PMCCPMCCPMCC

Search tips
Search criteria 

Advanced

 
Logo of nihpaAbout Author manuscriptsSubmit a manuscriptNIH Public Access; Author Manuscript; Accepted for publication in peer reviewed journal;
 
Bioconjug Chem. Author manuscript; available in PMC Apr 18, 2013.
Published in final edited form as:
PMCID: PMC3347768
NIHMSID: NIHMS369332
Evaluation of Endcapped DNA Modules for pRNA Capture and Functionalization
Brian M. Laing and Donald E. Bergstrom*
Department of Medicinal Chemistry and Molecular Pharmacology and Bindley Bioscience Center, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47907
*Correspondence to: Donald E. Bergstrom, Department of Medicinal Chemistry and Molecular Pharmacology, Purdue University, 1205 W State St, West Lafayette, IN 47907-2057, Telephone: (765)-494-6275; Fax: (765) 494-1414, bergstrom/at/purdue.edu
An external file that holds a picture, illustration, etc.
Object name is nihms369332u1.jpg Object name is nihms369332u1.jpg
The ability of packaging RNA (pRNA) from the phi29 DNA packaging motor to form nanoassemblies and nanostructures has been exploited for the development of the nascent field of RNA nanotechnology and subsequent applications in nanomedicine. For applications in nanomedicine, it is necessary to modify the pRNA structure for the conjugation of active molecules. We have investigated endcapped double-stranded DNA segments as reversible capture reagents for pRNA. These capture agents can be designed to allow the conjugation of any desired molecule for pRNA functionalization. The results of model studies presented in this report show that 5- to 7-nucleotide overhangs on a target RNA can provide efficient handles for the high affinity association to capped double-stranded DNA.
Keywords: pRNA, RNA nanotechnology, RNA capture, Endcapped oligonucleotides
The emerging field of RNA nanotechnology was ignited by the discovery by Guo and coworkers that packaging RNA (pRNA) from the phi29 bacteriophage DNA packaging nanomotor can be re-engineered and manipulated to form a variety of nanoassemblies and nanostructures.16 Wild type pRNA spontaneously self-assemble into a hexameric ring via complementary base pairing interactions between loop regions within the pRNA structure.3,7,8 The pRNA monomer contains two functional domains (Figure 1A): the intermolecular-interacting domain comprised of a right hand and left hand loop and the 5′/3′ double-stranded helical DNA-translocation domain.4,5,8 It has been shown that these two domains fold independently of one another and modification of the one domain does not affect the function of the other.35,9,10
Figure 1
Figure 1
Structures of pRNA and endcapped DNA capture module system. (A) Wild type pRNA model showing functional domains. (B) Engineered pRNA dimer showing potential modifications for use in nanomedicine applications. (C) Model system for assessing the feasibility (more ...)
The two interlocking left and right loops of the intermolecular-interacting domain can be engineered for bottom-up nanoparticle assembly and has been modified to produce a variety of nanostructures and shapes including rods, triangles, twins, tetramers, and 3D arrays up to several micrometers in size.1,4,5 The 3′/5′-paired DNA translocation domain of the pRNA can be re-engineered and modified without affecting the conformation of the intermolecular binding domain and its ability to form multimeric nanostructures.3,1012 Guo and coworkers have fabricated pRNA monomers with functional RNA sequences (e.g. ribozymes, aptamers and siRNA) and small molecules (e.g. Folic acid, fluorophores) at the 5′/3′ translocation domain.2,6,9,10 These properties of pRNA are the basis for the design and fabrication of multifunctional pRNA nanoparticles of the types shown in Figure 1B (dimer model shown), for use in nanomedicine.
In order to take full advantage of the potential of pRNA nanotechnology, it is important to develop methods for the attachment of functional molecules to pRNA. The wild type pRNA contains a 3′ overhang with the sequence 3′-AAU followed by a double-stranded stem (Figure 1A). We believe that there is a way to rapidly and reversibly add modules to the 3′/5′-pRNA overhang that are small, have high affinity and specificity for the pRNA overhang, are simple to synthesize, and can link virtually any kind of molecule (including small ligands, peptides, lipids, carbohydrates, and fluorophores). Bergstrom and coworkers have utilized a method for stabilizing short segments of double-stranded oligonucleotides by covalently linking the 3′ and 5′ ends of the nucleic acid with a simple spacer.1315 The simplest spacer is the C12 hydrocarbon (S2) shown in Figure 1D. Nucleic acid duplexes containing just four base pairs and linked by a spacer at one end have melting temperatures (Tm values) in the range 41 to 62 °C (the same duplexes without the spacers are unstable at room temperature, i.e. Tm < 25°C). Importantly, we also determined that the endcaps protect double-stranded nucleic acids from degradation by exonucleases.
