|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
The NADPH oxidase enzyme complex, NOX2, is responsible for reactive oxygen species (ROS) production in neutrophils and has been recognized as a key mediator of inflammation. Here, we have performed rational design and in silico screen to identify a small molecule inhibitor, Phox-I1, targeting the interactive site of p67phox with Rac GTPase that is a necessary step of the signaling leading to NOX2 activation. Phox-I1 binds to p67phox with a submicromolar affinity and abrogates Rac1 binding, and is effective in inhibiting NOX2-mediated superoxide production dose-dependently in human and murine neutrophils without detectable toxicity. Medicinal chemistry characterizations have yielded promising analogs and initial information of the structure-activity relationship of Phox-I1. Our studies suggest the potential utility of Phox-I class inhibitors in NOX2 oxidase inhibition and present the first application of rational targeting of a small GTPase - effector interface.
Originally characterized in phagocytes, the multicomponent NADPH oxidase NOX2 enzyme complex facilitates the production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) to mediate innate immunity. These oxygen species are generated from a superoxide anion (O2−) that is produced by phagocytes in order to kill invading microorganisms (Bedard and Krause, 2007). In humans, mutations in any of the components of the NADPH oxidase complex can lead to chronic granulomatous disease (CGD), where the superoxide production defect results in a patient’s inability to fight infection and in aberrant inflammation (Roos, 1994). This NADPH oxidase-dependent process has now been shown to occur in many different cell types for both host defense and intracellular signal transduction (Sundaresan et al., 1996; Takemura et al., 2010). Thus, beyond its role in pathologies of host defense, inappropriate regulation of the NADPH oxidase complex has been proposed to contribute to a multitude of inflammation-mediated disorders including cancer, atherosclerosis, hypertension, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), myocardial infarction, and stroke (Armitage et al., 2009; Bedard and Krause, 2007; Kleinschnitz et al., 2010; Williams and Griendling, 2007).
Because superoxide and secondary ROS can also cause tissue damage and initiate inflammatory responses, NADPH oxidase activity must be stringently regulated. Biochemical studies over the past two decades have identified a well-defined molecular mechanism of NOX2 regulation; its activation is dependent on a series of protein interactions that are initiated in the cytoplasm and translocate to the cell membrane for full NADPH oxidase complex activation. In the prototypical phagocytic superoxide production event, in response to inflammatory stimuli, four cytosolic proteins in the “regulatory complex”, i.e. Rac1/2, p47phox, p67phox and p40phox, are translocated to the membrane where they interact with the plasma membrane bound NOX2 and p22phox subunits. Upon assembly of this complex, electrons are transferred from NADPH to oxygen to produce the superoxide anion and consequently other ROS. One limiting step in the assembly of this active NADPH oxidase complex is the binding of p67phox to the activated, GTP bound Rac1 and/or Rac2 (Abo et al., 1991; Diekmann et al., 1994; Lapouge et al., 2000). To this end, upon stimulation, cytosolic Rac1/2-GDP is released from the GDP dissociation inhibitor (Lambeth, 2004), allowing guanine nucleotide exchange factors (GEFs) to bind to Rac-GDP and catalyze the exchange of GDP for GTP (Etienne-Manneville and Hall, 2002). Once activated, Rac1/2-GTP translocate to the plasma membrane and recruits p67phox by binding to its N-terminus (Koga et al., 1999; Lapouge et al., 2000). The binding of p67phox to Rac1/2-GTP allows for the complete assembly of the complex and activation of NOX2 NADPH oxidase. High resolution x-ray crystal structures along with mutant data have revealed that the Arg 38 and Arg 102 residues of p67phox create a deep binding pocket that is necessary for interaction with Rac1/2-GTP (Koga et al., 1999; Lapouge et al., 2000).
Rac1/2 GTPases of the Rho family of small GTPases are pleiotropic regulators of a multitude of downstream cellular processes (Etienne-Manneville and Hall, 2002). In response to extracellular signals, the interconversion of Rac-GDP and Rac-GTP occurs via interaction with GEFs and GTPase-activating proteins (GAPs) (Bosco et al., 2009; Etienne-Manneville and Hall, 2002; Van Aelst and D’Souza-Schorey, 1997). The outcome of Rac activities hinges on their ability to interact with specific effectors, which regulate cell growth or survival programs, actin dynamics, or ROS production machinery. Since upregulated expression or activity, rarely mutation, of Rac GTPases, is often associated with human pathologies, recent studies have shown that targeting Rac activation by GEFs may serve as a tractable therapeutic option in various pathological settings (Bosco et al., 2010; Gao et al., 2004; Muller et al., 2008; Thomas et al., 2007). Previous rational design and drug discovery approaches utilizing structural information to predict high affinity binding small molecules that dock to a specific region of Rac1 involved in GEF interaction have yielded successful results in identifying inhibitory molecules in the Rac signaling axis (Gao et al., 2004; Nassar et al., 2006). However, given the multi-facet role of the Rac1/2 GTPases, it can be expected that strategies targeting Rac effectors may be more beneficial in reducing undesired effects at the level of Rac signaling, as higher specificity may be achieved downstream from Rac.
