Deletions of BUG1, BEM1, ARF1, HOG1, LAS17, VPS5, and SAC6 show low or no induction of [PSI+] but maintain propagation of [PSI+] and [PIN+]
Our goal was to identify genes that influence the induction of the [
PSI+] prion. Previous work approached this problem by making use of the observation that overexpression of Sup35PD-GFP in [
PSI+] [
PIN+] cells causes toxicity due to excessive sequestration of essential Sup35 into large aggregates
[46],
[47]. When Sup35PD-GFP is highly overexpressed in [
psi−] [
PIN+] cells, the frequent induction of [
PSI+] results in an intermediate level of toxicity, because only cells that have switched to the [
PSI+] state are sick
[23],
[46]. Therefore, genes whose deletions enhance or reduce the toxicity associated with overexpression seemed likely to increase or decrease [
PSI+] induction frequency, respectively
[46]. We tested 238 deletion strains that enhanced toxicity, 151 that reduced toxicity, and nine other strains studied in Tyedmers
et al.
[46] (
Table S1; Tyedmers and Lindquist, unpublished) for their effects on [
PSI+] induction.
First, to distinguish the inability to induce [
PSI+] from the inability to propagate [
PSI+] we tested if the 398 deletions could maintain weak and strong variants of [
PSI+] in a propagating culture after cytoduction with [
PSI+]. A plasmid encoding a copper inducible Sup35PD-GFP fusion was plasmiduced into the deletion strains simultaneously with the cytoduction of weak or strong [
PSI+]. After over 50 generations of growth, we scored for maintenance of [
PSI+] by overexpressing Sup35PD-GFP and examining cells for the presence of fluorescent aggregates. All deletion strains cytoduced with either weak or strong [
PSI+] contained fluorescent aggregates, indicative of [
PSI+], except for
hsp104Δ, which had the characteristic diffuse fluorescence of [
psi−] cells (data not shown). Additionally, we have previously shown that [
PIN+] is maintained in all strains of the deletion library except
rnq1Δ and
hsp104Δ [48].
Next, we used a standard nonsense suppression assay for [
PSI+] to screen the 398 yeast deletion library strains, in the BY4741 background, for their effects on induction of stable propagating [
PSI+]. To do this, the [
PIN+] prion, the Sup35PD-GFP plasmid, and a plasmid containing a
ura3–
14 nonsense allele to score for [
PSI+] cells
[49] were simultaneously cytoduced into the 398 deletion strains as described previously
[48]. Following overexpression of Sup35PD-GFP to induce [
PSI+], cells were plated on–Ura where suppression of the plasmid borne
ura3–
14 nonsense allele allowed [
PSI+], but not [
psi−], cells to grow.
Six novel deletion strains:
bem1Δ, def1Δ, scp160Δ, rpp1aΔ, spt4Δ, and pre9Δ, as well as the expected
rnq1Δ and
hsp104Δ deletions, failed to grow on -Ura (). Previous work has shown that in the presence of the
SUP35 R2E2 allele, which increases the appearance of [
PSI+] without
SUP35 overexpression,
bem1Δ and
pre9Δ decreased [
PSI+] appearance
[46]. In addition, 29 other deletions showed either low or extremely low induction of [
PSI+] (; ). While strains carrying deletions of
SPT4 or
YML010C-B failed to express Sup35PD-GFP, all other deletion strains expressed Sup35PD-GFP at similar levels (data not shown).
| Table 1Yeast deletion library strains that show no, very low, or low induction of [PSI+]. |
Deletion strains that decrease the efficiency of [
PSI+] induction () were from both enhanced and reduced toxicity groups. This makes sense if we consider that toxic side effects of the deletions could overlay the positive effect on growth rate due to the reduced [
PSI+] induction. Furthermore, in some deletions, even the overexpression of YFP alone (without the Sup35 prion domain) causes strong toxicity that must be, therefore, completely unrelated to prion induction frequency
[46].
To eliminate the effects of secondary mutations known to have accumulated in library strains
[50],
[51], multiple independent deletions of nineteen of the best candidates that showed no or reduced induction of [
PSI+] () were re-engineered in a wildtype 74-D694 [
PIN+] strain. This 74-D694 genetic background contains a [
PSI+] suppressible
ade1–
14 allele that provides the ability to directly score for [
PSI+] by examining growth on -Ade. Of the 19 re-engineered deletions, only the six deletions (
bre1Δ, bug1Δ, bem1Δ, arf1Δ, pre9Δ, and
hog1Δ) that reproducibly reduced the frequency of [
PSI+] induction, relative to the wildtype induction frequency of approximately 7.5 X 10
−3 (), were pursued further. Since a slow growth phenotype complicates the scoring for [
PSI+], deletions that significantly inhibited growth in the 74D-694 background, like
lst7Δ and
swa2Δ (data not shown), were eliminated from further analysis.
