|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
Conceived and designed the experiments: CO TD RB LF. Performed the experiments: YA KCK MM LF CO CA MZ. Analyzed the data: CO LF TD RB RI MZ YA. Wrote the paper: CO LF TD.
Loss of the conserved “cryptic” plasmid from C. trachomatis and C. muridarum is pleiotropic, resulting in reduced innate inflammatory activation via TLR2, glycogen accumulation and infectivity. The more genetically distant C. caviae GPIC is a natural pathogen of guinea pigs and induces upper genital tract pathology when inoculated intravaginally, modeling human disease. To examine the contribution of pCpGP1 to C. caviae pathogenesis, a cured derivative of GPIC, strain CC13, was derived and evaluated in vitro and in vivo. Transcriptional profiling of CC13 revealed only partial conservation of previously identified plasmid-responsive chromosomal loci (PRCL) in C. caviae. However, 2-deoxyglucose (2DG) treatment of GPIC and CC13 resulted in reduced transcription of all identified PRCL, including glgA, indicating the presence of a plasmid-independent glucose response in this species. In contrast to plasmid-cured C. muridarum and C. trachomatis, plasmid-cured C. caviae strain CC13 signaled via TLR2 in vitro and elicited cytokine production in vivo similar to wild-type C. caviae. Furthermore, inflammatory pathology induced by infection of guinea pigs with CC13 was similar to that induced by GPIC, although we observed more rapid resolution of CC13 infection in estrogen-treated guinea pigs. These data indicate that either the plasmid is not involved in expression or regulation of virulence in C. caviae or that redundant effectors prevent these phenotypic changes from being observed in C. caviae plasmid-cured strains.
Chlamydiaceae are gram-negative obligate intracellular pathogens that infect ocular, genital and respiratory tissues in both humans and animals. The genomes of chlamydial species are highly conserved, which likely reflects the specific requirements of intracellular pathogens for survival and the limited opportunity for genetic exchange with other bacterial pathogens within this intracellular niche (reviewed by Stephens et al. ). This high degree of genetic-relatedness extends to carriage of a 7.5 kb “cryptic” plasmid by Chlamydia trachomatis (human), C. muridarum (mice), C. psittaci (birds), C. felis (cats), strains of C. pneumoniae that do not infect humans and C. caviae (guinea pigs). Plasmid-deficient C. trachomatis isolates are extremely rare, leading to speculation on the importance of the plasmid for chlamydial pathogenesis .
We developed a protocol for the derivation of plasmid-deficient chlamydiae and demonstrated its efficacy using C. muridarum . The plasmid-cured derivative of C. muridarum Nigg, strain CM972, displays distinctive phenotypic changes in vitro and in vivo when compared with its parent. CM972 is less infectious in vitro  and this is associated with significantly reduced chlamydial load in the oviducts of intravaginally inoculated mice , . In addition, CM972 lacks the ability to accumulate glycogen within the inclusion, a property shared by naturally occurring plasmid-deficient isolates , . CM972 also did not cause oviduct pathology or signal via Toll-like receptor 2 (TLR2) , which is important for the development of oviduct pathology in this model . Importantly, primary infection with CM972 prevented the development of pathology upon secondary challenge with wild-type Nigg. Recently, we demonstrated that these phenotypic changes are conserved in plasmid-cured C. trachomatis and identified a number of PRCL that, in addition to plasmid-encoded gene products, are candidate effectors of these virulence properties .