In the present study, oligodeoxyribonucleotides containing a 5 bp duplex segment capped at one end by a stabilizing spacer and having a 5 nt or 7 nt single stranded overhang at the other end (Figure 1C, capture modules 5 and 7), would be used as reagents for the capture and modification of the 3′/5′ terminal region of a modified pRNA. Modified bases such as the commercially available C5 substituted thymine, bearing an alkyne moiety (Fig 1D, M1), may be incorporated into the capture module. This modification will allow the conjugation of fluorophores, affinity probes, and targeting ligands through a bio-orthogonal 3+2 cycloaddition reaction between the alkyne on the modified base and an alkyl azide on the conjugate moiety.
In order to determine the feasibility of our pRNA capture strategy, the model system shown in Figure 1C was developed and tested. The truncated pRNA models are stabilized by a well established RNA tetraloop (5′-UUCG-3′) known to form RNA hairpins with remarkable stability (Tm values > 70 °C).16,17 The DNA modules were constructed by using a hexaethylene glycol linker (S1) or a C12 hydrocarbon (S2) which confers significant stability to short sequences.
The ability of the endcapped DNA capture modules to stably hybridize with the truncated pRNA models were investigated by conducting melting temperature experiments. The RNA hairpin models- RNA5 and RNA7, had Tm values of 81.5 °C and 74.4 °C respectively (Table 1). The higher Tm value for RNA5 is most likely due to the higher C•G content in the stem region of RNA5 compared to that of RNA7. The DNA capture modules, DNA5-S1 and DNA7-S1, were determined to have Tm values of 64.6 °C and 65.8 °C respectively (Table 1). Spacer S1 was used in the initial experiments because the hexaethylene glycol linker is well established as one of the first linkers used to stabilize duplex structure and is commercially available.18,19
Table 1
Table 1
Mass Spectrometry (MALDI-TOF-MS) and melting temperature (Tm) analysis of endcapped DNA capture modules and truncated pRNA hairpin models
We anticipated that these structures would be sufficiently stable such that the first dissociation event would be the dissociation of the RNA from DNA when equimolar quantities of complementary RNA and DNA modules are heated (Scheme 1). Hence, at least two transitions (A → B and B → C) should be readily observed in the thermal profile from which approximate Tm values for the first dissociation event (A → B, Tm1) can be determined. The second transition (B → C, Tm2) is expected to involve the melting of the RNA hairpin and the endcapped DNA hairpin. These two events are indistinguishable in the thermal profile in some cases.
Scheme 1
Scheme 1
Anticipated change in structure and hybridization of the endcapped DNA based RNA capture model system (A → B → C) with increasing temperature.
Thermal melting profiles were obtained for the hybridization of equimolar (1μM) concentrations of RNA5 + DNA5-S1 and RNA7 + DNA7-S1 (Figure 2). The anticipated transitions were observed in both cases with the Tm values for the first dissociation events determined to be 43.2 °C and 61.1 °C for capture module 5 and capture module 7 respectively. For biological and therapeutic applications it is important to have structures that are stable at 37 °C. The Tm values indicate that both capture module 5 and capture module 7 would have sufficient thermal stability under physiological conditions, with capture module 7 exhibiting significantly greater stability.
Figure 2
Figure 2
Thermal melting profile and 1st derivative plots for (A) RNA5 + DNA5-S1 (table 2, exp 1) and (B) RNA7 + DNA7-S1 (table 2, exp 2). The states a, b and c corresponds to structures A, B and C in scheme 1.
Control experiments were conducted to assess the level of enhancement provided by the endcapped 5 bp stem used in capture module 7 when compared to modules having a 1 bp stem (DNACtrl-S1) or a 1 nt overhang with no endcap (DNACtrl-dC). The Tm value obtained for the first dissociation event with DNACtrl-S1 was found to be 44.1 °C (Table 2, exp 3 and supplementary Figure S3) whereas the Tm value for DNACtrl-dC was found to be 41.2 °C (Table 2, exp 4 and supplementary Figure S4). The observed Tm values indicate that the endcapped 5 bp stem significantly enhances the ability of the DNA capture module to stably hybridize with the RNA target. These results suggest that ‘pre-organization’ of the 5 bp duplex stem in the capture module by the endcap plays a role in augmenting the hybridization stability of the RNA capture system.
