PMCCPMCCPMCC

Search tips
Search criteria 

Advanced

 
Logo of nihpaAbout Author manuscriptsSubmit a manuscriptHHS Public Access; Author Manuscript; Accepted for publication in peer reviewed journal;
 
Nature. Author manuscript; available in PMC 2011 December 16.
Published in final edited form as:
PMCID: PMC3150833
NIHMSID: NIHMS313088

Forces between clustered stereocilia minimize friction in the ear on a subnanometre scale

Abstract

The detection of sound begins when energy derived from an acoustic stimulus deflects the hair bundles atop hair cells1. As hair bundles move, the viscous friction between stereocilia and the surrounding liquid poses a fundamental physical challenge to the ear’fs high sensitivity and sharp frequency selectivity. Part of the solution to this problem lies in the active process that uses energy for frequency-selective sound amplification2,3. Here we demonstrate that a complementary part of the solution involves the fluid-structure interaction between stereocilia and the liquid within the hair bundle. Using force measurement on a dynamically scaled model, finite-element analysis, analytical estimation of hydrodynamic forces, stochastic simulation, and high-resolution interferometric measurement of hair bundles, we characterize the origin and magnitude of the forces between individual stereocilia during small hair-bundle deflections. We find that the close apposition of stereocilia effectively immobilizes the liquid between them, which reduces the drag and suppresses the relative squeezing but not the sliding mode of stereociliary motion. The obliquely oriented tip links couple the mechanotransduction channels to this least dissipative coherent mode, whereas the elastic horizontal top connectors that stabilize the structure further reduce the drag. As measured from the distortion products associated with channel gating at physiological stimulation amplitudes of tens of nanometres, the balance of viscous and elastic forces in a hair bundle permits a relative mode of motion between adjacent stereocilia that encompasses only a fraction of a nanometre. A combination of high-resolution experiments and detailed numerical modelling of fluid-structure interactions reveals the physical principles behind the basic structural features of hair bundles and shows quantitatively how these organelles are adapted to the needs of sensitive mechanotransduction.

A hair bundle is a microscopic array of elastically interconnected, quasi-rigid, cylindrical stereocilia separated by small gaps filled with viscous endolymph. When a solid object moves through a viscous fluid, the interplay between viscosity and inertia produces a spatial gradient of fluid velocity and the shear between successive layers of fluid causes friction4. The characteristic decay length of the shear waves created by an oscillating body scales as equation M1, in which η is the fluid’s dynamic viscosity, ρ its density, and ω the angular frequency of motion5. Because this length scale greatly exceeds the distance between stereocilia, viscous forces can couple all motions within a hair bundle. On the other hand, the pivotal stiffness of individual stereocilia rootlets opposes deflection. Together, viscous forces in the endolymph, elastic forces in the stereociliary pivots and links, and at high frequencies inertial forces associated with the liquid and stereocilia masses determine all the motions within a bundle.

Although stereociliary motion can be directly measured with an interferometer (Supplementary Information section 1), a qualitative appreciation of the liquid’s movement can be obtained from the associated drag. When a fluid moves between nearby cylinders with axes perpendicular to the flow, the drag on each cylinder exceeds that on an identical cylinder placed alone in a flow with the same average velocity. At a Reynolds number well below one, this effect is strong and long-ranged6,7. One might therefore expect a drag coefficient for a hair bundle several hundred times that of an isolated stereocilium. In contrast, the measured values are of similar magnitude: for six interferometric measurements in each case, the drag coefficient for a single stereocilium is 16 ± 5 nN s m−1 whereas that for an entire bundle lacking tip links is only 30 ± 13 nN s m−1. Because we determined the drag coefficient for hair bundles that lacked tip links and displayed coherent Brownian motion, the latter value is about one-fourth that typically reported in the literature8. Note that these values resemble those calculated for geometrical solids of similar dimensions pivoting at their bases and evaluated at their tips9,10: 14 nN s m−1 for a cylinder of the size of a stereocilium and 29 nN s m−1 for a hemi-ellipsoid with the dimensions of a hair bundle. The small difference between the drag coefficients for a single stereocilium and for an entire hair bundle reveals the striking advantage that grouping stereocilia in a tightly packed array offers to the auditory system.

