|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
We have created a mouse genetic model that mimics a human mutation of Shank3 that deletes the C-terminus and is associated with autism. Expressed as a single copy [Shank3(+/ΔC) mice], Shank3ΔC protein interacts with the WT gene product and results in >90 % reduction of Shank3 at synapses. This “gain of function” phenotype is linked to increased polyubiquitination of WT Shank3 and its redistribution into proteasomes. Similarly, the NR1 subunit of the NMDA receptor is reduced at synapses with increased polyubiquitination. Assays of post-synaptic density proteins, spine morphology and synapse number are unchanged in Shank3(+/ΔC) mice, but the amplitude of NMDAR responses is reduced together with reduced NMDAR-dependent LTP and LTD. Reciprocally, mGluR-dependent LTD is markedly enhanced. Shank3(+/ΔC) mice show behavioral deficits suggestive of autism and reduced NMDA receptor function. These studies reveal a mechanism distinct from haploinsufficiency by which mutations of Shank3 can evoke an autism-like disorder.
Autism represents a broad spectrum of behavioral and cognitive disorders characterized by early onset deficit of language development and social interactions, accompanied by repetitive behaviors. Most cases of Autism Spectrum Disorders (ASD) are sporadic and cannot yet be linked to mutations of specific genes. Nevertheless, a significant fraction of ASD is caused by de novo or rare mutations (Geschwind, 2008). One of the most commonly associated genetic conditions is fragile X-mental retardation syndrome in which 30% of patients show symptoms of ASD. Mouse models that delete the Fmr1 gene show changes in synaptic plasticity; especially enhanced mGluR evoked long-term depression, which has been linked to cognitive deficits (Huber et al., 2002). Another ASD-linked mutation involves the Shank3 gene, also called ProSAP1/CortBP1. Shank3 is located on chromosome 22q13.3 in humans and was first implicated in ASD associated with the 22q13.3 microdeletion syndrome (also known as the Phelen-McDermid Syndrome) characterized by dysmorphic facial features, delayed expressive speech and autistic behavior (Nesslinger et al., 1994). Subsequent genetic analysis of patients with chromosome 22q13.3 deletion syndrome revealed a balanced translocation of chromosome 12 and 22 causing a disruption of Shank3 gene at exon 21, implicating the haplo-insufficiency of Shank3 gene as a causal mechanism (Bonaglia et al., 2001). More recently, heterozygous mutations in Shank3 gene have been shown to cause ASD in a gene-dosage dependent manner (Durand et al., 2007; Moessner et al., 2007). ASD cases with Shank3 mutations range from severe cases of autistic disorder to milder variants with Asperger syndrome (Durand et al., 2007). Genome wide association studies confirm the link between Shank3 mutations and ASD (Marshall et al., 2008; Sebat et al., 2007). Additionally, a Shank3 mutation is reported in association with schizophrenia (Gauthier et al., 2010).
Shank proteins are products of three related genes, Shank1-Shank3, and are expressed as a number of spliced variants. Shank proteins include 5–6 N-terminal ankyrin repeats followed by a well-conserved SH3 (Src Homology 3) domain, a PDZ (PSD95/Discs large/zona-occludens-1) domain, a proline-rich domain, and a C-terminal SAM (sterile alpha motif) domain. Homer proteins bind Shank to create a polymeric network structure that is dependent on Homer tetramerization, as well as physical interactions between Shank proteins(Hayashi et al., 2009). Human genetic studies point towards a possible role of Shank3-Homer interaction in ASD. The balanced translocation of chromosome 12 and 22 causes a disruption of exon 21, which encodes the Homer binding site (Bonaglia et al., 2001). A second instance involves two siblings heterozygous for a guanine insertion in exon 21, creating a frame shift and a truncated Shank3 protein lacking the Homer binding site (Durand et al., 2007). Point mutations elsewhere in Shank3, for instance within the ankyrin repeats, are also associated with ASD but are typically less severe than mutations with loss of the Homer binding domain (Durand et al., 2007).