C. caviae is a natural pathogen of guinea pigs that causes inclusion conjunctivitis and respiratory infection in newborns. The guinea pig has been used to model sexual transmission of chlamydial infection from males to females  and to study genital tract infection and disease pathology in females , , . Nevertheless, C. caviae is more distant genetically from C. trachomatis and C. muridarum and differs phenotypically from them in several respects including intrinsic resistance to sulphonamides , non-fusing inclusions  and an inability to accumulate glycogen . We sought to examine the role of the conserved cryptic plasmid more broadly within the Chlamydiacae by examining the in vitro and in vivo consequences of curing the plasmid from C. caviae. We hypothesized that plasmid-deficient C. caviae would not activate TLR2 and would fail to cause oviduct disease in the guinea pig model. However, in contrast to plasmid-cured C. muridarum and C. trachomatis, plasmid-cured C. caviae strain CC13 signaled via TLR2 in vitro and elicited cytokine production in vivo similar to wild-type C. caviae. Furthermore, pathology induced by guinea pig genital tract infection with this strain was not reduced although we observed more rapid resolution of infection with CC13 in estrogen-treated guinea pigs. These data indicate that the association of the chlamydial plasmid with virulence is not universally conserved among chlamydial species.
Female 20-week-old outbred Hartley strain (Hilltop Labs, Scottdale, PA) guinea pigs were used for experiments. Guinea pigs were given food and water ad libitum in an environmentally controlled room with a cycle of 12 h of light and 12 h of darkness. All animals were determined to be seronegative for anti- C. caviae antibodies prior to infection. All animal experiments were pre-approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee of the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center under protocol # 0807981.
C. caviae, guinea pig inclusion conjunctivitis (GPIC) strain, was provided by Dr. Roger Rank and plaque-purified before use. Chlamydiae were cultured in L929 fibroblasts. Cells were infected at an approximate MOI of 0.5–1 before being centrifuged for 1 hour at 37°C. The cell culture medium was then removed and replaced with 1 X Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium (DMEM) supplemented with 10% heat-inactivated FBS, gentamicin (20 µg ml−1) and 0.1 µg ml−1 cycloheximide. Infected cells were harvested into sucrose phosphate glutamate buffer at 40 hours post infection, sonicated, and maintained at −80°C. Bacteria were subsequently titrated by either the plaque assay  or as inclusion forming units (IFU)  using a genus-specific fluorescently tagged anti-chlamydial LPS monoclonal antibody (Biorad, Hercules, CA). Evaluation of plaquing efficiency under different culture conditions (e.g. with or without centrifugation) was achieved by the titration of individual strains by plaque-forming assay, with indicated modifications, in parallel with titration to estimate IFU. The efficiency of plaquing (EOP) was calculated as PFU ml−1 /IFU ml−1.
Total RNA was isolated from chlamydia-infected L929 cells 24 hours post-infection (MOI~1) using an RNeasy RNA isolation kit (Qiagen, Valencia, CA). For quantitative PCR analysis, the RNA (2 µg) was pretreated with DNase I (Ambion) and cDNA prepared using an iScript cDNA synthesis kit (BioRad, Hercules, CA) according to the manufacturer's instructions. Primer pairs for amplification of 16S rRNA and the genes identified in this study (Table 1) were selected using Beacon Designer 2.13 (Premier Biosoft International, Palo Alto, CA). Primers were purchased from Integrated DNA Technology (Coralville, IA). Real time PCR reactions were carried out using iQ Sybergreen supermix (BioRad) in a BioRad iCycler using a two step reaction, 95°C for 10 seconds, 55°C for 1 minute for a total of 40 cycles. Melt curve analysis showed that the accumulation of SYBR green-bound DNA was gene specific and not caused by formation of primer dimers. Transcripts from the 16S rRNA gene of C. caviae served as an endogenous reference and data were analyzed by the 2−ΔΔCT method  using BioRad proprietary software. Each sample was assayed in triplicate and each experiment was performed at least twice. Statistical significance was determined by using Student's t test. A p value of <0.05 was considered significant.