Although stereocilia may slide past each other quite easily, large forces are required to squeeze them together or separate them. To estimate these forces, we constructed a macroscopic model of a hair bundle with the surrounding liquid, preserving the scaling between the physical quantities of importance (Supplementary Information section 2). A simplified model of a bullfrog’s hair bundle enlarged 12,000 times was placed in a 2.2 % solution of methylcellulose, which is 5,000 times as viscous as water. A single stereocilium was pulled at speeds of 0.015–1.11 mm s−1 while the frictional force was measured. After rescaling of time, length, and mass values to those of a biological hair bundle, we estimated the drag coefficient for the small-gap separation of a single stereocilium as 1,000–10,000 nN s m−1, which is several hundredfold that for the movement of an isolated stereocilium. This order-of-magnitude demonstration confirmed that very large frictional forces oppose the squeezing motion, indicating the importance of hydrodynamics in the coupling of stereocilia.

Elastic and inertial forces become dominant in respectively the low- and high-frequency regimes of hair-bundle motion. To quantify the forces as a function of frequency, we developed a finite-element model in which we could manipulate the mechanical properties of the elastic links while representing explicitly the liquid around and between the stereocilia (Supplementary Information section 3). The model has about 800,000 degrees of freedom and is the first finite-element model to resolve the liquid motion in the gaps between stereocilia as well as in the outer boundary layer. The hair bundle is excited in the model by imposing an oscillatory displacement at varying frequencies on the kinocilium.

We first examined the model with only pivotal stiffness, hydrodynamic drag, and inertial mass (Supplementary Movie 1). At low frequencies, the viscous force is small and only the stimulated kinocilium and its tightly joined next neighbours move (Fig. 1a). The associated drag coefficient is about 5,000 nN s m−1 (Fig. 1b, inset), a value in agreement with the result obtained with the scaled dynamical model. Because frictional forces increase linearly with frequency whereas elastic coupling remains constant for a given displacement, hydrodynamic coupling progressively entrains the whole hair bundle at higher frequencies (Fig. 1a). As the squeezing modes subside, the drag coefficient per stereocilium decreases, dropping by two orders of magnitude by 100 Hz (Fig. 1b). Above that frequency the entire bundle moves as a unit (Fig. 1a).

Figure 1
Finite-element analysis of fluid-structure interactions in a hair bundle

Exciting the hair bundle and recording the linear responses at its opposite edges allowed us to compute the coherence of motion, a quantity that could be directly compared with interferometric measurements11 (Supplementary Information sections 1, 3, and 4). A hair bundle in the finite-element model with no links displays a coherence exceeding 0.6 between 100 Hz and 5 kHz until inertia intervenes at higher frequencies (Fig. 1c). Adding to the model horizontal top connectors with a stiffness of 20 mN m-1 strongly increases the coherence, especially at low frequencies, and reduces the drag (Figs. 1b and c and Supplementary Movie 2). This value for the stiffness of top connectors was chosen such that the output coherence spectrum matched the experimental observations. It is corroborated by distortion-product experiments discussed below and accords with published experimental and modelling studies1214.

Adding instead tip links with a stiffness of 1 mN m−1 introduces some elastic coupling between the stereocilia of a given column (Fig. 1c and Supplementary Movie 3), but this coupling is inefficient. For low frequencies at which hydrodynamic coupling is weak, only the excited column moves significantly. Moreover, because they are oriented obliquely, the tip links pull the stereocilia toward each other during positive deflections and allow them to separate during the complementary half-cycles. Both effects dramatically increase the drag, which originates almost entirely from the liquid within the hair bundle (Fig. 1b).

