|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
Coagulase-positive Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus) is the major causal pathogen of acute endocarditis, a rapidly progressing, destructive infection of the heart valves. Bacterial colonization occurs at sites of endothelial damage, where (together with fibrin and platelets) it initiates the formation of abnormal growths known as vegetations. Here we report that an engineered analog of prothrombin detected S. aureus in endocarditic vegetations via noninvasive fluorescence or PET imaging. These prothrombin derivatives bound to staphylocoagulase and intercalated into growing bacterial vegetations. We also present evidence for bacterial quorum sensing in the regulation of staphylocoagulase expression by S. aureus. Staphylocoagulase expression was limited to the growing edge of mature vegetations, where it was exposed to the host and co-localized with the imaging probe. When endocarditis was induced with an S. aureus strain with genetic deletion of coagulases, survival of mice improved, highlighting the role of staphylocoagulase as a virulence factor.
The majority of life-threatening acute endocarditis cases are caused by coagulase-positive S. aureus infections. Due to the high mortality (25-47%), there is an urgent clinical need to diagnose S. aureus endocarditis early and reliably1-5. However, the clinical diagnosis of endocarditis has remained difficult, and primarily relies on unspecific signs such as the occurrence of a new heart murmur, fever, and the detection of circulating bacteria in blood cultures. In this study, we demonstrate the efficacy of targeted imaging strategies for the specific detection of S. aureus in vivo. In so doing, we also provide new insight into the role and molecular topography of staphylocoagulase (SC). Our strategy was to tag prothrombin and track its deposition at infection sites, essentally exploiting S. aureus’ ability to clot human blood6 to evade immune clearance. SC binds prothrombin with high affinity (KD ~ 17–72 pM)7, activates prothrombin through a conformation change8, and forms an active SC•prothrombin* complex that has all the fibrinogen-clotting abilities of thrombin, but is impervious to physiologic thrombin inhibitors7,9. Here, we determined that SC uses a tethering mechanism to facilitate localization of protease activity to the fibrin-rich vegetations. The systemic application of prothrombin analogs as imaging probes allowed SC to capture the circulating agent via high affinity prothrombin binding.
To determine the expression pattern of SC in a vegetation, we established a mouse model of S. aureus endocarditis that featured aortic valve bacterial vegetations (Supplementary Fig. 1 and Fig. 1a-c) resembling those in patients. Our method for imaging SC-dependent prothrombin recruitment to the S. aureus vegetation relied on the activation of prothrombin by SC, which simultaneously tethers the SC•(pro)thrombin* complex to fibrin(ogen)-rich vegetations (Fig. 1d). We employed a human prothrombin analog in which the active site was modified by a thrombin inhibitor with a protected thiol group. This prothrombin analog was then reacted with Alexa Fluor 680 dye (AF680-ProT). Injection of AF680-ProT into mice with S. aureus endocarditis resulted in its deposition into the vegetation (Fig. 1e,f and Supplementary Fig. 1d,e). This observation was consistent across cohorts infected with different strains of S. aureus (Tager 104, Xen29, and Xen8.1), but not in mice infected with coagulase-negative Staphylococcus epidermidis or in mice without bacteremia (Fig. 1f).
Although bacteria were present throughout the vegetations, immunoreactive staining for SC and von Willebrand factor binding protein (VWbp), an SC-like prothrombin activator10, was limited to the periphery (Fig. 1g,h and data not shown, respectively). This pattern was also seen using in situ hybridization with anti-sense SC RNA (Fig. 1i and Supplementary Fig. 2). AF680-ProT deposition co-localized with SC production and presence at the interface of the vegetations with the host’s circulation (Fig. 1j). Together, these findings imply that the location of SC is governed by its expression site rather than by redistribution following secretion. The topography of SC location and activity at the leading edge of vegetations may be caused by differential expression of SC during vegetation development, since in younger lesions with lower bacterial burden the entire Staphylococcus population stained positive for SC (Supplementary Fig. 3a,b).
To determine the molecular mechanism underlying prothrombin recruitment to the vegetations, we performed in vitro native gel binding experiments using either the NH2-terminal active fragment, SC(1-325), or the full-length SC(1-660) (Fig. 2a for domain organization). On incubation of these SC forms with prothrombin and fibrinogen fragment D (FragD), we found that SC(1-325) and prothrombin bound together (Fig. 2b, lane 4), but lacked the ability to interact with FragD (lane 5). SC(1-660), however, formed an SC•prothrombin•FragD ternary complex (Fig. 2c, lane 5).
