In previous studies, we demonstrated that HSV-1 preferentially establishes latency in neurons recognized by MAb A5, while HSV-2 preferentially establishes latent infection in neurons recognized by MAb KH10 (
21,
28). In the studies described in the present work, we report that dissociated adult trigeminal neurons are relatively nonpermissive for productive infection with HSV. At an MOI of 10, only about 20% of the cultured neurons became productively infected; even at an MOI of 100, only 45% of the cultured neurons supported productive viral infection. Data from studies with KOS/58 indicate that this was not a consequence of limited viral entry or uncoating of the genome. Furthermore, we show that neuronal subtypes were not equally permissive for productive infection; when we specifically evaluated the ability of A5
+ neurons to support productive infection, <5% were permissive at an MOI of 100, an inoculum presumably much greater than biologically relevant levels. Forty percent of the non-A5
+ population also failed to support productive HSV-1 infection at this high MOI, indicating that other neuronal populations are also refractory to productive infection. These results correlate well with our previous
in vivo reports indicating that HSV-1 preferentially establishes latent infection in A5
+ neurons, with approximately 50% of HSV-1 latent sites located in A5
+ neurons, although only about 11% of the neurons in the trigeminal ganglion are A5
+ (
52). This would suggest that HSV-1 enters a quiescent or latent state in A5
+ neurons because these neurons cannot support productive HSV-1 infection. In contrast, our work demonstrates that A5
+ neurons and non-A5
+ neurons support productive HSV-2 infection equivalently, suggesting that the restriction by A5
+ neurons for productive infection is specific for HSV-1. This result also correlates with our previous finding that latent HSV-2 infection is found infrequently in A5
+ neurons (
28). Thus, productive infections with HSV-1 and HSV-2 are regulated differently in different types of neurons in the trigeminal ganglion.
The neuronal composition of the trigeminal and dorsal root ganglia is heterogeneous, and these ganglia undergo significant change during embryogenesis, as well during the first several weeks of life. During embryonic development, approximately 80% of rodent ganglionic neurons require NGF for survival. Postnatally, a population of small neurons that is selectively labeled by the lectin IB4 and is identical to the KH10
+ population stops expressing TrkA (the high-affinity NGF receptor) and starts expressing Ret and GDNF receptor alpha (GFRα), switching their dependence from NGF to GDNF (
3,
33). This postnatal reduction in the percentage of TrkA
+ neurons occurs gradually over 3 weeks (postnatal day 1 [P1] to P21), coinciding with the critical period during which alteration of neurotrophins can permanently alter the physiology of neonatal dorsal root and trigeminal ganglion neurons (
19,
25). Downregulation of TrkA by IB4-binding neurons results in differences in expression profiles and signaling cascades in response to certain classes of stimuli (
33,
39,
53). Between P1 and P6, the neuronal expression of somatostatin, FRAP, P2X3, and oligosaccharide conjugates (which include lactoseries carbohydrates recognized by MAbs A5 and KH10) changes dramatically in response to GDNF (
18,
48). These differences are significant because A5
+ neurons, which are nonpermissive for productive HSV-1 infection
in vitro and maintain the latent HSV reservoir
in vivo, are mostly TrkA positive, while the IB4-labeled, KH10
+ neurons, which support productive infection with HSV-1, express the GDNF receptor. Neonatal and adult sensory neurons also differ in their responses to injury. IB4-binding neurons are selectively vulnerable to neonatal axotomy (
49), and adult neurons are more resistant than neonatal neurons to apoptotic stimuli, including phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase (PI3K) inhibition and NGF withdrawal (
47). Finally, although adult ganglionic neurons differ in size (both
in vitro and
in vivo), cultured neonatal neurons are homogeneous in size (
19). Thus, neonatal cultures may lack specific neuronal populations as well as important regulatory signaling cascades and functional properties critical to the regulation of HSV infection in the fully developed nervous system.
During productive infection, HSV undergoes tightly regulated temporal expression of productive-cycle genes. Assuming that acute infection of neuronal cultures follows a similar cycle, our work strongly suggests that the block to productive HSV-1 infection in A5-positive neurons occurs at or before the level of viral IE gene expression. It is clear that many cellular factors regulate the expression of HSV-1 immediate early genes, including Oct-1, Oct-2, and HCF, and it is likely that specific cellular factors present in the biochemically distinct neuronal populations of the sensory ganglia play a role in initiating or repressing HSV immediate early genes, which in turn regulate productive versus latent infection within specific neuronal cell types. Mechanistically, the most widely accepted view of latency establishment is a failure of IE gene activation (
16,
17,
22), which we observed in the A5
+ neurons in the TG cultures after infection with HSV-1. Chromatin modulation, regulatory microRNAs, and cellular localization of specific neuronal factors are proposed mechanisms that could differentially regulate IE gene transcription in different types of sensory neurons (
7,
23). Chromatin structure modulation plays an important role in transcriptional regulation in neurons (
36,
38), and proposed mechanisms of HSV chromatin modulation include host cell factor 1 (HCF-1)-mediated recruitment of lysine-specific demethylase 1 (LSD-1) to viral immediate early promoters (
26,
34) and HSV IE promoter repression by Nab2 (
42), early growth response gene 1 (Egr-1) (
2), or the repressor element 1 silencing transcription factor (REST)/neuronal restrictive silencer factor (NRSF)/corepressor for element 1 silencing transcription factor (CoREST) complex (
15,
35). MicroRNAs also play an important role in the transcriptional regulation of neurons (
24,
44) and have been proposed to regulate productive HSV infection by silencing the expression of ICP0 (
43,
45) and/or ICP4 (
40,
45).