To examine the importance of Shank3-Homer interaction in the pathogenesis of ASD, we generated a mouse model of Shank3 that deletes the Homer-binding domain at the C terminus (ΔC), thus mimicking the reported mutation in ASD patients (Durand et al., 2007). Here we report that the heterozygous ΔC Shank3 mutation results in a striking down-regulation of wild type (WT) Shank3. This down-regulation of Shank3 is not consistent with a simple gene-dosage model since Shank3 at excitatory synapses is reduced >90%. Instead, we find an increase in WT Shank3 that is polyubiquitinated and relocalized to proteasomes. This effect appears highly specific to Shank3 since Shank3ΔC does not result in down regulation of Shank1, Shank 2, GKAP, AMPA type glutamate receptors or most other synaptic proteins. The notable exception is the NR1 subunit of the NMDA receptor (NMDAR), which is down regulated at synapses in association with increased polyubiquitination. Assays of synaptic morphology and synapse number do not reveal differences between adult WT and Shank3(ΔC) mice. However, electrophysiological studies confirm a reduction of NMDAR responses in cortical and hippocampal neurons and reduced NMDAR-dependent LTP and LTD. Moreover, the amplitude of mGluR-LTD is increased in the hippocampus of Shank3(+/ΔC) mice. Studies of Shank3(ΔC) mice in behavioral assays reveal deficits of social interaction, consistent with ASD. Additionally, Shank3(+/ΔC) mice show enhanced locomotor responses to amphetamine and the NMDA antagonist MK-801, consistent with the reduction of NMDAR function and similar to “schizophrenia-like” symptoms reported in mouse models with reduced NR1 expression (Mohn et al., 1999). Our studies reveal a molecular pathway that may underlie neurodevelopmental disorders linked to human mutations of Shank3.
To determine how Homer affects Shank3 expression in vivo, we examined Homer-triple KO (HTKO) mice for Shank3 levels. These mice lack all Homer (1, 2, 3 and 1a) isoforms. We found an 80% reduction in Shank3 in cortical lysates using three independent Shank3 antibodies (Fig. S1A–B). Shank1 and 2 isoforms, which also bind Homer, were reduced ~50%. Similarly, cortical cultures from the HTKO mice showed ~80% reduction in Shank3 measured by immunohistochemistry (Fig. S1C–E). Single Homer1 KO mice had ~40% reduction in Shank3 (Fig. S1F). We were able to rescue the reduction in Shank3 levels in the HTKO cultures by transiently expressing full-length Homer 1c isoform (Fig. S1G), but not point mutants of Homer 1c (W24A and G89N) that do not bind Shank3 (Beneken et al., 2000), suggesting that the physical association of Homer with Shank3 is necessary to maintain Shank3 levels. We found no evidence of changes in Shank3 mRNA in the HTKO brains (Fig. S1H). These data support the notion that Homer stabilizes Shank3 protein in vivo.
Given the reduction of Shank3 in the Homer TKO and the importance of Shank3 in ASD, we generated a mouse that affords conditional deletion of exon 21 of Shank3 (Fig. S1I). Excision of exon 21 creates a frame shift such that the resulting Shank3 protein (termed ShankΔC) is predicted to lack the entire C-terminal portion of Shank3, including the Homer-binding site in the proline-rich domain and the SAM domain (Fig. S1K). We confirmed excision of exon 21 in a cross with a mouse expressing actin-Cre (Fig. S1J), and evaluated expression of Shank3 proteins using N- and C-terminal targeted Shank3 antibodies reacted with cortical lysates from WT [Shank3(+/+)], Shank3(+/ΔC) and Shank3(ΔC/ΔC) mice (Fig. 1A). Both the C-terminal antibodies (JH3025 and H160) reacted with two prominent bands (~190 and ~120 kDa) that are absent in Shank3(ΔC/ΔC), indicating that they specifically detect Shank3. The N-terminal Shank3 antibody reacted with a single band that is the same apparent MW as the largest band detected by the C-terminal antibody, and is absent in Shank3(ΔC/ΔC). Additionally the N-terminal Ab reacted with a ~90 kDa that is present in Shank(ΔC/ΔC) and Shank(+/ΔC) but absent in Shank3(+/+) (Fig. 1A). These studies confirm the specificity of antibodies and demonstrate expression of mutant Shank3ΔC protein in brain.
