Glaucoma is a complex disease that appears to be influenced by multiple genetic and environmental factors. Mutations in myocilin (
MYOC) are an important cause of POAG. Considerable progress has been made in understanding the role of mutant MYOC in glaucoma by using cell culture. However, the in vivo mechanisms leading to MYOC-associated glaucoma are not well understood due to the lack of a faithful animal model. We and others previously attempted to generate a mouse model of glaucoma by knockout of the mouse
Myoc gene (
8) as well as by knockin of specific human mutations (
21). These strategies led to mice that had either no phenotype or a minimal glaucoma phenotype. Here, we report the development of a mouse model that closely replicates the POAG phenotype observed in glaucoma patients. In the current work, we used a CMV promoter to drive the expression of the human
MYOC gene containing the Y437H mutation. We reasoned that the CMV promoter had the potential for relatively high
MYOC expression in relevant tissues. The Y437H mutation was selected because human patients with this mutation have early (juvenile) onset of POAG with elevated IOPs (
4). A human rather than mouse transgene was inserted due to potential important differences between mouse and human
MYOC. The mutant human transgene proved to be expressed in tissues relevant to the development of glaucoma, specifically the iridocorneal angle including the TM and sclera. The transgene is not expressed in the retina of
Tg-MYOCY437H mice. This pattern is similar to the expression of the endogenous gene. It is known that the
CMV promoter does not necessarily lead to ubiquitously expressed transgenes. DNA methylation of the
CMV promoter plays an important role in tissue-specific silencing of transgenes (
22). Thus, it is possible that lack of transgene expression in retina is due to methylation of the
CMV promoter. The study of relevant phenotypes in
Tg-MYOCY437H mice reveals development of glaucoma phenotypes closely mimicking those seen in human patients. Notably, adult transgenic mice develop elevated IOP at about 3 months of age and undergo progressive RGC death and optic nerve degeneration. Mutant mice do not display other ocular or nonocular phenotypes. We believe that the
Tg-MYOCY437H mouse is the first genetic model of
MYOC-associated POAG that faithfully replicates the human disorder.
We find it very intriguing that RGC cell death is not linear even though IOP is constantly elevated from 3 months of age. It is possible that initial elevated IOP insult causes cell death of a particular type of RGCs that are the most sensitive to pressure-related damage, while the remaining RGCs are more resistant to cell death by elevated IOP. However, it is important to note that PERG, which is a measurement of RGC function, more dramatically decreases with age (40% in 4-month-old Tg mice and 60% in 12-month-old Tg-MYOCY437H mice). Future studies will be aimed at further understanding loss of RGCs in Tg mice.
The development of
Tg-MYOCY437H mice provided the opportunity to investigate the in vivo pathophysiology of MYOC-associated glaucoma. Normal MYOC is secreted, although there are conflicting reports concerning the intracellular localization of MYOC (
23–
25). In vitro studies indicated that I477N and P370L missense mutations in human MYOC lead to accumulation of the mutant protein in the ER (
11,
13). Here, we show that Y437H MYOC accumulates intracellularly in the ER of primary TM cells. In addition, myocilin also accumulates in the ER of TM tissue in vivo, as evident from colocalization of the ER marker KDEL with myocilin in
Tg-MYOCY437H mice. Consistent with the nonsecretion and accumulation of mutant MYOC in the ER, MYOC is greatly reduced in the aqueous humor of
Tg-MYOCY437H mice compared with controls. The intracellular accumulation of myocilin induces ER stress in the TM of
Tg-MYOCY437H mice. To alleviate ER stress, TM cells activate the cytoprotective UPR, as shown by phosphorylation and activation of ER stress sensors as well as downstream signaling pathways, including increased key ER chaperones. Failure to resolve chronic and persistent ER stress may lead to TM loss/dysfunction, which is associated with induction of ER stress–initiated apoptotic transcriptional factor Chop and activation of ER-specific caspase 12. We observed TM cell loss in 12-month-old
Tg-MYOCY437H mice. Interestingly, 3-month-old
Tg-MYOCY437H mice have normal TM cell numbers compared with WT littermates. Furthermore, in primary TM cells, expression of mutant myocilin leads to cell death. The induction of ER stress–initiated cell death signals, including Chop and activated caspase 12, suggests the involvement of ER stress in TM loss. It is interesting to note that older
Tg-MYOCY437H mice lose only 30% of TM and PBA reduces IOP of 12-month-old
Tg-MYOCY437H mice by 3.5 mmHg compared with 5.5 mmHg in 4-month-old mice. Based on these data, it is possible that elevated IOP in combination with chronic ER stress is involved with TM cell loss observed in older mice. Future studies will be aimed at further understanding the cause of TM loss in
Tg-MYOCY437H mice. These findings indicate that mutant myocilin induces chronic ER stress, which may lead to dysfunction and/or loss of TM cells in
Tg-MYOCY437H mice, thus elevating IOP. Consistent with these findings, chemical induction of ER stress using tunicamycin significantly elevated IOP in normal C57BL/6J mice.