In the current study, we also demonstrated that HSV-1 established a quiescent infection with LAT expression in cultured adult murine trigeminal ganglion neurons and that the quiescent infection, like latent infection
in vivo, represented a reactivation-competent state. Of interest, only about one-third of the quiescently infected neurons had detectable expression from the viral LAT promoter. These data are consistent with those of previously reported studies in which approximately one-third of the infected cells expressed the LAT at latent time points (
8,
30). We have shown previously that the LAT region, specifically exon 1, appears to regulate the neuron type-specific establishment of latency (
5), and it is well known that a number of different host cell factors, including Oct-1, HCF-1, Sp1, CREB, GRB-2, EGR-1, AP2, and AP1, regulate gene expression from this region of the viral genome (reviewed by Millhouse and Wigdahl in 2000 [
32]). We were able to reactivate HSV-1 from its quiescent state by treating the cultures with TSA, a histone deacetylase inhibitor. However, HSV-1 was not reactivated equivalently from all types of neurons in response to the TSA treatment. A5
+ neurons, which were nonpermissive for productive infection at earlier time points, were also largely nonpermissive for reactivation induced by the histone deacetylase inhibitor, indicating that either A5
+ neurons may be completely nonpermissive for HSV-1 replication and reactivation in general or mechanisms other than those involving histone deacetylases are responsible for inducing reactivation in A5
+ neurons. Our studies did not, however, address the possibility that the reactivating cell population derives from a proportion of neurons that survived initial lytic infection, and they did not determine whether this population initially established quiescence immediately upon infection. Since the LAT is not expressed equally in all latently infected neurons and the virus is not reactivated equally from all neuronal populations, dissociated adult trigeminal neurons that maintain neuronal heterogeneity in culture will likely be useful for determining the specific mechanisms regulating LAT expression and the role it plays in the establishment of latency and reactivation from a latent state.
Although previous
in vitro models of HSV neuronal infection have been valuable for studying several aspects of HSV pathogenesis, most are limited or restricted in their use for investigating the mechanisms regulating the preferential establishment of latency in different neuronal subtypes. We believe that our
in vitro model of HSV infection detailed here using dissociated adult murine trigeminal neuron cultures is superior in many respects. These cultures maintain neuronal heterogeneity with proportions of A5
+ and KH10
+ neurons nearly identical to those found
in vivo. Furthermore, HSV infection of these neuronal cultures leads to a heterogeneous outcome, with productive infection in some neurons and quiescent infection in others, without the use of acyclovir to suppress lytic growth. Thus, the system that we have developed models a number of
in vivo characteristics of HSV infection not modeled by PC12 cells, sympathetic neurons, or embryonic/neonatal sensory neurons. However, the neuronal culture system we have described for studying HSV infection is not without its limitations. First, we were unable to maintain quiescently infected neurons for extended periods at higher MOI, as has been reported for embryonic cultures (
50,
51) or differentiated PC12 cells (
9). However, in contrast to these prior studies, we did not attempt to use acyclovir to induce or maintain a quiescent state. Second, by 5 days postinoculation, the vast majority of infected neurons no longer expressed productive-cycle genes, a finding similar to those in previous reports of
in vitro infection of neonatal DRG and TG (
1,
12). However, we found substantial well-to-well variability, and GFP-positive plaque-like formations occurred periodically after day 5 postinoculation. The relatively low frequency, and clustering, of GFP-positive neurons at these later time points in cultures previously negative for GFP expression likely represents spontaneous-reactivation events, similar to those that occur
in vivo. These spontaneous reactivations appeared to originate from an individual GFP-positive neuron and to spread to adjacent neurons, with the spread presumably limited by the pooled immunoglobulin in the culture medium. Third, we observed that satellite glial cells (SGCs) became infected early and were transformed into phagocytic cells, significantly reducing neuronal cell survival in cultures infected at high MOI. While SGCs are not the focus of this report, these observations suggest that SGCs play an important role in clearing virus in the ganglia but may also exacerbate neuronal damage in response to viral infection, consistent with previous reports (
20,
46). However, resident SGCs could not be removed from the cultures entirely without jeopardizing the health of the neurons.
In summary, we have shown that in cultured dissociated adult sensory neurons, A5+ neurons are relatively nonpermissive for productive infection with HSV-1, a finding that correlates with the selective establishment of HSV-1 latency in A5+ neurons in vivo. Using the model culture system described above, we are now poised to efficiently dissect the mechanisms that regulate preferential productive or latent infection in specific types of neurons.