The dimeric SC•prothrombin* complex is thought to bind to the central E domain of fibrinogen through interactions with the SC NH2-terminal domain11. It is also believed to simultaneously bind to the D domains through seven 27-amino acid COOH-terminal repeats, present on SC. To understand better how AF680-ProT localizes in vivo through the binding of SC to FragD, we subjected mixtures of the two proteins to non-denaturing native-gel electrophoresis. During individual reactions, the SC concentration remained constant, while FragD concentrations were increased. Interestingly, we observed excess FragD only after a 5-fold molar excess over SC, indicating that multiple FragD subunits interact with a single SC molecule (Fig. 2d). It is therefore conceivable that SC, secreted during S. aureus infection, interacts with at least four fibrinogen/fibrin molecules per SC molecule to form a mega-protein complex. This would then act to anchor the active SC•prothrombin* complex to the growing vegetation. Since the interaction of the COOH-terminal region of SC is distinct from that of the NH2-terminal prothrombin binding domains, this mega-complex could also bind one prothrombin per SC, a possibility that is consistent with our results (Fig. 2b, lane 5). Direct evidence for the SC repeat binding to FragD was obtained in an experiment that used a recombinant fragment of SC that contained only the pseudo-repeat and the first SC repeat (PR-R1; Fig. 2a). Fluorescence equilibrium binding experiments showed that a fluorescein labeled analog of PR-R1 (PR-R1[5F]) bound FragD with a KD 36 ± 8 nM (Fig. 2e).
We next investigated the use of AF680-ProT to non-invasively detect S. aureus endocarditis. Repetitive blood sampling showed that AF680-ProT had a blood half-life of 79 ± 14 minutes. Using fluorescence molecular tomography fused to X-ray computed tomography (FMT-CT), we found high local concentrations of AF680-ProT in S. aureus-induced vegetations 24 hours after injection of the probe (Fig. 3). Subsequently, we investigated the ability of this approach to detect different S. aureus strains by inducing endocarditis using three strains that express SC (Tager 104, Xen29, and Xen8.1). FMT-CT revealed that the increased fluorescence signal originated from the left ventricular outflow tract and the ascending aorta, and encompassed the vegetation in the aortic valve (Fig. 3a-c). The fluorescence concentration in the vegetations was then compared to mice without bacteremia and to mice with S. epidermidis challenge (Fig. 3d-f). We found that there was a 20-28-fold higher signal associated with the pathogenic S. aureus strains.
To determine the specificity of AF680-ProT, we injected the probe into mice in which femoral artery thrombosis was induced by topical application of FeCl312. No accumulation of AF680-ProT was observed (Supplementary Fig. 4). Next, we induced endocarditis with S. aureus strains that were deficient in both coagulases, SC and vWbp13. In mice infected with these bacteria, AF680-ProT concentration in vegetations was reduced to background levels (Fig. 4a-c). Interestingly, we found improved survival in these mice (Fig. 4d), suggesting that the coagulases increase the virulence of S. aureus. Histology from mice infected with SC and VWbp double knock-out S. aureus showed leukocyte infiltration in the vegetations and an absence of the protective fibrin barrier (Supplementary Fig. 3c-f), indicating an impaired ability of bacteria to evade the host defense. In an additional control group, 5 mice were infected with an S. aureus strain that only lacked SC; in vivo AF680-ProT concentration was reduced to 14% compared to mice that were infected with isogenic wild type Newman strain bacteria (P < 0.0001).
We next tested whether AF680-ProT could monitor antibiotic therapy. FMT-CT imaging 48 hours after infection showed that AF680-ProT was able to quantitate the effects of vancomycin (Supplementary Fig. 5). Termination of therapy resulted in a re-occurrence of the infection and a high risk of mortality, similar to relapse observed in some patients.
