Using different genetically modified mouse models, we investigated whether β-catenin pathway activation, one of the most frequent events found in human HCC, induces a specific inflammatory microenvironment that could be involved in the oncogenic process. Our main finding is that β-catenin triggered a smoldering inflammation through the control of both pro- and antiinflammatory programs that was permissive for tumor development. The essence of the immune response determines tumor progression and metastatic capabilities.
We found that β-catenin induces a specific inflammatory program. Strikingly, the classical liver inflammatory cytokines described in a number of HCC-linked liver inflammation models, such as IL-6, TNF-α, IL-1α, and IL-1β (for review, see refs.
3,
4), were absent from the chemokine/cytokine profile induced by β-catenin activation in hepatocytes. The inflammatory program controlled by β-catenin and the singular inflammatory response that we described in this study constitute specific hallmarks of the inflammatory fuel induced by β-catenin in the liver. Our Chip-Seq data obtained from isolated hepatocytes revealed that several chemokine, cytokine, and cytokine receptor genes (e.g.,
Lect2,
Cxcl2,
Cxcl10,
Cxcl11,
Il1, and
Il1r1) are cell-autonomous direct targets of β-catenin activation through the LEF/TCF motifs present in their promoters. Furthermore, we also observed a strong constitutive activation of NF-κB in the livers of
Apc–/– mutant mice as well as in β-catenin–activated tumors. The increased expression of the chemokine/cytokine genes
Ccl2,
Ccl5, and
Il15, all of which are bona fide NF-κB targets, probably results from this NF-κB activation. Thus, the proinflammatory chemokine/cytokine program arose from a combination of direct control by Wnt/β-catenin signaling and indirect control through NF-κB activation. The NF-κB activation likely resulted as a consequence of the cytokines produced by the immune cells and from β-catenin–induced increases in the expression levels of partners in the NF-κB pathway (such as
Il1r1 and
Il15). As observed in other models of cancer-related inflammation (
3), a feed-forward loop between the β-catenin–activated hepatocytes and the immune/inflammatory cells is likely to exist, and this could sustain tumor-associated inflammation (see Figure ).
The induction of an intrinsic proinflammatory transcriptional program has been described for several other oncogenes, such as Ras and Myc family members, and constitutes a part of their oncogenic properties (
3). What we believe is new in our findings is that we clearly demonstrate that β-catenin signaling is able to induce simultaneously a pro- and an antiinflammatory program that shapes a protumorigenic microenvironment with a low grade of chronic inflammation. We identified at least 2 interconnected mediators that could explain how β-catenin could induce a smoldering inflammation: a molecular mediator, LECT2, which is a chemokine-like protein that regulates the function of the cellular mediator, and the iNKT cells. Indeed, deletion of LECT2 resulted in a dramatic aggravation of the inflammatory response observed in the liver of
Apc–/– mutant mice. The antiinflammatory functions of LECT2 have been reported to play a suppressive role in anti–type II collagen antibody–induced arthritis (
30). The precise mechanism by which LECT2 exerts an antiinflammatory action in the liver is presently unknown, but our results provide some clues. Analysis of
LECT2-deficient animals demonstrated that LECT2 regulates iNKT cell homeostasis in the liver through at least 2 nonexclusive mechanisms: (a) the control of iNKT homing activity toward the liver and (b) the control of the iNKT Th1/Th2 cytokine secretion profile (
27). Our data strongly support the notion that LECT2 controls the homing of the iNKT in β-catenin–activated livers. As expected (
27), the number of iNKT cells in these livers increased in
LECT2-deficient mice, suggesting that LECT2 prevents iNKT homing toward the liver. In addition, iNKT cells were not recruited to the livers of
Apc–/– mutant mice, which retain the ability to produce high levels of LECT2 induced by β-catenin. In contrast, most other immune cell populations were actively recruited to this β-catenin–induced liver microenvironment. These observations support the view that LECT2 prevents the homing of the iNKTs toward the liver. In addition, the numbers of iNKT cells in
Apc–/–LECT2–/– livers and in the livers of
LECT2–/– mice were the same, showing the key role of LECT2 in iNKT cell homing. Corroborating the present data, we recently found that the number of iNKT cells in the livers of mice that harbored a hepatospecific deletion of β-catenin and lacked LECT2 expression increased following tamoxifen treatment, revealing that these mice have an immune phenotype similar to that of
LECT2-deficient mice (J.P. Couty and S. Colnot, unpublished observations). Furthermore, we found that iNKTs were more highly activated in
Apc–/–LECT2–/– mice than in
Apc–/– mice, but exhibited an altered cytokine secretion profile. This was more pronounced in the CD4
– iNKT subpopulation, which had shifted toward a Th2 phenotype. The CD4
– iNKT subpopulation has been reported to display potent antitumoral activities through its production of high levels of IFN-γ. Thus, the shift in its cytokine secretion profile to lower levels of IFN-γ is consistent with the higher grade of malignancy observed in Lpk-myc
+LECT2–/– mice compared with that found in Lpk-myc
+ mice.
