Subendothelial matrix VWF and immobilized plasma-derived VWF
Among the substrates required for thrombus formation, VWF is thought to be unique for its role in initiating platelet adhesion and sustaining platelet aggregation under conditions of elevated shear stress [
36,
38]. These functions are carried out primarily trough the tethering of GP Ibα in the platelet membrane GP Ib-IX-V receptor complex [
91] to the A1 domain of immobilized VWF exposed to flowing blood. As a constitutive component of the ECM of endothelial cells [
92], in which it is associated with collagen type VI filaments [
93,
94], subendothelial VWF can directly support platelet adhesion [
95–
98]. Nonetheless, hemostasis can be normal in the absence of endogenous endothelial VWF if plasma VWF is present. The relative contribution of these two forms of VWF to platelet adhesion was elucidated by studies on the transplant of normal pig bone marrow into pigs affected by severe von Willebrand disease, characterized by a complete deficiency of VWF [
99]. As expected, the procedure could not correct the endothelial cell defect, thus there continued to be no VWF secretion into blood or subendothelial matrix while the VWF content in platelet α-granules was normalized. This was not sufficient to restore a normal hemostasis, although some transplanted animals showed a partial amelioration of the prolonged bleeding time. The latter finding is in agreement with the concept that α-granule-derived VWF, released after activation, can contribute to thrombus growth but not to the initial platelet adhesion occurring before activation [
100]. In contrast, hemostasis was completely normal in the transplanted pigs after infusion of normal plasma VWF. The prolonged bleeding time of pigs with severe von Willebrand disease was also normalized by transfusion of VWF concentrates alone, even though their platelet VWF remained absent, but a considerably higher dose was required than in transplanted pigs with normal platelet VWF [
101]. These results prove that plasma VWF can initiate platelet adhesion after binding to the vessel wall in the absence of matrix VWF and support subsequent thrombus growth with the contribution of platelet-released VWF, even though the latter is not strictly essential. Consequently, the interaction of circulating VWF with exposed vascular and perivascular tissues is a key early event in thrombus formation.
The transition from soluble to immobilized VWF
Plasma VWF can become immobilized onto subendothelial surfaces through the binding to ECM components and through self-association with other VWF multimers. The main substrate capable of binding VWF is collagen, particularly types I and III present in deeper layers of the vessel wall and microfibrillar collagen type VI in the subendothelial matrix. VWF-A1, comprising residues 497–716 of the mature subunit (add 763 to obtain the corresponding residue number in pre-pro-VWF) [
102], was initially shown to interact with collagen types I and III [
103], but its main role may be binding to collagen type VI [
104,
105]. The latter contains VWF type A domains in its non-collagenous regions [
106] that may become engaged in homotypic interactions with VWF-A1. The VWF A3 domain (VWF-A3), comprising residues 910–1111, also binds to collagen types I and III, and is apparently necessary and sufficient to mediate the interaction with fibrillar collagens [
36,
107]. The VWF-A3 residues involved in collagen binding have been mapped [
108,
109], and a high affinity binding site for VWF has been identified in collagen type III [
110]. Fluid dynamic conditions and mechanical forces may modulate the VWF-collagen interaction, and the interplay of domains A1 and A3 may be necessary to support VWF immobilization onto extracellular matrices containing various collagen types [
105,
111]. Of note, VWF multimer size directly correlates with the affinity for collagen binding [
112].
Contrasting the information on the role played by VWF-A3 in the interaction with fibrillar collagens
in vitro, supported by the demonstrated anti-thrombotic activity of a function-blocking anti-VWF A3 antibody [
113], stands the evidence that mutations preventing collagen binding (such as Ser968Thr) are compatible with normal hemostasis
in vivo [
114,
115]. It appears, therefore, that different VWF domains can ensure the interaction with collagen in ECM, possibly depending on the nature of a lesion, and/or extracellular substrates other than collagen can support VWF in initiating platelet adhesion. In favor of the first hypothesis, evidence has been obtained that collagen type VI may play an important role in VWF binding by interacting with the A1 domain [
94]. Moreover, particularly under flow conditions, VWF-A1 can substitute for VWF-A3 in supporting binding to collagen, in which the sites interacting with the two domains appear to be overlapping [
111]. Concerning the second hypothesis, it is known that VWF can interact with ECM components independently of collagen. The A1 domain contains a heparin-binding site [
116,
117] that has been localized to the sequence Tyr565-Ala587 [
118]. A second, lower affinity heparin-binding sequence exists within the first 272 residues of the mature VWF subunit [
119].
