Functional significance of different microdomains
The vestibular calyx integrates afferent signals from hair cells and efferent signals from the brain into spike activity representing head motions. Calyces in different zones contribute to afferents with distinct discharge patterns and response properties. The localization of ion channels and various associated proteins suggests that these large synaptic cups, previously thought of as uniform, are divided into several discrete domains (), from a postsynaptic Domain 1 deep in the calyceal cup to the heminodal Domain 4 adjacent to the first myelin wrapping ( and ). In addition to ion channels, the domains express a number of scaffolding, CAM and ECM proteins characteristic of axonal nodes and initial segments. Our results support the hypothesis that differences in molecular organization of these domains, between zones and between calyx-only and dimorphic afferents, may help differentiate the discharge patterns of irregular afferents and regular afferents (
Smith and Goldberg, 1986;
Baird et al., 1988;
Goldberg et al., 1990b;
Kalluri et al., 2010).
| Table 2Comparison of Calyx Proteins to Proteins in Nodes of Ranvier and Initial Segments |
Domain 1 comprises much of the calyceal inner face and is contiguous with a dense substance in the intervening synaptic cleft, apposing the synaptic ribbons. Indeed, the extent of the immunolabeled cups () co-varies with hair cell membrane devoted to transmitter release, as reflected by adjacent synaptic ribbons. Ribbons cluster in the bottom third in peripheral-zone type I hair cells but in the bottom two-thirds of central-zone type I hair cells (
Lysakowski and Goldberg, 1997). Therefore, in addition to the proteins shown here, Domain 1 also expresses glutamate receptors – principally AMPA-type, but also NMDA receptors (
Matsubara et al., 1999;
Bonsacquet et al., 2006).
Domain 1 has an impressively dense expression of K
V and Na
V channels. K
V channels include multiple KCNQ (K
V7) and erg (K
V11) channel isoforms as well as K
V1.1 and K
V1.2. Their expression closely matches that of the CAM Caspr1, known to occur at paranodes (
Salzer, 2003).
Sousa et al. (2009) showed that Caspr1 is necessary for retention of KCNQ4 in the calyx membrane and for maintaining appropriate synaptic cleft width. We report that contactin labeling is comparable to the Caspr1 pattern. Both CAMs may together stabilize other K
V channels in this domain, such as KCNQ2, KCNQ5, K
V1.1, and K
V1.2.
Several proteins localized to Domain 1 are reported to associate with Na
V subunits in other tissues: contactin (
Kazarinova-Noyes et al., 2001;
Rush et al., 2005), tenascin-C (
Srinivasan et al., 1998;
Evers et al., 2002;
Dityatev and Schachner, 2006;
Ullian and Dityatev, 2006), and dystrophin (
Byers et al., 1991,
1993;
Kim et al., 1992;
Saito et al., 2003;
Occhi et al., 2005). Thus, Na
V1.5 subunits in Domain 1 may associate with any or all of these proteins. Contactin may regulate current density and expression of Na
V1.5 channels, as it is thought to do for Na
V1.8 and 1.9 subunits (
Kazarinova-Noyes et al., 2001;
Isom, 2002;
Rush et al., 2005). Tenascin-C contributes to the electron-dense cleft material in the synaptic cleft of Domain 1 and could interact with Na
V β subunits and/or contactin in Domain 1 to stabilize the Na channels (
Zisch et al., 1992;
Srinivasan et al., 1998). Dystrophin forms a complex with dystroglycan that connects the actin cytoskeleton to the extracellular matrix, and is found where Na
V channels are present in high density, e.g., the deep folds of the neuromuscular junction (
Byers et al., 1991), nodes (
Byers et al., 1993;
Occhi et al., 2005), and postsynaptic densities (
Kim et al., 1992).