The following cell lines were examined: HEK293 cells stably expressing either TLR2 or TLR4/MD2 . X-ray-irradiated preparations of chlamydiae were also assayed using HEK-TLR2 cells transfected with an NF- κB reporter plasmid as previously described . In addition, in vitro infection was performed in murine bone marrow-derived dendritic cells (BMDDCs) cultured following the procedure of Inaba et al. . The TLR2 agonist, Pam3Cys-Ser-(Lys)4 (Axxora, San Diego, CA), the TLR4 agonist LPS (Sigma, St. Louis, MO), and human rTNF-α (R&D Systems, Minneapolis, MN) were used as positive control stimulants. Cells were plated in 24-well tissue culture dishes at a density of ~105 cells/well. Infections were conducted by overlaying cells with a multiplicity of infection of 1 or 3. Cells were incubated for 24 hrs at 37°C, 5% CO2. Supernatants from the HEK cells were harvested and assayed for IL-8 (DuoSet, R&D Systems). The BMDDC supernatants were assayed for IL-1α, IL-1β, IL-2, IL-4, IL-5, IL-6, IL-9, IL-10, IL-12p70, IL-13, IL-17, G-CSF, GM-CSF, KC, MIP-1α, TNFα, IFNγ, and MCP-1 via Multiplex bead assay (Millipore Billerica, MA). IL-2, IL-4, IL-5, IFNγ, IL-9, IL-12p70, IL-13, MCP-1 and IL-17 were not detected above media (data not shown). BMDDC data points represent the mean levels of two independent experiments ± SD.
Guinea pigs were inoculated intravaginally with 106 IFU of either GPIC or CC13 suspended in 30 µl SPG intravaginally. Estradiol administration has been demonstrated to potentiate infection and pathology in the guinea pig model  so selected experimental groups were dosed with 1 mg sesame oil-emulsified β-estradiol-3-benzoate (10 mg/ml) (Sigma) daily where indicated, beginning 7 days before infection and continuing until sacrifice. Three separate experiments were conducted with groups of estrogen-treated animals sacrificed on days 9 or 30 and groups of untreated animals sacrificed on day 30. The kinetics of lower genital tract infection was monitored via culture of cervical swabs on L929 cells.
Guinea pig genital tract secretions were collected via vaginal sponges as described previously . Sponges were stored at −70°C until they were eluted individually in 0.5 ml of Eagle minimal essential medium and assayed via ELISA for IL-8 (Human IL-8 DuoSet, R&D Systems).
IgG1, and IgG2a, and IgA antibody to C. caviae in serum was measured by an ELISA as described previously  using gradient purified GPIC elementary bodies as antigen and goat, anti-guinea pig-Ig antibodies obtained from AbdSerotech (Oxford, UK).
Guinea pigs were sacrificed at day 9 or day 30 post infection, and the entire genital tract was removed en bloc, fixed in 10% buffered formalin, and embedded in paraffin. Longitudinal sections (4 µm) were stained with hematoxylin and eosin and evaluated by a pathologist blinded to the experimental design. Each anatomic site (exocervix, endocervix, uterine horn, and oviduct) was independently assessed for the presence of acute inflammation (neutrophils), chronic inflammation (lymphocytes/monocytes), plasma cells, and erosion of the mucosa. Right and left uterine horns and right and left oviducts were evaluated individually. A four-tiered semiquantitative scoring system was used to quantify the inflammation as previously described . Oviduct dilatation scores also include a subjective assessment of flattening of the oviduct epithelial plicae and destruction of the oviduct mucosa.
Statistical comparisons between GPIC and CC13-infected guinea pigs for levels of infection and cytokine production over the course of infection were made using a two-factor (days and strain) RM ANOVA. A post-hoc Tukey test was used as a multiple comparison procedure. Kaplan-Meier survival analysis was used to compare the durations of infection over time. The Fisher-exact test was used for determination of significant differences in frequency of pathological characteristics between groups. One-way ANOVA on ranks was used to determine significant differences in the pathological data between groups. Statistical tests were performed using SigmaStat software with p<0.05 considered significant.
L929 cells infected with C. caviae GPIC were treated with novobiocin (62.5 µg/ml) and plated in a plaque assay as previously described for curing of the plasmid from C. muridarum . Individual plaques were selected at random and each isolate was plaque-purified twice more in order to obtain clones. A total of 28 clones were screened by PCR using primers directed against pgp1, a gene encoded by the resident plasmid. Three plasmid-deficient clones were identified and one was selected for further analysis and designated strain CC13. Amplification and sequencing of a portion of the 16S rRNA gene from CC13 (Fig. 1A, Table 1) confirmed its genetic lineage, and Southern hybridization using a 1.58 Kb probe that spans the open reading frames encoding pGP4-6 of pCpGP1 confirmed the absence of the plasmid from this strain (Fig. 1B). PCR amplicons representing each of the plasmid-encoded open reading frames were detected in C. caviae GPIC only (Fig. S1).