28 These heparin-binding sites may reflect the ability to interact with matrix proteoglycans that contain sulfated carbohydrates. For example, the small proteoglycan decorin, which associates with several matrix components and contributes to matrix assembly, has been reported to bind VWF in an interaction mediated by the glycosaminoglycan chain and regulated by the degree of sulfation [
120]. In addition, VWF binds to sulfated glycosphingolipids (sulfatides) [
121] that are present on cellular membranes and may serve an accessory role in promoting localization on wounded tissues. The binding site for sulfatides has been localized within A1 domain residues 512–673, possibly with a more direct involvement of residues 569–584 [
122] and/or 626–646 [
123]. Sulfatides can inhibit platelet adhesion to VWF mediated by GP Ibα, suggesting an overlap of interacting sites [
124]. Because VWF is multimeric, sulfatides may mediate binding to surfaces and still allow platelet adhesion to different A1 domains in the same immobilized polymer, and the same may be true for heparin bound to the A1 domain [
125]. Another pathway to VWF immobilization may be through interaction with a forming clot. Thus, the cross-linking of VWF to the α-chain of fibrin [
126,
127] can contribute to platelet deposition onto altered vascular surfaces, and this may become a relevant adhesion mechanism in areas where acute or chronic inflammation causes fibrin formation.
The ability to self-associate on a surface represents an additional mechanism supporting the transition from soluble to immobilized VWF, in which case circulating multimers interact with matrix-bound and endogenous subendothelial VWF [
128]. This mechanism was demonstrated by immobilizing a mutant VWF devoid of domain A1 (ΔA1-VWF), thus unable to promote platelet adhesion, onto collagen and showing that GP Ibα-mediated tethering was restored by the presence of soluble VWF in plasma (). As reported, this phenomenon is fully reversible. Very large VWF multimers locally released by stimulated endothelial cells [
129]
42may enhance the efficiency of the process, as these molecules form high strength bonds with GP Ibα [
130]. Self-association of VWF multimers can occur onto the platelet surface [
131] under conditions of hydrodynamic shear that favor the binding of soluble VWF [
132]. The self-association of VWF apparently involves multiple domains [
133] and none has been identified as essential, including A1 and A3 [
128].
A distinct form of self-association may involve thiol-disulfide exchange. In this mechanism, as recently reported, surface-exposed free thiols present in at least some circulating VWF multimers can form new disulfide bonds under the effect of shear stress >50–100 dynes/cm
2, and the resulting increase in VWF multimer size may support enhanced binding to platelets [
134]. This process of self-association apparently applies to VWF multimers in solution, i.e. precedes immobilization onto a surface, but a similar mechanism involving free thiol groups has been shown to support the elongation of ultralarge VWF strings released from endothelial cells. In this case, VWF strings on the endothelial surface, i.e. immobilized, increase in size through the covalent association of plasma VWF multimers that are recruited from solution [
135]. Of note, inter-subunit disulfide bonds formed during biosynthesis inside the cell are the foundation of the polymeric VWF structure. The reported findings, which need to be confirmed, indicate that disulfide exchange involving VWF multimers may continue after secretion of the molecule into blood and potentially represent a relevant mechanism regulating adhesive functions dependent on platelet binding. One obvious question posed by these experiments concerns the possibility that shear-induced enhancement of VWF adhesive functions could be irreversible, a conclusion that apparently conflicts with the evidence that shear-induced VWF-mediated platelet aggregation is largely reversible if shear stress decreases before platelet activation takes place.