Table 2
Table 2
Melting temperatures for endcapped DNA capture module hybridization to truncated pRNA models
Having established the feasibility of the system using spacer S1 in the DNA capture modules, experiments were conducted using spacer S2 (C12 spacer), which more closely matches the average distance between the terminal 3′-O and 5′-O of B-DNA duplexes between the terminal base pairs, previously shown to be approximately 16.2 Å.13 Spacer S2, when used as the endcap in DNA capture module 7 resulted in a Tm value of 67.2 °C for the melting of the 5 bp duplex stem (Table 1), a value slightly higher than spacer S1. The first dissociation event when hybridized to RNA7 was determined to be 47.4 °C ((Table 2, exp 5 and supplementary Figure S5)). This Tm value, despite being sufficient for physiological conditions, is significantly lower than that obtained with spacer S1. This difference in observed hybridization stability may be due to the differences in length, flexibility and hydrophobicity of the spacers. These are attributes that are important to consider in the future design of endcaps for stabilizing DNA capture modules.
It was of interest to determine the level of tolerance for mismatches or imperfect target sequences. Imperfect sequences and mismatches are potential issues to consider in the proposed strategy since one of the main methods of preparing full-length (117 nt) pRNA is in vitro transcription using T7 RNA polymerase. T7 RNA polymerase lacks proofreading ability and is known to produce aberrant RNA transcripts and extra bases at the 3′ terminus.20 Another potential application for the use DNA capture modules is in the capture of microRNA (miRNA) or other small RNA that present short overhanging regions. Mismatch discrimination would be an important concern in these applications. A simple approach was used for these studies in which the previously synthesized RNA models (RNA5 and RNA7) and DNA capture modules (5 and 7) were mismatched such that RNA7 was hybridized with DNA5-S1 and vice versa (Scheme 1-III and IV).
Hybridization of equimolar concentrations of RNA5 and DNA7-S1 would produce an equilibrium comprising three possible structures shown in Scheme 1-III. The Tm value obtained for the first dissociation event with these structures was found to be 36.2 °C ((Table 2, exp 6 and supplementary Figure S6)) indicating that the net result of this interaction is less stable than the exact complement. Combination of RNA7 with DNA5-S1 produces a structure with two unpaired nucleotides (Scheme 1-IV) and results in a Tm value for the first dissociation event of 32.6 °C (Table 2, exp 7 and supplementary Figure S7). Both mispaired structures are unstable under physiological conditions and show that the overall system relies on high fidelity of base pairing.
The results presented here indicate that the endcapped DNA capture module system for the functional modification of pRNA is a potentially feasible strategy. The successful application of this strategy would require further optimization in order to create the most versatile and effective capture and functionalization system. The studies of the control modules DNACtrl-S1 with 1 bp stem and DNACtrl-dC with no endcap are instructive for the design of an optimized system. These control modules, although less stable than DNA7-S1, displayed stability under physiological temperatures. These observations suggest that it may be possible to design even simpler modules with shorter stems or by using stabilizing nucleotides (e.g. LNA) in the single stranded overhang to enhance hybridization to the pRNA overhang. It would also be necessary to conduct studies at different concentrations in order to assess the concentration dependence of hybridization. It is evident from the study of the C12 hydrocarbon endcap, that the nature and length of the endcap are important considerations in the design. This observation is supported by previous work conducted in the Bergstrom lab on the evaluation of spacers for use as dsDNA endcaps.1315 The endcapped duplex stem in the capture modules confers high affinity and specificity for hybridization to overhanging sequences at the termini of pRNA over hybridization to the same sequence within the RNA. This specificity is due to the ‘pre-organization’ of the duplex stem region by the endcap. The DNA capture module system can therefore be widely applied to the capture of any nucleic acid structure bearing overhanging sequences at their termini.
Supplementary Material
1_si_001
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by the NIH Nanomedicine Development Center on Phi29 DNA-packaging Motor for Nanomedicine, through the NIH Roadmap for Medical Research (PN2 EY 018230). Support from the Walther Cancer Institute and assistance from the National Cancer Institute Grant (P30 CA23168) awarded to Purdue University is also gratefully acknowledged.