Thus, a complex involving contactin, tenascin-C, dystrophin, and Caspr1 may hold both K
V and Na
V channels at high density and in specific sub-domains within the calyceal synaptic cleft. Analogous roles are proposed for agrin and laminin at the neuromuscular junction and for reelins and integrins at forming synapses (
Dityatev and Schachner, 2003;
Ullian and Dityatev, 2006).
The between-zone differences we report in ion channel expression in Domain 1 may play a role in differentiating afferent firing patterns between epithelial zones (
Smith and Goldberg, 1986;
Baird et al., 1988;
Goldberg et al., 1990a;
Kalluri et al., 2010). Recent work has specifically proposed that low-voltage-activated channels (Kv1 and KCNQ) help make the firing of central afferents irregular (
Iwasaki et al., 2008;
Kalluri et al., 2010). KCNQ4 immunolabeling correlates with irregular spike timing: it is more extensive and intense in the central-zone calyces of irregular afferents than in the peripheral-zone calyces of regular afferents. Furthermore, M-current through KCNQ channels in calyces might be modulated by G-protein coupled receptors activated by acetylcholine, ATP, CGRP, opioid peptides or GABA released from efferent terminals onto calyx outer faces. In that case, the greater expression of KCNQ4 in central calyces could contribute to the greater effect of efferent activation on irregular afferents (
Holt et al., 2011).
KCNQ4 is present at high density on the calyx inner face (Domain 1) and much lower density on the outer face (Domain 3; see and (
Lysakowski and Price, 2003). In heterologous expression systems, KCNQ4 can form homomeric channels (
Søgaard et al., 2001;
Xu et al., 2007) and can heteromultimerize with KCNQ2, KCNQ3 and KCNQ5 (
Howard et al., 2007;
Xu et al., 2007;
Bal et al., 2008). Our results suggest that KCNQ4 could partner with KCNQ2 in Domain 1 of any calyx (). In peripheral dimorph calyces, KCNQ4 could also partner with KCNQ5 on the inner face (Domain 1, ) and KCNQ3 on the outer face (Domain 3, ).
Immunoreactivity for erg subunits was much stronger in calyces of dimorphic afferents than in calyces of calyx-only afferents. This difference explains the reduced erg staining previously noted in central zones in immature epithelia (
Hurley et al., 2006). Again, such zonal differences in M-like channel expression have the potential to shape afferent discharge regularity and/or efferent responses.
Na
V1.5, localized to Domain 1, includes an amino acid sequence that shifts activation and inactivation voltage ranges negative relative to tetrodotoxin-sensitive Na
V isoforms (
Camacho et al., 2006). In this way, the voltage range of Na
V channel activation in calyces may be matched with that of nearby KCNQ and erg channels (
Hurley et al., 2006). Either Na
V1.5 or Na
V1.6 could contribute to a persistent Na
V current (
Holt et al., 2007;
Wooltorton et al., 2007), which could shape spike timing. In the rat utricular macula, Na
V1.5 immunoreactivity is strongest in the striola, at least up to P21 (
Wooltorton et al., 2007), thus Na
V1.5 is also a candidate to contribute to zonal differences in discharge regularity.
Domain 2, the apical calyx membrane, is defined both by what is expressed and what is not expressed. Antibodies against βIV spectrin, Caspr2, erg1, and erg2 labeled Domain 2 more than other zones. Antibodies that labeled Domain 3 and not Domain 2 include those against Na
V channels, dystrophins, KCNQ3, and ankyrinB. Since βIV spectrin associates with Na
V channels at nodes, and Caspr2 associates with K
V channels at juxtaparanodes (
Arroyo and Scherer, 2000), Domain 2 may express yet-to-be-identified voltage-gated channels.
