We and others have recently shown that apical lipid-raft-localized functional wt-CFTR is critical for controlling the innate immune response (
7,
27,
35,
38,
44). Although the link between CFTR dysfunction and inflammatory pathophysiology of CF lung disease remains controversial (
45), recent work clarifies and discusses these findings that we have recently reviewed in detail (
11,
27). Here, we verify that CFTR is not only critical for regulating the innate immune response in epithelial cells but also regulate adaptive immune response as lack of functional CFTR confers a hyper-inflammatory phenotype to the splenocytes. It has been reported that CD4
+ T cells from CF patients, have lower IFNγ response (
46). We report here that mouse CD4
+ T cells lacking CFTR (
Cftr−/−) secrete higher amounts of IFNγ as compared to the
Cftr+/+. A recent study by Svetlana O
et al showed that although natural T regulatory cells (T regs) were increased in
Pa infected
Cftr+/+ mice, depletion of T regs did not alter the disease outcome (
47). Our original finding shows that lack of functional
Cftr was able to modulate FoxP3 expression in the lungs and the peripheral tissues indicative of increased number of T regs. The lungs of COPD patients similarly harbor higher number of T regs that are proposed to be involved in controlling pulmonary inflammation or autoimmunity (
48). We anticipate that similar mechanism may be triggered in the absence of functional CFTR and strategies directed to modulate functional T regs to revert acute or chronic lung disease warrants further investigation (
49,
50).
The pro-inflammatory response in the
Cftr-deficient mice is known to be mediated by neutrophils and macrophages, the primary cells of the innate immune response (
39,
51-
54). We evaluated if the defect in lipid metabolism in the absence of CFTR (
7) extends to these immune effector cells. For these studies we used the common
P. aeruginosa-LPS (
Pa-LPS) induced acute lung injury model (
55) that is also a component of air pollutants that cause lung inflammation (
56). Interestingly, we observed increased ceramide staining in macrophages (, left panel) but not neutrophils (, left panel) from uninfected
Cftr−/− mice, which correlated with the higher constitutive and
Pa-LPS induced pro-inflammatory cytokine levels. We also observed an increase in ZO-1 staining in both macrophages and neutrophils in the absence of
Cftr. Some recent studies support our finding and have shown the expression of tight junction proteins like ZO-2 in human macrophages (
57,
58). Our data supports the recent findings that CFTR inhibition by CFTR siRNA in human alveolar macrophages renders them a pro-inflammatory phenotype along with an increase in caveolin-1 expression, as it is related to inflammation and apoptosis in macrophages (
59). Although constitutive activation of neutrophils in CF is well documented (
44,
60), CFTR expression in neutrophils is a subject of debate. Based on current literature CFTR expression in neutrophils is either very low or absent. It may be possible that lack of CFTR regulates neutrophil function in a ceramide-independent manner. The lower expression of functional CFTR protein on murine and human neutrophils as compared to epithelial or other inflammatory cells (
52) may account for lack of ceramide accumulation in the
Cftr−/− as compared to
Cftr+/+. Moreover, a recent study inversely correlates CFTR mediated SCN(-) transport to the MPO activity (
14). We anticipate this as a potential mechanism of neutrophil activation in the
Cftr−/− mice that mediates the pathogenesis of chronic lung disease in the presence of
Pseudomonas aeruginosa (
Pa) infection or lung injury.