Since Shank3 mutations in humans are associated with ASD in a heterozygote genotype (Durand et al., 2007), we decided to analyze the Shank3(+/ΔC) mouse. Shank3(+/ΔC) mice were born with expected Mendelian frequency and appeared healthy and of normal size through development and into adulthood. Biochemical analysis of the Shank3(+/ΔC) cortical lysates of 8-week old mice revealed a 70–80% reduction in Shank3 protein levels (Fig. 1B–C) using three independent Shank3 specific antibodies (JH3025, H160 and N-term). We also assessed Shank3 levels in DIV 14–21 cortical cultures made from Shank3(+/ΔC) mice and found a similar 75% reduction in Shank3 with no change in PSD-95 or Vglut1 (Fig 1D–E). The measured loss of Shank3 in the Shank3(+/ΔC) cultures increased to 90% when we assayed in synaptic fractions (Fig. 1F), suggesting that Shank3 at the synapse is preferentially down-regulated. We did not observe changes in other Shank isoforms (Shank1 and 2) or other scaffolding molecules GKAP, PSD-95, Homer and Neuroligin-3 in cortical lysates (Fig. 1B–C). However, we did detect ~ 50% reduction in NMDAR subunit NR1 levels in the Shank3(+/ΔC) cortex without significant changes in NR2A, NR2B, AMPA (GluR1) or mGluR5 (Fig. 1B–C). Shank3 mRNA in Shank3(+/ΔC) brains was ~90% that of Shank3(+/+) (Fig. 1G) likely representing compensation from the WT allele. This indicates that the down-regulation of Shank3 protein in Shank3(+/ΔC) is not due to a commensurate reduction of Shank3 mRNA.
We examined the notion that reduced expression of WT Shank3 in the Shank3(+/ΔC) mouse might be linked to enhanced ubiquitination, since Shank proteins have been reported to be ubiquitinated (Ehlers, 2003). WT Shank3 was immunoprecipitated from cortical lysates with C-terminal Ab and assayed for polyubiquitination using the FK1 Ab (Fig. 2A). A 2 fold increase in polyubiquitinated Shank3 was evident in the Shank3(+/ΔC) mouse (Fig. 2B). Since polyubiquitination can be a signal for proteasomal degradation, we examined co-localization of WT Shank3 with a proteasomal marker Rpt6 in cortical cultures and detected a 2.5 fold increase in Shank3 puncta co-localizing with Rpt6 in cultures from the Shank3(+/ΔC) mice (Fig. 2C–D). These findings suggest that the increased polyubiquitination of Shank3 results in enhanced proteasomal degradation in Shank3(+/ΔC) mice. We found no change in total Rpt6 levels in +/ΔC cortical lysates (Fig. 2E–F) indicating that there was no global up-regulation of the proteasome.
Shank3ΔC protein is expressed in brain of Shank3(+/ΔC) mice (Fig. 2G Input) and co-immunoprecipitates with WT Shank3 in vivo (Fig. 2G). Shank3ΔC also co-IPed with WT Shank3 when these proteins were co-expressed in HEK293 cells (data not shown), indicating that Shank3 proteins can physically associate independently of their C-terminal SAM domain. The physical association of Shank3ΔC with WT Shank3 may be important for increased polyubiquitination of Shank3, although this issue will require further analysis. To confirm that Shank3ΔC is causal for enhanced degradation of Shank3, we expressed Shank3ΔC transgene in WT cortical cultures and a found a 65% reduction in WT Shank3 (Fig. 2H–I) and an ~80% reduction in synaptic Shank3 (Fig. 2J) with no reduction in Vglut1. We examined the possibility that Shank3ΔC is ubiquitinated using the N-terminal Shank3 Ab for immunoprecipitation, but failed to detect ubiquitinated-Shank3ΔC (data not shown).
We considered a model in which the disruption of Homer binding to Shank3 might result in its enhanced polyubiquitination. To negate possible effects of Shank3ΔC protein, we examined cortical lysates from Homer TKO and found a 2-fold increase in polyubiquitinated Shank3 (Fig. S2A–B). Similarly, we found 2-fold increase in Shank3- Rpt6 co-localization in cortical cultures from the Homer TKO (Fig. S2C–D). We also looked at the role of the activity-dependent dominant negative Homer isoform, Homer1a. Overexpression of Homer1a in cortical cultures resulted in 50% reduction of Shank3 (Fig. S2E–F), while the Homer1a KO mouse cortex had about a 2.5 fold increase in Shank3 (Fig. S2G–H) and a concomitant 2-fold reduction in Shank3 polyubiquitination (Fig. S2I–J). These findings suggest that interruption of Homer binding is sufficient to evoke enhanced proteasomal degradation of Shank3.