Including both horizontal top connectors and tip links increases the coherence for all frequencies below 5 kHz to 0.94 (Fig. 1c and Supplementary Movie 4), a value comparable to the experimental measurement. This model displays a low drag coefficient of 85 nN s m−1 that changes little with frequency (Fig. 1b), primarily from the external liquid but with some contribution from relative motions in the bundle, and a stiffness of 450 mN m−1 (Fig. 1d), similar to that reported for intact hair bundles8,15. Note that at frequencies below 1 kHz the tip links strongly increase the hair bundle's drag, whereas the top connectors largely suppress this effect. At higher frequencies, the liquid alone provides such a strong coupling that the tip links do not affect the drag significantly. This frequency-dependent transition between elastic and viscous regimes might explain why some high-frequency hair cells, in particular mammalian inner hair cells, apparently lack top connectors16.

We next explored the fluid-structure interactions in an analytically tractable and intrinsically stochastic model that allowed us to generate time series that could be compared directly with experiments (Supplementary Information section 5). Unlike the harmonic single-point excitation in the finite-element model, the movement in this instance was caused by the coupling of each individual stereocilium to the thermal bath through a Langevin equation. The movements between each pair of stereocilia were derived from a basis set of elementary motions, for which we solved the Stefan-Reynolds equations within the lubrication approximation (Supplementary Information section 6).

Setting the elastic coupling to zero, we obtained a damping matrix whose eigenvalues span about three orders of magnitude from the least damped collective modes to the most damped relative ones (Fig. 2a). This analysis demonstrates that low values of the drag comparable to those measured experimentally arise only when the common modes predominate. We next simulated stereociliary motions that matched the experimental records in time resolution and computed the associated coherence, which exceeded 0.95 up to 5 kHz (Fig. 2b). Changing the elastic coupling in the model revealed its importance at low frequencies, whereas viscous coupling intervened at higher frequencies.

Figure 2
Fluid-structure interactions in a stochastic model

These results show that the magnitude of the relative motion in a hair bundle depends on the balance between hydrodynamic and elastic forces. That hair bundles undergoing Brownian motion display a high coherence11 indicates that the relative mode is very small, which makes it difficult to detect and quantify. We therefore devised an experiment in which hair bundles were stimulated at physiological amplitudes to evoke channel gating and cause intrinsic oscillations at the combination frequencies (Supplementary Information section 7). Because the gating of each mechanotransduction channel in a hair bundle changes the force in the associated tip link17, it must cause a relative motion of the interconnected stereocilia that is balanced by the frictional drag and elastic linkages. Blocking the distortion products at one edge of the hair bundle while measuring the relative motion at the opposite edge allowed us to isolate and quantify the amount of splay between adjacent stereocilia during small deflections, assess the forces at play, and compare the results with our model.

In agreement with a previous report18, using a flexible glass probe attached to a hair bundle's tall edge to stimulate it at two frequencies evoked distortion products at several combination frequencies. These distortion products were robust at both edges of a hair bundle and disappeared when the tip links were disrupted by BAPTA, confirming their origin in the gating of mechanotransduction channels. We then used a stiff glass probe to stimulate the long edge of the hair bundle. The rigid probe in this key experiment prevented any internally generated motion from contaminating the signal at the tall edge, which therefore consisted purely of the two excitation frequencies. With this constraint, the distortion products were significant only at the free, short edge of the hair bundle (Fig. 3a). We related the distortion of the short-edge motion to the linear displacement by a power series. The inverse of the quadratic term of this fit was 0.14 ± 0.12μm (n = 8) for the flexible probe and 1.6 ± 0.9μm (n = 4) for the stiff probe. The distortions were therefore reduced to less than one-tenth of their original value when the bundle's tall edge was forced to follow exactly the stimulus signal. The finite-element model with viscous coupling replicated this effect with the top-connector stiffness determined independently from the other experimental data. The remaining distortions revealed that the relative movement between adjacent stereocilia was less than 1 nm, only a few times the size of a water molecule (Fig. 3a).