To apply the targeting mechanism to clinical S. aureus detection, we designed a radiolabeled agent for PET imaging. Here, the prothrombin analog was synthesized by alkylation of the free thiol with a maleimide derivative of a diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid (DTPA) chelator and then reacted with the PET isotope copper-64 (64Cu). A molecular model indicated that the chelator should have the required flexibility to interact with the metal (Fig. 5a,b). PET-CT (Fig. 5c-f) showed a robust localization of 64Cu-DTPA-ProT signal in vegetations, corroborated by ex vivo autoradiography (Fig. 5g). In mice without bacterial injection, we did not observe accumulation of 64Cu-DTPA-ProT at the site of endothelial trauma (Fig. 5i).
Bioluminescence signal from luxA-E expressing S. aureus Xen8.1 correlated to 64Cu-DTPA-ProT accumulation (Fig. 5g-k), suggesting that the in vivo PET signal reflects bacterial burden. Comparison of PET-CT imaging after injection of 64Cu-DPTA-ProT or 18F-FDG labeled leukocytes, a method that is clinically used to identify inflammatory foci14, showed a higher target to background ratio for 64Cu-DPTA-ProT (Supplementary Fig. 6). Finally, in preliminary toxicity experiments we did not observe signs of toxicity or clotting abnormalities (Supplementary Fig. 7).
Detection and management of acute endocarditis remains a clinical challenge. We continue to lack a means of visualizing bacteria in situ, and therefore currently rely on blood cultures for diagnosis. However, negative blood cultures do not rule out the presence of S. aureus in valvular vegetations. Here, we present a molecular imaging strategy capable of detecting small amounts of S. aureus in endocarditic vegetations. The approach exploits a mechanism used by S. aureus to evade the host immune system; namely SC’s ability to clot human plasma9 locally and seal itself off from surveiling immune cells. Prothrombin analogs engineered with fluorescent or PET beacons allowed us to specifically detect S. aureus vegetation formation non-invasively, and to monitor antibiotic therapy in mice with acute endocarditis. Furthermore, we showed that prothrombin localizes to growing vegetations via the bifunctional binding capability of SC, which anchored itself to the vegetation through binding multiple fibrin(ogen) D domains, whilst concurrently snaring circulating prothrombin.
The ability for coagulase-positive S. aureus to initiate infection under flow conditions, while simultaneously evading the host immune defense, is a remarkable feat that is poorly understood. Our findings demonstrate that SC plays a greater role in the development of vegetations than was previously appreciated15-18. We investigated the COOH-terminal repeat units of SC, and found that SC uses these 27-amino acid repeats to form a ternary complex with FragD and prothrombin. Binding of multiple fibrin(ogen) D domains to a single SC molecule may provide the necessary avidity for SC to withstand the shear stress exerted on a growing vegetation, given that a SC repeat has a KD of 36 ± 8 nM.
Early in vegetation development, SC was ubiquitously expressed throughout the vegetation. As the vegetation matured, however, SC expression at the core was lost. Chevalier et al. recently demonstrated that SC expression was directly repressed by the quorum sensing-controlled RNAIII, which (via direct binding to SC mRNA) arrests translation and facilitates degradation19. Our results are consistent with the notion that quorum sensing is responsible for regulating the SC mRNA signal, which would thus control SC-dependent prothrombin localization in developing vegetations. Improved understanding of the role of SC may provide alternative antibiotic drug targets, for instance disrupting growth of the vegetations and their ability to evade host immunity.
Previously proposed techniques for imaging endocarditis have generally lacked specificity for bacterial infection14,20-22. The approach reported here focuses on detection of coagulase-positive S. aureus, the deadliest pathogen responsible for the majority of acute endocarditis cases. While further studies are needed to explore translation in large animals and humans, the use of a pathogen-targeting PET tracer in patients would not only facilitate identification of S. aureus (i.e. from ’in vivo blood cultures’), but could also inform on the site, the bacterial load, and the activity of the infection and thus guide antibiotic and surgical therapy.
