Slt2 phosphorylation levels in nourseothricin-resistant mutants identified in the screening
A reliable method for monitoring signaling through the CWI pathway is to follow the activation state of the MAPK Slt2 by using commercially available antibodies that recognize the dual phosphorylation of conserved threonine and tyrosine residues within the activation loop of Slt2, analogous to Thr
202/Tyr
204 of mammalian p44/p42 MAP Kinase (ERK) [
39]. In order to associate the phosphorylation status of Slt2 to
MLP1 up-regulation, the 174 deletant strains formerly selected were examined following this approach. After densitometric quantification of the phospho-Slt2 bands obtained by Western blotting analysis of the total protein extracts from each mutant strain, 64 mutants recorded higher Phospho-Slt2 levels (at least twofold) than the wild-type strain. The relative amount of phospho-Slt2 in these mutants was distributed over a wide range of values (from twice to thirtyfold) (Table ). Representative examples of Slt2 activation in different mutants are shown in Figure . The complete data set (Western blots) for all the selected mutants is presented in Additional file
1. These data indicate different levels of CWI pathway activation for each mutant, suggesting that yeast cells modulate pathway activation as required by specific stimuli. Remarkably, more than 20% of the mutations identified in a large-scale analysis revealing synthetic lethal interaction with
slt2 Δ [
40] have also been isolated in our screening (Table ).
| Table 1S. cerevisiae mutants with increased levels of dually phosphorylated MAP Kinase Slt2 |
As shown in Table , the functional categorization of mutants identified for constitutive Slt2 activation revealed the most representative functional groups according to the BIOBASE Knowledge Library Proteome and Saccharomyces Genome Database classifications, being those involved in cell wall organization and morphogenesis (28%), genes of unknown function (17%), signal transduction (17%), transport (11%) and transcription (9%). The remaining functional categories comprise mutants linked to metabolism (principally of RNA and proteins) and other cellular functions with lower representation in the screening (see Table ). This distribution is consistent with putative inputs of the pathway, namely, cell wall alterations or regulatory proteins.
An analysis was conducted of predicted and known interactions between the whole set of genes identified in the screening using the STRING web resource (
http://string-db.org) [
41]. This tool is very useful for the retrieval of an overall perspective of interacting genes/proteins. As shown in Figure , a large number of genes (38 out of 64) showed functional interactions between them. Interestingly, the interaction network was clustered again in the three main functional nodes (cell wall and morphogenesis, signal transduction and transcription) described above. From the large group of 18 mutants related to cell wall and morphogenesis, different subgroups can be highlighted. The first subgroup comprises seven genes (
SLA1,
ABP1,
BUD6,
VRP1,
ARC18,
TPM1,
DMA2) related to actin cytoskeleton organization. Actin cytoskeleton disruption has been shown to activate the CWI pathway, probably due to the induction of cell wall stress, but the precise molecular mechanism by which Slt2 is stimulated has not been fully established [
42]. Moreover, related to this group we found the Doa4 deubiquitinating enzyme (Figure ), which has been associated with cell morphology and actin cytoskeleton defects. In fact,
DOA4 had a synthetic genetic interaction with
SLA1 [
43]. A second subgroup encompasses six mutants, including structural cell wall-related proteins. Three of them are glycosylphosphatidylinositol-anchored proteins (GPI-APs) on the cell surface: Gas1, which is a β-1,3-glucanosyltransferase; Ecm33, which is linked to cell wall maintenance; and Yps7, an aspartyl protease. The corresponding deletant strains have severe cell wall defects that may explain their high basal Slt2 activation. In fact, the compensatory response elicited in a
gas1Δ strain has previously been characterized, and it involves a significant induction in
MLP1 expression [
12]. In agreement with this,
gas1Δ and
ecm33Δ mutants have previously been shown to have a constitutively high level of Slt2 phosphorylation [
44,
45]. Moreover, within this second subgroup we found Las21, an ER membrane protein involved in the synthesis of the GPI core structure. The absence of this protein leads to global cell wall defects. Functionally linked to Las21, the protein Arv1 was identified (Figure ). This protein is involved in sphingolipid metabolism and has recently been related to the process of GPI synthesis and anchoring [
46]. Finally, two proteins related to chitin metabolism, Chs6, which is involved in chitin synthase Chs3 activity, and Chs1 (chitin synthase I), which is required for repairing the chitin septum during cytokinesis [
7] were uncovered in our screening. The identification of these mutants is significant since, due to functional redundancy and the existence of gene families, the deletion of certain individual genes encoding cell wall-related proteins does not usually lead to observable phenotypes. A third subset includes
pmt1Δ,
hoc1Δ and
alg6Δ strains. All of them encode mannosyltransferase activities, and their selection in the screening is consistent with the finding that protein glycosylation of cell surface proteins is important for cell wall assembly [
7,
47]. Interestingly, transcriptional responses to O- and N-glycosylation defects in yeast include the fingerprint of the cell wall damage transcriptional profile [
48,
49]. In
S. cerevisiae, mannosyltransferases are highly redundant, being included in different protein families [
7,
50]. The identification of the abovementioned proteins is indicative of their specific importance in cell wall homeostasis.