In summary, the available evidence suggests that different types of injury may elicit distinct pathways for the local immobilization of soluble VWF. As a consequence, for example, VWF binding to collagen may not be essential to ensure normal hemostasis, but may be a primary determinant of the pathological thrombogenic response caused by the rupture of collagen-rich atherosclerotic plaques. From an experimental point of view, it is difficult to recreate such a functional diversity using purified molecules, which can explain some of the inconsistencies found in the literature with respect to the mechanisms of VWF binding to vascular surfaces.
The distinctive functional properties of immobilized and soluble VWF
Platelets have no measurable interaction with circulating VWF in solution, but adhere to immobilized VWF. Such a regulation prevents intravascular platelet aggregation, and has led to the concept that the interaction with GP Ibα depends on a conformational change in surface-bound VWF. Indeed, VWF molecules may change shape depending on hemodynamic conditions, so that upon binding to the vessel wall under high shear stress they appear as elongated filaments rather than the loosely coiled structures seen under static or low shear stress conditions [
136]. Uncoiling may expose the repeating functional sites present in multimeric VWF, allowing a more efficient multivalent binding to platelets. Three-dimensional structural studies [
137] have shown that more subtle conformational changes can occur in the GP Ibα-binding VWF A1 domain as a result of amino acid substitutions, such as those causing type 2B von Willebrand disease [
138], which overcome the affinity barrier for soluble VWF binding to platelets. These findings indicate that conformation can influence the interaction between VWF-A1 and GP Ibα, but they provide no evidence that conformational changes occur as a result of the transition from soluble to surface-immobilized VWF. Studies with a specific “nanobody” [
139] support the concept of a common “active” conformation in the VWF A1 domain of surface-bound multimers, soluble ultralarge multimers released by endothelial cells and mutant type 2B plasma VWF, in contrast to the “inactive” conformation of normal plasma VWF. In fact, the “nanobody” binds preferentially to the A1 domain of VWF species with enhanced affinity for GP Ibα, indicating that they may share the same conformation. It remains to be determined whether such a conformation is dynamically transient or reflects one of the known crystallized structures seen in the VWF-A1 complex with GP Ibα [
140,
141]. A particularly relevant “active” form of soluble VWF is represented by the ultralarge multimers released from the storage granules of stimulated endothelial cells and platelets [
142,
143]. Ultralarge VWF multimers function locally, but under normal conditions they do not accumulate in circulating blood [
144] because they are processed by a specific protease, ADAMTS-13 (ADAMTS:
A Disintegrin
And
Metalloproteinase with a TromboSpondin type 1 motif) [
145].
ADAMTS-13 and the regulation of VWF-mediated platelet adhesion and aggregation
VWF released by endothelial cells and/or activated platelets at sites of vascular injury promotes both platelet adhesion and aggregation, particularly under high shear stress conditions, thus exerting a potent prothrombotic effect. The largest, most active VWF multimers are present inside cellular storage granules but are not normally found in the circulation. The reason for this is the efficient processing of all secreted VWF by the metalloprotease, ADAMTS-13, which cleaves one single peptide bond in the VWF subunit [
146] and in so doing reduces multimer size [
147]. Absence of ADAMTS-13 results in a thrombotic microangiopathy [
148], suggesting that the physiologic function of the protease is to limit the activity of the most active VWF multimers to the sites where they are released from cells. Recently, the results of
ex vivo perfusion experiments have added to this concept by showing that ADAMTS-13 can further cleave circulating VWF multimers while they mediate activation-independent inter-platelet cohesion induced by elevated shear stress, resulting in a time-dependent dispersion of the aggregates [
149]. In contrast, the protease appeared to have no effect, at least under the
ex vivo conditions studied, when thrombus formation was induced by blood exposure to a collagen surface.
