In humans, mutations in the Norrie Disease Protein
) are responsible for Norrie Disease (ND), a severe X-linked retinal vascular disease (Berger and Ropers, 2001
). The Ndp
gene codes for a small secreted protein, Norrin, that is highly conserved among vertebrates. Frizzled-4 (Fz4), the Norrin receptor, is the only Frizzled family member that binds to Norrin with high-affinity (Smallwood et al., 2007
), and in conjunction with a co-receptor, Lrp5 or Lrp6, and a an associated integral memebrane protein, Tspan12, this interaction potently activates canonical Wnt signaling (Xu et al., 2004
; Junge et al., 2009
; Ye et al., 2009
). Norrin/Fz4/Lrp/Tspan12 signaling in endothelial cells plays a central role in retinal vascular development, and partial or complete loss of any of these signaling components in humans or mice results in retinal hypovascularization, which typically leads to retinal damage and vision loss (Richter et al., 1998
; Xu et al., 2004
; Luhman et al., 2005; Ye et al., 2009
). In mice, loss of Norrin or Fz4 also leads to progressive loss of the stria vascularis in the inner ear, accompanied by progressive hearing loss (Wang et al., 2001
; Rehm et al., 2002
; Xu et al., 2004
); in humans, over one third of ND patients develop progressive sensorineural hearing loss (Berger and Ropers, 2001
). In addition, ~50% of ND patients are mentally retarded (Berger and Ropers, 2001
), indicating a function for Norrin beyond the eye and ear.
Previous attempt to analyze Ndp
expression in the mouse by in situ
hybridization were hampered by poor cellular resolution and low sensitivity (Hartzer et al., 1999
). We have recently generated a human placental alkaline phosphatase (AP) reporter knock-in allele, NdpAP
, at the Ndp
locus for the purpose of analyzing Ndp
expression histochemically (see of Ye et al., 2009
). AP is a GPI-anchored plasma membrane protein that can be localized with a highly sensitive histochemical reaction, facilitating the visualization of cell morphologies in a variety of contexts (e.g., Badea et al., 2003
). In the Ndp
knock-in allele, the AP coding region and 3′ UTR were inserted 84 bp 5′ of the Ndp
initiator methionine codon without deleting any chromosomal sequences in or around the Ndp
gene. The Ndp
coding region starts in the second exon, which is separated by a 16.5 kb intron from the first exon and the adjacent promotor sequences. The frt
-flanked phosphoglycerate kinase promotor-Neo
used for drug selection in embryonic stem cells was subsequently removed by in vivo
Flp-mediated recombination. We assume that the insertion of ~2 kb of AP and 3′ UTR sequences 16.5 kb from the Ndp
promotor has little or no effect on Ndp
gene transcription. Here we use the NdpAP
reporter mouse to systematically analyze the spatial and temporal pattern of Ndp
expression in the developing and adult nervous system.
NdpAP expression in the developing retina.
1.1 Ndp expression in the developing retina
Previously, we reported that at all postnatal ages the NdpAP
gene is expressed by Müller glia, the radial glia that span the full width of the retina (Ye et al., 2009
). This identification was facilitated by the availability of NdpAP/+
females, in which tissue mosaicism generated by X-chromosome inactivation provides information on cell morphology in the form of spatial contrast between AP-expressing and AP-non-expressing cells. Müller glia-derived Norrin activates the Fz4 receptor on both endothelial cells and mural cells and promotes retinal vascular proliferation, maturation, and stabilization. It is interesting to note that in mice most Müller glia are born postnatally (Young, 1985a
; Young, 1985b
), and the timing of Müller cell differentiation closely matches that of retinal vascularization.
