RCCs placed in aqueous buffers containing oxygen and DTT generate significant concentrations (μM) of H
2O
2 that may indirectly inhibit the activity of target proteins susceptible to oxidation.
1–4,6,7,26,27 For example, the active site cysteines of PTPs have a low p
Ka of 4.7–5.4 and exist as thiolate anions at neutral pH, which enhances their catalytic activity and also their susceptibility to inactivation by H
2O
2 generated by RCCs in the presence of DTT.
1–4 A reaction scheme for the generation of H
2O
2 by redox cycling between a RCC and DTT in the presence of oxygen has been proposed
1,3,5 (): (1) DTT reacts with the RCC to form dihydroxydithiane (ox-DTT) and a hydro-RCC; (2) when the hydro-RCC and RCC are present together they undergo a synproportionation to form a transient radical anion species (RCC
˙−) and 2H
+; (3) the RCC
˙− radical anion reacts with O
2 to form superoxide (O
2˙−) and regenerates the RCC; (4) DTT may also react with O
2 in the buffer to generate O
2˙− and ox-DTT; (5) O
2˙− can oxidize a hydro-RCC resulting in the production of a RCC
˙− radical anion and H
2O
2. There are several hallmark characteristics that have been used to distinguish RCCs from hit compounds that modulate target protein activities directly.
1–4,7,27 Caspase 8 inhibition by quinone RCCs is time-dependent, abolished by catalase, and occurs in strong reducing agents like DTT or TCEP, but not in GSH or Cys.
7 Inhibition of PTPα by
ortho-quinone RCCs is also time-dependent, is sensitive to superoxide dismutase (SOD) and catalase, and depends on the concentrations of both the compound and DTT.
1 Ortho-quinone RCCs produce H
2O
2 through redox cycling in the presence of strong reducing agents such as DTT or TCEP, but not in GSH or Cys.
1 The
in vitro inhibition of Cdc25B by quinolinedione RCCs is irreversible, time-dependent, and sensitive to pH, catalase, and reducing agents.
2,26 In the absence of DTT, the quinolinedione RCCs did not inhibit Cdc25B
in vitro, and the addition of catalase to the
in vitro assay buffer containing DTT abolished Cdc25B inhibition.
2,26Rather than expend critical resources and time to identify RCCs in a complex follow-up testing paradigm,
1,2,6,7 we have developed an assay that accurately measures the H
2O
2 generating capability of RCCs in DTT containing buffers with respect to time and concentration dependence, catalase sensitivity, and the requirement for strong reducing agents.
1–4,7,27 Recently a surrogate assay to detect small molecule redox activity has been used to identify undesirable promiscuous nuisance compounds in the hits from historical HTS campaigns conducted at GlaxoSmithKline (GSK).
6 Pyrimidotriazinedione hits identified in a Cathepsin L (CatL) cysteine protease inhibitor screen were subsequently found to be promiscuous hits in many GSK HTS campaigns, predominantly those against cysteine proteases, metalloenzymes, or other drug targets with an active site cysteine.
6 In a HTS campaign to identify activators of glucokinase (GK) activity, 97% of the 2,262 primary screening actives were found to be nuisance hits that interfered with the resazurin-coupled assay format.
6 The generation of resorufin product was independent of GK activity and required only compound, resazurin and DTT. This inspired the development of a surrogate assay to identify redox active compounds.
6 Several structural classes of RCCs were identified in screening hits (caspase 8, PTP-1B, and taurine dioxygenase), and 2.3% of a 10,000 compound HTS validation library were found to be redox active at 10 μM.
6There are, however, inconsistencies between the performance of the resazurin surrogate assay
6 and the behavior of RCCs.
1–4,7,26,27 The pyrimidotriazinedione control compound (5 μM) generated O
2˙− in the presence of DTT (10 μM) that was readily detected in a cytochrome
c assay, but was prevented by the inclusion of SOD.
6 However, the inclusion of SOD and/or catalase in the resazurin assay reaction did not prevent the generation of resorufin by compounds in DTT, indicating that the reaction is not mediated by either the O
2˙− or H
2O
2 ROS.
6 In addition, the amount of resorufin product generated was limited by the amount of resazurin and DTT in the reaction, but not by the compound concentration.
6 It was proposed that the compound is not a substrate but behaves as a catalyst facilitating the 2e
− reduction of resazurin by DTT.
6 Addition of 10 mM GSH or
N-acetyl cysteine had no effect on the reaction of the pyrimidotriazinedione control with the resazurin-DTT mixture, but it is unclear whether weak reducing agents such as GSH or Cys can substitute for DTT in the surrogate assay.
6 Despite these inconsistencies, the surrogate assay successfully identified previously described RCCs
1,7 and several other structural classes.
6 The reduction of resazurin to resorufin is a widely utilized assay format to measure cell viability (mammalian cells, bacteria, and parasites), and is frequently employed in coupled enzyme assays to measure the activity of target enzymes that reduce NAD to NADH.
