Patients with DC have high rates of bone marrow failure, pulmonary fibrosis and cancer, and a triad of epidermal findings, including oral leukoplakia, nail dystrophy and abnormal skin pigmentation
7,11. The severity of DC and its age of onset vary widely; the reason for this range of phenotypes is unclear, but depends in part on the mode of inheritance and the specific genes involved. Patients with X-linked DC due to mutations in
DKC1 typically present in early childhood with the classic manifestations of the disease
11,12. In contrast, autosomal dominant DC due to mutations in
TERT or
TERC, the telomerase RNA component, presents later in life (
i.e. in adolescence or young adulthood), and disease manifestations are often milder, with patients commonly lacking the epidermal triad. Patients with autosomal recessive DC due to
TCAB1 mutations have the classic and severe form of the disease, with early age of onset and shortened life expectancy
13. All forms of DC are associated with very short telomeres in peripheral blood lymphocytes
14. Telomerase is restricted in its expression in many tissues to stem cells and progenitor cells, and the challenges in isolating and studying these rare cells have precluded a direct analysis of telomere maintenance mechanisms in stem cells from patients with DC. In skin fibroblasts, telomerase expression is silenced, but during reprogramming the
TERT gene is reactivated and telomerase activity is reconstituted
1,15–17. DC iPSCs have been used to study telomerase reactivation and TERC regulation during reprogramming, but thus far disease-specific iPSCs have not recapitulated telomere shortening
15.
To study DC in patient-derived iPSCs, fibroblasts from five patients carrying different mutations in
TERT (P704S and R979W),
TCAB1 (H376Y/G435R) and
DKC1 (DKC1_L54V and ΔL37) were transduced with retroviruses or lentiviruses expressing the reprogramming factors
SOX2,
c-Myc,
KLF4 and
OCT4 (
Supplementary Tables 1, 2). DC fibroblasts were resistant to reprogramming in ambient oxygen, but successful reprogramming was achieved under low oxygen conditions (5% O
2), a method that mitigates cellular stress responses
18 (
Supplementary Table 1). To generate isogenic iPSCs with the DKC1_ΔL37 mutation but with long telomeres, we reprogrammed DKC1_ΔL37 fibroblasts in which TERT and TERC were stably overexpressed, which bypasses the effects of the dyskerin mutation
19 (DKC1_ΔL37_TT iPSCs). The resulting iPSCs from DC patients were morphologically indistinguishable from human embryonic stem cells (hESCs), were positive for all markers of pluripotency tested and gave rise to cells derived from all three germ layers (
Supplementary Fig. 1–6).
Both autosomal dominant
TERT mutation-positive patients presented with bone marrow failure and short telomeres, but lacked the epidermal triad (;
Supplementary Fig. 7a,
Table 2). To assess the effects of the mutations on telomerase catalytic activity, wild-type or mutant TERT proteins were assembled into telomerase in human 293T cells. Following immunopurification, telomerase activity of each reconstituted enzyme was analyzed using a quantitative direct enzymatic assay (). For each mutant TERT, the enzymatic activity of reconstituted telomerase was reduced by 90%, and the defect was not suppressed by the telomere-binding proteins POT1 and TPP1, which enhance processivity
20 (
Supplementary Fig. 8). In the iPSCs derived from these patients, TERT mRNA and TERC were upregulated similarly compared with wild-type iPSCs by RT-PCR and Northern blot, respectively (). Both dyskerin and TCAB1 were strongly upregulated by Western blot with reprogramming (). Telomerase activity in both TERT-mutant iPSCs was reduced by approximately 50% compared to wild-type iPSCs, consistent with our findings that each mutant TERT protein retains only 10% residual activity, which when added to the activity from the wild-type allele would be predicted to yield 55% total activity in a heterozygote (). Thus, our findings in TERT-mutant iPSCs are compatible with a mechanism of telomerase haploinsufficiency, whereby a 50% reduction in activity is the cause of disease in this form of DC
21,22.
