The role of primary cilia in the neonatal and adult mouse kidney was studied by conditional inactivation of
Kif3a, which encodes a kinesin-II subunit that is required for ciliogenesis. Kidney-specific inactivation of
Kif3a in newborn mice beginning at P2 resulted in the loss of primary cilia and the formation of kidney cysts. These results confirmed that inhibition of IFT and loss of primary cilia produces PKD. In contrast, kidney-specific inactivation of
Kif3a in adult mice caused no histological abnormalities within 4 weeks after tamoxifen administration. The absence of rapid cyst formation in adult
Kif3a mutant mice was observed despite a comparable loss of primary cilia: The percentage of
lacZ-positive cells that contained cilia was reduced from 57 to 14% in the adult
Kif3a mutant mice that did not develop cysts. A similar reduction in cilia formation from 54 to 11% was observed in newborn Pkhd1/Cre;
Kif3aflox/− mice that developed cysts. Although the loss of cilia in adult
Kif3a mutant mice did not result in cyst formation within 4 weeks after tamoxifen administration, it is possible that these mice would have developed kidney cysts had we analyzed them at later time points. Our findings are consistent with a recent study from Davenport
et al. (
25) who showed that inhibition of IFT at E16.5, either by inactivation of
Tg737 or
Kif3a, caused very severe cystic disease soon after birth. However, inhibition of IFT in adult mice did not cause kidney cyst formation until after 6 months. Collectively, these results suggest that disruption of IFT during embryogenesis (
25) or soon after birth (our results) causes kidney cyst formation. However, disruption of IFT in adult mice does not cause cyst formation in the short term (4 weeks).
To explore the mechanism for the distinct effects of
Kif3a inactivation and loss of primary cilia in adult and newborn mice, we examined the role of cell proliferation. Here, we provide three lines of evidence that the formation of kidney cysts in
Kif3a mutant mice is dependent on elevations in the basal rate of cell proliferation in the renal tubules. First, we showed that the absence of cysts in older mice correlated with a decrease in cell proliferation in the kidney. The proliferative activity in the postnatal kidney was measured at various ages after birth by staining mitotic cells with an Ab against phosphohistone H3. In newborn mice, in which inactivation of
Kif3a produced kidney cysts, 0.99% of the cells in the kidney were undergoing mitosis. In adult mice that did not develop kidney cysts, only 0.06% of the cells were undergoing mitosis. Although a requirement for cell proliferation would explain the age-dependence of cyst formation, inactivation of
Kif3a at P10 and P14, when the rates of cell proliferation were still higher than in the adult, did not result in the rapid formation of kidney cysts. These results suggested that a threshold of cell proliferation must be exceeded or that increased cell proliferation is only one of several factors responsible for the higher rate of cyst formation in newborn mice compared with older mice. Other mechanisms that may explain the differences in the phenotype observed at different ages include the transcriptional programming of kidney cells, which is markedly different in the postnatal period compared with the adult (
26).
Additional support for the role of cell proliferation was provided by the differences in the frequency of cyst formation in different nephron segments at various stages of development. Inactivation of
Kif3a in postnatal mice produced cysts that originated primarily from the loops of Henle (74% from loops of Henle and 22% from collecting ducts). In contrast, inactivation of
Kif3a during embryonic development produced cysts that originated primarily from collecting ducts (73% from collecting ducts and 5% from loops of Henle) (
14). This difference in the origins of the cysts was not explained by differences in the efficiency of Cre/loxP recombination, since the recombination rate was actually higher in collecting ducts than in the loops of Henle in postnatal mice treated with tamoxifen. Instead, the frequency of cyst formation correlated with the relative rates of cell proliferation in different nephron segments in the postnatal kidney. The proliferative activity of cells in the postnatal loops of Henle was 4-fold higher than in the collecting ducts, which was similar to the observed ratio of cyst formation in these nephron segments. In rodents, much of the development and elongation of the loops of Henle occurs after birth, and previous studies have shown that the proliferative activity in the postnatal loops of Henle is higher than in the proximal and distal tubules (
27). Moreover, the highest rate of cell proliferation in the loop of Henle is in the cells near the cortico-medullary junction, which may explain the abundance of cysts in this location.
A third line of evidence supporting the role of cell proliferation in inducing cyst formation in
Kif3a mutant mice was provided by studies in mice with acute kidney injury. Following AKI, the kidney has a remarkable capacity to regenerate by cellular proliferation (
22,
23). To test whether inducing proliferation by AKI caused cyst formation, adult
Kif3a mutant mice were subjected to unilateral renal IRI. We have previously shown that renal regeneration after IRI is primarily mediated by proliferation of surviving tubular epithelial cells (
23).
Kif3a mutant mice that were subjected to renal IRI developed cysts in the injured kidney within 2.5 weeks. No cyst formation was observed in the uninjured contralateral kidney or sham-operated
Kif3a mutant mice despite the comparable loss of cilia in the recombined tubules. These results indicated that injury and/or tubular regeneration trigger cystogenesis in adult
Kif3a mutant mice and supported the hypothesis that cell proliferation stimulates cyst formation. To our knowledge, these studies are the first to show that AKI stimulates cyst formation in an animal model of PKD. Further studies will be required to determine whether stimulating cell proliferation by other means also induces cyst formation in adult
Kif3a mutant mice. In addition, AKI may have other effects besides increasing cell proliferation that stimulate cyst formation.
