Increased Ca
2+ influx via LTCCs has been implicated in the development of hypertrophy and pathological remodeling of the heart with select stress stimuli (
15,
28). For example, studies in animal models of heart disease have shown that antagonizing LTCC activity with pharmacologic inhibitors can prevent or reverse pathological cardiac remodeling and hypertrophy (
17–
19). We previously showed that upregulation of LTCC activity in the hearts of transgenic mice due to overexpression of the β2a subunit induced cardiomyopathy (
29). Total LTCC currents were increased by nearly 50% in adult myocytes from these hearts, which enhanced cardiac contractility and eventually caused necrotic death of myocytes, leading to dilated failure, with slightly heavier hearts. However, one perplexing observation from these mice was the relative lack of bona fide hypertrophy associated with enhanced Ca
2+ influx, especially in mice that were less than 3 months old, as we initially hypothesized that such a dramatic increase in Ca
2+ would induce calcineurin activation (
29). Similarly, α1C-overexpressing transgenic mice did not show cardiac hypertrophy until 8 months of age, and then it was mild and possibly secondary to neurohumoral effects (
30,
31). Thus, increasing the peak or acute release of Ca
2+ appears to be a weak inducer of hypertrophic disease and pathologic signaling, though it can lead to mitochondrial Ca
2+ overload and cellular necrosis, leading to dilated heart failure, with slight increases in heart weight that are likely dilatory in nature (sarcomeres added in series) and secondary to neurohumoral status.
In contrast to the above interpretation, downregulation of the β2 subunit using a gene transfer strategy in aortic banded rats showed prevention of the hypertrophic response (
32). However, this knockdown approach of β2 did not reduce systolic function in these animals, and α1C protein was not reduced compared with that in sham viral-injected hearts. Hence, it remains uncertain how these data relate to our observations in α
1C–/+ and α
1Cfl/fl-Cre mice that did show reduced current, α1C protein, and cardiac function. Indeed, Rosati et al. recently showed that heart-specific deletion of α1C resulted in reduced cardiac function and early postnatal lethality, although heterozygous deleted mice showed no baseline phenotype in their analysis (
33). These disparities notwithstanding, perhaps the most important observations are from clinical trials with Ca
2+ channel antagonists, which failed to show protective effects in patients with heart failure with systolic dysfunction and, in some cases, showed signs of worsening disease and increased mortality (
34,
35). Thus, reducing Ca
2+ influx through LTCCs in cardiomyocytes may not be a desirable therapeutic strategy for systolic heart failure, consistent with our observations of worsening disease due to graded deletion of α1C in our multiple genetic strategies.
We did not anticipate that a genetic-based reduction in LTCC current would induce spontaneous cardiac hypertrophy or dramatically enhance hypertrophy after pressure overload stimulation. Our new working hypothesis is that, in the absence of sufficient LTCC current, SR Ca
2+ release is sensitized in an attempt to maintain cardiac contractility, leading to hypertrophic remodeling through calcineurin/NFAT activation. The reduction in cardiac function likely causes a compensatory neuroendocrine response through β-adrenergic receptors that in turn mediates PKA and CaMKII activation to phosphorylate nodal Ca
2+ handling and contractile proteins in an attempt to augment contractility (
36,
37). In this manner, phosphorylation of the LTCCs and RyR2s would attempt to compensate for the reduced Ca
2+-induced Ca
2+ release relationship by allowing the RyR2 to leak and open with substantially less trigger Ca
2+. This would tend to elevate Ca
2+ in the cleft microenvironment in diastole, which may be a more potent Ca
2+ pool in activating calcineurin and CaMKII (
22,
38,
39). Indeed, the T-tubule/RyR2 junctions align with sarcomeric Z-discs in which calcineurin/NFAT are anchored through calsarcin and α-actinin, suggesting they could directly sample Ca
2+ in this microenvironment (
40). Moreover, leaky RyRs in the heart associated with PKA/CaMKII activation and oxidation and nitrosylation, downstream of β-adrenergic signaling, are known disease determinants for hypertrophy and worsening heart failure (
25,
41). This contention is entirely consistent with a recent report from Wehrens and colleagues, in which they made a RyR2 knockin mouse model that leaks Ca
2+, leading to greater cardiac hypertrophy and calcineurin/NFAT activation (
42). Thus, enhanced β-receptor signaling and elevated resting Ca
2+ in the cleft microenvironment due to RyR2 leak (or Ca
2+ from another source) likely serve as interrelated effects, leading to a greater hypertrophic response in α1C-deleted mice. In addition, decreased Ca
2+ influx via α1C could decrease Ca
2+-dependent inactivation of
ICa-L and thereby also contribute to increasing junctional cleft Ca
2+ concentration. Indeed, we observed a significant elevation in the fast component of inactivation (τ
f) in both α
1C–/+ and α
1C–/fl-Cre myocytes (Supplemental Figure 2).
