In this sample of African-American breast cancer survivors, we found the Trp64Arg substitution in ADRB3 was associated with reduced measures of adiposity. Specifically, we found that women who were homozygous for ADRB3 wildtype allele had significantly higher levels of visceral abdominal fat compared to women who carried the variant. Further, women with the wildtype allele were more likely to be obese. This association was strongest among premenopausal women, women who had been treated with chemotherapy, or who were less physically active; however the numbers of women in each stratum were small. We did not find significant associations for ADRB3 with other measures of weight, including weight gain, waist circumference, hip circumference, or waist to hip ratio.
The 12.3% minor allele (A) frequency in our African-American sample is similar to the frequency reported for other African-American (12%) and Mexican-American populations (13%), but higher than the frequency reported for Caucasians (8%), and lower than the frequency reported for Pima Indians (31%)
24.
In previous epidemiologic studies, the association between the
ADRB3 variant and obesity-related phenotypes has been investigated among individuals from several racial/ethnic groups and nationalities, including Caucasians
13, Japanese
12,25,26, Pima Indians
24, Mexican Americans
14, African Americans
27,28 and Jamaicans
29. Previous studies of white or Japanese populations found the variant allele of the
ADRB3 receptor to be associated with elevated measures of obesity
13, whereas two previous studies of African-Americans reported associations with the wildtype receptor. Consistent with our data, Lowe Jr. et al reported a protective association between the variant allele and BMI among African-American women (P=0.04)
27. Similarly, Terra et al reported that African-Americans who were homozygous for the wildtype allele had higher mean BMI than variant carriers, although the association did not reach statistical significance
28. In contrast, McFarlane-Anderson et al found that Jamaican women who were carriers of the variant allele had a significantly increased BMI compared to women who were homozygous for the wildtype allele
29.
ADRB3 is a G-coupled protein receptor
30 that stimulates the mobilization of lipids from white fat cells and increases thermogenesis in brown fat cells
31. The tryptophan-to-arginine substitution at codon 64 of
ADRB3 was initially reported in 1995
13,15,24. The substitution is located in the first coding exon, at the junction of the first transmembrain domain and the first intracellular loop of the receptor
32,33. The impact of the missense change is not known; it has been suggested that the substitution could impact receptor protein folding or alter functional properties such as ligand binding or receptor activation
32. The biochemical evidence that the substitution impairs receptor signaling is mixed. In vitro studies suggest the substitution does not impact ADRB3 receptor expression, its ability to bind andrenergic agonists, or its activation in response to selective or non-selective agonists
32. However, several studies found the maximal activation potential of cyclic AMP in Arg variant cells was reduced, suggesting the substitution may alter the receptor's ability to interact with G protein
31–33. In clinical studies, a significant reduction in receptor sensitivity to a beta3-agonist was found in adipocytes of Arg carriers
34, whereas two studies observed no association with basal metabolic rate
35,36.
The
ADRB3 receptor is more abundant and active in visceral adipose tissue than subcutaneous adipose
11,37–39. The high expression and activity of
ADRB3 in visceral adipose tissue is consistent with our observed association between the
ADRB3 variant and visceral, but not subcutaneous fat. Findings from a previous study of Japanese women
40 also indicated a significant association between the
ADRB3 Trp64Arg substitution and visceral abdominal fat. In our African American cases, the positive association between
ADRB3 and obesity was found for the wildtype receptor, and in Japanese women, the association was found for the variant. A third study (Quebec Family Study) found no association present between the missense change and abdominal visceral fat
36.
We found the association of
ADRB3 and measures of obesity to be stronger among premenopausal than postmenopausal women. Pasquali et al. also found an association of the
ADRB3 gene and weight among pre-menopausal women, but not postmenopausal women
41. Whereas, a study by McFarlane-Anderson et al.
29 found a strong association between
ADRB3 and BMI among both pre- and postmenopausal women. The presence of a stronger association between the
ADRB3 missense change and obesity in premenopausal women may be explained by the fact that the expression of
ADRB3 is age-dependent and expression has been shown to decrease with age
11. Studies also have found postmenopausal women to have significantly higher BMI
41 and significantly less fat-free mass
41–43 than premenopausal women while others have reported the odds of being obese was similar for pre- and postmenopausal women
44.
In our sample of breast cancer cases, the association of
ADRB3 and obesity was strongest among women with a history of chemotherapy. Higher chemotherapy associated weight gain among breast cancer cases has been reported by HEAL investigators using data from the Washington and New Mexico sites
17,18. Previous studies also have found that women experience increasing levels of fat mass, percent body fat
45, and body weight
35,46,47 following adjuvant chemotherapy. This increase appears to occur shortly after diagnosis, typically within the first year and includes a larger increase in fat mass than weight gain associated with normal aging. This sarcopenic weight gain is believed to be due, at least in part, to decreased physical activity and possibly to metabolic changes
17. One possible explanation is lower activity during the first year of diagnosis due to nausea and fatigue following therapy. This difference was not observed in our sample of African American breast cancer cases, as women who were treated with chemotherapy reported similar levels of moderate and vigorous physical activity (Mean MET hours chemo = 20.7; Mean MET hours no chemo = 19.9) at the 24-month follow-up interview as women who did not take chemotherapy. We did not collect physical activity history at the time of diagnosis and treatment, so it remains possible that women with chemotherapy gained weight due to lower activity at the time of their treatment.
Physical activity has been shown to impact levels of visceral, subcutaneous, and total body fat
48–50. Accumulation of visceral fat, more so than accumulation in other parts of the body, has been of clinical concern because of its potential contribution to risk of chronic conditions including diabetes, hyperinsulinemia, and hypertension
51 and to risk of postmenopausal breast cancer due to the production of estrogens in adipose tissue. There is growing evidence that physical activity can decrease the risk of breast cancer
52–54 and suggestive evidence that physical activity after breast cancer diagnosis may improve survival
55. In the current analysis, we found the association between the
ADRB3 Trp genotype and obesity to be highest among sedentary women. Our finding that physical activity modifies the effect of
ADRB3 on obesity is supported by data from the study of Spanish participants
56 where risk of obesity was higher among carriers of the
ADRB3 variant when restricted to sedentary people. Together, these data suggest that the association between the
ADRB3 gene and obesity may be altered by moderate levels of physical activity. While we were able to detect an association between
ADRB3 and measures of weight among HEAL African-American breast cancer cases, these results may not be generalizable to other racial/ethnic groups. The associations for our African-American set of cases and two other African-American populations
27,28 were found with the wildtype allele, whereas the
ADRB3-weight association in white and Japanese populations has been described with the variant allele. While some experimental studies suggest that carriers of the Arg variant may have reduced fat metabolism, the functional role of the missense is not yet established, nor do we know how lifestyle or other lipid metabolism pathway genes influence the ADRB3-weight association. Further, nearly 46% of our population was obese, which may represent a group of individuals prone to weight gain due to genetic background or other individual characteristics. Another limitation of our study is that we collected weight at 24-months post diagnosis and at various ages prior to diagnosis (e.g. 5 years prior to diagnosis, age 35, age 18), but we did not measure weight or physical activity at the time of diagnosis so we could not examine changes from the time of diagnosis to the 24-month follow-up interview.