Following AKI, the surviving renal tubular cells transiently lose epithelial characteristics such as apical–basal polarity and differentiation markers. Similar properties are exhibited by epithelial cells from cystic kidneys. However, unlike the injured kidney where recovery is marked by re-establishment of the differentiated epithelial state, the epithelium of the cystic kidney remains persistently dedifferentiated (
28). Based on these observations, it has been hypothesized that progression of cystic disease may result from failure of complete recovery after kidney injury (
29). Our studies provide
in vivo evidence directly linking kidney injury to cyst formation. Our findings may also explain the focal nature of cyst formation and the variability in the severity of cystic disease observed in humans affected with PKD, even among those carrying the same gene mutation. Individual differences in exposure to factors that cause subclinical kidney injury and tubular regeneration may contribute to the variability in cyst formation. Taken together, these results provide a mechanistic explanation for the differences in cyst formation at various ages after disruption of IFT. Disruption of IFT in the setting of elevated rates of cell proliferation (postnatal development or repair after AKI) causes kidney cyst formation, which suggests that baseline proliferation plays a permissive role in cyst formation.
To elucidate the mechanism by which disruption of IFT in the setting of high rates of cell proliferation leads to cyst formation, we analyzed pre-cystic kidney tubules from newborn Pkhd1/Cre;
Kif3aflox/− mice. Pkhd1/Cre;
Kif3aflox/− mice developed cysts in the renal collecting ducts only after P14, which permitted analysis of pre-cystic tubules in newborn mice at younger ages. Analysis of mutant mice at P7–P10 prior to the onset of cyst formation at P14 revealed that primary cilia were absent in
lacZ-positive tubular epithelial cells. These results indicated that inactivation of
Kif3a led to the loss of primary cilia prior to the onset of cyst formation. Surprisingly, the rates of cell proliferation in pre-cystic tubules in mutant mice were similar to the rates in control littermates. These results indicated that the loss of primary cilia did not stimulate cell proliferation prior to the onset of cyst formation. Rather than increased rates of cell division, we found that the loss of primary cilia produced abnormalities in the orientation of cell division as a manifestation of aberrant planar cell polarity (PCP). PCP is defined as polarity along a tissue plane that is perpendicular to the apical–basal axis (
30). PCP is involved in the establishment of epithelial polarity, convergent-extension movements during embryogenesis, ciliogenesis and oriented cell division (
30). In mice, PCP signaling is required for the normal development of the kidney. By orienting the direction of cell division along the longitudinal axis of the nephron, PCP signaling is thought to permit the elongation of tubules without changing their diameter (
6). Fischer
et al. (
24) were the first to identify abnormalities of PCP in two murine models of PKD, the
Pck rat and kidney-specific HNF-1β knockout mice. Measurements of the orientation of mitotic cells in pre-cystic tubules revealed that rather than dividing parallel to the longitudinal axis of the tubule, the cells in the mutant animals divided in more a random orientation that would be predicted to cause tubular dilatation. These results suggested that PKD arises from defects in PCP that manifest as abnormalities in the orientation of cell division within the plane of the tubular epithelium. To define the role of primary cilia in PCP, we measured the orientation of cell division in pre-cystic renal tubules from
Kif3a mutant mice. In control mice, cells divided along an axis that was parallel to the longitudinal axis of the tubules. However, in the
Kif3a mutant mice that lacked primary cilia in the kidney, the orientation of cell division was shifted towards a more random orientation. These studies are the first to demonstrate that primary cilia are required for the maintenance of PCP in the mammalian kidney and the loss of cilia produces aberrant PCP prior to cyst formation.
The mechanism by which primary cilia regulate PCP in the kidney is not known. It has been shown that PCP signaling provides a polar bias for ciliogenesis by influencing the actin cytoskeleton and arrangement of the microtubules (
31). Moreover, once the cilia are formed, fluid flow has been shown to further refine the planar polarity of the cilia within the tissue (
32). It has also been reported that in response to fluid flow, the ciliary protein inversin causes upregulation of PCP signaling (
33). Based on these findings it is has been suggested that the primary cilium aids in the propagation of PCP signaling by (i) signaling in response to flow or an unidentified ligand(s) and (ii) providing a vectorial cue to the centrioles of the dividing cells so that mitotic spindles form in the correct orientation (
34). Abnormalities of PCP in PKD were first described in rodents with mutations of the transcription factor HNF-1β or its downstream target gene,
Pkhd1 (
24). The
Pkhd1 gene product, fibrocystin, is localized on primary cilia. These findings suggest that alterations in PCP in
Kif3a mutant mice might arise from loss of the ciliary function or localization of fibrocystin. Consistent with this hypothesis, Kaimori
et al. (
35) have shown that fibrocystin undergoes proteolytic cleavage releasing an extracellular fragment from the cilium into the tubule fluid. The concentration gradient of fibrocystin cleavage products in the tubule fluid may be important for establishing PCP. Alternatively, abnormalities in PCP may arise from alterations in the balance between canonical and non-canonical Wnt signaling (
6). In this regard, we have previously shown that kidney-specific inactivation of
Kif3a leads to accumulation of nuclear β-catenin and increased expression of c-Myc, possibly reflecting activation of canonical Wnt signaling (
14).
In summary, our results demonstrate that primary cilia maintain normal tubular diameter through PCP signaling. Loss of primary cilia does not stimulate cell proliferation per se. Rather, the loss of cilia perturbs PCP signaling causing randomization of the orientation of cell division. In settings where cell proliferation is increased, such as during kidney development or following AKI, the randomization of cell division leads to tubular dilatation and kidney cyst formation. Since human PKD is thought to involve dysfunctional cilia due to mutations in ciliary proteins, these processes may also underlie cyst formation in individuals affected with PKD.