Our initial observation of NR1 reduction in cortical lysates from Shank3(+/ΔC) mice was verified in cortical synaptoneurosomal (P2) fractions, which showed ~70% reduction in NR1 with no significant changes in NR2A, GluR1, GluR2 or mGluR5 (Fig. 3A–B). Similarly, we found ~ 50% reduction in both total and surface NR1 using cortical cultures from Shank3(+/ΔC) mice (Fig. 3C–E). This decrease in NR1 levels could not be explained by a transcription defect because the NR1 mRNA levels were unaltered in the Shank3(+/ΔC) mice compared to WT (Fig. 3F). NR1 is reported to undergo ubiquitination (Kato et al., 2005); therefore we assessed whether polyubiquitination of NR1 could underlie the NR1 reduction in the Shank3(+/ΔC) mice. Cortical lysates immunoprecipitated with NR1 and assayed for polyubiquitination using the FK1 antibody (Fig. 3G) revealed a ~3 fold increase in polyubiquitinated NR1 in Shank3(+/ΔC) lysates (Fig. 3H). Similarly, NR1 expression in HTKO cortex was reduced ~50% (Fig. S3A–B) with increased polyubiquitination (Fig. S3C–D).
Since NR1 is an obligatory subunit of functional NMDAR, we predicted that a change in NR1 levels would alter NMDAR dependent synaptic responses. Using acute cortical slices from frontal cortex of 3–4 week old mice, we monitored the amplitude of evoked responses in layer 2/3 cortical neurons following stimulation of presynaptic fibers in layer 4, using conditions that separately reveal AMPA and NMDAR-dependent responses. The ratio of the NMDA/AMPA dependent responses in Shank3(+/ΔC) cortex was reduced compared to the WT mice (0.38 ± 0.07 in the Shank3(+/ΔC); 0.70 ± 0.06 in littermate WT; p<0.005) (Fig. 4A, S4A–B). The voltage dependence of the evoked AMPA current was similarly linear in WT and Shank3(+/ΔC) (Fig. S5A). The AMPAR-mediated miniature EPSCs amplitude and frequency were unaltered (WT 15.2 ± 1.2 pA, 10.3 ± 1.7 Hz; Shank3(+/ΔC) 15.4 ± 0.9 pA, 8.6 ± 0.9 Hz) (Fig. 4B and Table S1). These results are consistent with biochemical data, and suggest a selective reduction of synaptic NMDAR responses.
Shank3 has been postulated to be a scaffolding molecule with putative roles in PSD maintenance, spine morphogenesis, NMDAR and AMPAR function (Roussignol et al., 2005). Accordingly, we assessed whether changes in synaptic function might be coupled to cyto-architectural changes. We prepared EM images of layer 5 somatosensory cortex of 8 week old mice and found no change in PSD length or thickness in Shank3(+/ΔC) mice (Fig. 4C–E). We also examined spine density by labeling neurons in fixed tissue with biolistic-DiI (Fig. 4F) and performed automated counting and found no change in spine density (Fig. 4G) or spine volume (Fig. 4H–J and S4D) in 8 week old Shank3(+/ΔC) mice. Similarly, synapsin staining of DIV14–21 cortical neurons revealed identical puncta density in Shank3(+/ΔC) and WT mice (Fig. S5B–C). These data indicate that spine and synapse formation are not altered in representative regions of adolescent Shank3(+/ΔC) brain and cultured neurons, and are consistent with preservation of spontaneous mEPSC frequency and amplitude in Shank3(+/ΔC) brain. Accordingly, changes in NMDAR function are likely due to reduced expression rather than spine dysmorphogenesis or deficits of synapse formation.
We assessed whether NR1 reduction in the Shank3(+/ΔC) mice alters aspects of synaptic plasticity using acute hippocampal slices. We first examined the efficacy of Schaffer collateral-CA1 synapses by monitoring the evoked field excitatory postsynaptic potential (fEPSP) following paired pulses as an indicator of presynaptic function. This response was not different between WT and Shank3(+/ΔC) mice (Fig. S5D). Similarly, analysis of the amplitude of the presynaptic fiber volley relative to both the initial slope of the fEPSP (Fig. S5E) and the peak of the population spike (Fig. S5F) revealed no change in either relationship. The former indicates that basal synaptic efficacy was unaltered and the combination of both measures suggests that the intrinsic conductances underlying spike generation are not altered in Shank3(+/ΔC) mice.