The patient with compound heterozygous mutations in
TCAB1 presented with classical symptoms of DC, including very short telomeres (;
Supplementary Fig. 7b,
Table 2). TERT, TERC, and dyskerin were each appropriately upregulated in TCAB1-mutant iPSCs, whereas TCAB1 protein levels were markedly reduced ()
13. Although patients with mutations in
TCAB1 have short telomeres, telomerase activity was unperturbed by
TCAB1 mutations and indistinguishable from activity in wild-type iPSCs (). TCAB1 is enriched in Cajal bodies, nuclear sites of ribonucleoprotein modification and assembly, and is required for trafficking of telomerase to Cajal bodies
23,24. Whereas TCAB1 colocalized in discrete foci with the Cajal body marker p80-coilin in wild-type iPSCs, TCAB1-mutant iPSCs exhibited a dramatic reduction of TCAB1 accumulation in Cajal bodies (;
Supplementary Fig. 9a; p<0.0001). Dyskerin normally accumulates both in Cajal bodies, where it binds small Cajal Body RNAs (scaRNAs) and TERC, and in the nucleolus, where it binds H/ACA small nucleolar RNAs (snoRNAs). Efficient accumulation of dyskerin in Cajal bodies requires functional TCAB1
13. TCAB1-mutant iPSCs showed a significant reduction in dyskerin accumulation in Cajal bodies, whereas nucleolar localization of dyskerin was unperturbed (;
Supplementary Fig. 9b; p<0.0001). RNA fluorescent
in situ hybridization (FISH) using probes complementary to TERC revealed that, whereas TERC localized to a single Cajal body focus in wild-type iPSCs, it dramatically mislocalized to nucleoli in TCAB1-mutant iPSCs (;
Supplementary Fig. 9c,10; p<0.0001). Together, these data show that TCAB1 mutations in patient-derived iPSCs result in mislocalization of the telomerase complex without affecting telomerase activity. Our results indicate that simple catalytic assays can falsely suggest that telomerase is active in a setting in which the telomerase enzyme is profoundly dysfunctional, results reminiscent of the first telomerase mutations in yeast
25.
Patients with X-linked DC included one with classic DC due to the DKC1_ΔL37 mutation
12,15 and another who presented with bone marrow failure, the epidermal triad and very short telomeres due to a DKC1_L54V mutation (;
Supplementary Fig. 7c,
Table 2). TERT mRNA, dyskerin protein and TCAB1 protein were upregulated appropriately following cellular reprogramming in DKC1-mutant iPSCs (). Dyskerin serves a central role in assembling telomerase and other ribonucleoprotein complexes with RNAs containing H/ACA motifs
12,26. The H/ACA motif within TERC is shared with scaRNAs and a subset of snoRNAs, involved in modification of splicing RNAs and ribosomal RNAs, respectively
26. TERC was reduced in DKC1 fibroblasts by northern blot, consistent with previous studies
12 (). Despite an upregulation of TERC with reprogramming, TERC in DKC1-mutant iPSCs remained significantly suppressed compared with wild-type iPS controls. DKC1 point mutations selectively reduced TERC levels without affecting H/ACA snoRNAs and scaRNAs recapitulating results in lymphoblasts and fibroblasts
12 (
Supplementary Fig. 11). In marked contrast to TERT-mutant and TCAB1-mutant iPSCs, all DKC1-mutant iPS clones exhibited a severe reduction of telomerase activity, ranging from 5–15% of wild-type controls (;
Supplementary Fig. 12). Overexpression of TERT and TERC restored TERC levels by northern blot and rescued telomerase activity in DKC1_ΔL37_TT fibroblasts and DKC1_ΔL37_TT iPSCs by TRAP (
Supplementary Fig. 12).
To assess the composition of the fully assembled telomerase holoenzyme in DKC1-mutant iPSCs, dyskerin and TCAB1 were immunoprecipitated from whole-cell extracts using antibodies directed against each protein. TERC was readily detected by northern blot in dyskerin and TCAB1 complexes from wild-type iPSCs. In contrast, the amount of TERC assembled with either dyskerin or TCAB1 was markedly reduced in DKC1_ΔL37 iPSCs (,
Supplementary Fig. 13). Overexpression of TERT and TERC in DKC1_ΔL37_TT iPSCs rescued the assembly defect and led to an amount of TERC in the mature holoenzyme that exceeded wild-type levels. Overall the amount of TERC in dyskerin and TCAB1 complexes in DKC1-mutant, wild-type and DKC1_ΔL37_TT iPSCs correlated directly with telomerase enzymatic activity in X-linked DC IPSCs. Thus, the reduction in both TERC and telomerase activity in DKC1-mutant iPSCs is consistent with a defect in a dyskerin-mediated assembly step, impairing the maturation of the active telomerase complex.