To specifically inhibit the effector function of Rac1 in the NOX2 NADPH oxidase signaling axis, we have performed an in silico screen to identify inhibitors of the Rac1 - p67phox interaction. This unprecedented approach of targeting a small GTPase effector may afford greater specificity and circumvent the blockade of multiple Rac-mediated functions such as actin reorganization by Rac activity inhibitors like NSC23766 (Gao et al., 2004) or Compound 4 (Ferri et al., 2009). We found that small molecules that bind to the Rac1 binding pocket of p67phox can readily inhibit Rac1 interaction and abrogate ROS production with a high degree of specificity. This novel targeting strategy has generated a class of lead inhibitors of a pathologically relevant inflammatory pathway of Rac signaling with a defined structure-activity relationship.
Virtual screening was performed to identify candidate molecules that could disrupt the formation of p67phox complex with Rac1, by binding to p67phox within the interaction interface with Rac1. Docking simulations for the virtual screening were performed using rigid body docking, as implemented in AutoDock ver. 3.5 and ver. 4.0 (Huey et al., 2007; Morris et al., 2009). A crystal structure of the complex (Lapouge et al., 2000) (PDB code 1E96) was used to build the model of the p67phox receptor for the docking simulations, using ADT graphical interface to define the simulation grid boxes. Two libraries of compounds were used, including the drug-like subset of the ZINC library (Irwin and Shoichet, 2005), and in house diversified library of about 340,000 drug-like compounds assembled by the former Procter & Gamble Pharmaceuticals, now owned by the University of Cincinnati Drug Discovery Center (UCDDC). Gesteiger partial charges were used for both the receptor and ligands. Screening was performed in three stages, using increasingly stringent parameters (e.g., changing grid density from 0.6 Ang in the initial screening to 0.375 in the refinement stage) and gradually more extensive sampling by increasing the number of energy evaluations (from 100,000 to 10 mln), Genetic Algorithm runs (from 10 to 33) and population size (from 75 to 150). After initial fast screening, promising candidates with high estimated binding affinities were retained for the refinement stage. Candidate compounds were ranked based on their estimated binding affinities and top candidates were further assessed from the point of view of their properties.
The p67phox protein was expressed in BL21(DE3) bacteria (Stratagene) using the pET30-HIS p67(1-212) plasmid (Molshanski-Mor et al. 2007). Protein was purified using the QIAexpress Ni-NTA kit (Qiagen) or the GST Bind Resin Chromatography Kit (Novagen) for RacV12 and RacWT proteins. Mutagenesis was carried out using the Quick Change Lightening Site Directed Mutagenesis Kit (Stratagene). Proteins were labeled for microscale thermophoresis using the Monolith NT Protein Labeling Kit Red (Nano Temper Technologies) as recommended by the manufacturer. Binding reactions were carried out using the Monolith NT.115 (Nano Temper Technologies). Binding data was analyzed using Graphpad Prizm to estimate Kd values. The arbitrary fluorescence value from the thermophoresis plots for the smallest compound titration was subtracted from every other data point (Delta depletion) prior to normalization to a Vmax of 100. In thermophoresis plots where there was no binding, a curve could not be fit and therefore no Vmax could be assigned. In these instances the highest delta depletion value was set to 100 and all data were normalized accordingly.
HL-60 cells (a kind gift of Dr. Christopher Karp, Cincinnati Children’s Hospital) were propagated in RPMI 1640 medium containing 10% heat inactivated fetal bovine serum, 2mM L-glutamine, 100 U/mL penicillin/streptomycin at 37°C in air containing 5% CO2. For differentiation, HL-60 cells were cultured in 1.3% dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) as previously described (Servant et al., 1999). Primary murine neutrophils were isolated from C57Bl/6 mouse bone marrow according to a published protocol (Filippi et al., 2007) using a discontinuous Percoll (Pharmacia) gradient and were utilized immediately in experiments. Human neutrophils were obtained from fresh blood (IRB #2010-1855, Cincinnati Children’s Hospital medical Center) following a well established protocol using density gradient separation from whole blood (Oh et al., 2008).
PMA, apocynin, H2O2, DPI chloride, DTT, HRP, glucose oxidase, xanthine, xanthine oxidase were purchased from Sigma Aldrich. All Phox-I compounds and derivatives, except for those used in initial screening, were custom synthesized by Radikal Therapeutics Inc. (Beverly, MA). The chemicals were subjected to LC/MS analysis prior to use, as shown in an example in supplemental Figure S1.
Whole-cell lysates were prepared by cell extraction using lysis buffer containing 20 mM Tris-HCl (pH 7.6), 100 mM NaCl, 10 mM MgCl2, 1% Triton X-100, 0.2% sodium deoxycholate, 1 mM phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride, 10 μg/mL of leupeptin, 1 μg/mL of aprotinin, and 1 mM dithiothreitol for 30 min. Equal amounts of protein, as determined by Bradford assay, were resolved by SDS-PAGE. Specific proteins were detected by standard immunoblotting procedures using the following primary antibodies: (Cell Signaling, 1:500 dilution) phospho-PAK1 (Ser144)/PAK2 (Ser141), (Sigma-Aldrich 1:500) β-Actin.
