In this study, we demonstrate that
Bcl11b/Ctip2 is required for structural as well as functional development of the dentate gyrus. Functions of
Bcl11b are phase specific and restricted to the postnatal period of dentate development: (i)
Bcl11b controls progenitor cell proliferation and the size of the neural stem-cell compartment in the dentate gyrus through indirect mechanisms. In addition, loss of
Bcl11b expression increases apoptosis of postmitotic neurons. Thus, mutation of
Bcl11b leads to a hypoplastic dentate gyrus with reduced numbers of granule cells. (ii)
Bcl11b is further required for cell type-specific differentiation of dentate granule neurons. In the absence of
Bcl11b, newborn neurons are arrested at early differentiation levels, colonizing the residual GCL. (iii)
Bcl11b is essential for functional integration of granule cells into hippocampal circuitry. In
Bcl11b mutant granule cells, both synaptic input as reflected by reduced dendritic spine numbers, and synaptic output as reflected by aberrant mossy fibre projections and reduced thorny excrescences on CA3 neurons (
Gonzales et al, 2001), are impaired. This results in reduced spatial learning capacities in Bcl11b mutants.
Finally, we found Desmoplakin to be a direct transcriptional target of
Bcl11b in dentate granule cells, and demonstrate that
Bcl11b binds directly to regulatory sequences in close proximity to the transcription start site of
Dsp, which includes putative
Bcl11b binding sites (
Avram et al, 2002;
Cismasiu et al, 2006). Furthermore, re-introducing
Dsp expression into the
Bcl11b mutant dentate gyrus rescues the progenitor proliferation phenotype. This is in accordance with previous reports defining a role of
Dsp in stem-cell proliferation (
Gallicano et al, 1998). Comparing
Bcl11b and
Dsp mutant hippocampi, we were able to separate functions of
Bcl11b depending on
Dsp expression from those independent of
Dsp and likely involving additional, yet undetermined signals.
Bcl11b in hippocampal neurogenesis
We found that
Bcl11b expression in the dentate gyrus is restricted to postmitotic neurons. In addition, at embryonic stages we could not detect
Bcl11b expression in migrating progenitor cells contributing to the dentate primordium. Thus, impaired progenitor cell proliferation and depletion of the neural stem-cell pool, as defined by BrdU incorporation, and reduction of
Sox2/
Tbr2 expressing cells (
Kempermann et al, 2004;
Englund et al, 2005;
Li et al, 2009) are most likely caused by a lack of indirect feedback signals from postmitotic neurons, no longer expressing
Bcl11b. Analysing
Bcl11bflox/flox;Nex
Cre mice, where
Cre-recombinase is only active in postmitotic cells (
Goebbels et al, 2006;
Seuntjens et al, 2009), further supports this hypothesis. Although we cannot exclude that the observed increase in apoptosis could contribute in part to the depletion of the neural stem-cell pool we found most apoptotic cells were located in the GCL. These data suggest that
Sox2-positive cells aberrantly migrating to the GCL may loose their proliferation capacity and are unable to complete the differentiation process. Instead these cells undergo apoptosis. Indirect control of hippocampal stem cells was recently demonstrated for the transcription factor
Sox2 as well. Unlike
Bcl11b,
Sox2 is expressed by neural stem cells regulating the maintenance of the dentate stem-cell niche through
Wnt3a and
Shh signals (
Favaro et al, 2009). Previous reports suggest that
Bcl11b interacts directly with members of the cyclin-dependant kinase inhibitor family, for example,
p21WAF1 and
p57KIP2 (
Topark-Ngarm et al, 2006;
Cherrier et al, 2009). p57KIP2 is an important regulator of the cell cycle and neuronal differentiation. During early embryogenesis,
p57KIP2 is expressed in newly differentiated neurons but not in the proliferative ventricular zone (
Yan et al, 1997).
Bcl11b directly represses
p57KIP2 expression in Sk-N-MC neuronal cells resulting in impaired neuronal differentiation (
Topark-Ngarm et al, 2006). Control of neurogenesis in the dentate gyrus through
Bcl11b-dependent regulation of
p57KIP2 levels would require active repression of
p57KIP2 by
Bcl11b in proliferating progenitors, which is not supported by our expression analysis of
Bcl11b.
Dsp mutant mice exhibit a similar although weaker phenotype when compared with
Bcl11b mutants, for example, smaller dentate gyrus, and reduced proliferation rate suggesting that
Dsp acts downstream of
Bcl11b in these processes. Complete recovery of the proliferation phenotype by re-introducing
Dsp expression into
Bcl11b mutants further demonstrates an important role of
Dsp in progenitor cell proliferation. This coincides with a previous report demonstrating that ablation of
Dsp expression causes reduced proliferation during early embryonic development (
Gallicano et al, 1998). The weaker Dsp phenotype might be due to the decrease in apoptosis in the
Dsp mutant in contrast to the increase in apoptotic cells in
Bcl11b mutants. However, this does not exclude additional factors to be involved.