Figure 3
Experimental verification of model predictions

To confirm further the correspondence between experiment and modelling, we tested the prediction that removal of the horizontal top connectors should diminish the coherence (Fig. 1c) and increase the overall drag (Figs. 1b and and2a).2a). We placed hair bundles in a Ca2+-free, isoosmotic solution of mannitol that has the same viscosity as saline solution but a lower ionic strength. This medium has been reported to remove the top connectors19, and we verified the treatment’s effect by transmission electron microscopy (Supplementary Information section 8). After 20 min treatment, the top connectors were overstretched or broken, but not entirely absent (data not shown). Some elastic coupling thus persisted in mannitol. As our model predicted, the procedure decoupled the stereocilia and increased the drag, although quantitatively the effect was variable from cell to cell, presumably because of heterogeneity in the residual top connectors. For the same six cells in both conditions, the coherence between 100 Hz and 5 kHz declined from 0.96 ± 0.01 in perilymph to 0.83 ± 0.12 in mannitol (Fig. 3b). At the same time, the drag coefficient in mannitol increased to 99 ± 63 nN s m−1. Together with the close match between the coherence values in the experiment and in the models, this and the foregoing set of results confirm the accuracy of the numerical models and indicate that they capture the essential physics of the fluid-structure interactions in a hair bundle.

In conclusion, because all stereocilia and the liquid between them move in unison over the whole auditory spectrum, with the relative motions apparent only on a sub-nanometre scale, most stereocilia inside the hair bundle are shielded from the external liquid and experience little viscous drag. Although viscous forces might be thought to impair sensitivity and frequency selectivity, the hair bundle’s structure actually minimizes energy dissipation, making it easier for the active process to keep the ear tuned. The tight clustering of stereocilia even transforms liquid viscosity into an asset by using it as a simple means of achieving the concerted activation of numerous mechanosensitive ion channels.

Methods Summary

The methods used in this study are described in the Supplementary Information.

Force measurements on a scaled hair-bundle model respected the physiological character of the liquid flow.

The finite-element method provided approximate solutions to partial differential equations reflecting the hair bundle's geometry. The small amplitudes of motion allowed the elimination of non-linear terms. The velocity variable of the liquid was substituted by the time derivative of the displacement; fluid pressure was approximated by linear shape functions and the displacements of liquid and solid by quadratic ones.

The hydrodynamic forces between stereocilia were estimated analytically by solving the Stefan-Reynolds equations under the lubrication approximation, which is valid when the gaps between adjacent stereocilia are much smaller than their diameter.

Stochastic simulations based on these results were performed for a system of linearly coupled dynamic variables following a Langevin description with Gaussian white noise at room temperature. The integration procedure was validated by choosing time steps small enough to assure that the results were independent of the increment.

The robustness of our conclusions was investigated by a detailed parameter-variation study. We tested the effects of inertia and of the estimated top-connecter stiffness and confirmed the validity of our conclusions for mammalian hair bundles.

Dual-beam differential interferometry was used to record stereociliary motions with sub-nanometre spatial and sub-millisecond temporal resolution. Fourier analysis of the records was performed with the multitaper method to obtain coherence spectra as well as stiffness and drag coefficients.

Distortion products were evoked by stimulating hair bundles with calibrated glass probes. These results were used to verify the predictions of the numerical model and to measure directly the relative mode of motion between stereocilia.

Transmission and scanning electron microscopy was performed by standard techniques with minor modifications.

Supplementary Material

Acknowledgments

The authors thank A. J. Hinterwirth for assistance in constructing the interferometer and B. Fabella for programming the experimental software; M. Fleischer for help with programming the fluid finite-element; R. Gartner and A. Voigt for discussions of the finite-element model and stochastic computations; M. Lenz for discussions of stochastic computations and the analytic derivation of fluid-mediated interactions; and O. Ahmad, D. Andor, and M. O. Magnasco for discussions about data analysis. This research was funded by National Institutes of Health grant DC000241. Computational resources were provided by the Center for Information Services and High Performance Computing of the Technische Universitat Dresden. J. B. was supported by grants Gr 1388/14 and Vo 899/6 from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft. A. S. K. was supported by Howard Hughes Medical Institute, of which A. J. H. is an Investigator.

Footnotes

Supplementary Information is linked to the online version of the paper at www.nature.com/nature.

AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS: A. S. K. organized the collaboration, designed and performed the experiments, analyzed data, and wrote most of the manuscript; J. B. developed the finite-element formulation and conducted the corresponding computations, implemented the stochastic modelling, derived analytic estimates of fluid-mediated interactions, wrote the corresponding SI sections, analyzed data, and edited the manuscript; T. R. derived analytic estimates of fluid-mediated interactions, developed the stochastic models, implemented the data analysis, wrote the corresponding SI sections, and edited the manuscript; C. P. C. V. built the scaled model and performed the corresponding experiment; A. J. H. designed the experiments, performed the electron microscopy, and edited the manuscript.

Reprints and permissions information is available at npg.nature.com/reprintsandpermissions.

COMPETING INTERESTS STATEMENT

The authors declare that they have no competing financial interests.

References

1. Hudspeth AJ. How the ear's works work. Nature. 1989;341:397–404. [PubMed]
2. Hudspeth AJ. Making an effort to listen: mechanical amplification in the ear. Neuron. 2008;59:530–545. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
3. Hudspeth AJ, Julicher F, Martin P. A critique of the critical cochlea: Hopf —a bifurcation— is better than none. J Neurophysiol. 2010;104:1219–1229. [PubMed]
4. Stokes GG. On the effect of the internal friction of fluids on the motion of pendulums. Trans Cambridge Philos Soc. 1850;9:1–86.
5. Batchelor GK. An Introduction to Fluid Dynamics. Cambridge University Press; Cambridge, UK: 2000.
6. Tamada K, Fujikawa H. The steady two-dimensional flow of viscous liquid at low Reynolds numbers passing through an infinite row of equal parallel circular cylinders. Quart Journ Mech and Applied Math. 1957;10:425–432.
7. Yeom J, Agonafer DD, Han JH, Shannon MA. Low Reynolds number flow across an array of cylindrical microposts in a microchannel and figure-of-merit analysis of micropost-filled microreactors. J Micromech Microeng. 2009;19:1–10.
8. Denk W, Webb WW, Hudspeth AJ. Mechanical properties of sensory hair bundles are reflected in their Brownian motion measured with a laser differential interferometer. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 1989;86:5371–5375. [PubMed]
9. Perrin F. Mouvement brownien d’un ellipsoide (I). Dispersion dielectrique pour des molecules ellipsoidales. J Phys Radium. 1934;5:497–511.
10. Broersma S. Viscous force and torque constant for a cylinder. J Chem Phys. 1981;74:6989–6990.
11. Kozlov AS, Risler T, Hudspeth AJ. Coherent motion of stereocilia assures the concerted gating of hair-cell transduction channels. Nature Neurosci. 2007;10:87–92. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
12. Pickles JO. A model for the mechanics of stereociliar bundle on acousticolateral hair cells. Hear Res. 1993;68:159–172. [PubMed]
13. Cotton J, Grant W. Computational models of hair cell bundle mechanics: II. Simplified bundle models. Hear Res. 2004;197:105–111. [PubMed]
14. Karavitaki KD, Corey DP. Sliding adhesion confers coherent motion to hair cell stereocilia and parallel gating to transduction channels. J Neurosci. 2010;30:9051–9063. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
15. Martin P, Mehta AD, Hudspeth AJ. Negative hair-bundle stiffness betrays a mechanism for mechanical amplification by the hair cell. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2000;97:12026–12031. [PubMed]
16. Verpy E, et al. Stereocilin connects outer hair cells stereocilia to one another and to the tectorial membrane. J Comp Neurol. 2011;519:194–210. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
17. Howard J, Hudspeth AJ. Compliance of the hair bundle associated with gating of mechanoelectrical transduction channels in the bullfrog's saccular hair cell. Neuron. 1988;1:189–199. [PubMed]
18. Jaramillo F, Markin VS, Hudspeth AJ. Auditory illusions and the single hair cell. Nature. 1993;364:527–529. [PubMed]
19. Neugebauer DC, Thurm U. Surface charges of the membrane and cell adhesion substances determine the structural integrity of hair bundles from the inner ear of fish. Cell Tissue Res. 1987;249:199–207.