Within the group of mutants involved in cellular signaling, we have identified several well-known negative regulators of Slt2 activity, such as the Rho1 GTPase activators Sac7 and Bem2, and protein phosphatases Sit4 and Msg5, which negatively regulate the pathway acting on Pkc1p and Slt2p, respectively [
51,
52]. We also identified Rom2 in spite of being an activator (Rho1 GEF) of the CWI pathway and the protein kinase Ypk1, a regulator linking sphingolipid signaling and CWI pathway [
53]. The effect on Slt2 activation in a
rom2Δ strain has previously been described [
54]. These authors hypothesized that
rom2Δ mutants have a defective cell wall due to a decreased activity of the CWI pathway, and this alteration may triggers Slt2 activation through Rom2-independent mechanisms. The singling out of these mutants further validates our screening for discovering novel potential regulators of the CWI pathway. This is the case of Nbp2, Ksp1, Fpk1, Mog1 and Skn7. Nbp2 acts as a negative regulator of the HOG pathway by recruiting Ptc1 phosphatase to Hog1 [
55], and has been involved in cortical ER inheritance via Slt2 [
56], the protein kinase Ksp1 has recently been linked to filamentous growth in haploid yeast cells [
57], and Fpk1 (flippase kinase 1) regulates phospholipid membrane translocation [
58]. Skn7 is a multifunctional transcription factor, as reflected by its ability to partner a variety of other transcriptional regulators under different conditions. It has previously been shown that Skn7 may be activated by Rho1p in response to cell wall stress [
59], whereas Mog1p is a protein involved in nucleocytoplasmic transport. At the same time, Mog1 is required for optimal recruitment of Skn7 to specific gene promoters [
60]. The fact that Slt2 is hyperactivated in these mutants suggests novel connections between the CWI pathway and the cellular processes controlled by these elements.
Regarding the set of mutants related to transcription, many of the proteins identified are involved in RNA polymerase II dependent transcription controlling responses to a variety of conditions such as, heat stress (
RTR1), oxidative stress (
YPR115w) and anaerobic conditions (
ROX1). Additionally, as visualized in the network map (Figure ), there is a connection between the transcription factors Skn7 and Rox1, with both participating in the transcriptional response to oxidative stress [
61]. Also, we identified two components of a module of the mediator complex (Ssn3 and Ssn8), involved in the regulation of Skn7 activity [
62]. The appearance of these mutants in our study suggests a functional link between them and the CWI pathway. These insights enable an association to be made between this MAPK pathway and additional stressful cellular events. In this regard, it is also worth to mention that some of the mutants identified in our screening have previously shown altered sensitivity to osmotic stress (
phm8Δ,
glg2Δ and
mrs3Δ) or heat stress (
ncl1Δ,
suv3Δ and
vps64Δ).
A connection has been described between the CWI pathway and endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress. When a cell encounters conditions that increase misfolded proteins, the Unfolded Protein Response (UPR) is activated to compensate for high levels of ER stress [
63]. The Slt2 MAPK pathway is activated during ER stress [
23], while UPR is activated by signaling through the CWI pathway during cell wall stress [
64]. Moreover, a second pathway, the ER stress surveillance pathway (ERSU) independent of the UPR, has recently been linked to Slt2 activation [
65]. According to our results, in some of the selected mutants these mechanisms of Slt2 activation could be involved. In fact, Emp47 is required for the export of specific glycoprotein cargo from the endoplasmic reticulum, Sec72 is involved in targeting secretory proteins to ER, and Orm2 is a protein related to lipid homeostasis and protein quality control, being required for resistance to agents that induce UPR [
66]. In addition, Orm2 interacts with Slt2, but the biological significance of this interaction is still unknown [
67]. Finally, we found the
cne1 mutant to be associated with ER quality control mechanisms. Cne1 is a calnexin homologue of
Saccharomyces cerevisiae that may play a part in the degradation of misfolded glycoproteins.
