Our study shows that, in obese individuals with T2DM, moderate weight loss with ILI sustained over a 1-year period was sufficient to achieve significant reductions in PAI-1 levels when compared to usual care and that improvements in fitness, glucose control and HDL-C with ILI contributed, independently of adiposity change, to the lowering of PAI-1 levels. Finally, and contrary to our initial hypothesis, ILI did not change fibrinogen or D-Dimer levels, pointing to complex physiological relationships between PAI-1 inflammation and coagulation balance.
PAI-1 levels are elevated in diabetes, in this study over twice those in healthy subjects in the Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis (MESA; assays also performed at the Vermont LCBR)
20 and higher than those seen in non-diabetic obese
12 or pre-diabetic adults.
13 In support of our main hypothesis, ILI effected a greater reduction in PAI-1 levels (29% from baseline) than did usual care (2.5% reduction) in our obese diabetic participants. The relatively large decline in PAI-1 levels seen in this study is similar to the reduction observed in less obese subjects without diabetes
12, 13 and was associated with a reduction in measures of adiposity. ILI participants reduced baseline weight by 8.7%, whereas DSE participants experienced less than a tenth of that change. Reductions in measures of both central and overall obesity were associated with the decrease in PAI-1 levels. Of interest, ILI was able to decrease PAI-1 to levels well within the normal range despite the presence of persisting obesity after the intervention (mean BMI at 1-year with ILI was 33.1 kg/m
2, down from 36.3). In obesity, activated macrophages and T cells accumulate in adipose tissue, shifting adipokine secretion towards a pro-inflammatory pattern.
21, 22 Of these adipokines, tumor necrosis factor–α (TNF-α) and transforming growth factor (TGF)-B appear to play an important role.
9,11 It has been postulated that the adipocyte microenvironment acquires a pro-inflammatory phenotype when local angiogenesis cannot keep up with the expanding adipose tissue mass.
23 It is possible that moderate weight loss in individuals who remain obese is sufficient to allow adipose tissue to reach a new balance between tissue mass and perfusion, decreasing pro-inflammatory adipokine production and reducing PAI-1 levels.
In agreement with our second hypothesis, improvement in metabolic factors and fitness decreased PAI-1 levels independently of changes in adiposity. ILI achieved a mean 0.7% reduction in HbA1c, an increase of 4.4 mg/dL in HDL-C and a 19% increase in fitness. Improvement in each of these metabolic factors, after accounting for demographic, medical history and medication covariates, explained 2–6% the variance in PAI-1 change (30–34% of the variance in PAI-1 change with ILI) at one year. The effect of each of the metabolic factors persisted in the full model after accounting for adiposity change. Recent work suggests that in obesity, oxidative stress accumulates in adipose tissue leading to the increased production of pro-inflammatory adipokines and of PAI-1.
24 Hyperglycemia is an kinducer of pro-inflammatory adipokine production and an oxidative mechanism has been shown to mediate these effects and the secretion of PAI-1.
25, 26 The beneficial effects of fitness on PAI-1 levels in our participants may be associated with those of regular moderate physical activity on adipose tissue function, including the promotion of antioxidant mechanisms,
27 an improvement in insulin sensitivity,
28 the modification of autonomic tone
29 and the redistribution of HDL subfractions with a shift from the smaller HDL-3 to the larger more cardioprotective HDL-2 subfraction.
30 Although we did not measure lipoprotein sub-fractions, others have shown that HDL-3, but not HDL-2, increases adipocyte PAI-1 secretion
in vitro.
31 This differential effect of HDL subfractions on adipokine secretion is thought to be ceramide-mediated and adds to potential effects of HDL on adipocyte cholesterol and adipokine secretion.
32, 33 HDL is also known to bind to macrophages, cells known to be present in the stromal fraction of adipose tissue, where the anti-inflammatory lipoprotein could contribute to lower PAI-1 levels by decreasing oxidative stress.
34Our data did not support our hypothesis that reductions in PAI-1 levels with ILI would be associated with changes in fibrinogen and D-dimer. Studies in non-diabetic individuals suggest that moderate weight loss does not alter fibrinogen levels
12, 13 and that major weight loss, in the order of a 40% reduction from baseline,
35 is necessary to see a decrease in levels. Fibrinogen is an acute phase protein, but unlike PAI-1, it is synthesized only in liver and not subject to adipose tissue control. We know, from previous work in Look AHEAD, that ILI decreases C-reactive protein (CRP), another marker of systemic inflammation.