It is proposed that changes in sphingosine and sphingosine-1-phosphate uptake in the absence of CFTR may result in membrane ceramide accumulation (
13) that triggers a pro-inflammatory and pro-apoptotic response in the respiratory tract. Ceramide forms membrane platforms and alters small lipid-rafts that consist of sphingomyelin and cholesterol. We anticipate that ceramide accumulation in the absence of CFTR might change the function of proteins in the membrane by altering the composition of sphingomyelin-cholesterol rich lipid-rafts. In favor of this hypothesis, wt-CFTR expression in
Cftr−/− cells controls ceramide accumulation and inflammatory signaling (
13). The data also supports the critical role of membrane or lipid-raft CFTR in ceramide biogenesis and pathogenesis of lung disease (
20,
40). This raises the important question if modulation of CFTR expression in airway diseases can contribute to pathogenesis of chronic lung disease. Interestingly, cigarette smoke extract (CSE) is previously shown to inhibit chloride secretion in human bronchial epithelial cells (
61). A more direct correlation between CSE and CFTR expression was established by André M. Cantin
et al (
62), showing that CSE decreased expression of CFTR- gene, protein and function in Calu-3 cells. Our
in vitro studies in HEK-293 cells transfected with wt-CFTR confirm their observation. We document here the first report showing that decrease in CFTR expression correlates with severity [Gold 0 (at risk)
vs Gold I (mild), II (moderate), and Gold III-IV (severe and very-severe)] of lung emphysema and ceramide accumulation (). We verified that acute CS exposure of
Cftr+/+ (C57BL/6) mice decreases cell surface and lipid-raft expression of
Cftr in murine lungs (). We also found an increase in co-localization of ceramide and zona occludens (ZO)-1 () in the murine lungs, post CS exposure. In support of our findings, a recent study (
63) demonstrates that CS induces ceramide accumulation in human bronchial epithelial cells. We anticipate based on this data that ceramide accumulation and chronic
Pa infections in severe COPD patients (
5) and CF (
5,
64) may be an outcome of decreased CFTR expression.
The previous clinical studies showing the association of CFTR mutations with asthma and COPD (
17,
18,
65,
66) were not conclusive due to lack of sufficient controls. Moreover, only few reports have verified emphysema development in CF subjects (
67). Our data suggest the critical modifier role of membrane- CFTR and ceramide levels in pathogenesis of severe emphysema. Interesting question here is why CF subjects with ΔF508-mutation, resulting in very low membrane-CFTR levels, do not develop severe emphysema? The paucity of emphysema in ΔF508-CF patients may be due to the absence of other contributors like cigarette smoke or lack of detection as they die before severe emphysema is developed or recognized. Nonetheless, our data suggest that pathogenetic changes in membrane and lipid-raft CFTR may have a modifier function in pathogenesis of COPD and emphysema. We propose, based on our data that the association of apical and lipid-raft CFTR expression with COPD disease severity, ceramide accumulation and signaling has a novel clinical application as both prognostic marker and therapeutics. Further clinical studies are warranted to confirm the role of CFTR as a modifier or pathogenetic susceptibility factor for COPD, emphysema and asthma.
Since ceramide is an important component of lipid-rafts (
43), we hypothesized that disruption of raft CFTR by CD (
27) may trigger ceramide accumulation and NFκB activation. We selected CD treatment as a method to selectively deplete CFTR from the lipid-rafts over CFTR siRNA or inhibitor as it would result in an overall decrease of CFTR expression and/or function. We found that depletion of raft-CFTR by CD abrogated its regulatory function, marked by a significant increase in NFκB activity, ceramide levels and IL-8 secretion (
Supplementary Fig 3A, B).
In vivo depletion of lipid-raft
Cftr also showed an increase in ceramide, NFκB and neutrophils (
Supplementary Fig 3C) levels and activity, confirming our hypothesis that lipid-raft localized CFTR controls ceramide and NFκB mediated pro-inflammatory signaling. We further verified these results by depleting (CD treatment) (
27,
41) or inducing (TNFα) (
40,
43) lipid-raft CFTR in CFBE4lo-wt-CFTR cells and observed that lipid-raft CFTR expression controls membrane ceramide accumulation (
Supplementary Fig 4). Although we understand that CD and TNFα may modulate NFκB signaling by CFTR independent mechanisms that warrants further investigation and identification of small-molecules that can selectively modulate lipid-raft CFTR expression. Nonetheless, our preliminary studies indicate that membrane localized wt-CFTR inhibits lipid-raft formation as the expression of lipid-raft marker, ZO-1/2 was elevated in the absence of
Cftr that is known to induce immune receptor clustering and signaling (
68). We anticipate this as a potential mechanism by which CFTR regulates ceramide mediated NFκB signaling.
