In this study we have characterized an
Spns2-targetted mouse line and demonstrated that Spns2 is required for normal lymphocyte development and localization, and for normal humoral immune response to immunization. Overall the changes in lymphocyte subpopulations in
Spns2tm1a/tm1a and
Spns2tm1b/tm1b mice closely mimicked the phenotypes of partial S1P deficiency and impaired S1P-dependent lymphocyte trafficking, including the depletion of lymphocytes in circulation, increase in the mature single-positive T cells in the thymus, and a selective reduction in the mature B cell population in the spleen and bone marrow (
5,
6,
10,
32,
47). Although we did not detect a reduction in S1P levels in
Spns2tm1a/tma1 mouse plasma, the phenotypic data presented here together with the previous
in vitro demonstrations that human Spns2 can transport S1P and S1P-mimic FTY720 (
40,
43), suggest that the
Spns2tm1a/tm1a phenotype may arise from localized disruptions in S1P concentrations at certain restricted physiological locations.
Critically this work indicates that Spns2 functions are limiting for lymphocyte trafficking with some degree of specificity, as the viability and lack of developmental defects in
Spns2tm1a/tm1a mice contrasts with lethality and defects in cardiovascular and neural development in
Spns2-mutant zebrafish (
40,
41). Importantly this is not due to different requirements for S1P-production between the two species, as knockout mice lacking sphingosine kinases
SphK1−/−SphK2−/− or S1P-receptor
S1P1−/− are also embryonic lethal with abnormal cardiovascular development (
31,
42). In comparison,
Spns2tm1a/tm1a mice more closely mimic the phenotypes of partially reduced S1P production, such as the single-null knockouts for
SphK1 or
SphK2 (
54-
56), or the knockout for S1P lyase with normal S1P production but disrupted S1P concentration gradients (
57). Overall this indicates that sufficient S1P levels are maintained in correct anatomical and cellular locations in the
Spns2tm1a/tm1a mice to allow normal embryonic development, and suggests significant divergence in the expression and functions of Spns2 between mouse and zebrafish. We can speculate that alternative mechanisms of S1P release may operate during embryonic development in mouse but not in zebrafish species. These may include other transporters that have been shown to pump S1P
in vitro in mammalian cells, such as ABCC1 and ABCA1 (
33,
34), or extracellular S1P production by secreted SphK1 enzyme (
38), or even the two Spns2 paralogs Spns1 and Spns3.
This work further demonstrated that Spns2 activity in the non-hematopoietic cells of the stroma is of key importance for normal immune system function. In contrast, previous studies showed that plasma S1P levels in the mouse are maintained by hematopoietic cells such as erythrocytes (
47), and ABC-family transporters have been implicated in mediating S1P export from erythrocytes (
33) and platelets (
35). This suggests that the primary role of Spns2 is to maintain appropriate S1P concentrations at other
in vivo locations, consistent with the unaltered S1P levels in the plasma of
Spns2tm1a/tm1a mice. Lymph is one of the sites were analysis of S1P concentrations would be particularly interesting (
47), as S1P in the lymph was shown to be derived from non-hematopoietic cells, in particular the lymphatic endothelium (
48). Overall this warrants further investigation of Spns2 expression in different non-hematopoietic cell types and tissues, including lymphatic endothelium (
47,
48).
S1P also acts as an intracellular messenger; and in mast cells and antigen presenting cells increased S1P production is associated with cell activation, degranulation, and inflammatory cytokine production (
18,
20,
23,
24). However, the current work indicates that in contrast to the
SphK1-knockdown cells ,
Spns2tm1a/tm1a macrophages respond normally to TNFR and TLR stimulation. This indicates that Spns2 likely does not impact on intracellular S1P levels, at least in this cell type. Whether the activity of Spns2 and other S1P transporters can affect intracellular S1P levels in other cell types, by altering S1P secretion or uptake, remains to be addressed in future research.
Components of the S1P signaling pathways are targets for therapies aimed at treating autoimmunity, transplant rejection, inflammatory diseases, and cancer (
2). S1P receptor agonist FTY720 is the most advanced of such therapies and was recently approved for the treatment of multiple sclerosis (
58), while other pharmaceutical agents are under development and have shown efficacy in animal models of inflammatory diseases, sepsis, and cancer (
28,
59,
60). Knowledge of the mechanisms regulating S1P concentrations
in vivo in a mammal is essential for the future development of such pharmaceutical agents and may lead to better targeted therapies. For example, S1P-targeting therapies for the treatment of autoimmunity and transplant rejection aim to achieve immunosuppression without inhibiting other S1P activities. S1P-targeting cancer therapies suppress vascularization, cell growth and migration, but ideally aim to maintain full immune system function. In contrast therapies for systemic inflammatory disorders primarily aim to suppress inflammation and intravascular coagulation, while retaining the protective activities of S1P on endothelial barrier integrity (
61,
62). Given the diverse roles of S1P in many physiological processes, understanding of the mechanisms regulating its bioavailability in different tissues and conditions is essential for the development of such therapies. Transporter proteins have proven highly effective drug targets in other areas, particularly neuropharmacology (
63). The demonstration that
Spns2-deficiency selectively impaired lymphocyte functions and antigen-specific immune responses, without affecting vascular and neural development, highlights Spns2 as a possible drug target with potential for the treatment of autoimmunity and transplant rejection.