The identification of deletant strains in genes whose function remains uncharacterized and those not previously associated to cell wall integrity, both recording an increase in Slt2 phosphorylation, was of special interest since they could be putatively associated with cell wall construction or regulation. To further investigate this possibility, a phenotypical analysis was conducted on the 11 deletant strains corresponding to genes of unknown function and 15 without clear cell wall phenotypes reported in yeast databases. Thus, the sensitivity to Congo red, caspofungin, hygromycin B, caffeine and SDS was determined. These compounds affect cell integrity through different modes of action, whereby the dye Congo red interferes with proper cell wall assembly [
68], caspofungin consists of a β-1,3-glucan synthase inhibitor, hygromycin B hypersensitivity has been associated with glycosylation defects [
69], SDS is a detergent that affects membrane stability and also, indirectly, cell wall construction (increased accessibility) [
70], and caffeine is a substance that indirectly activates the CWI pathway in a TOR1-dependent fashion [
71]. Eventually, 15 out of 26 strains analyzed displayed altered sensitivity in at least one of the tests described (Table ), suggesting that the activation of the CWI pathway in these mutants could be due to direct or indirect cell wall alterations. Interestingly, these mutants generally had more than one phenotype supporting the existence of relevant cell wall damage. In contrast, identification of mutants without apparent cell wall defects could be related to the possibility of CWI pathway activation by other stimuli. In this regard, the coordination under specific growth conditions between the CWI and other regulatory MAPK pathways has been extensively reported [
20,
25]. Further supporting this, Harrison and colleagues [
42] suggested that the activation of the CWI pathway by different stresses, rather than operating in a linear "top-down" manner, would provide lateral inputs that impact this regulatory pathway at different levels. Moreover, recent findings connect Slt2 MAPK to DNA damage responses [
72].
| Table 2Sensitivity test on yeast deletant strains |
Differences in chitin content between mutants with Slt2 activation
The yeast cell wall normally contains approximately 2% chitin. However, certain mutations affecting cell wall stability increase chitin levels to as much as 20% of total wall polymers [
73]. As this emergency response for cell wall repair is dependent on CWI pathway signaling, it prompted us to assess this response in the whole group of 64 mutants with basal activation of the pathway. Chitin content was measured by means of flow cytometry after staining the cells with the chitin-binding dye, Calcofluor white (CW). This is a reliable and sensitive method for chitin determination, since it has been established a linear relationship between fluorescence from yeast cells stained with CW measured by flow cytometry and the biochemical determination of chitin [
74]. Remarkably, 19 (~30%) strains contained more than twice the amount of chitin than the wild-type strain (Figure ), denoting that a cell wall compensatory mechanism is triggered in these cells. As described above for Slt2 activation, a wide range of chitin content was observed, suggesting that increased deposition of this polymer is adapted to specific cellular requirements. In some of these mutants (
nbp2Δ,
sla1Δ,
vrp1Δ,
ylr338wΔ,
gas1Δ and
arc18Δ) elevated chitin levels and genetic interactions with mutations involved in chitin synthesis have previously been described [
75]. In contrast, the remaining 45 mutants did not record an evident increase in CW binding. Interestingly, about half of those mutants with increased chitin levels have been related functionally to cell wall and/or morphogenesis, whereas within the group of mutants lacking significantly increased chitin deposition only 18% were assigned to this functional group. These data suggest a functional link between the chitin-related mechanism and activation of the CWI pathway by cell wall and morphogenesis alterations. Eight out of ten mutants with maximum Slt2 phosphorylation, most of them cell wall related (see Table ), recorded higher chitin levels, reinforcing the idea that this polymer plays a key role in yeast for salvaging the cell under conditions that jeopardize cell integrity.
However, the identification of mutants with no significant variations in the amount of chitin indicates that CWI pathway activation could be due to alternative stimuli or internal inputs on this signaling route. In this regard,
gat2Δ and
lea1Δ mutants are two examples of special interest because they have strong Slt2 activation without affecting their chitin content (Table and Figure ), despite they showed cell wall alterations.
GAT2 encodes for a poorly characterized putative zinc finger transcription factor, while
LEA1 gene product is involved in RNA splicing, although its null mutation shows synthetic sick interaction with several cell wall related genes, such as
CHS1 or
CHS5 [
40]. In order to gain further insights into the origin of pathway activation in these mutants, we decided to construct double mutants deleting
ROM2 or
BCK1 in the
gat2Δ and
lea1Δ backgrounds. Rom2 is the major GEF for Rho1 that is responsible for relaying signals from cell surface to Rho1 for its activation [
76,
77], while Bck1 is the first element of the CWI pathway MAPK module. These mutants allowed us to distinguish whether the phosphorylation of Slt2 was the result of cell wall stress sensing or otherwise took place directly through the MAPK module of the route independently of upstream elements. After investigating Slt2 phosphorylation in single (
gat2Δ and
lea1Δ) and double (
gat2Δ
rom2Δ;
gat2Δ
bck1Δ;
lea1Δ
rom2Δ;
lea1Δ
bck1Δ) mutants, it was evident that MAPK activation was fully dependent on Bck1, whereas the lack of Rom2 did not affect the Slt2 activation in
gat2Δ and
lea1Δ strains (Figure ). Nevertheless, participation of other Rho1 GEFs like Rom1 or Tus1 can not be ruled out. This is in contrast to the activation of the CWI pathway by the cell wall stress caused by Congo red, in which Rom2 is demanded for Slt2 activation [
37]. These results support the notion that particular cell wall alterations could trigger specific adaptive responses through the CWI pathway.