28,29 Although the homogeneous format and robust fluorescent assay signal window are attractive features of resazurin assays, the potential for interference by RCCs in DTT containing buffers
6 may contribute to high hit rates and large numbers of false positives.
We report here the first systematic use of the HRP-PR H
2O
2 detection assay to profile the LOPAC and NIH compound libraries for RCCs (). Two RCCs were identified in the LOPAC library, the
ortho-naphthoquinone β-lapachone (SID 207115) and the
para-naphthoquinone NSC 95397 (SID 400206) (). In agreement with previous studies,
3 the generation of H
2O
2 exhibited concentration-dependent behavior for both the RCC and DTT, and the DTT concentration response was biphasic (). No H
2O
2 was produced by RCCs in buffer alone or in the physiological reducing agent GSH, but β-lapachone also generated H
2O
2 in TCEP, another strong reducing agent (). From 195,826 compounds in the NIH small molecule library 37 (0.02%) concentration-dependent RCCs were identified (, ). None of the 37 RCCs generated H
2O
2 in HBSS buffer alone or in GSH, but 18 (48%) RCCs also generated H
2O
2 in TCEP (). Seventeen (45.9%) of the 39 RCCs identified in the 2 screens contained quinone functional groups () that are structurally similar to previously described pyrimidotriazinedione,
ortho-quinone, and
para-quinone RCCs.
1–4,6,7 Seventy-one structurally related quinone compounds were screened in the primary assay and 60% of the
ortho-quinones and 80% of the pyrimidotriazinediones in the library were identified and confirmed as RCCs (). However, only 3.9% of the
para-quinones that were screened behaved as concentration-dependent RCCs (). Only 16 of the 251 arylsulfonamides in the library generated H
2O
2 in the primary screen, and 15 (6%) were confirmed as concentration-dependent RCCs (,
, and ). Consistent with and our observations with quinone RCCs,
3 H
2O
2 generation by arylsulfonamide RCCs required a strong reducing agent such as DTT or TCEP, and the level of H
2O
2 generated was proportional to the compound concentration (). Only quinone and arylsulfonamide RCCs generated H
2O
2 in the presence of TCEP (, ), The singleton RCC
N-(1-butyl-3-cyano-1H-pyrrolo[2,3-b]quinoxalin-2-yl)-2-chlorobenzamide benzooxadiazol-4-yl ester (, SID 857446), is structurally related to a previously described RCC (SID 3712327) identified in the hits from a MKP-1 HTS.
3,15 We have identified 4 new RCC pharmacophores: 2 nitrothiophene-2-carboxylates (); 2 tolyl hydrazides; and 2 singleton RCCs, 5-acetamido-4,5-dihydroisoxazolo[4,5-c]pyridine-4,7-diyl diacetate (SID 847359), and 1-(benzo[
c][1,2,5]thiadiazol-5-yl)-3-(4-ethoxyphenyl)thiourea (SID 17504835) ().
Screening quinone RCCs in buffers containing DTT generates H
2O
2 that inhibits the
in vitro activity of target proteins that are susceptible to oxidation; caspase 8, cathepsin L, PTPα, MKP-1, and Cdc25B.
1,6,7,15,27 Pyrimidotriazinedione and
ortho-quinone RCCs were among the promiscuous hits identified in HTS campaigns against cysteine proteases, metalloenzymes, and other target proteins with active site cysteines.
6,7 Seven confirmed pyrimidotriazinedione hits, identical to the RCCs presented here () or that have been characterized previously,
3,6,7 were identified in an HTS campaign conducted by the NIH Chemical Genomics Center (NCGC) to identify small molecules that disrupt the interaction between the C-terminal peptide of heat shock protein 90 (Hsp90) and the TPR2A domain of the Hsp organizing protein (HOP) (AIDs 595, 632, and 1400).
30–32 The TPR2A domain of HOP contains 2 Cys residues and binding to the C-terminal peptide of Hsp90 is better in the presence of DTT.
32 Even though both the primary HTS and secondary assays for the Hsp90–TPR2A interaction screen were conducted in the presence of DTT,
32 the potential role of H
2O
2 generated by the pyrimidotriazinedione RCCs in the observed disruption of the Hsp90–TPR2A interaction was neither considered nor excluded.
30,31 The
ortho-quinone β-lapachone is an effective cytostatic agent in tumor cell lines that can generate damaging ROS following 1- or 2-electron reductions, and may function as a checkpoint activator in the absence of DNA damage.
33,34 Several of the
ortho-quinone RCCs in the NIH library have also been confirmed in tumor cell growth suppression and cytotoxicity assays (). The
para-quinone NSC 95397 is a potent inhibitor of the Cdc25 A, B, and C isoforms
in vitro, and inhibits the growth of a number of human and murine tumor cell lines by blocking the G2 to M transition.
4,35,36 NSC 95397 is also an RCC capable of generating H
2O
2 in buffers containing DTT ().
