In this large prospective cohort of AARP members, history of self-reported diabetes was associated with a 25% increase in thyroid cancer risk. This appeared to be primarily due to a 46% significantly increased risk of thyroid cancer among women, with only a slight change in risk observed among men. The finding of an elevated risk was observed for both papillary and follicular histologic types of thyroid cancer.
Although thyroid cancer typically occurs about three times more frequently in women than in men in the United States, rates of diabetes in men and women in the United States are similar (
1,
5). Nonsignificant increases in risk in women have been observed in previous epidemiologic investigations of the association between thyroid cancer and diabetes (
31,
36,
37) as well as in men (
28,
32,
36,
38), although the association between thyroid cancer and diabetes in general has been inconsistent. A study conducted by Meinhold
et al. of U.S. Radiologic Technologists (
24) reported a relative risk of 1.34 (95% CI: 0.49–3.77) among women and no association among men (although only about 25% of the cohort are men). Similarly, Chodick
et al. recently reported an increased risk of thyroid cancer in women (HR

=

1.61; 95% CI: 0.96–2.69) but not men (HR

=

0.72; 95% CI: 0.25–2.04) with T2D in an Israeli cohort (
39).
There are a variety of possible biological mechanisms for the relationship between thyroid cancer and diabetes. Diabetics have a higher prevalence of thyroid disorders compared with the general population (10.81% vs. 6.6%) (
6). Type 1 diabetics are prone to autoimmune thyroid disease, with up to 30% of women with T1D affected. As such, screening for thyroid dysfunction is recommended in this population (
44). The association between T2D and subclinical hypothyroidism is also well recognized with reported prevalence in 2.2%–17% range (
44). Although screening is not recommended, endocrinologists examining those patients are more prone to screen for thyroid dysfunction and nodularity than general practitioners, thus contributing to increased detection of thyroid cancer in this population. Furthermore, diabetics are more prone to mild, chronic TSH elevation, which, in recent studies, was demonstrated to be an independent risk factor for thyroid cancer development (
15–
20).
The association between thyroid cancer and diabetes risk may be due to variation in deiodinase expression in these disorders. Deiodinase enzymes regulate intracellular thyroid hormone levels, converting circulating prohormone T4 into its active form T3 (DIO1 or DIO2) or its inactive form rT3 (DIO3) (
45,
46). Specifically, type 2 deiodinase regulates intracellular T3 concentration in the pituitary, brain, and brown fat (
47). It is also expressed in skeletal muscle, where it indirectly regulates GLUT4 expression (
48). As such, inactivation of DIO2 results in decreased intracellular T3 levels in skeletal muscle, which, in turn, would decrease GLUT4 transcription in skeletal muscle and adipose tissue, further contributing to insulin resistance. Similarly, inactivation of DIO2 results in decreased intracellular T3 levels in pituitary cells, which in turn stimulates TSH release (
45,
46). DIO2 expression is modulated by a host of factors, including selenium and vitamin D3 levels, activation of Protein Kinase A, and Protein Kinase C pathways, and the presence of a DIO2 gene mutation (Thr92Ala variant). A recent metaanalysis of 11,033 participants found that subjects who had DIO2 Thr92Ala missense variation experienced increased T2D risk (
49). Furthermore, DIO1 and DIO2 expression is reduced in papillary thyroid cancer (
50,
51), whereas DIO2 expression is reported to be significantly increased in widely metastatic follicular thyroid carcinoma (
52–
54). Although the role of DIO1 and DIO2 in carcinogenesis is not known, studies have suggested that they play a role in tumor differentiation as opposed to
de novo neoplastic transformation. In contrast, reactivation of DIO3 expression in tumoral cells with its ensuing intracellular hypothyroidism (low T3, elevated rT3) results in inhibition of thyroid hormone receptor-mediated suppression of ras-mediated transcription, proliferation, and transformation (
55). This provides tumoral cells proliferation advantage as compared with neighboring normal cells.
In diabetics, chronic exposure to elevated circulating insulin levels is characteristic, from either endogenous (mediated by insulin resistance) or exogenous (chronic insulin therapy) sources. Insulin and insulin-like growth peptides share structural homology and affinity of its respective receptors (
56). They are both important determinants of cell proliferation and apoptosis (
56). Elevated circulating levels of insulin and insulin-like growth factor 1 are linked to increased risk of various cancers, including breast and colon (
57–
59). To date, there has been no association between insulin exposure and thyroid cancer in human studies. However, in laboratories, thyroid cancer cell lines are grown using a medium containing TSH, insulin, and cortisol, suggesting that insulin may play a role in thyroid carcinogenesis (
60).
Chronic exposure to certain hypoglycemic agents used to treat patients with diabetes may also play a role in the complex relationship between diabetes and thyroid cancer incidence (
22). Patients receiving metformin therapy (decreases insulin resistance) have a decreased risk of cancer and cancer mortality compared with those on insulin or sulfonylureas (increases insulin secretion) (
22). Among insulin users (which typically includes all patients with T1D and some with T2D), those on Glargine (an insulin analog) may have an increased risk of cancer compared with those on human insulin, as suggested by a recently published observational study (
22). The effect is believed to be mediated by increased and prolonged binding to the insulin-like growth factor 1-receptor leading to increased mitotic activity. To date, thyroid cancer has not been specifically implicated with prolonged sulfonylurea or insulin therapy. More recently, GLP-1 agonist therapy was linked with C-cell hyperplasia in humans and increased incidence of C-cell hyperplasias and medullary thyroid carcinoma in rodents. GLP-1 agonist does not appear to modulate differentiated thyroid cancer risk (
22). The PPAR gamma agonist, Rosiglitazone (Avandia), was shown to induce apoptosis in PPAR gamma-positive thyroid cancer cell lines and increases radioiodine uptake in dedifferentiated thyroid tumors (
20).
Alternatively, increased thyroid cancer risk in diabetics may be accounted for by metabolic syndrome-related confounding variables, including abnormal glucose metabolism, triglyceride levels, and BMI. Obese subjects are at a 10-fold increased risk of developing diabetes (
61), and obesity is also associated with increased risk of thyroid cancer including in this cohort (
25). Obesity is thought to promote insulin resistance through the inappropriate inactivation of gluconeogenesis. In this study, detailed adjustment for BMI slightly reduces (<10%) the risk of thyroid cancer, but did not explain the association between diabetes and thyroid cancer in women.
Recently, researchers from the Metabolic Syndrome and Cancer project linked glucose and triglyceride, independent of BMI, with increased risk of cancer (
8). Specifically, an increased risk for thyroid cancer was observed for both men and women (RR