Upregulation of telomerase leads to significant telomere lengthening during reprogramming of wild-type fibroblasts
1,15,16(). However, in TERT-mutant iPSCs, telomere elongation during reprogramming was blunted, with telomeres in TERT-mutant iPSCs always remaining significantly shorter than in wild-type iPSCs (;
Supplementary Fig. 14). In marked contrast, telomere elongation failed in all TCAB1-mutant iPSCs and DKC1-mutant iPSCS. For both TCAB1-mutant iPSCs and DKC1-mutant iPSCs, telomeres were shorter than in their parental fibroblasts and telomeres continued to shorten as cells divided in culture ( and
Supplementary Fig. 14,15). In DKC1_ΔL37_TT fibroblasts and iPSCs, telomerase overexpression fully restored telomere elongation, with telomere lengths increasing significantly beyond those of their wild-type counterparts (). These data show that telomerase mutations can severely impair telomere maintenance in DC iPSCs, providing evidence for a defect in maintaining telomeres in DC stem cells.
With extended growth in cell culture of DKC1_ΔL37 iPSCs, telomeres continued to shorten through passage 19 and the bulk population of telomeres reached a plateau at passage 26 by Southern blot (
Supplementary Fig. 15b). Using telomere-FISH, we found that telomere signals were readily detected at all chromosome ends in wild-type iPSCs and in DKC1_ΔL37_TT iPSCs. In contrast, average telomere intensity was greatly reduced in DKC1_ΔL37 iPSCs, which also showed an increase in the number of signal-free ends (SFEs), chromosome ends lacking detectable telomere repeats ( p<0.01). Continued passage of DKC1_ΔL37 iPSCs resulted in an abrupt increase in spontaneous differentiation within iPSC colonies and the culture could no longer be maintained as undifferentiated iPSCs after passage 36. Critical telomere shortening leads to a loss of telomere capping function, which triggers a DNA damage response that activates the p53 tumor suppressor protein. The p53 pathway was strongly activated in DKC1_ΔL37 iPSCs at passage 36, as evidenced by p53 protein stabilization and induction of its downstream target p21 by western blot. No such activation of p53 was seen at passage 9, or in late passage human ES cells (). Taken together, these data show that impaired telomere maintenance in DC iPSCs can ultimately compromise self-renewal, resulting in a finite cellular lifespan.
Our data in patient-derived iPSCs provide evidence for severe defects in telomerase function and telomere maintenance in stem cells from DC patients. The spontaneous differentiation in DKC1-mutant iPSCs suggests that exhaustion of self-renewal in hematopoietic stem cells and other tissue stem cells may underlie the tissue defect in DC. Restoration of telomerase function through pharmacological or genetic means in stem cells from blood, lung or epidermal tissues may therefore provide a rational guide for therapy of DC. Data from these iPSCs provide an explanation for the longstanding clinical observation that X-linked DC is often more severe and presents at a younger age than autosomal dominant DC caused by mutations in
TERT or
TERC8. Our data indicate that effective telomerase activities in the 15%-50% range may represent a critical threshold in which telomere maintenance is particularly impaired. Thus, a reduction in telomerase activity to the 15–50% range may be necessary to yield severe phenotypes in a single generation, whereas genetic anticipation
21,22 through inheritance of heterozygous mutations in TERT for several generations may be important in eliciting disease phenotypes for autosomal dominant patients with greater than 50% residual telomerase activity. Together, our data show that many important features of a human stem cell disease are accurately recapitulated in patient-derived iPSCs, providing an iPSC-based system that is not dependent upon differentiation to probe disease mechanisms or to identify potential therapeutics.