Overexpression of proteins can lead to induction of ER stress. Therefore, it is possible that overexpression of myocilin under the control of the CMV promoter in
Tg-MYOCY437H mice may lead to ER stress and elevate IOP. When WT and Y437H human myocilin were overexpressed at comparable levels in the TM of normal mice, only mutant mice developed elevation of IOP and RGC cell death, indicating that only mutant myocilin expression leads to glaucoma. These data are consistent with the previous studies performed by Shepard et al., which demonstrated that transient overexpression of Y437H human MYOC elevates IOP in mice compared with WT human myocilin (
10). Furthermore, our data indicate that ER stress is induced prior to IOP elevation based on the following observations. First, mice injected with adenovirus harboring either Y437H or G364V mutants of human myocilin did not have elevated IOP 24 hours after injections. However, Western blot analysis of iridocorneal angle tissues from these mice demonstrates that Y437H or G364V mutants of human myocilin induce ER stress (Figure E). Second, mice injected with tunicamycin induce ER stress 24 hours after injections but do not elevate IOP (Figure B). Third, TM cells expressing only mutant myocilin show ER stress compared with TM cells expressing WT myocilin, indicating that mutant myocilin is sufficient to induce ER stress (Supplemental Figure 6). Furthermore, we show that ER stress occurs in the skin fibroblasts of POAG patients with the
Y437HMYOC mutation, indicating that a similar phenomenon of ER stress occurs in a human patient with the
MYOCY437H mutation. Interestingly, fibroblasts from POAG patients with the
Y437HMYOC mutation appear to make low levels of myocilin. but the low levels of myocilin still induce ER stress. Thus, these data indicate that misfolding and not the overexpression of mutant myocilin leads to ER stress.
Mutant myocilin is expressed in tissues throughout the body, yet the only recognized phenotype of mutant myocilin in humans is glaucoma (
3,
4). Consistent with this phenomenon in humans,
Tg-MYOCY437H mice express human mutant myocilin in heart and kidney at high levels, yet these mice do not show other phenotypes associated with ER stress (data not shown). It is possible that myocilin is misfolded in these tissues; however, these tissues may be able to better handle misfolded myocilin by the UPR pathways. We hypothesize that there are tissue-specific differences in ER stress responses to misfolded myocilin and that malfunction or inefficiency of the ER stress response in the TM leads to cell death. This hypothesis is supported by the findings from a previous study showing significant differences in the ER stress response to mutant myocilin between TM cells and HEK293 cells (
11).