Cells (5×105) were harvested and processed for Annexin V/7AAD staining according to manufacturer’s protocol (Becton Dickinson). Flow cytometry data were acquired on a FACS Canto bench-top flow cytometer (Becton Dickinson) and the cell cycle distributions were determined by an BrdU incorporation assay using Flo-Jo software (Bosco et al 2010). For ROS production assay, primary murine neutrophils or dHL60 cells were incubated with compound for 2 hours prior to addition of H2-DCFDA according to manufacturer’s instructions (Molecular Probes). Cells were then stimulated with 10μM fMLP(Sigma), 1mM CaCl2, and 1.5 mM MgCl2 for 15 minutes prior to wash and FACS analysis for mean fluorescence intensity. Non-fMLP stimulated control values were subtracted from all samples before normalization to fMLP-stimulated, vehicle control treated sample in order to display percent ROS inhibition.
Cells were pretreated with compound for 40 minutes prior to wash, and resuspended in HBSS with compound. Cells were allowed to adhere to fibronectin (Sigma Aldrich) coated glass coverslips (15 min) and then stimulated with 100nM fMLP (3 min). Coverslips were then fixed with 3.7% paraformaldehyde (Sigma Aldrich) and then staining for F-actin was performed with rhodamine phalloidin per the manufacturer’s instructions (Molecular Probes).
Primary neutrophils from mouse bone marrow were subjected to fMLP stimulation in the presence or absence of various chemicals for 5 min. Cells were stained for NBT activity as previously described (Filippi et al., 2004) to reveal relative ROS production.
Human neutrophils (2×105) were stimulated in HBSS supplemented with 0.1% BSA, 1mM Ca2+, 1mM Mg2+ and with fMLP (10μM), PMA (300nM) or glucose oxidase (200 mU/ml) for 30 min in the presence of 10μM [8-amino-5-chloro-7-phenylpyrido[3,4-d]pyridazine-1,4(2H,3H)dione] L012. Chemiluminescence was measured using GloMax®-96 Microplate Luminometer (Promega) (Tarpey et al., 2004). The generation of hydrogen peroxide by the xanthine/xanthine oxidase was performed in PBS supplemented with xanthine oxidase (0.004 U), HRP (0.005 U·mL−1) and L012 (Wind et al. 2010). The reaction was started by the addition of xanthine (0.5 mM).
Primary mouse neutrophils were suspended in 100μl NucleofectorR solution with 10 μg plasmid pCDNA3-NOX4 encoding NOX4 (a kind gift of Dr. T. Leto, NIH) or mock vector. Cells were transfected using a Cell Line V NucleofactorTMR kit (Amaxa Biosystem, Amaxa Inc.) and the NucleofectorTM program Y-001. Cells were recovered at 37°C for 2 hours and subjected to the luminol chemiluminescence assay using 10μM L012 and HRP (0.005 U·mL−1) to record ROS produced by NOX4 expression.
The three dimensional structure of p67phox in complex with Rac1 (PDB 1E96) was visually analyzed using PyMOL in order to determine the contact region between the two proteins. Extraneous objects such as water molecules and ions that did not belong to the protein complex were removed. The structure of the Rac1-p67phox complex is shown in Figure 1A: Arginine residues 38 and 102 of p67phox surround the site within the Rac1 interaction interface, and Rac1 residues 25–27 (Thr-Ans-Ala motif in Switch I) are buried upon complex formation and are sandwiched by Arg38 and Arg102. Next, the Rac1 chain was then displaced from the complex and the molecular surface representation of p67phox residues involved in the interaction with Rac1 was visually inspected to identify suitable small molecule binding sites. A concave surface comprising Arg 102 and Arg 38 was qualitatively selected as the binding site for virtual screening (Koga et al., 1999; Lapouge et al., 2000). This crystallographic structure of p67phox was subsequently overlapped and aligned with the N-terminal region of another p67phox structure (PDB 1HH8) crystallized not in complex with Rac1. Negligible differences were observed from the root mean square deviation (RMSD) analysis in the spatial region involved in the Rac1 - p67phox interaction, suggesting the conformation of the chosen docking pocket is mostly conserved before and after Rac1 binding and is suitable for virtual screening.
Virtual screening was performed using Autodock 4 for docking calculations of 350,000 diverse drug-like compounds from the proprietary University of Cincinnati Drug Discovery Center (UCDDC) compound library and from the public ZINC library which contains over 700,000 compounds (Irwin and Shoichet, 2005; Morris et al., 2009). Automated docking was performed according to the docking flow chart (Figure 1B). The Autodock 4 -conformed UCDDC and ZINC libraries were screened using Lamarckian Genetic Algorithm (LGA) in three successive steps (Figure 1C). During the first two steps, the docking results were ranked for the lowest binding energy change, and the two sub-libraries containing the selected hits were populated using a DGbinding cut-off of −6.7 and −8.0 kcal/mol, respectively, for subsequent docking steps. The top hits derived were visually inspected using AutoDockTool (ADT) by considering several parameters such as DGbinding, cluster convergence, hydrogen bonding and predicted molecular geometry. The selected top 100 hits were ranked for predicted water solubility (LogS), and compounds with LogS < −4.3 were chosen for further evaluation.