To further analyze Ndp
expression in the developing retina, we followed NdpAP
expression from embryonic day (E) 10.5 to postnatal day (P) 3 by AP histochemistry (). At E10.5, no expression is detected in the retina, but the mesenchyme surrounding the optic stalk is AP positive (). By E15.5, NdpAP
expression is seen in the retina at the optic disc, and this pattern is maintained until P0 (). From P0 to P3, with the birth of Müller glia, NdpAP
expression rapidly increases throughout the retina, without any detectable spatial gradient (). By P3, the retinas of hemizygous NdpAP/Y
males are homogeneously AP positive, indicating that the adult-like expression pattern has been established (). The pan-retinal AP staining that is apparent at P1 () is reminiscent of the appearance of the Muller cell marker SLC1A3 (the glutamate transporter GLAST), suggesting that by this age many Muller glia are already expressing markers indicative of the fully differentiated state (Vazquez-Chona et al., 2009
During retinal vascular development, the growing vascular plexus spreads centrifugally along the vitreal surface of the retina. This centrifugal expansion is driven, at least in part, by a VEGF gradient produced by a network of astrocytes that grows on the vitreal face of the retina ahead of the vascular plexus (Chan-Ling et al., 1995
; Gerhardt et al., 2003
). The lack of a Norrin gradient in the developing retina, indicates that Norrin-induced retinal vascular growth does not require a spatial concentration gradient. This is in contrast to some Wnt-mediated processes in the Drosophila
embryo and wing, where different positions along a Wingless concentration gradient are associated with different developmental responses (van den Heuvel et al., 1993
; Cadigan, 2002
). The lack of an Ndp
expression gradient across the retina is consistent with previous work showing that an Ndp
transgene controlled by a lens specific promoter fully rescues the retinal vascular defect of Ndp
mutant mice, presumably by uniformly bathing the retina in lens-derived Norrin (Ohlmann et al., 2005
). These data are consistent with a model in which Norrin regulates the competence of retinal endothelial cells but does not function as a directional guidance cue.
1.2 Ndp expression in the neural tube and brain
At E10.5, NdpAP
expression is observed in the hindbrain and throughout the neural tube (). Cross sections of NdpAP/Y
embryos show that NdpAP
expression in the spinal cord and hindbrain is restricted to the dorsal and mid-dorsal regions of the neuroepithelium, respectively. This pattern is similar to the Ndp
expression pattern observed during chick embryonic development, as determined by in situ
hybridization (Paxton et al., 2010
). The conservation of the embryonic Ndp
expression pattern, as well as the Norrin amino acid sequence, between mammals and birds suggests a conserved and still unknown function for Norrin in early vertebrate development.
NdpAP is expressed in discrete regions of the central nervous sytem at E10.5.
Interestingly, canonical Wnt signaling has recently been identified as an important regulator of CNS angiogenesis, with Wnt7a and Wnt7b redundantly controlling vascularization of the ventral neural tube (Daneman et al., 2009
; Stenman et al., 2008
). Consistent with that function, both Wnt7a and Wnt7b are expressed by the ventral neuroepithelium. Canonical Wnt signaling is also required in endothelial cells for vascularization of the dorsal neural tube, although the identities of the dorsal ligand(s) and the relevant receptor(s) are unknown (Daneman et al., 2009
; Stenman et al., 2008
). As no single receptor or single ligand knockout mouse mutant has been reported to exhibit an angiogenesis defect in the dorsal neural tube, there could be functional redundancy at both the ligand and the receptor levels. The expression of Ndp
at this time and location, as well as the ability of Norrin/Fz4/Lrp/Tspan12 to activate canonical Wnt signaling and promote angiogenesis in the retina, favors them as candidates for regulating angiogenesis in the dorsal neural tube.
NdpAP expression is down-regulated in the spinal cord during late prenatal development, but during the same time NdpAP expression increases in the brain. At E10.5, a cluster of NdpAP-expressing cells is observed between the two lobes of the telencephalon, the site of the developing hypothalamus (). At E15.5, NdpAP expression is observed in several brain regions: the olfactory bulb and along the lateral olfactory tract, the inferior region of the subventricular zone of the lateral ventricles, the territories flanking the medial ganglionic eminence (MGE), the hypothalamus, the amygdala (the target of the lateral olfactory tract), a narrow transverse territory within the posterior thalamus, and the cerebellar primordium ().