36 Recent data suggest that, like PAI-1, CRP is synthesized not only by hepatocytes but also by several non-hepatic cells including adipocytes.
37, 38 The unaltered fibrinogen levels with ILI suggest that the effects of moderate improvements in adiposity, metabolic control and fitness on inflammation in obese people with T2DM may be derived from improvements in adipose tissue function rather than in relation to changes in the acute phase response. Although non-adipose tissue sources of PAI-1, including liver, endothelial cells and platelets, could have contributed to the change in PAI-1 levels with ILI in our study, studies investigating the origin of circulating PAI-1 suggest that the source of PAI-1 may differ by age and health status and that, in obesity, adipose tissue is a major source.
8, 39, 40 Our results are also in agreement with a factor analysis in healthy individuals that showed that PAI-1 clustered with a body mass factor and not with an IL-6 dependent inflammatory factor that included fibrinogen.
41The absence of associated changes in D-dimer with ILI, despite the important reduction in PAI-1 levels, was unexpected. PAI-1 is a major regulator of fibrinolysis
3 and D-dimer a measure of ambient coagulation balance that includes intraluminal fibrinolysis.
42 Both coagulation (resulting in fibrin formation) and fibrinolysis (resulting in clot dissolution) have to occur for D-dimer to be formed.
42 Similar findings have been observed with weight loss in younger less obese persons without diabetes.
12 Our results may be explained by the relatively normal D-dimer levels found in our stable ambulatory participants with T2DM, levels that indicate that on-going fibrin formation and dissolution were not elevated. Based on these findings one could hypothesize that elevated PAI-1 may exert an effect on clotting only in the setting of a relatively large stimulation, such as that occurring in the presence of a ruptured atherosclerotic plaque. An alternative hypothesis would be that if there were to be a CVD benefit associated with a decline in PAI-1 with ILI it would not be through regulation of on-going, so-called “ambient” coagulant balance and blood-based clot formation, but rather through its effect in the vessel wall.
4 PAI-1 expression in the vessel wall is increased in the presence of diabetes
43 and Sobel has proposed a deleterious effect of elevated tissue-based PAI-1 on vessel remodeling, leading to an increased risk of plaque rupture.
4Our study has several limitations. First, our PAI-1 assay measured total PAI-1 and was not specific for the active form. However, preliminary experiments in our laboratory found that it correlates highly with two frequently used assays: one measuring uncomplexed PAI-1 (active and latent free PAI-1; in-house immunoassay; R= 0.82) and a commercial assay measuring total PAI-1 (BioPool Tintelize immunoassay;R = 0.80). Furthermore, PAI-1 antigen and activity are strongly correlated (R = 0.77).
44 Given the relatively stringent blood collection requirements for an activity assay, coupled with the multi-center nature of Look AHEAD, and the fact that much of the epidemiological data linking PAI-1 to CVD was assembled with assays for either uncomplexed or total PAI-1 (e.g.,
1), we chose the automated total PAI-1 assay. We also evaluated the use of citrate plasma compared to a specialty collection tube (Biopool Stabilyte, Trinity Biotech USA) and found excellent correlation (R=0.99). Second, Look AHEAD did not measure insulin levels and the effects of insulin on PAI-1 change could not be directly assessed. It is possible that the association of hyperglycemia and PAI-1 could be explained in part by the presence of hyperinsulinemia. However, there is ample evidence that hyperglycemia is able to increase PAI-1 secretion independently of insulin change.
26, 45In summary, our findings show that ILI decreases and normalizes PAI-1 levels in stable obese diabetic persons when compared to usual care and that the decrease is associated not only with moderate reductions in adiposity, but also with improvements in fitness, glucose and HDL-C levels, factors known to impact adipose tissue function and pro-inflammatory adipokine production. The absence of effects on fibrinogen, an acute phase reactant, supports the position that the decreases in PAI-1 levels with ILI result mainly from its effects on adipose tissue inflammation rather than as a consequence of systemic changes in inflammatory status. Finally, we show that despite the large reduction in PAI-1 with ILI, there were no changes in D-dimer, a marker of ambient coagulation balance. These results support expanding the role of PAI-1 to that of a marker of adipose tissue health. Future results from Look AHEAD will determine if decreases in PAI-1 levels with ILI will reduce cardiovascular events.