The chemical structure of one of the top hits, Phox-I1, in complex with p67phox is shown in Figure 1D. Hydrogen donor/acceptor interactions occur between the two nitro groups of the inhibitor and the Arg 102 and Arg 38 on p67Phox. The predicted binding energy (DGbinding) was −8.90 Kcal/mol, which is equivalent to a Ki of 2.9×10−7 M−1. Further, Lipinski parameters and Ki’s were calculated for the top 9 predicted candidates specific for p67phox (Figure 1E).
To test the ability of the lead compounds identified by virtual screening to bind to the p67phox protein in the N-terminal 200 amino acid region necessary for Rac1-GTP interaction (Ahmed et al., 1998; Diekmann et al., 1994; Han et al., 1998), we employed microscale thermophoresis (Wienken et al., 2010). This technology probes for fluorescent changes in the hydration shell of molecules in order to measure protein-protein or protein-small molecule interactions with high sensitivity in near-native conditions. The p67phox N-terminus showed binding activity to the Phox-I1 compound in titration assays, yielding a Kd value of ~100nM (Figure 2A). Mutagenesis of R38 residue of p67phox that is critical for Rac1-GTP binding disrupted the binding ability of Phox-I1 to p67phox (Figure 2B). As a positive control, a mutant made at residue R188 of p67phox, outside of the region critical for interaction with Rac1-GTP (Koga et al., 1999; Lapouge et al., 2000), retained the binding activity to Phox-I1 (Figure 2C). To demonstrate the ability of Phox-I1 to compete with active Rac1 for the binding pocket of p67phox, we first validated the high-affinity binding activity of the constitutively active Rac1V12 mutant with p67phox by microscale thermophoresis (Figure 2D). Rac1-GDP was unable to bind to p67phox in this assay, thus showing specificity of this interaction for the active Rac1 (Figure 2E). Next, to perform a competition binding, p67phox protein was first incubated with either 5μM Phox-I1 or an equal volume of vehicle control for 15 minutes prior to titration of purified Rac1V12 protein. The disruption of p67phox binding to Rac1V12 by Phox-I1, but not vehicle control, was evident (Figure 2F). Furthermore, as a control for specificity, Rac1V12 protein was incubated with various concentrations of Phox-I1 but no detectable binding was observed (Figure 2G). Thus, Phox-I1 binding to p67phox is specific and not due to non-specific effects, such as aggregation (McGovern et al., 2002). Together, these studies indicate that the lead p67phox inhibitor Phox-I1 can bind to the Rac1 interactive site of p67phox specifically and interfere with Rac1-GTP interaction with p67phox.
To validate the hits from virtual screening in cells, we performed several cellular functional assays using different cell types to measure the effect of compounds on inhibition of ROS production. ROS levels were first analyzed by FACS in HL-60 pre-incubated with compounds for 2 hours prior to stimulation of ROS production. Because inhibitors of ROS production and NADPH oxidase activity are well studied in vitro and have been tested in clinical applications, we tested the lead p67phox inhibitor, Phox-I1, against NAC (a ROS scavenger), DPI (a broad range inhibitor of NADPH oxidase), and NSC23766 (a Rac-GTP inhibitor) (Figure 3A). Phox-I1, at 20 uM, was able to attenuate ROS production similarly to 100 uM DPI or 100 uM NSC23766, and slightly more efficiently than 5 mM NAC. H2O2 added to the cells was included as a positive control for ROS measurement. Second, to test the capacity of Phox-I1 to inhibit ROS production in a primary cell context, primary murine neutrophils isolated from mouse bone marrow were treated with increasing concentrations of Phox-I1 and the efficacy of inhibition of fMLP-stimulated ROS production was analyzed. DPI treatment was included as a positive control for inhibition of ROS production (Figure 3B). Both 10 uM and 20 uM concentrations of Phox-I1 were able to inhibit ROS production nearly as well as DPI at 100 uM concentration. Next, to ascertain the optimal effective dose for ROS inhibition in cells, a dose titration series of Phox-I1 was administered to dHL-60 cells (Figure 3C). Optimal cellular response to this compound was achieved at doses of 10μM, with an IC50 of ~3 μM.
In addition to using the DCFDA-based FACS analysis of ROS generation in primary murine neutrophils, we validated the efficacy of Phox-I1 in primary human neutrophils by the luminol chemiluminescence assay. As shown in Figure 3D, Phox-I1 was able to suppress fMLP-induced ROS production in human neutrophils dose-dependently, with an IC50 ~8 μM based on an one-site competition model. Further, Phox-I1 did not affect the exogenous glucose oxidase-produced ROS (Figure 3E), nor the PMA-induced ROS production that is mediated through a PIP3-independent pathway (Figure 3F), suggesting that the fMLP-Rac-p67phox axis may mediate a pathway for NOX2 activation independently from the PMA pathway, consistent with previous studies indicating that fMLP and PMA induce superoxide generation through distinct pathways (Dong et al., 2005; Perisic, et al., 2004). All together, these data indicate that Phox-I1 can efficiently inhibit ROS production in the μM range in both human and murine neutrophils.