C. caviae GPIC plaques were visible after 4–5 days incubation, and unlike plasmid-cured C. muridarum CM972  or C. trachomatis CTD153 , no reduction in plaque size was observed for CC13 (Fig. 1 C). Furthermore, plaquing efficiency (EOP) in the absence of centrifugation was similar for GPIC (EOP=2.77x10−2±1.94x10−2) and CC13 (EOP=2.59x10−2±2.45x10−2), which contrasted with the reduced efficiency we previously observed for plasmid-cured C. muridarum  and C. trachomatis .
Comparison of the transcriptional profiles of plasmid-cured strains of C. muridarum and C. trachomatis revealed a conserved group of plasmid-responsive chromosomal loci (PRCL) whose transcription was altered in the absence of the plasmid . To determine if similar transcriptional changes have occurred in the plasmid cured CC13 we first confirmed that the absence of the plasmid does not impact the growth rate of CC13 when compared to GPIC (Fig. 2A). Furthermore, RT-PCR confirmed that transcripts of all plasmid-encoded ORFs could be detected by 24 hours after infection (Fig. 2B). Interestingly, both strains resembled C. muridarum Nigg  in developmental profile because new GPIC and CC13 EBs were detected in tissue culture by 16 hours post infection. Real time RT-PCR analysis of PRCL homologs expressed by C. caviae revealed significantly decreased transcription of several, but not all, of these genes at 24 hours post infection, including the putative operon encoding CCA00523-525 and CCA00259 (Fig. 2C). Transcription of CCA00416 and CCA00417, that encode orthologs of Pls1 and Pls2  respectively appeared only mildly reduced 24 hours after infection (Fig. 2C). In contrast, transcription of CCA00453, encoding a phospholipase D enzyme  and CCA00924 was not significantly altered in CC13 (Fig. 2C) although all four of these genes were plasmid-responsive in C. muridarum and C. trachomatis . Transcription of glgA, the gene encoding glycogen synthase, is plasmid-dependent in C. trachomatis  but not in C. muridarum . Transcription of glgA by CC13 was mildly increased whether detected by microarray (data not shown) or by quantitative PCR (Fig. 2C). A microarray screen comparing the transcriptional profile of GPIC with CC13, 30 hours after infection confirmed these findings (Fig. S2) and failed to detect additional plasmid-responsive loci with orthologs in C. trachomatis and C. muridarum.
Transcription of C. trachomatis PRCL was coordinately reduced in response to glucose limitation . We examined the impact of 2DG treatment on the development of GPIC inclusions. L929 cells infected with GPIC were cultured with medium containing the glucose-6-phosphate inhibitor 2-deoxyglucose (2DG). Inclusions formed by GPIC in the presence of 10mM 2DG appeared smaller, with fewer EBs (Fig. 3B) when compared with those formed in untreated cells (Fig 3A). Occasionally inclusions containing larger aberrant forms were observed (Fig. 3C) that were not noted in the untreated cells. Overall, the number of inclusions was reduced and the infectious yield dropped ~100 fold after treatment (data not shown). Treatment of GPIC-infected cells with 2DG also resulted in significantly reduced transcription of glgA (~6 fold reduction) and other PRCL homologs (4.5–34.4 fold reduction) (Fig. 3D). Transcription of CCA00416, CCA00417, CCA00453 and CCA00924 was also significantly reduced in CC13 in response to treatment with 2DG (Fig. 3E) indicating that glucose-responsiveness by C. caviae was not dependent on the presence of the plasmid. These observations suggested a reduced role for pCpGP1 in regulation of chromosomal loci in C. caviae and indicated that plasmid-deficient C. caviae may not express phenotypes described for plasmid-deficient C. muridarum and C. trachomatis.