In addition to the above deletions, we made a deletion of
LAS17, which was previously shown to inhibit the aggregation of the polyglutamine 103Q repeat
[52]. We also made deletions of
VPS5 and
SAC6, because they, like Las17 and other proteins shown to affect the appearance of [
PSI+], are associated with endocytosis and the actin cytoskeleton. Even though prion propagation is unaffected in these three deletion strains because they were all able to maintain [
PSI+] over many generations after cytoduction (data not shown),
vps5Δ caused a significant decrease in prion induction, and
las17Δ and
sac6Δ strains completely failed to induce [
PSI+] ().
To eliminate deletions that reduced [
PSI+] induction by altering the levels of Sup35, Sup35PD-GFP, or chaperones, we examined these levels in all strains. None of the deletions caused significant changes in Hsp104, Ssa1, Sis1, Sse1, or Ssb1/2 (data not shown). Since Sup35PD-GFP levels were reduced in
bre1Δ strains and Sup35 endogenous levels were decreased in
pre9Δ strains (
Figure S1), these deletions were dropped from further study.
To eliminate the possibility that the reduced [
PSI+] induction was due to the loss of [
PIN+] during the construction of any of the deletion strains, we showed that the maintenance of [
PIN+] was unaffected by the deletions. Each independently constructed deletion was crossed to a [
pin-] strain carrying a plasmid with the
CUP1 controlled
RNQ1-GFP fusion. When grown on medium containing copper, induction of the resulting diploid containing the
RNQ-GFP construct caused the appearance of punctate dots indicative of [
PIN+] (data not shown). Furthermore, we showed that [
PIN+] was maintained in deletion strains by the presence of [
PIN+] characteristic SDS-resistant oligomeric species after 24 hours of Sup35PD-GFP overexpression (
Figure S2). Differences in the migration of Rnq1 SDS-resistant oligomers have been shown to be associated with different [
PIN+] variants
[53]. We observed similar migration of Rnq1 oligomeric species in the deletion strains, suggesting that the [
PIN+] prion variants were not altered during construction of the strain or by Sup35PD-GFP overexpression. These results and other properties of the deletions investigated further below are summarized in .
| Table 2Properties of deletions that inhibit de novo induction of [PSI+]. |
Reduced [PSI+] formation is not always associated with reduced ring formation
Transient overexpression of Sup35PD-GFP in [
psi−] [
PIN+] cells leads to the appearance of cytoplasmic fluorescent rings and lines
[54]. Daughter cells derived from micromanipulated cells that contain such rings or lines, where overexpression of Sup35PD-GFP is turned off but where endogenous
SUP35 is tagged with GFP, always contained fluorescent punta indicative of [
PSI+]
[55]. In contrast, mother cells without ring or line aggregates always gave rise to daughter cells with diffuse fluorescence, indicative of [
psi−]
[44],
[54]–
[56]. Thus the appearance of rings/lines, while not necessarily a direct intermediate in the formation of [
PSI+], is nonetheless a hallmark of the potential appearance of induced [
PSI+]. No such rings have ever been observed during spontaneous appearance of [
PSI+] in the absence of Sup35PD overexpression (unpublished).
To determine the deletions that inhibit the induction of [
PSI+] and also prevent ring formation, we compared the number of cells that contained rings after 24 hours of expressing Sup35PD-GFP in the seven deletion strains. Ring containing cells in four of the deletions,
bug1Δ, bem1Δ, arf1Δ, and
hog1Δ, appeared at levels similar to wildtype (30%, ). The
rnq1Δ strains, which are [
pin−], always displayed diffuse fluorescence (), as expected, since [
PIN+] has been previously shown to be required for ring formation
[54].