NdpAP expression in the E15.5 mouse brain.
At P0, a faint AP signal is detected in scattered cells with diffuse processes throughout the forebrain and diencephalon of NdpAP/Y
mice (). In the mouse CNS, differentiation of astrocytes begins at this time (Mission et al., 1991
; Kriegstein and Alvarez-Buylla, 2009
). Since NdpAP
is expressed in astrocytes in the adult brain (described below), it seems likely that the diffuse AP staining seen at P0 represents the beginning of astrocyte expression. At P0, the AP signal remains in the lateral olfactory tract and the subventricular zone, the germinal center for neurons and glia in the postnatal brain.
NdpAP expression in the P1 mouse brain.
In the adult brain, NdpAP is widely expressed, with much of the brain - including the entire forebrain and diencephalon - of NdpAP/Y mice exhibiting intense and uniform staining. To more clearly visualize individual labeled cells, heterozygous female NdpAP/+ brains were AP stained (). This analysis revealed a relatively homogenous distribution of labeled cells with diffuse arbors, each occupying a ~50 um diameter spherical space - characteristics that match the morphology of astrocytes (). In the NdpAP/+ cortex, the AP-expressing cells show a subtle clustering into radial stripes, presumably reflecting radial migration from a subventricular zone that is mosaic for X-chromosome inactivation ().
NdpAP expression in adult mouse brain.
In the adult NdpAP/+
cerebellum, the AP signal is most intense in the molecular layer and is radially oriented; it is far less intense in the granule cell layer, the white matter, and the deep cerebellar nuclei (). This AP localization is consistent with a previous report of Ndp
expression in the Purkinje layer of the cerebellum by in situ
hybridization with radioactive probes, presumably reflecting hybridization to cell bodies of Purkinje neurons and/or Bergman glia (Hartzer et al., 1999
). Whereas both cell types extend a highly complex arbor radially into the molecular layer (Bellamy, 2006
), only Purkinje cells extend processes beyond this layer, with each Purkinje cell also projecting an axon across the granule cell layer and white matter to the deep cerebellar nuclei. In previous studies, histochemical detection of the same AP reporter was observed to label all classes of neurites, including axons (Badea et al., 2003
). Therefore, the absence of AP-positive axons traversing the molecular layer and white matter in the NdpAP/+
cerebellum implies that NdpAP
expression is confined to Bergman glia.
1.3 Ndp expression in the inner ear
Norrin/Fz4 signaling is required for the maintenance of the stria vascularis in the inner ear, but the initial development of this vasculature is unaffected by loss of either Norrin or Fz4 (Rehm et al., 2002
; Xu et al., 2004
). The stria vascularis produces the endolymph within the scala media, and capillary loss in the stria vascularis is presumably the cause of progressive hearing loss in mice and humans with Ndp
mutations. To identify the source of Norrin in the inner ear, we analyzed NdpAP
expression in P2 and adult inner ears (). At P2, NdpAP
is expressed in a highly vascularized zone between the organ of Corti and the spiral ganglion () and in the lateral wall adjacent to the stria vascularis (). In , the vasculature is decorated with fluorescent GS lectin, but the fluorescence is partially quenched by the purple AP histochemical reaction product. The P2 expression pattern is maintained essentially unchanged in the adult cochlea, consistent with the requirement for ongoing Norrin/Fz4 signaling for vascular maintenance ().
NdpAP expression in the postnatal mouse cochlea.
1.4 Functional implications of the Ndp expressino pattern
The expression data presented here define the pre-natal, peri-natal, and adult patterns of Ndp
expression in the mammalian CNS, and they complement and extend the Ndp
expression patterns described recently in the early embryonic chicken CNS (Paxton et al., 2010
). Taken together, the precisely defined territories in which Norrin is expressed in the developing CNS, the widespread expression of Norrin in glia in the adult CNS, and the expression of the Norrin receptor (Fz4) in essentially the entire vasculature from midgestation to adulthood, suggest the possibility that Norrin may have developmental and/or homeostasic functions beyond those identified thus far in the eye and ear.