Neonatologists and corticosteroids have had a long and unstable relationship.
198–201 Systemic glucocorticoids decrease inflammation and increase both surfactant synthesis and lung epithelial differentiation in the developing lung.
202,203 Irrespective of the precise mechanism, corticosteroids seem to have some benefit in treating ventilator-dependent infants at high risk for BPD. Efficacy of postnatal dexamethasone for treating ventilator dependency in BPD was first shown in 1983.
204 As postnatal corticosteroid use became routine, infants were treated prophylactically with longer courses and higher doses. This treatment practice dominated the 1990s. When Yeh et al
205 showed an increased risk of cerebral palsy in infants exposed to corticosteroids early, practices abruptly changed. A meta-analysis of controlled trials revealed a relationship between early dexamethasone exposure and cerebral palsy.
206 A major outcry ensued against steroids that limited their use, even for late disease.
207,208 Unfortunately, no distinction was made between the early, indiscriminate use of steroids and late, targeted use of this therapy. The influential statements of the American Academy of Pediatrics made it virtually impermissible to use steroids,
209 although there were occasional voices urging caution over the interpretation of the data.
210,211 This climate sabotaged an RCT that was designed to address the impact of postnatal corticosteroids on the primary outcome of neurodevelopmental outcome, which was stopped early because of a lack of equipoise.
212 Consequently, clinicians are left with broad confidence estimates for all efficacy or harm outcomes ().
| TABLE 4Efficacy of Selected Treatments for the Prevention of BPD |
The limited number of useful therapies available to prevent BPD, along with a decrease in steroid use, seemed to result in a rising incidence of BPD.
212–214 The recent meta-regression that demonstrated that corticosteroids will decrease the risk of poor neurodevelopmental outcome if an infant's baseline risk of developing BPD is >55%, along with recent updates of the Cochrane reviews, have affected our thinking.
215–217 They argue that the widespread use of steroids to prevent BPD is contraindicated but that therapy for ventilator dependency or early BPD is warranted.
218 Thus, determining an infant's risk of developing BPD becomes even more clinically important. Simple lung mechanics are unlikely to be helpful.
219 Although exhaled NO has been proposed as a marker of inflammation, whether it is a better predictor of BPD over simple clinical predictors (eg, birth weight) remains unclear.
220 However, end-tidal carbon monoxide on day-of-life 14 does predict BPD well (OR: 15.17 [95% CI: 2.02–113.8]).
221 Confirmation of this and other new predictive tools are needed.
Hence, the dexamethasone pendulum is beginning to swing back, as a recent statement from the American Academy of Pediatrics confirmed.
222 Concerns about dexamethasone have led some investigators to evaluate the use of hydrocortisone for preventing BPD.
223 A systematic review of available RCTs revealed no effect of hydrocortisone on preventing BPD.
201 However, most trials have used very low doses of hydrocortisone, especially when compared with the doses of dexamethasone used to prevent BPD. Others have advocated even lower doses of dexamethasone.
224 It remains eminently arguable that given the limited treatment options for the prevention of BPD, and its serious consequences,
225,226 the use of glucocorticoids is appropriate for specific patients at high risk of developing BPD.
203,227