In this study, we have provided evidence demonstrating that TSC is an essential regulator of ISC growth and division. In the absence of TSC function, ISCs have unrestricted cell growth, which halts cell division and leads to the formation of extremely large cells. Although stem cell markers are still expressed, these ISC-like cells are nonfunctional and can no longer divide or differentiate. As a consequence, the TSC mutant gut has a thinner epithelium and the mutant fly is more susceptible to tissue-damaging agents. Our study has uncovered a tissue context–dependent phenotype of TSC mutants, such that unrestricted cell growth can lead to a stop of cell division, and thus, TSC does not function all the time as a classical tumor suppressor.
The TSC–TOR and other growth regulatory pathways, such as InR and Myc, have intricate interactions. Some suggest that the InR pathway directly represses TSC, whereas others and our study here suggest that the two pathways act in parallel (;
Pan et al., 2004;
Avruch et al., 2006). The TSC–TOR pathway also has a negative feedback into upstream components of the InR pathway (
Huang and Manning, 2009;
Inoki and Guan, 2009). Recent identification of TORC2 in addition to the original TORC1 further complicates these pathways (
Hietakangas and Cohen, 2007;
Guertin et al., 2009). However, our results clearly show that
TORC2 mutants and
TSC mutants have different phenotypes in the adult
Drosophila midgut, suggesting that TSC does not function through TORC2 to regulate ISC division. Previous studies have demonstrated that Myc can modulate TSC–TOR in controlling the growth of mammalian and fly cells (
Tapon et al., 2001;
Teleman et al., 2008;
Schmidt et al., 2009), which is consistent with what we have observed.
In normal development and adult tissue homeostasis, cells need to grow in size by approximately twofold before they divide to maintain the original cell size. Reduction in cell growth below a certain threshold can lead to a halt of division (
Grewal and Edgar, 2003;
Jorgensen and Tyers, 2004;
Leevers and McNeill, 2005). Therefore, the balance between cell growth versus division is a complex process requiring delicate coordination (
Kohlmaier and Edgar, 2008). Here, we have shown that, in
TSC mutants, the increase in midgut ISC size is >10-fold ( and ), whereas the increase in larval disc cell size is less than twofold (
Ito and Rubin, 1999;
Gao and Pan, 2001;
Tapon et al., 2001). A possible reason for this difference is that the mutant larval disc cells continue to divide, thereby maintaining a moderate cell size. One key question that remains is why the larval disc cells that contain a
TSC mutation have somewhat coordinated growth and division, whereas the adult mutant ISCs have completely stopped their division. It is possible that because imaginal discs are developing organs, they are designed to have faster growth and division. Adult midgut ISCs have a slower intrinsic cell cycle of >24 h (
Micchelli and Perrimon, 2006;
Ohlstein and Spradling, 2006), and adult cells have differences in checkpoint controls (
Su et al., 2000;
Walworth, 2000;
Song, 2005). These may allow the excessive growth to take place until it passes a critical point that blocks division.
Phenotypes manifested in TSC patients are mostly benign tumors that rarely progress into higher-grade cancers (
Crino, 2008). TSC1 and 2 have expression in the intestine, and adult patients have occasional intestinal polyps (
Hizawa et al., 1994;
Fukuda et al., 2000;
Johnson et al., 2001). Mouse embryonic fibroblasts from mutant
TSC animals can also enter senescence, which is equivalent to a cessation of cell division (
Zhang et al., 2007). The adult midgut ISC phenotypes shown in this study are consistent with these phenotypes. We speculate that excessive cell growth leading to a block in cell division is a common phenotype in slowly dividing adult tissues when
TSC is mutated. The phenotype of increased cell growth and increased cell division may be applicable to rapidly dividing cells, including developing
Drosophila disc cells, mammalian hematopoietic stem cells, and tumor cells (
Ito and Rubin, 1999;
Gao and Pan, 2001;
Tapon et al., 2001;
Rosner et al., 2006;
Gan et al., 2008). A recent study demonstrates that in
TSC mutants, there is loss of adult female germline stem cells because of differentiation (
Sun et al., 2010). The ISCs and germline stem cells have different niche compositions that may contribute to the observed differences in the mutant phenotype. Moreover, it underscores the idea of a tissue context–dependent phenotype exhibited in
TSC mutants.