LTP was induced by four trains of high frequency stimulation with an inter-train interval of 5 min. In WT, fEPSP increased to 170.8 ± 8.3% of baseline immediately after stimulation (t=60 min) and sustained at the level of 158.4 ± 13.8% of baseline at t=180 min (Fig. 5A). In Shank3(+/ΔC) mice the magnitude of LTP induction was significantly reduced (143.1 ± 5.6% of baseline at t=60 min after stimulation) and decayed more rapidly than WT mice (115.1 ± 4.9% of baseline at t=180 min; p<0.005, Student’s t-test). NMDAR-dependent LTD of Schaffer collateral-CA1 synapses was also reduced in Shank3(+/ΔC) mice. LTD was evoked using low frequency synaptic stimulation (LFS) and resulted in a stable reduction of synaptic strength to 82.0 ± 3.3% of baseline at t=30 min (Fig. 5B). In Shank3(+/ΔC) mice, the initial synaptic depression was not different from WT, but beginning after 20 min returned to near pre-stimulus baseline (95.7 ± 2.9% of baseline at t=30 min, p<0.05, Student’s t-test). These findings are consistent with a reduction of postsynaptic NMDAR function.
Next we examined mGluR-dependent chemical LTD in slices from 3–4 week old Shank3(+/ΔC) mice. LTD of Schaffer collateral-CA1 synapses was induced by the group I mGluR agonist, DHPG (100 μM) for 5 min. In WT slices, bath applied DHPG resulted in a stable reduction of synaptic strength (69.1 ± 5.0% of baseline at t=90 min) (Fig. 5C). In Shank3(+/ΔC) mice, mGluR-LTD by DHPG was increased (56.9 ± 3.8% of baseline at t=90 min, p<0.05, Student’s t-test). Similarly, LTD produced by paired-pulse low-frequency stimulation (PP-LFS: 1 Hz for 20 min) was increased in the Shank3(+/ΔC) mice (88.7 ± 1.9% of baseline at t=40 min in WT mice compared to 74.3 ± 4.6% of the baseline at t= 40 min in Shank3(+/ΔC) mice) (Fig. 5D). The increase of mGluR-LTD in the Shank3(+/ΔC) is similar to the increase in Fmr1 KO mice. However, unlike the Fragile X model, the mGluR-LTD increase in the Shank3(+/ΔC) mice was completely inhibited by the protein synthesis inhibitor cycloheximide (Fig. 5E), indicating that the mechanism affecting mGluR-LTD may be different in these two models.
We first examined cognitive function, as a baseline for studies of social interactions. Long-term spatial memory tested in a classic version of the Morris water maze (Fig. S6A–B) as well as short-term spatial recognition and spatial working memory (Table S2) were not different between Shank3(+/ΔC) and WT mice. In addition, a classical fear-conditioning paradigm showed that context and cue-related fear memory and extinction in Shank3(+/ΔC) mice were similar to WT (Fig. S6C–D). Shank3(+/ΔC) mice also showed normal anxiety levels (Table S2) and learning of motor skills (Fig. S6E). These data indicate that Shank3(+/ΔC) mice exhibit preserved learning and memory functions.
A separate group of Shank3(+/ΔC) mice was tested in a set of social tasks in which accessibility and familiarity of social stimuli were modulated in a controlled fashion. First, we analyzed reciprocal social interactions in a habituation-dishabituation paradigm that provides a measure of hippocampus- and amygdala-dependent social memory and has been used in mouse models associated with ASD (Ferguson et al., 2002). As expected, WT mice showed a decrease in duration of social investigation during repeated presentations of the same stimulus mouse followed by a re-activation of investigation when a novel stimulus mouse was presented (Fig. 6A). Approximately half of the WT mice showed a short single bout of aggression per trial (Fig. 6D, S6F, I). The presence of these aggression episodes did not disrupt normal habituation-dishabituation curves in WT mice(Fig. 6B–C). By contrast, Shank3(+/ΔC) mice displayed significantly lower levels of social investigation (Fig. 6A) that were modulated by the presence of aggressive episodes (Fig. 6B–C). Shank3(+/ΔC) mice with aggressive behaviors showed significantly less social investigation as compared to WT (Fig. 6C), whereas Shank3(+/ΔC) mice that did not demonstrate aggression were not different from controls (Fig. 6B).