As discussed above, the virtual screen led to the identification of Phox-I1 as a lead inhibitor of p67phox. While this compound showed promising activity, progression to more advanced testing is limited by the generally poor solubility of the compound and toxicological concerns from the presence of nitro groups in the structure, as nitro groups are often associated with toxicity in animal studies and are rarely seen in clinical candidates. To develop a preliminary understanding of the Structure-Activity Relationships (SAR) in these classes, we conducted a substructure search of the University of Cincinnati Drug Discovery Core chemical library. Thirty-five compounds from this search were visually screened in an attempt to explore the structural space with the goals of (1) retaining or improving activity, (2) improving solubility, and/or (3) seeking a replacement of the nitro groups. Toward that end, 16 compounds bearing more polar functional groups and with replacement or altered positions of the nitro groups were selected for further screening (Figure 4A).
To validate the relative potency of the compounds identified in the analog screen, we performed a cellular functional assay of ROS inhibition in differentiated HL-60 cells. Cells were pre-incubated with analogs from Figure 4A for 2 hours prior to stimulation of ROS production and analysis of ROS levels by FACS (Figure 4B). Comparing with cells treated with vehicle control, analogs 4, 10, 16, and Phox-I1 displayed the greatest inhibition of ROS production while analogs 1, 7, 11, 12, and 13 showed little or no inhibition of ROS production. It is noteworthy that the structures of analogs 4 and 16, both of which displayed a high ROS inhibitory activity, are similar with the exception of one substituent, providing evidence of a core structure that is necessary for potency. Based on the improved ROS inhibitory activity displayed by analog 16, we termed it a second generation lead inhibitor, Phox-I2. Although Phox-I2 serves as an attractive lead based on its improved ligand efficiency (maximum potency relative to size), it suffers from the presence of two nitro functions. Future plans are to further modify the structure and adhere to standard guidelines of Oral Drug-like Properties, such as Veber and Lipinski rules (Lipinski et al., 2001; Veber et al., 2002).
To stringently confirm the effectiveness and specificity of these potential ROS inhibitors, it is advocated that multiple methods of measuring ROS production assays should be utilized (Jaquet et al., 2009). Therefore, to complement the DCFDA based FACS analysis and the luminol chemiluminescence method, we performed nitroblue tetrazolium (NBT) assays in fMLP-activated primary murine neutrophils (Figure 4C). These experiments revealed that a 10μM dose of Phox-I1 resulted in a significant blockade of superoxide production, which was heightened by similar treatment with Phox-I2. Both Phox-I1 and Phox-I2 were effective at a lower dose than our working concentration of DPI, which was included as a positive control for ROS inhibition. Thus, the results of these combined assay methods validated that the lead inhibitors could effectively inhibit ROS production by neutrophils.
We next confirmed the biochemical binding activity of Phox-I2 to p67phox protein with a titration series of Phox-I2 using microscale thermophoresis (Figure 4D). As predicted based on in silico docking (data not shown) and core structural similarity to Phox-I1, Phox-I2 displayed a high affinity binding to the p67phox target with an approximate Kd of ~150nM. Additionally, the dose-dependent potency of Phox-I2 was assessed in dHL-60 cells by the DCFDA assay, which revealed an IC50 ~1μM (Figure 4E), and in primary human neutrophils by the luminol chemiluminescence assay, yielding an IC50 ~6 μM (Figure 4F). As shown in Figure 3D, Phox-I1 was able to suppressed fMLP-induced ROS production in human neutrophils dose-dependently. To validate our preliminary SAR information and as a negative control, analog 13 displayed no ROS inhibitory activity in dHL-60 cells (Figure 4B) and was unable to bind to p67phox protein (Figure 4G). Analog 13 was thereby unable to dose-dependently inhibit ROS production in the dHL-60 DCFDA ROS production assay (Figure 4H).
Because several existing ROS inhibitors are associated with low potency and high cytotoxicity, we next assessed the levels of apoptosis in undifferentiated HL-60 cells treated with 20 or 100μM Phox-I1, Phox-I2, or NSC23766 by FACS analysis for Annexin V (Figure 5A). There was no detectable effect on cell apoptosis by NSC23766, Phox-I1 or Phox-I2 at either concentration as compared to the untreated control, indicating that these compounds have minimal cytotoxicity in the dosage range of maximal ROS inhibition. To analyze the biochemical specificity of these lead inhibitors on the effector pathways of active Rac1, undifferentiated HL-60 cells were treated with Phox-I1, Phox-I2 or NSC23766 for 18hr. Immunoblot of the cell lysates was performed to probe the activity of a Rac effector other than p67phox, Pak (Figure 5B). The phosphorylated Pak levels were abrogated by treatment with the Rac inhibitor NSC23766, but not Phox-I1 or Phox-I2, suggesting that Phox-I1 and Phox-I2 compounds are specific for the p67phox signaling arm of Rac-GTP, as opposed to Rac-GTP signaling in general, as is evidenced by NSC23766 treatment. Another method of addressing Rac signaling specificity in neutrophils is by monitoring their ability to polarize actin to the leading edge upon fMLP stimulation. Importantly, neither Phox-I1, Phox-I2, nor an inactive analog 13 (all at 10μM), were able to block the Rac-mediated dynamic process of F-actin polarization to the leading edge of primary murine neutrophils as observed by F-actin immunofluorescence imaging (Figure 5C, left panel). F-actin polarization was evident in about 80% of each treatment group of cells as in the control, untreated cells (Figure 5C, right panel). In contrast, Nocodazole (200nM), a microtubule disrupting agent that was used as a positive control for disruption of the cytoskeleton, treated cells showed drastic reduction of polarized cells from 80% to ~20%. These data indicate that the Phox-I1 and Phox-I2 p67phox targeting agents do not affect Rac-mediated F-actin assembly. To test if the inhibitors are specific for the NOX2 enzyme, we carried out a xanthine/xanthine oxidase assay and found that Phox-I1 or Phox-I2 does not affect xanthine oxidase mediated ROS production (Supplemental Figure S2) We further applied Phox-I1 to primary murine neutrophils expressing the constitutively active NOX4. As shown in Figure 5D, expression of NOX4 cDNA in neutrophils by nucleofection resulted in an elevated ROS production that is unresponsive to Phox-I1 treatment, in contrast to the fMLP-induced NOX2 mediated ROS response as assayed using a luminescence assay of L012 in the presence of HRP. To further rule out that Phox-I1 and Phox-I2 may simply act as scavengers of ROS, we pre-stimulated dHL-60 cells with fMLP for 30 minutes prior to treatment with Phox-I1 or Phox-I2. Unlike the ROS scavenger NAC, Phox-I1 and Phox-I2 do not affect the levels of superoxide that have already been produced, similarly to apocyanin, DPI, and NSC23766 (Figure 5E). Therefore, these lead p67phox inhibitors do not display antioxidant activity and are specific, consistent with their lack of inhibitory effect on glucose oxidase-induced ROS, as shown previously in figure 3E.
