with
MC1R variants exerting a phenotype-exacerbating effect on a different somatic, or possibly germline, genetic alteration that affects CMN development. The effect of
MC1R genotype on birth weight in our study was a generalized phenomenon that was found in two separate cohorts (CMN and ALSPAC), and in the
MC1R-pigmentary context the previously reported interactive effects of
MC1R genotype on oculocutaneous albinism (
King et al., 2003) was a generalized, rather than localized, effect on pigmentation. The fact that in the ALSPAC cohort of healthy children the larger birth weight in subjects with
MC1R variants was not associated with any other dysmorphic features suggests that in the normal situation
MC1R genotype may influence fetal development to affect body size in a proportionate manner. Interactive effects of
MC1R with other genes affecting birth weight have not yet been investigated, and further work on this topic will be required in the future.
MC1R variants are a risk factor for melanoma development in the general population and are associated with increased risk of melanoma in
CDKN2A mutation carriers (
Box et al., 2001;
Demenais et al., 2010). One important clinical consideration in our patient cohort is whether the pattern of germline
MC1R genotype is responsible for the excess risk of malignant melanoma in individuals with CMN. The lifetime risk for melanoma is around 1–2% when all CMN are considered together as a group (
Krengel et al., 2006;
Kinsler et al., 2009a), which is similar in magnitude to the excess risk associated with
MC1R variants in the normal population. The numbers of melanomas in our CMN cohort are too few to allow detailed investigations on the risk of melanoma attributable to
MC1R variants, but it is likely that this genotype is at least contributing to melanoma risk. In a recent family-based melanoma study, the odds ratio for melanoma in
CDKN2A mutation carriers was 5.67 (95% CI 2.1–15.29) for subjects with
MC1R variants (
Demenais et al., 2010); thus, it is possible that the
MC1R genotype may similarly alter the risk of melanoma in people with larger CMNs.
In conclusion, we have identified associations between CMN and red-hair/MC1R variants. Furthermore, the presence of a V92M or R allele was associated with larger CMN size and with larger birth weight in the CMN, and separately in the ALSPAC, groups consistent with a growth-promoting effect of these alleles during embryogenesis.