The right carotid artery of isoflurane (2% / 2L O2) anesthetized female C57BL/6 mice (Jackson Laboratories) was isolated, and a 1.4 cm segment of 4-0 suture material (Ethicon, Inc.) was inserted down the right carotid artery into the heart to cause damage to the aortic valve. Proper placement of the suture material was evident as the thread pulsated with heart movement. The suture material was left in place to facilitate sustained damage, and to mimic the presence of foreign material such as central lines, a frequent cause of endocarditis in patients. Mice were allowed to recover for 24 hours, and S. aureus (1 × 106 CFUs / 100 μl PBS) was injected via tail vein. We initially verified that the recombinant NH2-terminal fragment SC(1-325) (accession number AY225090) was able to activate mouse prothrombin. Indeed, we found that the mouse SC(1-325)•prothrombin* complex hydrolyzed the chromogenic substrate, H-d-Phe-Pip-Arg-pNA (S2238), at a rate that was equivalent that of mouse thrombin (kcat = 26 ± 1 s−1). We also found that the supernatants of all S. aureus strains were able to clot mouse plasma. These data are essential to verify that the mouse is an appropriate model organism to study SC function and regulation in vivo, given that there are considerable species effects (Supplementary Table 1). Endocarditis was evident in >85% of the animals, but the size of the vegetations and the extent of occlusion of the aortic valve varied, potentially correlating with the extent of denuded endothelium caused by the mechanical injury. The MGH Subcommittee on Research Animal Care approved all experiments.
Active-site inactivated human prothrombin derivatives were generated as previously described7, through the use of the thioester peptide chloromethyl ketone, Nα-[(acetylthio)acetyl]-d-Phe-Pro-Arg-CH2Cl. This method is similar to that used for generation of other fluorescent labeled derivates7,23 or for generation of heavy atom derivates of the SC(1-325)•(pre)thrombin complex8. Further details are given in the Supplementary Information.
On day 2 after suture insertion and 24 hours after induction of bacteremia, FMT-CT imaging was performed to interrogate the AF680-ProT incorporation in vegetations. To this end, mice were injected with 30-45 μg AF680-ProT and imaged 24 hours later using an FMT-2500 LX Quantitative Tomography Imaging System (PerkinElmer). After excitation at 680 nm and measurement of emission at 700 nm, a three-dimensional dataset was reconstructed that contained fluorescence concentration per voxel. FMT imaging was accompanied by hybrid X-ray CT angiography (Inveon PET-CT, Siemens) to visualize anatomy. Image fusion was achieved using Osirix software and fiducial markers on the frame of a dedicated multimodal imaging cassette, as described previously26. During CT acquisition, Isovue-370 was infused intravenously at 55 μl/min through a tail vein catheter to enhance vascular structures. The CT reconstruction protocol performed bilinear interpolation, used a Shepp-Logan filter, and scaled pixels to Hounsfield units. The isotropic spatial resolution for CT was 110 μm, and 1 mm for FMT. Fused data sets were used to place regions of interest in the left ventricular outflow tract.
The blood half-life of AF680-ProT (30 μg injected) was determined through repeated retro-orbital blood draws, followed by fluorescence imaging of the samples as well as of non-injected control plasma. To characterize further 64Cu-DTPA-ProT localization, a genetically-engineered S. aureus strain that stably expressed bioluminescence at sites of infection was used. In these studies, endocarditis was induced in 12 mice, which were then imaged for the presence of bioluminescence signal using an IVIS Imaging System 100 (Caliper LifeSciences). Animals were subsequently injected with 0.92-1.62 mCi of 64Cu-DTPA-ProT and imaged by PET-CT 12 hours later, with a total corporeal activity averaging at 365 μCi. We used an Inveon small animal PET-CT scanner (Siemens), a high resolution Fourier rebinning algorithm, and a filtered back-projection algorithm to reconstruct three-dimensional images. The PET voxel size was 0.796 × 0.861 × 0.861 mm, for a total of 128 × 128 × 159 voxels. Following the PET-CT imaging, the aortic root was excised and imaged for bioluminescence signal (1 min integration). This was followed by overnight exposure on an autoradiography cassette. Plates were read on a Typhoon™ 9400 Variable Mode Imager (GE Healthcare).
The results are expressed as mean ± SEM. Statistical comparisons between groups were evaluated by the Student t test. A p value of 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
An extended method section is available online in the Supplementary Information.
The authors would like to thank Y. Fisher-Jeffes for review of the manuscript and C. Vinegoni, Z. Mueller, and J. Sullivan for help with imaging and data analysis. The authors would also like to thank T. Foster for materials and helpful suggestions. This work was funded in part by grants from the National Institute of Health F32-HL094010, K99-HL094533 (P.P.); R01-HL096576, R01-HL095629 (M.N.); R01-EB006432, T32-CA79443, R24-CA92782, P50-CA86355 (R.W.) and R37-HL071544, R01-HL038779 (P.E.B.).