Domain 2 has been proposed as a possible source of retrograde feedback from calyces to hair cells, based on immunolocalization of such pre-synaptic proteins as rab3A (
Dechesne et al., 1997), synaptophysin (
Scarfone et al., 1988;
Dechesne et al., 1997), synapsin I (
Scarfone et al., 1988), syntaxin, SNAP25 and synaptotagmin (Dememes et al., 2000). Calyces might release neuropeptides (
Scarfone et al., 1996) or glutamate (
Devau et al., 1993) onto the type I hair cell. Detailed ultrastructural studies in rodents have revealed no post-synaptic densities in hair cell membranes adjacent to Domain 2, but clusters of dense-cored vesicles are seen in Domain 2 in squirrel monkey calyces (A. Lysakowski, personal observations). Dense-cored vesicles are consistent with the neuropeptide hypothesis, and because they release their contents away from active zones (
Lysakowski et al., 1999;
Shakiryanova et al., 2005), post-synaptic densities are unnecessary.
Domain 2 appears to be lacking in most calyx-only afferents (, , ), another zonal difference that could influence afferent physiology. In particular, retrograde feedback from the calyx to the hair cell might be missing at calyx-only synapses, which are principally found in central and striolar zones.
In
Domain 3, we identified many proteins characteristic of axonal initial segments but there are also some differences. To our knowledge, the combination of ion channels does not match any of those described in central neurons, although some diversity of expression has been reported for axonal initial segments (
Lorincz and Nusser, 2008). For example, olfactory mitral cells express K
V1.2, layer 5 pyramidal cells also express K
V1.1, and Purkinje cells express neither (
Lorincz and Nusser, 2008). Domain 3 of the vestibular calyx resembles the axonal initial segment in that it expresses a gradient of ion channels and scaffolding proteins. In addition to ion channels, Domain 3 contains ankyrinB, which anchors Na
+-K
+ ATPases and Na
+-Ca
2+ exchangers in heart (
Mohler et al., 2005) and retina (
Kizhatil et al., 2009). Na
+-Ca
2+ exchangers and the α3β1 isoform of Na
+-K
+ ATPase have been reported within the vestibular sensory epithelium (
ten Cate et al., 1994;
Boyer et al., 1999), but resolution was not sufficient to localize either to pre- or post-synaptic membranes. Unlike some axonal initial segments, Domain 3 does not express βIV spectrin and neurofascin 186.
Finally,
Domain 4 contains many known nodal proteins (
Peles and Salzer, 2000;
Salzer, 2003;
Dityatev and Schachner, 2006;
Ullian and Dityatev, 2006), and resembles in its organization one-half of a full node (,
inset). Many vestibular heminodes were recognized by the juxtaposition of Na
V1.6, the most common nodal Na
V channel, with the paranodal protein Caspr1 and the internodal protein myelin basic protein (MBP). Scaffolding proteins at nodes of Ranvier (βIV spectrin and neurofascin 186) also label vestibular afferent heminodes intensely (). The expression of K
V7 subunits (KCNQ3, but not KCNQ2, at dimorphic heminodes, and KCNQ4 at calyx-only heminodes) differs from the combination of KCNQ2 and KCNQ3 expression reported at other axonal nodes (
Pan et al., 2006;
Bennett and Healy, 2009).
The spike trigger zone in eighth nerve afferents has been a subject of speculation (
Goldberg, 1996;
Hossain et al., 2005). The presence of many known nodal proteins in Domain 4 suggests that the heminode immediately below calyces may be a spike trigger zone, but does not rule out a more distant locus (
Palmer and Stuart, 2006;
Bean, 2007). Furthermore, the location of spike initiation may vary with zone, given that peripheral dimorphic afferents have more extensive arbors with longer unmyelinated portions ().
In summary, the calyx terminal combines unique features of dendrites and initial segments in a highly ordered, novel arrangement. The large size of the ending has allowed us to define several regions, or microdomains, each characterized by a distinct set of ion channels, neurotransmitter receptors, and accessory proteins. None of the antibodies we used produced detectable labeling of bouton terminals on type II cells. The much smaller surface areas of bouton endings (5–10 µm2) compared to calyx endings (~1000 µm2) may be less able to accommodate microdomains.