A similar interference between aggressive behaviors and social investigation was observed in a separate cohort of Shank3(+/ΔC) mice exposed to stimulus mice of different strain backgrounds (Fig. S6G–I). Multiple tests for odor recognition and discrimination (Fig. S6K–L) indicated preserved olfactory processing in Shank3(+/ΔC) mice. A sharp increase in aggression toward a novel stimulus mouse observed in Shank3(+/ΔC) mice (Fig. 6D, S6F) suggested preserved social recognition memory as well. This was confirmed by additional testing in a situation where aggression toward a stimulus mouse is prevented by placing the stimulus mouse under an enclosure. In this situation, Shank3(+/ΔC) mice showed levels of social investigation comparable to that in WT (Fig. 6E). These data indicate that Shank3(+/ΔC) mice have preserved social recognition memory but display aberrant social interactions with aggressive behaviors.
To test whether Shank3(+/ΔC) mice are more aggressive in general, we employed two commonly used protocols: neutral arena and resident-intruder tests. As expected, aggressive behaviors significantly intensified when tested in the resident-intruder test (Fig. 6F, S4J), however there were no genotype-related differences in any of the test conditions. These data indicate that increased aggressive behaviors observed in Shank3(+/ΔC) mice during the dishabituation stage of the social recognition task were not a result of general augmentation of aggression.
To analyze possible changes in social motivation of Shank3(+/ΔC) mice, we tested approach behaviors to enclosed male or female conspecifics. Shank3(+/ΔC) mice spent more time investigating an enclosed male stimulus mouse than WT mice (Fig. 6G,I). This difference remained significant after repeated testing (Fig. 6J) indicating that the increase in social investigation of an enclosed male mouse was not a result of generalized exploratory activation of Shank3(+/ΔC) mice. The same mice were then tested with a sexually-receptive enclosed female. Total duration of social investigation was similar between Shank3(+/ΔC) and WT mice (Fig. 6H,K) but measures that specifically reflect an approach behavior showed significant genotype-related differences. The approach latency in Shank3(+/ΔC) was significantly longer than WT (Fig. 6L). To confirm this finding, an additional cohort of sexually naïve male mice was tested during reciprocal interactions with females. Because in this situation, the approach behavior can be affected by a free-roaming female mouse, we recorded ultrasonic calls that males emit in the presence of females. Latencies to the first ultrasound call emitted by Shank3(+/ΔC) mice were significantly longer than WT (Fig. 6M). Thus, these data indicate that Shank3(+/ΔC) mice have significant differences from WT in social approach behavior, communications and social reciprocal interactions with male and/or female conspecifics.
Schizophrenia-related phenotypes are reported in mouse models with reduced NMDAR function(Mohn et al., 1999). Accordingly, we extended our battery of behavioral tasks to include schizophrenia-related phenotypes in Shank3(+/ΔC) mice. We first utilized prepulse inhibition of startle reaction (PPI). In this paradigm, a brief, low-intensity acoustic stimulus (the prepulse) inhibits the startle reflex caused by a loud stimulus. Shank3(+/ΔC) mice showed significantly lower amplitudes and longer latencies of startle response than WT (Fig. 7A; Fig. S7A–D). The levels of prepulse inhibition were not different between genotypes as assessed by ANOVA (Fig. 7B). However, the prepulse inhibition in WT was negatively correlated with startle amplitude (Fig. 7C–D, S5E, Tables S3) resulting in an underestimation of prepulse inhibition in the control group due to their higher levels of startle (Fig. 7A). To correct for these differences we employed an analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) with the amplitude of startle reaction as a continuous predictor variable. This analysis revealed a significant effect of Genotype and Genotype × Trial interaction due to differences between Shank3(+/ΔC) and WT in the most challenging type of trials, which consisted of a combination of the highest level of startle stimulus and the lowest level of prepulse (Fig. 7E).
We also tested sensitivity to psychostimulants; a preclinical correlate of positive symptoms used extensively in animal models of schizophrenia (Powell and Miyakawa, 2006). Systemic injection of dizocilpine (MK-801), a non-competitive NMDAR antagonist, dose-dependently increased locomotor activity in both genotypes (Fig. 7F) However, the levels of motor activation were significantly higher in Shank3(+/ΔC) compared to WT (Fig. 7G). Similarly, amphetamine, a known psychostimulant that exerts its action through release of dopamine, resulted in a significantly stronger activation in Shank3(+/ΔC) compared to WT (Fig. 7H–I). By contrast, Shank(+/ΔC) mice did not show novelty-induced hyperactivity (Fig. S7J,H), indicating that the increased motor activity induced by MK-801 and amphetamine is specific to these agents.