4 Not surprisingly, both the β-lapachone and NSC 95397 RCCs were inhibitors of
in vitro PTP screens conducted in DTT containing buffers; MKP-1, MKP-3, YopH, and SptP (). β-Lapachone and NSC 95397 also exhibited activity in a significant number of NCI tumor cell growth inhibition assays ().
Quinones are Michael acceptors that may covalently bind to cellular nucleophiles including GSH, Cys residues on proteins, and amino groups on proteins and DNA.
4,37 In cells, quinones undergo an enzymatic one-electron reduction catalyzed by microsomal NADPH cytochrome P450 reductase to the semiquinone radical, and in the presence of molecular oxygen, the semiquinone radical can transfer an electron and generate O
2˙−.
37,38 This reaction shunts electrons toward oxygen as a futile pathway for reducing equivalents otherwise used for cytochrome P450 reductase-dependent reactions.
37,38 O
2˙− can dismutate to form other ROS like H
2O
2 and
˙OH and these highly reactive species may react directly with DNA or other cellular macromolecules causing cell damage.
37,38 The 2-electron reduction of a quinone to the hydroquinone can also be catalyzed by cytosolic and mitochondrial DT-diaphorase and quinone oxidoreductase.
37,38 Quinones may also undergo nonenzymatic redox cycling with their corresponding semiquinone radicals to generate ROS that can oxidize or damage DNA, mitochondria, lipids, and the cysteine residues of proteins.
4,37 Indeed, it has been proposed that the ability of quinone RCCs to undergo redox cycling and to generate H
2O
2 within cells may be the basis of their widespread cellular activities.
1,2,30,37,38 Quinones cause toxicity
in vivo through a variety of mechanisms including: GSH and/or ATP depletion, damage to DNA and/or mitochondria, and the oxidation or alkylation of critical cellular proteins.
4,37 Despite the challenges of acute toxicity
in vivo, a number of quinones have been clinically validated as anticancer drugs including; menadione, daunorubicin, doxorubicin, mitomycin C, mitoxanthrone, ametantrone, carbazilquinone, diaziquone, streptonigrin, and actinomycin D.
4,37,39The 15 arylsulfonamide RCCs identified in the NIH library ( and ) are structurally similar to 2 of the hits from a taurine dioxygenase inhibitor screen that were active in the resazurin surrogate assay.
6 The sulfonamides constitute an important class of pharmacological agents possessing antitumor, antiviral, antibacterial, antifungal, antimalarial, diuretic, hypoglycemic, and antithyroid activity among others.
40–42 Sulfonamide-based inhibitors have been designed for many enzyme targets: carbonic anhydrases, aspartic proteases, serine proteases, metalloproteases, matrix metalloproteinases, steroid sulfatases, and PTPs.
40–42 The sulfonamide functionality is widely used by medicinal chemists in the design of biologically active small molecules, and is often incorporated into drug candidates to improve physicochemical properties such as water solubility and bioavailability.
40–42 In 11 of the 15 arylsulonamide RCCs, the oxonaphthalen-1(4H)-yl-idene-benzenesulfonamides and the hydroxynaphthalen-1-yl-benzenesulfonamides, the amino groups of the arylsulfonamide groups are attached at the
para-position of quinone-like structures (). The other 4 1H-pyrrolo [2,3-
b]quinoxalin-2-yl-benzenesulfonamide RCCs contain amine components that have reactive functionalities prone to redox activities (). Since there were 17,868 compounds with a sulfonamide functional group and 251 structurally related arylsulfonamides in the library (), we conclude that the redox cycling activity of the 15 arylsulfonamide RCCs is not due to the sulfonamide function itself, but rather to peripheral reactive enone, aromatic, or heterocyclic functions.
The 195,826 substances from the NIH compound library were acquired and distributed by the SMR in multiple shipments during the first 2 years (2005–2007) of the pilot phase of the MLSCN.
3,15,20,21,23,27 Many of the MLSCN bioassay data sets uploaded to PubChem were screened against earlier versions of the library with fewer compounds (10K, 65K, or 97K).
3,15,20,21,23,27 Consequently not all of the compounds that we profiled for RCC activity would have been screened in the same bioassays, and many of these assays may have been conducted in cell-based and biochemical formats that did not employ exogenous reducing agents. Nonetheless, the 37 RCCs identified in the NIH library and the 37 randomly selected non-RCCs compounds were found to have been screened in a comparable number of bioassays (). We observed that the RCCs exhibited a significantly (
P value < 0.01) higher number of active flags and “confirmed” active flags in PubChem compared to non-RCCs, illustrating the potential of RCCs to populate screening databases with promiscuous bioactivity profiles (, ). It is of interest that the majority (91.9%) of the RCCs had not been screened against any of the well known oxidation-sensitive targets in the database (), suggesting that more targets may be susceptible to oxidation than has previously been recognized. H
2O
2 is a ubiquitous intracellular messenger that modulates the activity of a variety of proteins including protein phosphatases, protein kinases, cysteine proteases, transcription factors, phospholipases, ion channels, and G proteins.
43,44