The proposed elevation in resting Ca
2+ in the RyR2 cleft microenvironment should render these channels more likely to open with less LTCC influx. Another means of accomplishing this compensatory alteration could be to change NCX1 activity. Indeed, deletion of NCX1 from the mouse heart led to a compensatory reduction of nearly 60% in LTCC current, while increased NCX1 activity in the heart, due to transgene-mediated overexpression, produced more LTCC current (
43,
44). Moreover, LTCC activity directly influences NCX1 activity in the cleft microenvironment, leading to the hypothesis that reduced LTCC activity should produce less NCX1 activity, leading to increased cleft Ca
2+ and increased gain in ECC (
45). While we did not directly observe a change in NCX1 current from isolated adult cardiomyocytes from α
1C–/fl-Cre mice, in vitro conditions are probably not appropriate to observe the proposed compensatory alterations that might result in less Ca
2+ extrusion by NCX1 in vivo (Supplemental Figure 4). Finally, another compensatory alteration that might occur with reduced LTCC activity is through increased transient receptor potential canonical (TRPC) channel activity. Indeed, TRPC3 or TRPC6 overexpression in the heart induces Ca
2+ influx, calcineurin activation, and mild hypertrophy (
46,
47), and TRPC channels can functionally “couple” with LTCCs to alter each others’ activity (
48–
50). TRPC channels were also shown to couple to RyR1 in skeletal muscle to induce Ca
2+ release (
51). Despite these relationships, we did not observe an increase in store-operated Ca
2+ entry in cardiomyocytes from α
1C–/fl-Cre mice, suggesting that TRPC channel activity was not affected, at least as suggested by the surrogate measure of store-operated entry (Supplemental Figure 4). It should also be noted that we did not observe an increase in TTCC expression in hearts from α1C-deleted mice (data not shown). Despite a lack of changes in these and other Ca
2+ handling proteins and currents in α1C-deleted hearts, we did observe a mild increase in heart rate and a reduction in mean arterial blood pressure compared with those of control mice (Supplemental Figure 5).
While the ability to directly measure Ca
2+ in the cleft microenvironment is lacking, many additional indirect lines of evidence support a mechanism whereby Ca
2+ in this compartment is elevated and functions as the primary disease effector in α1C-deleted mice. First, metoprolol reversed manifestations of heart disease in α
1C–/+ mice, likely by antagonizing the neuroendocrine signaling machinery that enhances Ca
2+ leak from RyR2 or that otherwise contributes to Ca
2+ dysregulation secondary to CaMKII and PKA signaling. Second, augmentation in TTCC current with the α1G transgene rescued hypertrophy in α1C-deleted mice by providing more systolic Ca
2+ (presumably then reducing diastolic Ca
2+), although these mice still developed heart failure and perished prematurely (Supplemental Figure 3). The simplest interpretation of these observations is that the additional peak Ca
2+ release from TTCCs obviated the need for compensatory increases in cleft Ca
2+, though because the TTCC is not coupled in the same manner as the LTCC, it ultimately still resulted in lethality and arrhythmia. Third, despite dramatically reduced SR Ca
2+ levels, direct measures of relative SR leak and SR Ca
2+ sparks were enhanced in α
1C–/fl-Cre mice, suggesting that conditions are appropriate for RyR2 leak. Fourth, calcineurin/NFAT signaling was dramatically increased in the hearts of α
1C–/fl-Cre mice. Fifth, deletion of NCX1 in the heart, which also leads to a dramatic compensatory reduction in LTCC current (60%) (
43), similarly led to much greater cardiac hypertrophy and dysfunction in young adult mice after TAC stimulation (
45).
There may also be physiologic relevance to our results, such that LTCC current reductions might occur in the natural course of heart failure disease etiology. While it remains controversial whether LTCC current is reduced in cardiomyocytes from rats or humans with heart failure (
15), there is general agreement that myocytes from failing human hearts show less β-adrenergic LTCC reserve (
52). In the failing mouse heart, we reliably observed a significant (
P < 0.05) reduction in α1C protein after 8 weeks of pressure overload stimulation (Supplemental Figure 6). Myocytes from these same WT hearts showed hypertrophy, a reduction in the Ca
2+ transient, and a significant reduction in LTCC current (Supplemental Figure 6). Thus, a reduction in LTCC “function” (actual or reserve activity) may indeed be a physiologic consequence of heart failure, leading to the same increase in resting cleft Ca
2+ through RyR2 leak, leading to secondary hypertrophy signaling. Interestingly, BAY K8644-induced maximal
ICa-L in α
1C–/fl-Cre myocytes was significantly (
P < 0.001) blunted compared with that of control myocytes (data not shown), similar to what has been shown in failing human ventricular myocytes (
52). At the very minimum, our data at least suggest caution in applying LTCC antagonists for the treatment of heart failure, given the prominent disease-predisposing pathway that arose in the mouse with reduced cardiomyocyte-specific LTCC activity.