The present study supports a “gain of function” mechanism for synaptic and behavioral dysfunction in a mouse model designed to mimic human mutations of Shank3 associated with ASD(Durand et al., 2007). In combination with observations from Homer KO mice, we propose a model in which perturbations that reduce the stability of the Homer-Shank3 protein complex result in increased ubiquitination of Shank3 and reduced expression at the synapse. Changes of NR1 expression and ubiquitination are coupled to changes in Shank3. Determinants of the stability of the Homer-Shank protein complex have been reported in biochemical and crystallographic studies(Hayashi et al., 2009), and are consistent with our findings. Our model is also consistent with a report that Shank proteins undergo ubiquitination in physiological adaptations to neuronal activity(Ehlers, 2003). Data regarding effects of reduced expression of Homer cross-linking proteins include reduced Shank3 and NR1 expression and increased ubiquitination in Homer triple KO, Homer 1 KO and Homer 2/3 KO brain. Moreover, Homer1a expression, which inhibits the formation of Homer-Shank3 complex(Hayashi et al., 2009) mimics Homer KO to reduce Shank3 expression, while selective genetic deletion of Homer1a results in increased Shank3 and reduced ubiquitination in brain. In extending this model to include the effect of Shank3 mutation, we note that Shank3ΔC protein is stably expressed in the Shank3(+/ΔC) mice, and physically associates with full-length Shank3 from brain. Since Shank3ΔC lacks the Homer-binding domain and associates with full-length Shank3, its incorporation with WT Shank3 effectively reduces Homer cross-linking of the Homer-Shank3 protein complex. Acute over-expression of Shank3ΔC in neurons reduces WT Shank3, providing evidence that down-regulation of WT Shank3 is due to Shank3ΔC expression. We do not detect ubiquitination of Shank3ΔC even from Shank3(ΔC/ΔC) brain, which mitigates the notion that Shank3ΔC is primarily ubiquitinated and “drags” the rest of the proteins along. This model predicts that any mutation of Shank3 or Homer that effectively reduces the stability of the Homer-Shank complex will lead to increased ubiquitination and proteasomal degradation of Shank3 and NR1. This could include deletions or point mutations of Shank3 that limit their physical assembly with other Shank3 molecules or Homer. Consistent with this model, Homer1 KO mice exhibit behavioral phenotypes (Szumlinski et al., 2005) similar to Shank3(+/ΔC) mice.
Our model begs the question of why Shank3 expression and ubiquitination should be sensitive to physical association with Homer. We note that manipulations of Homer1a can influence Shank3 expression and ubiquitination, and this reinforces the notion that Shank3 is a nodal point for regulation of synaptic function in response to natural activity. Homer1a expression is tightly linked to behavioral experience(Brakeman et al., 1997) and can also be induced by a variety of pharmacological and pathological stimuli. Thus, dynamic expression of Homer1a could contribute to the disassembly of Homer-Shank3 complexes, especially if the complex is weakened by mutations of Shank or Homer. By this mechanism, Homer1a expression could contribute to the pathogenesis of ASD.
Our studies also suggest a link between Shank3 and group I mGluR function. The molecular basis of enhanced mGluR-LTD in Shank3(+/ΔC) does not appear to be linked to altered expression of mGluRs. mGluR-LTD is increased in Fmr1 KO mice and this has been linked to neurological deficits in this mouse and in patients with fragile X disease (Bear et al., 2004). Thus, enhanced mGluR-LTD may contribute to behavioral deficits in the Shank3(+/ΔC) mice.
Shank3(+/ΔC) mice exhibit behavioral phenotypes that parallel symptoms of ASD. The most striking differences between Shank3(+/ΔC) and WT mice were observed in a social recognition test that allowed for engagement in reciprocal interactions. Shank3(+/ΔC) mice reacted to novel conspecifics by a sharp increase in aggression rather than an increase in social investigation. Aggressive behaviors of Shank3(+/ΔC) mice were not generalized across different tasks indicating that the exaggerated aggression is likely a reaction to changes in social routine rather than a result of their generalized aggressiveness. Inferences regarding phenotypic relevance between mouse and human behaviors, such as aggression in individuals with ASD (Kanne and Mazurek, 2010) are difficult, however, the findings of exaggerated aggressiveness to novel conspecifics as well as deficits in ultrasound vocalization and alterations in social approach behaviors indicate that the effects of Shank3(+/ΔC) mutation are detected on multiple domains of social interactions tested in a species-specific manner.