The relevance of therapeutically targeting neutrophils in a pathological context is underscored by recent reports that the circulation time of human neutrophils in the periphery is longer than previously believed (< 1 day vs. 5.4 days) (Pillay et al., 2010). We next performed a stability experiment to determine the duration of effectiveness of the compound in suppressing neutrophils. To analyze the relative affinities of these compounds for the p67phox target in cells, we performed DCFDA ROS production assays in dHL-60 cells treated with compound for 2 hr followed by wash and recovery for 4 hr or 2 hr in normal media prior to ROS production analysis. Although Phox-I1 ROS inhibitory activity was still evident 4 hr or 2 hr after washing the cells, Phox-I2 and analog 4 did not display effective ROS inhibition following removal of the compounds at the dosage tested (Figure 5F). In comparison, the tested dosages of NAC and NSC23766 both retained the ability to inhibit ROS production following a wash of the cells. To assess the relative stability of these compounds in culture over time, DCFDA ROS assays were performed in dHL-60 cells following the indicated time of exposure to the compound. None of the compounds were effective at inhibiting ROS production after 18hr exposure in culture. Phox-I1 seemed to be the most stable in culture over time, displaying no significant change in efficacy in a 6 hr treatment window, while Phox-I2 and analog 4 retained some efficacies over 6 hours of treatment with more varied capacity to inhibit ROS (Figure 5G). Taken together, these data suggest that Phox-I1 and its derivatives display high biochemical and cellular activities in culture with a turnover time of >2–4 hr, indicating that their inhibitory effect is not short-lived but a continuous supply is required for maximum effectiveness in overnight culture conditions.
To further define the structure-activity relationship of Phox-I2, we performed medicinal chemistry synthesis of analogs of Phox-I2 to rationalize the key components of the structure for cellular activity. Compounds with similar structures to Phox-I2 through replacement of each nitro group, or addition of an extra aromatic ring to make the compound more “Phox-I1 like”, were synthesized. Specifically, based on the Phox-I2 structure, 7 compounds of 4 different categories as shown in Figure 6A were produced. When the ROS inhibitory activities of these compounds were tested by DCFDA FACS analysis in differentiated HL-60 cells, all compounds displayed activity (Figure 6B). It became evident that it is possible to replace the nitro group and retain activity (as shown by Analog 22). This was further validated by the NBT assay in primary murine neutrophils where many of the analogs displayed partial activity, with Analog 22 (fluorine groups replacing the outermost nitro groups) exhibiting profound superoxide inhibition (Figure 6C). These studies further define SAR of Phox-I2 structure and provide a solid ground for future optimization.
Because of the extensive role of NOX2 NADPH oxidase in innate immunity and pathophysiology, specific and effective inhibitors of this enzymatic complex have been long sought after but have proven to be challenging to develop. Several inhibitors of different components of the NADPH oxidase complex have previously been characterized, including apocyanin, diphenylene iodonium (DPI), gp91tat, NSC23766, and most recently, VAS2870. Although these inhibitors have been useful in broadening our understanding of the role of the NADPH oxidases in disease, they may not be promising candidates for further drug development due to problems related to toxicity, potency, and specificity (Aldieri et al., 2008; Jaquet et al., 2009; Lambeth et al., 2008). Collectively, most studies using these inhibitors underscore the need for the development of a highly specific and non-toxic inhibitor of NOX2. Recent studies that utilize peptide inhibitors of the Rac1-GTP–NOX2 interaction, although potentially limited by drug delivery issues, have yielded significant inhibition of ROS production, further validated the targeting approach focusing on Rac interaction with this enzyme complex (Dahan et al., 2002; Morozov et al., 1998; Rey et al., 2001).