Footnotes
Supporting Information Available: Experimental procedures and thermal profiles for experiments 3–7. This material is available free of charge via the Internet at http://pubs.acs.org
1. Shu D, Huang LP, Hoeprich S, Guo P. Construction of phi29 DNA-packaging RNA monomers, dimers, and trimers with variable sizes and shapes as potential parts for nanodevices. Journal of Nanoscience and Nanotechnology. 2003;3:295–302. [PubMed]
2. Guo P. RNA nanotechnology: engineering, assembly and applications in detection, gene delivery and therapy. Journal Of Nanoscience And Nanotechnology. 2005;5:1964–82. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
3. Hoeprich S, Guo P. Computer modeling of three-dimensional structure of DNA-packaging RNA (pRNA) monomer, dimer, and hexamer of Phi29 DNA packaging motor. Journal of Biological Chemistry. 2002;277:20794–803. [PubMed]
4. Shu D, Moll WD, Deng Z, Mao C, Guo P. Bottom-up Assembly of RNA Arrays and Superstructures as Potential Parts in Nanotechnology. Nano Letters. 2004;4:1717–1723. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
5. Khaled A, Guo S, Li F, Guo P. Controllable Self-Assembly of Nanoparticles for Specific Delivery of Multiple Therapeutic Molecules to Cancer Cells Using RNA Nanotechnology. Nano Letters. 2005;5:1797–1808. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
6. Guo P, Coban O, Snead N, Trebley J, Hoeprich S, Guo S, Shu Y. Engineering RNA for Targeted siRNA Delivery and Medical Application. Advanced Drug Delivery Reviews. 2010;62:650–666. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
7. Guo P, Bailey S, Bodley JW, Anderson D. Characterization of the small RNA of the bacteriophage phi 29 DNA packaging machine. Nucleic Acids Research. 1987;15:7081–90. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
8. Guo P, Erickson S, Anderson D. A small viral RNA is required for in vitro packaging of bacteriophage phi 29 DNA. Science. 1987;236:690–4. [PubMed]
9. Guo P. Bacterial virus phi29 DNA-packaging motor and its potential applications in gene therapy and nanotechnology. Methods in Molecular Biology. 2005;300:285–324. [PubMed]
10. Guo S, Tschammer N, Mohammed S, Guo P. Specific delivery of therapeutic RNAs to cancer cells via the dimerization mechanism of phi29 motor pRNA. Human Gene Therapy. 2005;16:1097–109. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
11. Garver K, Guo P. Boundary of pRNA functional domains and minimum pRNA sequence requirement for specific connector binding and DNA packaging of phage phi 29. RNA-A Publication Of The RNA Society. 1997;3:1068–1079. [PubMed]
12. Garver K, Guo P. Mapping the inter-RNA interaction of bacterial virus phi29 packaging RNA by site-specific photoaffinity cross-linking. Journal of Biological Chemistry. 2000;275:2817–2824. [PubMed]
13. Ng PS, Laing BM, Balasundarum G, Pingle M, Friedman A, Bergstrom DE. Synthesis and evaluation of new spacers for use as dsDNA end-caps. Bioconjug Chem. 2010;21:1545–53. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
14. Ng PS, Pingle MR, Balasundarum G, Friedman A, Zu X, Bergstrom DE. Endcaps for stabilizing short DNA duplexes. Nucleosides Nucleotides Nucleic Acids. 2003;22:1635–7. [PubMed]
15. Pingle MR, Ng P-S, Xu X, Bergstrom DE. Synthesis of Endcap Dimethoxytrityl Phosphoramidites for Endcapped Oligonucleotides. Current Protocols in Nucleic Acid Chemistry. 2003:5.6.1–5.6.15. [PubMed]
16. Hannoush RN, Damha MJ. Remarkable stability of hairpins containing 2′,5′-linked RNA loops. J Am Chem Soc. 2001;123:12368–74. [PubMed]
17. Proctor DJ, Schaak JE, Bevilacqua JM, Falzone CJ, Bevilacqua PC. Isolation and characterization of a family of stable RNA tetraloops with the motif YNMG that participate in tertiary interactions. Biochemistry. 2002;41:12062–75. [PubMed]
18. Durand M, Chevrie K, Chassignol M, Thuong NT, Maurizot JC. Circular dichroism studies of an oligonucleotide containing a hairpin loop made of a hexaethylene glycol chain: conformation and stability. Nucleic Acids Research. 1990;18:6353–6359. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
19. Gao H, Chidambaram N, Chen BC, Pelham DE, Patel R, Yang M, Zhou L, Cook A, Cohen JS. Double-Stranded Cyclic Oligonucleotides with Non-Nucleotide Bridges. Bioconjugate Chemistry. 1994;5:445–453. [PubMed]
20. Schenborn ET, Mierendorf RC., Jr A novel transcription property of SP6 and T7 RNA polymerases: dependence on template structure. Nucleic Acids Research. 1985;13:6223–36. [PMC free article] [PubMed]