=

1.88; 95% CI: 1.16–3.07 and RR

=

0.72; 95% CI: 0.47–1.10, respectively) with 1 mmol/L blood glucose increments, though nonsignificant in women (
8). Similarly, men were more prone to thyroid carcinoma with elevated triglycerides levels in the top studied quintile compared with bottom quintile (
8).
Finally, vitamin D deficiency is hypothesized to account for lower incidence of cancer and cancer-related death in individuals living in southern latitudes compared with northern latitudes (
62,
63). Vitamin D promotes differentiation and apoptosis of cancer cells in culture studies. Association of vitamin D therapy/sufficiency and risk of specific cancers (colon, breast, prostate, and pancreas) has yielded inconsistent results in observational studies (
64,
65). To date, vitamin D deficiency, detected in up to 70% of diabetics, has not been associated with thyroid cancer risk. Low vitamin D levels decrease DIO2 expression (
66), thus potentially linking diabetes to increased thyroid cancer risk.
The strengths of this study include its prospective design, completeness of follow-up, and the relatively large number of thyroid cancer cases with morphological diagnoses allowing for stratification by gender and histologic type. Limitations include the fact that we were unable to discriminate between T1D and T2D, and had no information on diabetes control, confounding variables such as TSH, lipid, and vitamin D levels, or diabetes medication. However, it seems that the proportion of subjects with T1D is likely to be small. The high proportion of non-Hispanic whites in our study population did not allow us to evaluate the effect of diabetes on thyroid cancer by race/ethnicity. As thyroid dysfunction is known to occur in diabetic patients and can contribute to significant metabolic disturbances, screening for thyroid abnormalities is not that uncommon (
5), increasing the opportunity for incidental findings in the diabetic population. Unfortunately, we did not have data on the frequency of thyroid examinations in our study population. In sum, in the largest prospective evaluation to date, we found that thyroid cancer was significantly associated with diabetes among women. This study is also the first to present findings suggesting elevated risks for both the papillary and follicular types of thyroid cancer. As thyroid cancer is the sixth most common cancer among American women and the most common cancer of the endocrine system (
1,
2), our findings warrant further evaluation.