MAPK phosphorylation vs. transcriptional activation
An important aspect we wanted to address about the functioning of the CWI pathway was the association between the magnitude of Slt2 phosphorylation and the concomitant effect on gene expression. To achieve this goal, a selected group of mutants, representing different levels of Slt2 activation, were transformed with a reporter construction where the promoter region of the
MLP1 gene was fused to the
lacZ coding sequence (
MLP1P-
lacZ) and transcriptional activation was studied under standard growth conditions by measuring β-Galactosidase activity. As shown in Figure , a good correlation between the expression levels of
MLP1 and Slt2 phosphorylation (Pearson's correlation coefficient of 0.8) was observed except for the mutant
lea1Δ, in which the reporter expression was significantly lower than expected from the MAPK phosphorylation status. Similar results were obtained when using the
CWP1 promoter, another reporter of the CWI pathway (Figure ). In this regard, comparable behavior was recently described for the mutant
msg5Δ in which Slt2 phosphorylation is not associated with Rlm1-dependent transcription [
78]. On the basis of this observation, the existence of additional
S. cerevisiae mutants with the same behavior cannot be ruled out.
In contrast to the group of mutants described above with increased levels of phospho-Slt2, another group of 110 mutants selected in the screening did not have detectable differences in Slt2 phosphorylation with respect to the wild-type strain. In order to confirm the nourseothricin resistance of these strains, we transformed them all with the reporter construct (
MLP1P-NAT1) and carried out minimal inhibitory concentration (MIC) assays using a microdilution method. Eventually, 38 mutant strains recorded higher antibiotic MIC values than that of the wild-type (Additional file
2), confirming the phenotype of nourseothricin resistance, whereas all the other mutants behaved the same as the wild-type strain. Bearing in mind that this phenotype was also confirmed for the 64 mutants with increased phosphorylation of Slt2, this group probably includes mutants with antibiotic resistance by non-CWI-related mechanisms, such as alternative effects on
MLP1 expression or intrinsic antibiotic resistance.
To further investigate the molecular mechanism involved in the group of antibiotic resistant strains without detectable variation in phospho-Slt2 levels, the
MLP1P-lacZ reporter was used to monitor levels of expression of
MLP1 in this set of mutants. For the majority of the mutants,
MLP1 expression levels were low and in general higher than the wild-type strain (Figure ). However, mutant strains
ssd1Δ and
pmt2Δ had very high levels of
MLP1 expression (Figure ) in spite of very slight, if any, Slt2 activation (Figure ). Pmt2 catalyzes the first step in O-mannosylation of target proteins [
79] and
SSD1 has been linked to cell wall integrity [
80,
81]. To elucidate a possible participation of the CWI pathway in the activation of the gene expression in these mutants, we proceeded to generate
pmt2Δ
slt2Δ,
pmt2Δ
rlm1Δ,
ssd1Δ
slt2Δ and
ssd1Δ
rlm1Δ double mutants. By using these strains transformed with plasmids containing transcriptional fusions of
MLP1,
CWP1 and
SED1 to
lacZ, we were able to delimit the requirement of the CWI MAPK and its main transcription factor (Rlm1) for the observed transcriptional up-regulation. As shown in Figure , gene activation in the absence of both CWI pathway elements, Slt2 or Rlm1, was completely annulled compared to
pmt2Δ and
ssd1Δ single mutants. These results point to the existence of situations where undetectable changes in MAPK activation (Figure ) give rise to remarkable consequences at gene expression levels. As further proof of the essentiality of Slt2 activity in the transcriptional response observed in the
pmt2Δ and
ssd1Δ strains, we took advantage of two mutant forms of MAPK Slt2. The first was a variant K54R, consisting of a mutation within the ATP-binding site, which blocks the catalytic activity of the protein. The second one (TA/YF) eliminates the phosphorylation of Slt2 by upstream MAPKKs Mkk1/Mkk2. Both alleles, borne on centromeric plasmids, were unable to restore
MLP1P-
lacZ expression in
pmt2Δ
slt2Δ and
ssd1Δ
slt2Δ strains (Figure ), indicating that signaling through active Slt2 was imperative. These results sustain a mechanism of MAPK signaling in which high levels of transcriptional induction through Rlm1 are not necessarily associated with MAPK phosphorylation levels. This is relevant for CWI pathway-related studies since the phosphorylation status of Slt2 might not always reflect the real pathway outcomes. Further studies will be necessary to characterize the mechanism involved.