We and others observed that ceramide mediated lung injury and NFκB signaling is prevented by inhibiting
de novo ceramide synthesis (FB1) (
19), therefore, we tested its efficacy to suppress TNFα induced NFκB reporter activity in the presence or absence of CFTR. FB1 was able to suppress NFκB reporter activity only in the CFBE4lo-wt-CFTR cells but not in the CFBE4lo- cells (
Supplementary Fig 3D). We speculated that wt-CFTR might be regulating membrane ceramide levels, by its interaction with lipid-raft signaling complex (TNF-R1-Sphingomyelin) while FB1 suppresses the
de novo ceramide hydrolysis. We anticipated that in the
Cftr-deficient scenario, membrane ceramide accumulation is catalyzed by acid sphingomyelinase (Asm); hence inhibition of
de novo ceramide synthesis is rendered ineffective. The importance of Asm pathway in several disease models has been comprehensively reviewed (
69). Recently, Teichgräber
et al (
7) demonstrated that
Cftr−/− mice induce lung ceramide accumulation
via Asm, and its inhibition by Amitriptyline (AMT) rescued the mice from
Pa infection. A clinical trial using AMT in CF patients also demonstrates its safety and efficacy as a potent drug candidate (
70). In the present study, we demonstrate that inhibition of
de novo (FB1) or membrane ceramide (AMT) synthesis/release has differential outcomes in controlling the
Pa-LPS induced lung injury in the presence and absence of
Cftr. We found that in the presence of wt-
Cftr, inhibition of
de novo ceramide synthesis by FB1 inhibits
Pa-LPS induced NFκB activityand recruitment of neutrophils in the lungs of
Cftr+/+ mice while its inhibitory effect was significantly lower in
Cftr−/− mice indicating that wt-
Cftr depletes NFκB activity by controlling TNF-R1 or sphingomyelin (). Moreover, treatment with FB1 may not only prevent the ceramide synthesis, it may also deplete sphingomyelin levels. This may indirectly modulate the function of Asm that leads to lower ceramide generation and thereby decreased inflammation in
Cftr+/+ mice. In contrast, inhibition of Asm by AMT showed an enhanced protective effect in controlling the
Pa-LPS induced lung injury in
Cftr−/− mice as compared to the
Cftr+/+ indicating that inhibition of
de novo ceramide synthesis by FB1 can be a more potent therapeutic strategy in lung injury, emphysema and COPD where CFTR raft expression is depleted but not absent while AMT me be more effective in absence of cell surface CFTR like in case of ΔF508-CF.
The previous observations that PDZ-interacting domain in CFTR is required for its apical polarization and Cl
− channel function (
23,
24) lead us to investigate its role in CFTR-dependent ceramide and lipid-raft signaling. Our data demonstrates that the absence of CFTR PDZ-binding domain (ΔTRL) leads to (a) reduction in membrane CFTR levels (), (b) decrease in binding of
E. coli LPS to the plasma membrane () and (c) increased ceramide accumulation, in both constitutive and CSE induced states (). These findings elucidate potential mechanism by which CFTR may be sequestered to the lipid-rafts, where it regulates ceramide mediated inflammatory signaling. We anticipate binding to PDZ domain containing proteins (ZO-1/2) is required for CFTR membrane stability and lipid-raft translocation. The present study not only describes the critical role of CFTR in pathogenesis of obstructive lung diseases, but also demonstrates the scope of an intervention strategy targeting CFTR-dependent lipid-rafts and ceramide for treatment of lung injury and emphysema. In addition, we evaluate CFTR-dependent lipid-rafts as a novel biomarker for lung injury and emphysema and demonstrate its potential utility as a prognosticator of aforementioned therapeutic strategy. It remains an open question if the development of potent CFTR corrector- (CF-ΔF508) and potentiator- (COPD and emphysema) drug (currently under Phase II-III clinical trial for CF from Vertex Pharmaceuticals) may serve as an effective therapeutic strategy to overcome the ceramide-induced pathological conditions emerging from decreased membrane or lipid-raft CFTR expression. Since Vertex drugs were identified based on their ability to correct CFTR chloride transport function only (
71), we anticipate that the development of the selective strategies to modulate CFTR dependent lipid-rafts and ceramide signaling as proposed in this study will have a more specific therapeutic outcome for treating the chronic stages of lung disease.