The microtubules are well recognized as a chemotherapeutic target, and there is an ongoing search for high efficacy microtubule targeting agents. In cultured, malignant cells, microtubules contribute to various mechanisms, including drug efflux transporter [
17], altered tubulin isotype expression [
5,
18], and tubulin mutation [
19]. Therefore, it is suggested that arsenic compounds might be useful for the treatment of some instances of human cancer [
20].
Our data demonstrates that As
2O
3 efficiently inhibits proliferation of NB4 cells and, in a previous study, the IC
50 value for As
2O
3 in MCF-7 breast carcinoma and A2780 ovarian carcinoma cell lines was approximately 3 µM, a concentration very close to the effective serum concentration for successfully treating patients with acute promyelocytic leukemia in the clinic [
8]. Although it was a different type of cancer cells line, the cytotoxicity of As
2O
3 at about 50% was in the range of the 5 µM for NB4 cells (). This evidence indicates that the efficiency of As
2O
3 was similar to previously described reports. Some investigators also report that As
2O
3 causes DNA damage, oxidative stress, and mitochondrial dysfunction [
21-
23]. In addition, As
2O
3 treatment blocked the cell cycle in these cell line. In the present study, we found that As
2O
3 treatment resulted in cell-cycle arrest at the G
2/M phase in NB4 cells ().
We also considered whether As
2O
3-induced G
2/M phase arrest is due to its interaction with tubulin, thus resulting in abnormal tubulin polymerization. To test this, we have taken advantage of an assay designed by Minotti et al. [
24] to separate polymerized "P" from "S" soluble tubulin fractions by centrifugation. This procedure, and subsequent modifications of it, has been widely utilized to quickly determine the percentage of tubulin polymers in cells under a variety of experimental conditions. An increase in the "S" fraction serves as an indicator of tubulin destabilization. In the present study, we were able to show that the presence of unstable microtubules in the treated cell populations by several criteria. First, compared to the controls, an increased proportion of tubulin was found in the soluble tubulin fractions. Soluble tubulin amounts were present in an As
2O
3 concentration-dependent manner. The effect of As
2O
3 on tubulin depolymerization was weaker than that of vincristine (). These data suggest that As
2O
3 directly or indirectly induces the disruption of microtubule formation via tubulin polymerization in contrast to data published by Ling et al., who reported that As
2O
3 increases tubulin polymerization [
8]. In addition, the disassembly of the microtubule network after treatment with As
2O
3 suggests that it acts as a microtubule depolymerizing agent. We were able to demonstrate that α-tubulin posttranslational modifications correspond to increased microtubule stability. Tubulin can undergo numerous posttranslational modifications, including phosphorylation, polyglutamylation, polyglyclation, deglutamylation, acetylation, and tyrosination/detyrosination. Although the functions of these α-tubulin modifications remain unclear, deglutamylation, acetylation, and detyrosination are indicative of stable microtubules [
14,
15,
25]. Acetylation occurs on lysine 40 near the amino terminus of α-tubulin and does not appear to increase the levels of stable microtubules but instead accumulates in existing stable microtubules [
14,
15]. Glu-tubulin is formed when the last residue on α-tubulin, a tyrosine, is removed by tubulin-carboxypeptidase and the glutamic acid is exposed [
25]. As such, the phenomenon observed here, depolymerization of microtubule by As
2O
3, could be explained, in part, by alteration of microtubule stability through microtubule modification. As compared to paclitaxel treatment, As
2O
3 significantly decreased acetylated α-tubulin (), this suggests that microtubule stabilization may play an important role in As
2O
3-mediated microtubule depolymerization.
Next, we tested the effect of As
2O
3, paclitaxel, and vincristine on tubulin assembly in a cell-free
in vitro system (). We found that the effect of As
2O
3 was similar to that of vincristine but different from paclitaxel. This does not rule out the possibility that As
2O
3 may bind to polymerized tubulins and stabilize microtubules. The reason for the appearance of tubulin depolymerization may be explained if As
2O
3 acts as a noncompetitive inhibitor, thus interfering with the GTP binding domain on β-tubulin [
9]. In this study, it is notable that the same concentration of As
2O
3 was capable of inhibiting the assembly of tubulin, but these concentrations were also found to elicit some differences in the cell-based assays or the cell-free systems. The intracellular conditions may provide an ideal environment for the reaction of As
2O
3 with microtubules whereas the reaction conditions of these widely used cell-free microtubule assembly-disassembly assays may not facilitate the As
2O
3-microtubule interaction. Indeed, this phenomenon has been observed before by using other tubulin ligands, although the discrepancies were not as pronounced as in this study [
26].
Finally, indirect immunofluorescence technique allowed us to detect morphological changes in the microtubule network, such as alterations in microtubule organization and arrangement. The changes in microtubule length and density constitute an appropriate method to qualitatively assess the intracellular microtubule polymerization or depolymerization caused by anti-tubulin agents. The results from our tubulin depolymerization experiments indicated that, similar to the effect of vincristine treatment, As2O3 treatment prevented tubulin polymerization. To validate these results, changes in the cellular microtubule network were observing immunocytochemically. We found that the effect of As2O3 was similar to that of vincristine (). Thick bundles of microtubule network surrounding cytoplasm were observed in paclitaxel-treated cells, whereas shortened depolymerized microtubules were observed in As2O3- and vincristine-treated cells.
In summary, our data demonstrate that As
2O
3 is efficacious in suppressing cell growth in NB4 cells. As
2O
3 directly or indirectly interferes with microtubules and blocks the cell cycle at the G
2/M phase. The effects of As
2O
3 on microtubule assembly are vincristine-like, but also distinct from vincristine. As
2O
3 is less active than vincristine in NB4 cells and is diametrically opposite of the observations published by Ling et al. who reported that As
2O
3 induced tubulin polymerization [
8]. The unique mechanism that allows for As
2O
3 to induce both cell death and cell cycle arrest, and to cause microtubule depolymerization, makes it an ideal candidate for antineoplastic therapy. This also suggests that As
2O
3 can be used at a low concentration and still selectively target the microtubules of rapidly dividing tumor cells, thus minimizing its general toxicity. Evidence that tubulin plays an important role in the treatment of leukemia raises the possibility for the development of a rationally designed arsenic-based antimitotic agent.