Here we have carried out a structure-based virtual screen to identify small molecules capable of specific interaction with the Rac1 binding pocket of p67phox. This interaction by small molecule compounds abrogates the ability of active Rac1 binding to p67phox and subsequent activation of the NOX2 oxidase complex in murine and human neutrophils. The efficacy of these compounds is impressive given the potential contribution to ROS production by non-Rac dependent sources, such as NOX4, NOX5 and DUOX1/2, or mitochondrial ROS generation, and reflects the strong dependency of NOX2 in neutrophils for ROS production. In fact, many NADPH oxidase related pathologies are mediated through the NOX2 enzyme, which requires Rac1/2 and p67phox binding for its activity (Bedard and Krause, 2007; Lambeth et al., 2008). As such, the p67phox inhibitor design described herein could serve as a principle for future development into clinically relevant leads. Additionally, this novel approach of targeting the p67phox constituent of the NADPH oxidase complex rather than Rac GTPase itself may circumvent a debate in the field regarding the Rac regulatory mechanism in NADPH oxidase complex activation (Bokoch and Diebold, 2002; Kao et al., 2008).
Prior work from our lab utilizing a similar rational design approach has yielded a specific inhibitor of Rac GTPases, NSC23766, which has been prolific, providing us with not only molecular mechanisms, but also a pre-clinical therapeutic tool to build upon for translational applications (Gao et al., 2004; Nassar et al., 2006). However, in the case of NSC23766, all downstream effectors of Rac GTPases are inhibited due to a suppression of Rac activity, thereby causing potentially undesired effects resulting from inhibition of multiple effector pathways. The approach described here is the first time the small GTPase interactive site of an effector has been rationally targeted, setting up a proof of principle that it can be a viable tactic for enhancing the specificity of inhibitors in the context of small GTPase-mediated cellular functions. Further, in terms of lead discovery and development, the advantages of our small molecule approach to NADPH oxidase inhibition are several-fold. First, lead small molecules yielded from a rational design approach, rather than a high throughput functional screen, are likely to display specificity and potency, that have been primary drawbacks of several NADPH oxidase inhibitors described previously. For example, DPI lacks specificity because it inhibits all NOX isoforms, nitric oxide synthase, xanthine oxidase, mitochondrial complex 1, and cytochrome P-450 reductase (Aldieri et al., 2008; Bedard and Krause, 2007), while apocyanin is thought to non-specifically inhibit NOX through an indirect mechanism only at high dose (Lambeth et al., 2008; Lapperre et al., 1999; O’Donnell et al., 2003). Second, Phox-I1 and Phox-I2 inhibitors can suppress NADPH oxidase activity dose-dependently in a relative short time window, thereby reducing the risk of abolishing the phagocyte immune response. Third, peptide inhibitors, although specific and effective at inhibition of ROS production (Lambeth et al., 2008), may have limitations with oral drug delivery that can be overcome by modifications of small molecule inhibitors such as those described here. Moreover, the rational design approach of virtual screening allows for the validation and optimization of “drug-like”, soluble, potent compounds that are more suitable for applications.
An advantage of small molecule screening is the ability to optimize the potency of the compound through analysis of related analogs. The initial SAR profiles derived from these studies allow for future development of compounds with an improved potential for applications. With respect to Phox-I1 and Phox-I2, one of the initial blockades to application would be the presence of the nitro groups in both compounds, which can be associated with toxicological concerns based on their ability to damage DNA following reductive activation. Thus, a major objective for the initial analog screening and secondary analog synthesis SAR studies was to understand the requirement of these groups in the compound structure. First, the analog screening experiments performed herein (Figure 4) allowed for the compounds to be grouped into 2 classes of structure, Analogs 1, 6, 7, 8, 10, 11, 12, 14 and 15 were characterized as more Phox-I1-like, while Analogs 2, 3, 4, 5, and 9 were defined as more Phox-I2-like. The SAR within the class of compounds derived from Phox1 was not well defined. Analog 1 revealed that the bare scaffold had little to no intrinsic activity. Analog 10 suggested that the addition of a substituent on the north phenyl ring was inconsequential, which is supported by the analog pairs of 11/12 and 8/14. This indicates that the north phenyl ring may be a region where substituents may be added to improve physical properties if a Phox-I1-like structure is to be pursued. In line with the key objective of reducing toxicity, Analogs 6, 8, 14 and 15 demonstrated that some level of activity was retained in absence of nitro groups, albeit potency was significantly reduced. However, the set of analogs that are related to Phox-I2 show a clear SAR pattern in which specific changes resulted in specific effects on activity. Analog 4 indicated that a substituent at the 6 position could be added without severe activity consequences, although Analog 5 suggested that this substituent should be less polar. Analogs 2 and 3 illustrated that the NO2 group could be replaced with more hydrophilic functions without catastrophic loss of activity, which would be hopeful for improving the toxicological profile and solubility. Importantly, Analog 9 demonstrated that the bare scaffold (no NO2 groups) retains some intrinsic activity, thereby supporting the non-essentiality of the nitro functions. Nitro groups are particularly vexing since they have quite unique binding properties with no particularly effective bioisosteres. Analog 9 displayed similar potency to Analogs 2 and 5, suggesting the 3′ NO2 may have less impact on activity. Thus, exploration of alternatives at this portion of the Phox-I2-like molecule subsequently became a major goal of the secondary synthetic screening effort described in Figure 6. One useful SAR conclusion from the compound synthesis experiments is that although deletion of the nitro groups altogether or shifting their position may negatively affect activity, nitro group substitution with fluorine maintains ROS inhibitory activity of the compound. Thus, removal of the potentially toxic nitro groups is possible and warrants further exploration and characterization.