Depletion of iNKT cells by anti-NK1.1 antibodies markedly aggravated the inflammatory response observed in the livers of
Apc–/– mutant mice in a manner similar to that produced by
Apc–/– mice lacking the
LECT2 gene. iNKTs are a specific population of immune T cells that are particularly enriched in the liver (
31). There is compelling evidence that iNKT cells have an important role in tumor immunosurveillance in mice (
32). The CD4
– iNKT cell subset appears to be responsible for the main antitumoral response through its production of IFN-γ. The cytokine profile of CD4
– NKTs in humans indicates that they might have a similar role (
22,
33,
34). iNKT cells from patients with cancer have been shown to produce less IFN-γ than iNKT cells from healthy individuals (
35,
36). Our results correlated with these observations, since genetic deletion of the iNKT cells in Lpk-myc
+Jα
18–/– mice led to a stronger progression of β-catenin–activated tumors. Our results provide some clues to explain how iNKTs exert their antitumoral properties. By dampening the inflammatory response (adequate immune response) and by controlling the composition of the inflammatory milieu through immunosuppressive effectors, iNKTs might prevent the tumor microenvironment from becoming permissive to the metastatic process. We found that the number of a subpopulation of immature inflammatory macrophages expressing F4/80
+ CD11b
+ Gr1
+ was higher in iNKT-depleted
Apc–/– livers compared with the livers of
Apc–/– mice treated with control antibodies. These inflammatory macrophages were recently identified in inflammation-induced colorectal tumorigenesis and were reported to be a major source of tumor-promoting factors (
37).
Another important implication of our results is that β-catenin signaling appears to determine the metastatic spread of β-catenin–mutated HCCs by controlling the level of inflammation. Genetic deletion of either LECT2 or the iNKT cells in Lpk-myc
+ mice caused β-catenin–induced HCCs to progress into high-grade tumors, and in almost half of mice, these produced lung metastases. As both LECT2 and the iNKT cells displayed antiinflammatory properties, these results highlight the critical role of the magnitude of the inflammatory response as a driving force in cancer metastasis. The mechanisms involved need further investigation, but 2 of the chemokines that were upregulated in
LECT2-deficient mice, CXCL1 and CXC12, have already been implicated in metastasis (
38,
39).
Finally, our data are sharply relevant to human HCC pathogenesis. Constitutive activations of NF-κB and STAT3 have been described in human HCCs (
40). Although the β-catenin genetic status of these tumors was not determined, these authors found an inverse relationship between NF-κB and STAT3 and also found that the majority of STAT3-positive HCCs were negative for NF-κB activation. NF-κB–positive tumors were also found to be less aggressive than the STAT3-positive tumors (
40). Our data showing that β-catenin–activated tumors, as well as those in the livers of tamoxifen-treated
Apc–/–mice, displayed NF-κB pathway activation, but not STAT3 pathway activation, are in perfect correlation with the human study (
40). In addition, constitutive activation of the STAT3 pathway leads to the development of benign adenomas that progress to HCC only when it is combined with β-catenin–activating mutations (
41). This observation reinforces our results that oncogenic β-catenin activation did not result in constitutive STAT3 activation, and may explain why β-catenin gain-of-function mutations are required for the progression of STAT3-activated liver adenoma to HCC. Finally, since the immune response in the presence of LECT2 retained antitumor activity, our results suggest that the particular inflammatory program induced by β-catenin that results in low-level inflammation may be part of the reason why β-catenin–activated human HCCs belong to a subclass of HCCs with rather better prognoses than other HCCs (see Figure ). A second point is that, in a previous study, we found that LECT2 expression levels in β-catenin–activated human HCCs inversely correlated with the differentiation status of the tumor (
23). Consistent with our present data, LECT2 transcripts were found to be downregulated in HCC patients with vascular invasion, again suggesting that LECT2 has tumor suppressor functions (
26). The reasons that LECT2 is downregulated in human HCCs is still unknown, but the results of a recent study indicate that it could be linked to an epigenetic mechanism (
42). In their investigation of the role of a methyl-binding domain protein (Mbd2) in Wnt signaling, the authors found that the
Lect2 gene was the only β-catenin target gene that was upregulated in an Mbd2 deficiency context. All other β-catenin target genes whose expression was modified in Mbd2 deficiency were downregulated (
42).
Our data identified inflammation as a new player of β-catenin–induced liver tumorigenesis and showed that oncogenic β-catenin signaling constructed a permissive inflammatory environment that had an impact on HCC development. LECT2 and iNKT cells are potentially new targets in immunotherapeutic approaches to the treatment of liver cancer.