Plasmid-deficient C. muridarum and C. trachomatis do not signal via TLR2, and induce production of significantly lower levels of proinflammatory cytokines than wild-type strains . We infected HEK 293 cells stably expressing TLR2 (HEK-TLR2) or TLR4/MD2 (HEK-TLR4) with C. caviae GPIC or CC13. HEK 293 cells endogenously express TLR1, TLR6 and MyD88, but not TLR2 or TLR4 , thus, specific signaling can be determined by measuring cytokine production in cells stably transfected with TLR2  because TLR-ligand interactions are highly conserved in nature . Analysis of supernatants after 24 hours incubation revealed similar levels of IL-8 production by HEK-TLR2 cells in response to infection with GPIC or CC13 (Fig. 4A). IL-8 production above media was not detected in the supernatant of HEK-TLR4 cells infected with either strain, consistent with the weak immunostimulatory capabilities of chlamydial LPS . These data indicate that despite absence of the plasmid, CC13 was able to induce TLR2-dependent cytokine production at levels equivalent to GPIC. Interestingly, while we observed no difference between TLR2 activation by CC13 or GPIC when we assayed X-ray inactivated preparations of the bacteria using HEK-TLR2 cells transfected with an NF- κB reporter plasmid (Fig. 4B), we noted that the amount of C. caviae required to activate TLR2 in these cells was considerably lower (~100 fold reduced) when compared with C. muridarum Nigg or its plasmid-cured derivative CM3.1, suggesting that the TLR2 ligands of this chlamydial species is extremely potent.
C. muridarum plasmid-deficient strains induce significantly less cytokine production by dendritic cells in vitro than their wild-type parent . We incubated murine bone marrow derived dendritic cells (BMDDCs) with CC13, GPIC, C. muridarum Nigg or CM3.1 to determine if dendritic cell cytokine release was altered by the loss of the plasmid from C. caviae and to compare cytokine release during infection with C. caviae or C. muridarum. After 24 hours, BMDDCs stimulated with GPIC and CC13 secreted IL-1α, IL-1β, IL-6, IL-10, G-CSF, TNF-α, GM-CSF, MIP-1α, and KC. Strikingly, IL-6 (Fig. 4C), IL-1β (Fig. 4D), IL-1α, IL-10, MIP-1α, and KC (data not shown) were secreted at significantly higher levels in response to infection with C. caviae compared to C. muridarum, whereas G-CSF (data not shown), GM-CSF (data not shown), and TNF-α (Fig. 4E) levels were similar between the strains. In all instances, we observed no difference in cytokine response to infection with CC13 compared with GPIC. These data indicate that CC13 stimulated dendritic cell cytokine production to levels equivalent to GPIC and contrasted with C. muridarum where wild-type Nigg induced significantly greater cytokine release than plasmid-deficient CM3.1.
In order to determine the possible impact of plasmid-deficiency on the virulence of C. caviae in the genital tract infection model, groups of guinea pigs (N=5) were inoculated intravaginally with either GPIC or CC13 and sacrificed on day 30. The course and intensity of infection was monitored via endocervical swabs. No difference in the magnitude or duration of infection was noted between the strains (Fig. 5A). In addition, IL-8 levels measured in genital secretions obtained during the first 10 days of infection were similar in the two groups (Fig. 5B). Histologic examination of oviduct tissue recovered from these guinea pigs failed to detect any pathology regardless of infecting strain.