The decrease in NR1 observed in Shank3(+/ΔC) mice invites comparisons with mice hypomorphic for NR1 (Mohn et al., 1999). The preserved structure of synapses and spines that are observed in Shank3(+/Δ C) mice is consistent with reports from the conditional NR1 KO where NR1 excision within CA1 did not effect spine density (Rampon et al., 2000). The most striking difference between mice hypomorphic for NR1 and Shank3(+/ΔC) mice is that behavioral phenotypes of Shank3(+/ΔC) mice occur in the context of normal cognitive function as assayed in multiple tests of learning and memory. NMDAR-dependent LTP and LTD are reduced in Shank3(+/ΔC) hippocampus, but are not absent, and plasticity is apparently sufficient for normal cognitive function. The preserved cognition in these mice mitigates the concern that aberrant social behaviors might arise non-specifically in a mouse with major cognitive dysfunction, and suggests that Shank3ΔC models will be useful to explore the cellular and developmental determinants of social deficits associated with ASD, and relate these to a molecular model that includes enhanced ubiquitination of NR1. Our studies, however, should not be taken as direct evidence of a role of Shank3 in schizophrenia since human genetic evidence remains incomplete. Genetic studies report linkage of schizophrenia at 22q11-13 locus, which includes Shank3 (Condra et al., 2007; DeLisi et al., 2002), but the single reported association of Shank3 mutations with schizophrenia (Gauthier et al., 2010) is notable for inclusion of patients with early onset symptoms that may overlap with ASD (Rapoport et al., 2009). Nevertheless, our study supports the notion that patients with ASD or schizophrenia may share the molecular pathology of reduced NMDAR function.
Detailed experimental methods are provided in the online supplemental material.
Mice were generated on a mixed 129s6; C57BL6/J background and backcrossed to C57BL6/J background to at least the F5 generation. Littermate pairs of male mice (unless otherwise noted) 3 to 6 months of age were used in behavioral testing. All procedures involving animals were under the guidelines of JHU and UTSW Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee.
Behaviors were recorded by computer-based tracking systems (HVS Image Analysis VP-200, HVS Image, Hampton, England; Any Maze™ 4.72, Stoelting Co, Wood Dale, IL; Noldus, Ethovision 2.3.19, SR-LAB, San-Diego Instruments, CA) and scored when necessary by trained observers blind to genotype using a computer-assisted data acquisition system.
The ubiquitination of Shank3 and NR1 was measured from cortical lysates and is described in detail in the online supplemental materials.
Electrophysiology was done using standard techniques. Details are provided in the online supplemental methods.
The behavioral data were analyzed using ANOVA/ANCOVA with the statistical package STATISTICA 8.0 (StatSoft, Tulsa, OK) and a minimal level of significance p<0.05. Fisher LSD post hoc tests were applied to significant main effects or interactions. All data are shown as means ± SEM unless noted otherwise.
MAB, AS, BX and PFW designed the study. MAB executed and analyzed all the biochemistry, immunocytochemistry and DiI experiments. BX, MAB, DW, YC and XZ created the Shank3 mouse. JMP, SKJ and JK did the electrophysiology experiments and analysis supervised by PFW and DJL. RSP did the electron microscopy. TM, DL, SS, MK, HES, SEK did the behavior experiments and analysis supervised by AS and CMP. JCT and JHH provided reagents. MAB, AS and PFW wrote the manuscript and PFW supervised the overall project. We thank Maria Papapavlou for administrative assistance; Holly Wellington, Ann Lawler, Johnisha Witherspoon and Charles Hawkins for assistance in generating the Shank3(+/ΔC) mice; Uejin Kim, Jasmin Harpe, Matt Jo, Pennson Wang, Dakim Gaines, Olivia Tong, Julia Wynne and Eugenia Cho for help with behavioral testing and data handling; Ya-Xian Wang for help with the electron microscopy preparation. This work was supported by National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke grant 5R01NS070301-02 (PFW), National Institute of Mental Health Core grant 5P50MH084020-03 (PFW), National 973 Basic Research Program of China 20009CB941400 (BX), R21HD065290 (CMP), R01MH081164 (CMP), Autism Speaks (CMP & MK), The Autism Science Foundation (CMP & HS), The Hartwell Foundation (CMP), NIDCD Intramural Program (RSP) and Weatherstone predoctoral fellowship from Autism Speaks (MAB).
Publisher's Disclaimer: This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final citable form. Please note that during the production process errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.