Mycobacterial diseases remain a significant cause of morbidity and mortality worldwide. Tuberculosis (TB) is responsible for approximately two million deaths per year. TB has historically been regarded as a thin man's disease. Yet in our studies in Texas, a considerable proportion of the patients have been overweight and obese (
33,
34). In addition, other studies have demonstrated that patients with diabetes mellitus, who are often overweight as part of metabolic syndrome, are at an increased risk of developing active pulmonary TB (
20,
30). This is a problem given that the “average” American's weight has increased by 10 kg in the last 4 decades, so that 2 in every 3 Americans are now overweight (body mass index [BMI] ≥ 25 kg/m
2), 1 in 3 are obese (BMI ≥ 30 kg/m
2), and 6% are morbidly obese (BMI ≥ 40 kg/m
2) (
10,
32). In high-burden TB countries in southern Africa and South America, obesity has also become a major problem, rivaling even that in the United States, with considerable proportions of overweight/obese people and underweight/malnourished people coexisting within the same populations (
9,
23). In Egypt, for example, obesity rates among women are >45%, while in the Pacific Islands of Samoa and Tonga they are 60 to 70% (
39). Approximately 1.3 billion out of the 6 billion humans are at least overweight, so clearly the entire species is becoming obese (
31). This is a major challenge, given that anti-TB dosing regimens were designed decades ago for an underweight population of patients with “consumption.”
Body mass (M) or weight is a physical phenomenon. Physical phenomena occur on a large range of scales. As an example, the mass of living things can vary from about ~6 × 10
−16 kg for a bacterium to ~6 × 10
4 kg for a sperm whale, a span of 10
20. Scaling biochemical relationships using linear relationships across such a large span is often inaccurate. Second, the shapes of most natural objects, such as human organs, trees, mountains, and galaxies, do not follow smooth Euclidean geometrical shapes, such as parallelograms and cubes. The human heart, for example, is not a sphere, and the brain is not a cube. The roughness and true exact shape of anatomical shapes of living things, such as leaves, tree trunks, blood vessels, and kidneys, are a result of maximization of energy and metabolite transfer by evolution. Third, many of these rough shapes, from snowflakes to human anatomical shapes, demonstrate a recursive pattern, since dimensions change over the large dimension spans discussed above. Examples are branching of the cardiovascular system from the aorta through the capillaries and back or bronchi and bronchioles, essential for delivery of oxygen and metabolites. Fourth, such shapes can have dimensions that are fractions. Fractal geometry explains relationships across such large scales of dimensions, across recursive scaling patterns, and across nonregular (rough) shapes (
27,
28). In the late 1930s, it was observed that metabolic rates of different animal species across a large span of M were proportional to M
3/4 (
21,
22). Recent work has demonstrated that this “3/4 power law” applies to metabolism of all organisms and is due to fractal geometry constraints: in other words, 3/4 is dimension that scales metabolic rate to mass (
43,
44). Recent work by us and others has demonstrated that the between-patient systemic clearance (SCL) of echinocandins also obeys this rule within the human species alone, even over a span of weight with only 4-fold variation (
16,
17,
19). Here we investigated if this was also true in the case of ethambutol in obese persons.
Ethambutol continues to be a mainstay of first-line treatment in patients with active TB (
4). TB is a global problem, affecting 12 million people per year, and will thus be diagnosed in patients with weight that varies over a wide span. Moreover, ethambutol is also a vital part of first-line treatment for patients with
Mycobacterium avium complex (MAC). MAC affects approximately 3,000 persons per year in the United States and has a treatment failure rate of 40 to 60% (
11–
14,
40,
41). In addition, several pathogenic
Mycobacterium species are also susceptible to ethambutol, including
M. kansasii,
M. gordonae,
M. marinum,
M. scrofulaceum, and
M. szulgai (
15). Thus, ethambutol is a broad antimycobacterial agent with uses beyond treatment of TB.
We have demonstrated that microbial killing by ethambutol is concentration dependent while resistance suppression best correlates with the percentage of the dosing interval in which the drug concentration is above the MIC (
TMIC) (
8,
36). Since the 24-h area under the concentration-time curve (AUC
0–24) is inversely proportional to SCL, and
TMIC decreases with faster SCL, between-patient variability of SCL will alter both microbial kill and resistance suppression. This is a crucial factor, given that we have recently demonstrated that low drug exposures due to pharmacokinetic variability are a more important cause of multidrug-resistant (MDR) TB emergence than directly observed therapy (
37). Thus, it is crucial to determine if between-patient ethambutol variability is due to differences in weight and thus provide a pathway for designing optimal ethambutol dosing in obese patients.
(This work was presented in part at the 50th Interscience Conference on Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy [abstract no. A1-058] and the 3rd International Workshop on Clinical Pharmacology of Tuberculosis Drugs.)