Treatment with estrogen maintains the reproductive tract epithelium and results in dramatically increased bacterial burden , which might facilitate detection of subtle differences in the course of infection and outcome with respect to upper reproductive tract pathology between CC13 and its plasmid-containing parent GPIC. Groups of estradiol-treated female guinea pigs (N=5) were intravaginally inoculated with GPIC or CC13 and sacrificed on day 9 or day 30 post-infection. Culture of endocervical swabs again revealed no significant difference (two-way RM ANOVA, p=0.898) in shedding of chlamydiae from the lower genital tract between GPIC and CC13 infected animals (Fig. 5C). However, GPIC infection was prolonged compared to CC13 (Kaplan-Meier, p=0.02), with infection resolving by day 22 for CC13 and day 30 for GPIC (Fig. 5C). Swabs obtained from the upper uterine horns of guinea pigs sacrificed on day 9 were titrated via plaque assay and the bacterial burden did not differ significantly (p=0.052, Student's t-test) between the strains (GPIC: 9.8×104±4.1×104; CC13: 4.3×103±2.1×103 PFU/ml). Thus, in estradiol-treated animals, the duration of genital tract infection was shortened and upper genital tract bacterial burden was slightly decreased during infection with CC13.
However, we were unable to detect differences in the cytokine response to infection between estradiol-treated guinea pigs infected with GPIC or CC13. Genital tract secretions collected from CC13 and GPIC infected animals through day 10 contained similar levels of IL-8 (Fig. 5D). Examination of the antibody response to infection in the estradiol-treated animals was performed using serum collected at the time of sacrifice on day 30. Analysis of antibody titers revealed no difference in the mean ± SD log10 titers of IgG1 (GPIC, 3.94±0.38 vs. CC13, 3.51±0.35), IgG2a (GPIC, 3.89±0.34 vs. CC13 3.59±0.46) or IgA (GPIC, 2.81±0.3 vs. CC13, 2.81±0.42) between the strains. These data indicate that despite the mildly prolonged infection observed during infection with GPIC, the humoral immune response did not significantly differ from that of animals infected with CC13.
Genital tract tissues harvested from estradiol-treated guinea pigs infected with GPIC or CC13 were analyzed histologically. The groups sacrificed on day 9 post-infection were graded for cellular infiltrates because infection was still present. The groups sacrificed on day 30 were analyzed for cellular infiltrates and for pathology remaining after clearance of infection. On day 9, the levels of inflammation in the exocervix (data not shown), endocervix (data not shown), uterine horns (Fig. 6A), and oviducts (Fig.6B-F) did not differ between the strains. On day 30, histologic examination did not reveal any difference in the degree of inflammation in the exocervix (Fig. 7A), endocervix (Fig. 7B), uterine horns (Fig. 7C) or oviducts (Fig. 7D; Fig. 8 A–F) during infection with GPIC or CC13. In addition, there was no difference in the percentage of animals with oviduct dilatation (Fig. 8A) or degree of dilatation between the groups (Fig. 8B–F).
The overall degree of oviduct dilatation and oviduct epithelial cell damage resulting from genital tract infection was low. In contrast, we observed severe abdominal pathology in 3 of 5 GPIC-infected and 1 of 5 CC13-infected animals that were treated with estradiol, with fibrous adhesions noted between the genital tract and peritoneum, bowel, and bladder in these animals. These findings had been previously described in estrogen-treated, GPIC-infected guinea pigs by Rank et al  and are reminiscent of Fitz-Hugh-Curtis syndrome observed in a subset of Chlamydia-infected human females . This syndrome results from migration of the bacterium into the abdomen and leads to inflammation and fibrous adhesions in infected women.
Our studies ,  and others  have revealed an important role for the chlamydial plasmid in the expression of key virulence properties by both C. muridarum and C. trachomatis. However the role of the resident plasmid in other Chlamydiaceae has not been investigated. Strains of C. pneumoniae infecting humans generally lack the plasmid, but it is present in strains that infect a diverse range of other mammals including horses  and koalas . Recent studies of C. felis clinical isolates indicate that plasmid carriage is highly conserved  in this species suggesting that the plasmid may be important for virulence, and although the plasmid appears conserved in C. psittaci, plasmid-deficient strains have been described . In this study we investigated the role of the plasmid in C. caviae, a natural pathogen of the guinea pig, by curing GPIC of pCpGP1 to derive strain CC13 and by examining CC13′s ability to cause infection and genital tract disease.