Interestingly, when measured after 24 hrs of Sup35PD-GFP induction, the three deletions associated with endocytosis and organization of the actin cytoskeleton,
sac6Δ, las17Δ, and
vps5Δ, all showed a significant reduction in cells containing rings. Since by 25 hrs of induction, wildtype,
sac6Δ, and
vps5Δ cultures were in stationary phase, where ring formation peaks
[54], the inhibition of ring formation in
sac6Δ and vps5Δ was not the result of a failure of these cultures to reach stationary phase (
Figure S3). Also, since
las17Δ cells reached saturation phase only after 36 hours, we also measured ring formation in
las17Δ cultures following 50 hrs of induction, well after the culture reached stationary phase. These cultures still showed a 50% reduction in ring formation relative to the wildtype cultures (data not shown).
Ring-associated toxicity
Ring formation is associated with [
PSI+] appearance
[54]. However, it has been shown that cells that contain rings have a higher rate of cell death than those that have diffuse fluorescence
[44],
[47],
[54]. Therefore, we asked if the deletions might be more toxic to ring bearing cells, which would result in a decrease in [
PSI+] induction. To test this, we micromanipulated individual ring containing cells from selected deletion strains and assessed whether they were viable. Similar to previous findings
[47], only 36% of wildtype ring containing cells were viable, whereas 95% of wildtype cells with diffuse cytoplasmic fluorescence were viable (). In general, the viability of ring containing wildtype,
bem1Δ, and
hog1Δ cells appeared to be similar () and therefore cannot explain the strong reduction of
de novo induction of [
PSI+]. Ring containing
arf1Δ cells had reduced viability (21%), which could account for the decrease in [
PSI+] induction (). In contrast,
bug1Δ ring cells showed an increase in viability (59%), but apparently these cells did not efficiently give rise to [
PSI+] cells. In the absence of rings, there appeared to be no effect on the viability of any of the deletion strains (, green bars).
Since isolating ring cells in strains with low ring formation was difficult, we focused on one example and found that of the small population of cells in vps5Δ strains that formed rings, a majority were inviable (). This suggests that rings in the absence of VPS5 may be harmful to the cell and likely explains the decreased percentage of rings observed in .
Deletion strains affect aggregation and toxicity of polyglutamine
We next asked if our deletion strains also affect the [
PIN+] dependent aggregation of the polyglutamine (polyQ) expanded repeat found in the mutant huntingtin protein associated with Huntington's disease. Since
las17Δ strains, carrying a galactose inducible expanded polyQ repeat (103Q) fused to GFP, were previously shown to delay 103Q-GFP aggregate formation compared to wildtype strains
[52], we tested our other deletions for similar aggregation patterns. When wildtype [
PIN+] cells expressed 103Q-GFP for approximately one to two hours, 82% of cells displayed strong fluorescent puncta, while [
pin-] cells showed mostly cells with diffuse fluorescence (73%) and a minor population that contained a few faint fluorescent foci on a diffuse background (27%; ). Similar analyses of [
PIN+] strains with
bug1Δ, bem1Δ, arf1Δ, and
hog1Δ deletions resulted in a reduced number of cells that contained strong fluorescent puncta (, green bars) and an increased number of cells that had faint fluorescent foci with a diffuse background (, purple bars). As in the previous study
[52], [
PIN+]
las17Δ strains had barely any strong fluorescent foci. Examination of [
PIN+]
vps5Δ and [
PIN+]
sac6Δ strains also showed a strong reduction in cells having bright foci and a similar distribution of cells with faint foci vs. no foci as seen in wildtype [
pin-] strains.
We next examined the effect of these deletions on toxicity associated with expression of the expanded polyglutamine protein in the presence of the [
PIN+] prion
[57]. Our controls verified earlier findings
[57] that wildtype [
PIN+] cells carrying a galactose inducible 103Q-GFP plasmid show toxicity compared to cells carrying the non-toxic 25Q-GFP plasmid. As expected, polyglutamine expressing cells that are either [
pin-] or
rnq1Δ did not exhibit toxicity, whereas wildtype [
PIN+] cells were sick (). Since previous studies have correlated the presence of polyQ aggregates with cell toxicity
[57], the lack of strong polyQ fluorescent foci in the class of deletions that also reduced ring formation after Sup35PD-GFP overexpression (
las17Δ, vps5Δ, and
sac6Δ; ) nicely explained the observed decrease in polyQ toxicity. Interestingly, the class of deletions that reduced [
PSI+] induction, but not ring formation (
bug1Δ, bem1Δ, arf1Δ, and
hog1Δ), increased the frequency of cells containing faint polyQ-GFP fluorescent foci on diffuse backgrounds and clearly enhanced 103Q toxicity.