To test RNAi in B. malayi, we decided to target orthologs of a number of genes known to be involved in C. elegans development and which show clear cellular phenotypes when depleted in that species. We specifically targeted proteins with a structural role, and their regulators.
We started with γ-tubulin, a cytoskeleton component critical for centrosome-dependent microtubule nucleation and consequently proper spindle formation and cytokinesis [
28,
29]. A 2 day incubation with 100 nM hsiRNA against
B. malayi γ-tubulin lead to cytokinesis defects during early embryogenesis, as visualized by our optimized immunostaining procedures (Figure ), and was sufficient to target all zygotic and very early embryonic divisions. Cytokinesis did not occur in zygotes from γ-tubulin hsiRNA-treated worms resulting in polynucleated 1-cell embryos (Figure ). This suggests that robust phenotypes can be induced by our hsiRNAi procedures at relatively low concentrations of RNA. Similarly, exposure of
B. malayi to
par-1 hsiRNA (1 μM) for 2 days resulted in polarity defective embryos. In
C. elegans, the Ser/Thr kinase PAR-1 is crucial for establishing the embryonic anterior-posterior polarity, and PAR-1 removal leads to defects in posterior spindle rotation and loss of division asynchrony at the 2-cell stage [
30]. In
B. malayi embryos from untreated worms, divisions at the 2-cell stage were asynchronous with the anterior blastomere dividing first and the spindle in the posterior blastomere rotating to align with the anterior-posterior axis (Figure ) as in
C. elegans. However, following exposure to
par-1 hsiRNA, divisions at the 2-cell stage became synchronous and the spindle in the posterior blastomere failed to rotate (Figure ), again precisely phenocopying defects assigned to removal of the corresponding protein in
C. elegans [
30]. In a third example, that of the epithelial cell junction protein AJM-1, we observed a more severe phenotype in
B. malayi than in
C. elegans. Removal of AJM-1 in
C. elegans results in embryonic elongation defects and developmental arrest [
31,
32]. After targeting the
B. malayi ajm-1 transcript by RNAi we not only observed robust elongation defects but also severe ventral closure defects and/or epidermal rupture leading to cell protrusions (Figure ) entirely consistent with disruption of epithelial junction components in
C. elegans [
32].
The unequivocal phenotypes we report were obtained using hsiRNA concentrations in the range of 0.1 to 1 μM (~1.3 to 13 μg/ml), whereas other studies addressing RNAi in animal parasitic nematodes have generally used much higher long dsRNA concentrations, frequently in the range 1 to 3.5 mg/ml [
13,
14,
20,
22,
27]. In the few reports on the use of synthetic short interfering RNA (siRNA) or hsiRNA in animal parasitic nematodes, the concentration has typically ranged from 1 to 5 μM, with gene silencing observed in some, but not all, cases [
13,
22,
33]. It appears that the nematode cuticle may be more permeable to smaller RNA molecules [
22,
33].
We have confirmed phenotypes for all 7 transcripts targeted by this approach including 6 genes expressed during embryogenesis and 1 in adult tissue, comprising cytoskeleton components, some of them regulators or interactors, as well as genes involved in metabolism. This high rate of effective gene targeting contrasts earlier reports of inefficient RNAi-induced silencing in animal parasitic nematodes [
13-
18]. Our success may be due in part to targeting genes known to show cellular phenotypes in
C. elegans (6 of 7 cases), although in previous studies efficient silencing in
C. elegans has not translated well into silencing of orthologs in animal parasitic species. For example of 10 genes that show clear larval phenotypes when subjected to RNAi in
C. elegans, not one resulted in a phenotype when the orthologous genes in
Haemonchus contortus orthologs were tested and only two showed any transcript reduction [
13]. Our method of RNA delivery may contribute to the effective RNAi results we demonstrate. Most studies have used long dsRNA or one (or a few) synthetic siRNAs that correspond to the gene targeted [
14]. Few studies have used hsiRNA mixtures produced enzymatically from longer dsRNA molecules to yield multiple overlapping short RNAs. In one report [
22] a variant of the present method was performed using an RNase III digestion protocol which generates predominantly short RNA species (~13 bp) that are not expected to be effective in gene silencing [
34]. Unlike other methods employing RNase III, the enzyme conditions used in the present study convert long dsRNA to a mixture of short RNAs ranging from ~18-25 bp, predominantly of around the optimal 21 bp size [
35]. Furthermore, since all molecules in the mixture are specific for the targeted gene very potent silencing can be achieved. Conversely, off-target effects are minimized since the molar concentration of any molecule in the mixture that matches a non-target transcript will be very low [
35].