Three plasmid-associated phenotypes have been identified in C. muridarum and are conserved in C. trachomatis: plasmid-deficient strains are unable to accumulate glycogen within the intracellular inclusion during the developmental cycle, display reduced infectivity in vitro , and in vivo  and do not stimulate TLR2 signaling during infection . Whether the effectors of these phenotypes are encoded directly by the plasmid is unknown, but we have identified a conserved group of plasmid-responsive loci encoded on the chromosome that may also contribute to the expression or regulation of these traits . Microarray screening using a custom GPIC array indicated that the transcriptional profile of CC13 very closely resembled that of its parent, but we nevertheless observed that several of the PRCL identified in plasmid-deficient C. muridarum and C. trachomatis were also differentially transcribed in CC13 including CCA00523-525 (orthologous to CT142-44 and TC_419-421), and CCA00259 (orthologous to CT382.1). However, other candidate PRCL such as the CT084 (TC_0357) ortholog CCA00453, and the CT702 (TC_075) ortholog CCA00924 did not differ transcriptionally from GPIC. Mild reduction in transcription of CCA00416-17 (orthologous to CT049-50 and [TC_319-320]) was detected that did not reach significance. Furthermore, transcription of glgA appeared slightly but significantly elevated (~2 fold) in C. caviae CC13. The significance of this observation is unclear because glycogen accumulation within wild-type C. caviae inclusions is not observed and glycogen production by this chlamydial species has not been detected  but indicates that glgA transcription is not plasmid-dependent in C. caviae, more closely resembling what we have previously observed for C. muridarum.
Phenotypic analysis of CC13 in vitro revealed that loss of pCpGP1 did not impact plaque size or plaquing efficiency. GPIC, in common with C. pneumoniae and C. psittaci, does not accumulate glycogen intrainclusionally , so no change in iodine-staining phenotype was anticipated and was not observed (data not shown). Most significantly, CC13 retained the ability to activate TLR2 expressed on stably transfected HEK293 epithelial cells, an observation that contrasted with the plasmid-cured strains CM972 and CTD153 that are unable to stimulate TLR2-dependent signaling in vitro and in vivo , . The overall conservation of chlamydial plasmid organization suggests that the plasmid may not encode a pathogenic TLR2 ligand directly and further, that the conservation of plasmid-responsiveness for CCA00523-25 and CCA00259 indicates that their expression is likely not required for TLR2 activation, reducing the likelihood that their orthologs encode candidate TLR2 ligands in C. trachomatis or C. muridarum. Alternatively, is also possible that GPIC encodes additional TLR2 ligands that are unaffected by the absence of the plasmid, preventing detection of differential TLR2 signaling effects as are observed in plasmid-cured C. trachomatis and C. muridarum. In support of this hypothesis, we observed that GPIC and CC13 activated TLR2 ~100 fold more effectively than C. muridarum Nigg, reflecting the expression of a potent, plasmid-independent TLR2 ligand by C. caviae.
CC13 and GPIC both displayed a strongly pro-inflammatory profile in dendritic cells. Consistent with our observation that C. caviae expresses a potent, plasmid-independent TLR2 ligand we detected strong induction of both TNF-α and IL-6 by BMDDCs in response to incubation with GPIC and CC13. C. caviae strongly induced IL-1β production by BMDDCs while C. muridarum did not. Prestimulation with TLR ligands is required for IL-1β production during infection of macrophages with C. muridarum . The high levels produced by BMDDCs infected with GPIC or CC13 suggests C. caviae is able to independently prime and induce release of IL-1β in these cells, unlike C. muridarum. Thus, it appears that in addition to a lack of plasmid-control for TLR2 activation, stimulatory pathways are activated by C. caviae differentially when compared to C. muridarum.
In light of our discovery that TLR2 signaling and infectivity were unimpaired in CC13 despite the absence of pCpGP1, it was not surprising that we were unable to demonstrate any significant attenuation in the guinea pig model of genital tract infection. Only with the potentiating effects of estradiol treatment were we able to detect a minor shortening in the course of infection and a slight reduction in upper genital tract bacterial load. Ultimately, these differences were not sufficient to drive differences in the development of oviduct immunopathology. Intra-abdominal adhesions were noted in animals in both groups and were likely the result of prolonged inflammation caused by the enhanced bacterial burden associated with administration of estradiol.