There is emerging evidence that cell–cell adhesion is important for the control of stem-cell behaviour and the transmission of regulatory signals provided to the stem-cell niche (
Marthiens et al, 2010;
Redmer et al, 2011), raising the possibility that
Dsp may exert similar functions in the control of hippocampal neurogenesis. As mentioned above,
Dsp expression rescues the
Bcl11b proliferation phenotype. In addition, we observed a misdistribution of
Sox2-positive cells, for example, loss of
Sox2-positive cells in the SGZ and increase of
Sox2-positive cells in the GCL, suggesting that stem cells leave the stem-cell niche but are not able to further differentiate. It is possible that
Dsp is required to provide cell–cell adhesion in order to establish the signalling pathway from neighbouring cells to allow neuronal differentiation (see also below).
Bcl11b in neuronal differentiation
We found that
Bcl11b is required for cell type-specific differentiation of dentate granule cells. Previous reports demonstrated similar regulatory functions for
Bcl11b in the development of corticospinal motor neurons and the striatum (
Arlotta et al, 2005,
2008). Outside the CNS,
Bcl11b is critical for the differentiation of T lymphocytes (
Wakabayashi et al, 2003;
Liu et al, 2010), suggesting the regulation of cellular differentiation to be a conserved function of
Bcl11b. Surprisingly, our mosaic deletion data suggest a non-cell autonomous role of
Bcl11b in the regulation of neuronal differentiation, and deletion of
Bcl11b in a fraction of dentate neurons leads to impaired neuronal differentiation in surrounding wild-type cells. It was shown that
Bcl11b plays an important non-cell autonomous role in the proliferation and differentiation of keratinocytes, suggesting that
Bcl11b regulates transcription of secreted dermal factors including KGF, a dermal fibroblast-derived growth factor, which in turn regulates epidermal morphogenesis in a paracrine fashion (
Golonzhka et al, 2009). This is also supported by a recent report demonstrating a non-cell autonomous role for
Bcl11b in tissue formation during wound healing that is most likely due to impaired cell–cell adhesion and might include the regulation of E- and P-cadherin (
Liang et al, 2012). From our data, we conclude that
Bcl11b regulates progenitor proliferation as well as differentiation in a non-cell autonomous fashion but that different additional factors might be involved in the regulation of these processes. We cannot exclude that
Bcl11b, in addition, has a cell autonomous function in neuronal differentiation. Defective differentiation of dentate granule cells was also observed in
Dsp mutants.
Dsp interacts with desmosomal cadherins via plakoglobin connecting desmosomes with intermediate filaments of the cytoskeleton (
Garrod and Chidgey, 2008). The cytoskeleton plays an important role in cell division, cell polarity and cell differentiation as well as signalling (
Hoogenraad and Bradke, 2009). In the epidermis,
Dsp rearranges microtubules according to the differentiation state of the cell (
Lechler and Fuchs, 2007). Thus, it is possible that
Dsp has a similar function in neuronal cells. Lack of
Bcl11b and
Dsp expression could therefore cause defects in the organization of the cytoskeleton resulting in granule cell dispersion as well as in impaired neuronal differentiation. Further, indirect evidence for an interaction between
Bcl11b and
Dsp was provided by
Bcl11b regulation of proliferation and late differentiation in keratinocytes where
Dsp expression occurs (
Golonzhka et al, 2007,
2009).
Ablation of
Bcl1b in the hippocampus caused aberrant mossy fibre projections and severe deficits in spatial learning and memory. None of these mutant phenotypes was recapitulated in
Dsp mutants. This indicates that major functions of
Bcl11b in hippocampal development occur independent of
Dsp. Furthermore, it suggests that the failure of
Bcl11b mutant granule neurons to integrate into the hippocampal circuitry is critical for the development of learning and memory deficits (
Schwegler et al, 1990;
Schwegler and Crusio, 1995).
Perspectives
Regulation of the developing dentate gyrus is of special interest because it is one of only two brain regions with ongoing neurogenesis in adulthood. Expression of
Bcl11b in the dentate gyrus is sustained throughout the life (LB, RS and SB, unpublished). It will be interesting to determine whether
Bcl11b executes a similar function during neurogenesis of the adult and aged hippocampus. Dysregulated neurogenesis is associated with disorders like Alzheimer's disease and Schizophrenia (
Zhao et al, 2008;
Clelland et al, 2009;
DeCarolis and Eisch, 2010).
Bcl11b with its dual phase-specific regulatory functions during postnatal development can provide an excellent model system to gain better insight into the mechanisms of learning and memory and the pathophysiology of associated diseases.