We demonstrate that relieving ER stress induced by mutant myocilin in the TM of
Tg-MYOCY437H mice prevents glaucoma. We demonstrate that oral administration of PBA not only facilitates secretion of mutant MYOC, but also suppresses ER stress and thus prevents elevated IOP, RGC death, and optic nerve degeneration in
Tg-MYOCY437H mice. Previous studies indicate that mutant MYOC is thermally unstable and misfolded. Enhancing proper folding of MYOC by the use of temperature modifications or small chemical chaperones can reverse the pathogenic events in vitro (
11,
26–
28). Our data show that rescue of
Tg-MYOCY437H mice by PBA is likely due to its chaperone property; this works by enhancing the folding of mutant MYOC leading to increased secretion. Enhanced secretion reduces ER stress and prevents TM cell death. It is remarkable that PBA was able to reduce IOP in 12-month-old mice. Since 12-month-old mice lose only 30% of TM cells, it is possible that PBA works on the remaining 70% of TM cells. However, it is interesting to note that PBA’s effects on IOP in 12-month-old mice is less efficient compared with that in 4-month-old mice. PBA treatment decreases IOP by approximately 6 mmHg in 4-month-old
Tg-MYOCY437H mice. However, in 12-month-old mice, PBA reduces IOP by approximately 3.8 mmHg.
A recent study by Shepard and colleagues demonstrated that expression of glaucomatous mutations in human myocilin caused aberrant peroxisomal localization in TM cells and IOP elevation in mice (
10). Human myocilin contains a cryptic carboxyterminal peroxisomal target site (PTS1) that is normally not recognized because WT myocilin is sequestered in the secretory compartment. Mouse myocilin lacks this carboxyterminal PTS1 site. Replacing the human PTS1 site (SKM) with the mouse carboxyl terminal 3 amino acids (LEM) prevented human mutant myocilin from elevating IOP in mice. This concept is further supported by the lack of a glaucoma phenotype in mice expressing mutant mouse myocilin (
9). Glaucoma-associated mutations in both human and mouse myocilin cause myocilin misfolding and retention of mutant myocilin in the ER. In addition to our current data, there are also data by others showing that mutant human myocilin activates UPR and ERAD pathways (
11–
13). However, although mutant mouse myocilin was not secreted into the aqueous humor and accumulated in the angle of mouse eyes, it did not activate UPR/ERAD and did not elevate IOP in mice (
9). Since mutant human MYOC activates the UPR/ERAD pathways and causes mislocalization to peroxisomes, we currently do not know whether one pathway or both pathways are required for damaging the TM leading to IOP elevation. Treatment with the chemical chaperone PBA should promote refolding of mutant myocilin and thereby rescue both pathways. Thus, failure to secrete myocilin, induction of ER stress, and mislocalization of mutant myocilin to peroxisomes appear to be central features of MYOC-associated glaucoma and support the gain-of-function hypothesis of mutant MYOC. This study provides a basis for examining the role of ER stress in POAG patients and evaluating the use of chemical chaperones in the mitigation of POAG.
There are several widely used rodent models of glaucoma, and each has its own strengths and weaknesses (
29,
30). The naturally occurring DBA/2J mouse model of glaucoma develops pigmentary glaucoma-like changes in the anterior segment, which causes IOP elevation followed by progressive optic nerve damage and RGC loss (
31). There also are a number of induced models of ocular hypertension that cause optic nerve and RGC damage, including injection of hypertonic saline into episcleral veins in rats (
32), laser photocoagulation of the aqueous outflow pathway in rats and mice (
33–
35), cautery of extraocular vessels in rats (
36) and mice (
37), and injection of microbeads to occlude the outflow pathway in rats and mice (
38). The current
Tg-MYOCY437H model is based on our previous work demonstrating that intraocular injection of mouse eyes with specific adenoviral Myoc expression vectors elevated IOP (
10). Our new model uses a mutant human glaucoma gene to mimic many features of POAG including the following: TM damage with an open anterior chamber angle, elevated IOP, progressive optic nerve and RGC damage, and loss of visual function. Unlike in acute models, the pressure-related damage occurs progressively over the course of months. In addition, the damage is synchronous, with similar IOP elevations and damage at a specific age occurring in both eyes (intraindividual) and among littermates (interindividual). We have also shown that therapeutic intervention both early and late in the disease process can protect from glaucomatous damage.