Although structurally diverse, it is striking that the compounds identified by our rational design approach and subsequently the analogs derived from medicinal chemistry contain extended double-bond conjugated systems. These structures are described to be capable of mediating electron exchange as it would occur during ROS generation, and in this respect the p67phox inhibitors described here share similarities to some leading NOX inhibitors developed by the pharmaceutical industry (Jaquet et al., 2009).
In order to complement the in silico and cellular results, we also tested the Phox-I leads in cell-free superoxide production assays (Molshanski-Mor et al. 2007). Phox-I2 was able to dose-dependently inhibit Rac1-GMPPNP induced superoxide burst under the reconstitution conditions (supplemental Figure S3), consistent with the mode of action proposed for the inhibitor. However, the dose curve displayed a higher concentration shift of Phox-I2 than that required in the p67phox binding and cell assays. The requirements of higher concentration of inhibitors in the cell free assay have been previously observed for peptide-based NOX2 inhibitors (Joseph and Pick, 1995; Dahan et al., 2002). Further investigation is necessary to provide insight into this difference. Moreover, there is a difference in target p67 binding affinity (Kd) and ROS inhibitory efficacy in cells (IC50) by the inhibitors, at close to 2 order of magnitude; this could be related to multiple factors such as the route/efficacy of entry, stability, metabolism, etc., in cells.
NAC, a global ROS scavenger, has been described to have a positive effect in a broad array of pathologies such as neurological disorders (Berk et al., 2008), cystic fibrosis (Tirouvanziam et al., 2006), and cancer progression (Estensen et al., 1999; Radisky et al., 2005; van Zandwijk et al., 2000), but its effect is broad and non-specific. Although therapies directed at components of the NOX enzyme have shown promise in disorders including metabolic dysfunction of the pancreatic β-cell, neuronal degeneration following cerebral ischemia, therapeutic resistance in hematological malignancy, and cardiovascular disease (Bedard and Krause, 2007; Kleinschnitz et al., 2010; Kowluru, 2011; Raz et al., 2010; Sawada et al., 2010; Velaithan et al., 2011; Williams and Griendling, 2007), none of the existing NOX inhibitors are ready for application in the clinics due to issues of toxicity and efficacy. Therefore, drugs which potently and specifically inhibit ROS production by NOX enzymes are an unmet clinical need that will have far-reaching implications, and novel strategies for their development, such as the one described here, are critical. To this end, targeting of small GTPases has emerged as an attractive area of lead development (Nassar et al., 2006). However, effective inhibition of a signaling node of a small GTPase that controls a multitude of effector pathways, as seen with a Rac targeting agent such as NSC23766, could also yield increased toxicity and non-specific effects. The current approach of targeting one specific effector of Rac could circumvent this concern. Importantly, not only may our rationally design approach has potential implications in diseases mediated by inflammatory responses, but it also presents a new avenue for generating lead inhibitors of other effectors for pathologically relevant small GTPase signaling axes including that of Ras, Rab and Rho.
Because of the wide array of cellular functions regulated by Rho GTPase activities and the numerous pathologies to which their deregulation may contribute, their signaling axes serve as attractive drug targets. Recently, a number of studies have utilized NSC23766, a Rac activation inhibitor, to inhibit the activity and signaling events of Rac GTPases. However, this targeting approach blocks multiple downstream signaling pathways from Rac, and thus, may lack specificity for distinct cellular functions controlled by Rac. The current study aims to utilize structure-function information to rationally design inhibitors of a unique downstream effector of Rac GTPases. Upon Rac binding, the downstream effector, p67phox, directly regulates the production of ROS by assembling the NOX2 NADPH oxidase complex. Since ROS generation via NADPH oxidase is implicated in a wide array of human diseases, it can be envisioned that specifically targeting the Rac1 - p67phox interaction will prevent activation of the oxidase and may serve as a tractable therapeutic option. As existing NADPH oxidase inhibitors lack specificity or potency, the development of novel inhibitors is important for evaluating the efficacy of NADPH oxidase targeting strategies. Here, we describe the rational design and characterization of small molecule inhibitors of the Rac - p67phox interaction. The Phox-I1/Phox-I2 lead inhibitors bind p67phox with submicromolar affinity and compete with the binding of activated Rac. Consequently, they are capable of abrogating superoxide production in neutrophils without affecting Rac-mediated actin cytoskeleton structure. Structure-activity relationship studies of the lead inhibitors have yielded promising analogs that are amenable to future optimization. Our studies present the first evidence that structure-function based rational design can be a useful means of identifying inhibitors targeting the small GTPase–effector interface downstream of small GTPase signaling.
The authors thank all members of the Zheng lab for thought provoking discussion and acknowledge the CCHMC Biomedical Informatics computational cluster and CCHMC institutional support for assistance in the virtual screening process. The work is partly supported by NIH grants R41 HL099244, R01 CA141341, and T32 HL091805.
The authors have no conflict of interest to declare.
Publisher's Disclaimer: This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final citable form. Please note that during the production process errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.