Comparisons of the effects of plasmid-curing on C. trachomatis, C. muridarum and C. caviae gene expression, regulation and virulence indicate significant differences that may be important for understanding the outcome of genital tract infection with these pathogens (Fig. 9). The overall similarity of both plasmid organization and sequence homology is high. Recent phylogenetic analysis of the plasmids expressed by 6 of the 9 chlamydial species indicates that they group distinctly, in a manner greatly resembling their genomes, with the plasmids obtained from C. pneumoniae strains most closely related to each other and to a lesser extent to those carried by C. psittaci, C. felis and C. caviae, and finally C. muridarum and C. trachomatis isolates . With such genetic similarity, how can we account for the differences in phenotype that we have observed in plasmid-cured strains? If the plasmid encodes effectors of chlamydial virulence directly, why aren't these phenotypes conserved in all species that carry the plasmid? Carlson et al.  proposed that the plasmid encodes a transcriptional regulator, and we have identified a conserved sub-population of chromosomal loci that are under its control . However, we observed only partial conservation of plasmid-dependence for these genes in C. caviae and if these are effectors of these phenotypes in C. muridarum and C. trachomatis, then this is a likely explanation of the failure of plasmid-curing to alter C. caviae virulence.
Interestingly, we observed significant reduction of all candidate PRCL transcription in GPIC in response to 2DG treatment, indicating that C. caviae, like C. trachomatis, alters gene expression in response to an environment in which glucose is limiting. Furthermore, this response persisted in the cured CC13 strain indicating that this process is plasmid independent. Consequently, glgA expression was plasmid-insensitive but glucose-limited by C. caviae, a novel transcriptional profile that contrasts with our observations for both C. trachomatis where glgA transcription is both plasmid and glucose sensitive and C. muridarum where glgA transcription is unaltered in response to plasmid loss or glucose limitation . This may reflect a glucose-responsive regulatory pathway evolving within Chlamydiaceae to facilitate modulation of non-essential, plasmid-associated, virulence gene expression. This is a common theme in bacterial pathogens where expression of virulence loci may be tightly controlled in response to environmental signals such as temperature , nutrient limitation , carbon availability , or phosphate homeostasis . In the context of such a model, it appears that C. muridarum has not co-evolved or has dispensed with the transcriptional controls exerted by this pathway with the result that transcription of PRCL remains constitutively active in glucose-limiting conditions . If true, this may explain the high incidence of upper reproductive tract pathology observed in the mouse model  while human infection is predominantly sub-clinical and reproductive tract sequelae relatively uncommon . Indeed, it may be worth noting that neither C. caviae nor C. muridarum are natural pathogens of the genital tract, infecting the eye and respiratory tract of their respective hosts, so coordination of virulence-associated gene expression in response to glucose availability might not be relevant for these sites. Our preliminary observations indicate that TLR2 signaling by C. trachomatis but not by C. muridarum is impaired when the chlamydiae have been cultured under glucose-restricted conditions , but until the pathogenic TLR2 ligand(s) have been identified, limited or altered expression of the TLR2 ligand(s) cannot be confirmed. If correct, then identification and characterization of the regulatory factor(s) encoded by the plasmid and those involved in the chlamydial carbon response will greatly advance our understanding of this important virulence process.
Primers directed against the predicted open reading frames encoded on pCpGP amplify predicted fragments from C. caviae GPIC but not from CC13. Primers pairs directed against each ORF are detailed in Table 1 and amplification conditions are described in Methods.
Scatter plot illustration of microarray comparison of the transcriptional profile of C. caviae GPIC and its plasmid-cured derivative CC13 30 hours after infection.
Competing Interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Funding: The Hartwell Foundation (http://www.thehartwellfoundation.org/) to TD, National Institutes of Health via grants R21 AI083657 to COC, R01 AI070693 to RB, and R01 AI064749 to RI. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.