The latter finding stands in apparent contradiction with the results of
in vivo studies in mouse thrombosis models, which have shown the ability of recombinant ADAMTS-13 to dissolve experimentally-induced thrombi in the arteriolar circulation leading to the conclusion that the protease could be used as an antithrombotic agent [
150]. While the effect of ADAMTS-13 on microarteriolar thrombi is in agreement with the phenotype caused by its deficiency, i.e. microarteriolar thrombosis, the situation may be different in larger arteries. In this case, the antithrombotic activity of ADAMTS-13 may depend on the extent to which adhesive molecules such as fibrinogen and fibronectin, rather than VWF, contribute to platelet aggregation. Thus, the antithrombotic activity of ADAMTS-13 may be selective for platelet aggregation under high shear stress conditions in which VWF is important for platelet cohesion [
151]. During hemostasis, ADAMTS-13 activity may be needed to avoid the propagation of platelet aggregates beyond the limits of a vascular wound, which typically involves the microarteriolar circulation with rapidly flowing blood. It remains to be demonstrated whether ADAMTS-13 may limit the potential role of VWF in mediating the occlusion of stenotic arteries where pathologically elevated shear rates develop. In this regard, it is intriguing to observe that a recent study found a positive correlation between ADAMTS-13 levels and the risk of myocardial infarction in men [
152], a finding that is in apparent contrast with the suggestion that ADAMTS-13 may act as an anti-thrombotic agent. The mechanism through which increased ADAMTS-13 levels and/or activity might constitute a risk for arterial thrombosis remains to be understood.
Membrane receptors and the mechanism of platelet tethering to VWF
Platelets have two main binding sites for VWF [
153,
154], GP Ibα in the GP Ib-IX-V complex [
91] and the integrin αIIbβ3 [
155], which recognizes the ligand Arg-Gly-Asp (RGD) sequence. A second β3 integrin, αvβ3, albeit present at much lower density than αIIbβ3 [
156], may contribute to VWF binding, a function shown on endothelial cells [
157]. Both platelet receptors for VWF are promiscuous and bind several ligands that may mediate adhesion to other platelets and cells. In particular, the GP Ib-IX-V complex is a counter-receptor for P-selectin [
158] and for the leukocyte integrin Mac-1 (α2βM) [
159], supporting two interactions that may contribute more to inflammatory responses than to platelet thrombus formation. The integrin αIIbβ3, on the other hand, binds several ligands, in addition to VWF, that are key to the process of platelet adhesion and aggregation, primarily fibrinogen [
160], fibronectin [
67] and CD40 ligand [
161].
The distinguishing feature of the interaction between GP Ibα and VWF-A1 is the ability to support activation-independent platelet tethering to thrombogenic surfaces even when the velocity of blood is elevated. The bond has a fast dissociation rate and, for this property, it is considered selectin-like [
162]. Also akin to selectin-mediated bonds [
163], recent studies have shown that increasing tensile stress prolongs the lifetime of the interaction between VWF-A1 and GP Ibα when force is relatively small but shortens it above a certain threshold, indicating a shear dependent transition from the properties of a “catch” bond to those of a “slip” bond [
164]. A catch bond requires a high shear stress to achieve functionally efficient lifetimes, and such a property could prevent VWF-A1 from interacting with platelets in the circulation. Intuitively, when a molecule in solution interacts with a membrane receptor on a flowing cell, the resulting bond is unlikely to be subjected to significant tensile stress as long as the bound ligand flows with the cell, thus a catch bond would not achieve a significant lifetime. Of interest, VWF-A1 containing type 2B mutations does not appear to form catch bonds with GP Ib, rather it forms typical slip bonds with relatively long bond lifetimes even when exposed to low shear stress [
164]. Such a functional property is consistent with the significantly slower rolling velocity of platelets interacting with immobilized type 2B VWF-A1 [
137], and can explain the ability of soluble type 2B VWF to induce platelet agglutination in circulating blood [
165]. In fact, the lifetime of the bond between type 2B VWF-A1 and GP Ib on circulating platelets may be sufficient to mediate efficient adhesion even without exposure to a minimum level of tensile stress [
164]. Recent results of molecular dynamics simulation have suggested a structural basis to explain how flow-induced conformational changes in GP Ibα, in addition to the intrinsic properties of VWF-A1 discussed above, can contribute to the functional modulation as well as enhanced adhesive properties of the GP Ib/VWF-A1 adhesive bond under increasing shear stress [
166].
Under most circumstances, platelets tethered to the vessel wall solely through VWF-GP Ibα move slowly in the direction of flow and, until recently, it was thought that this interaction by itself cannot support irreversible adhesion [
38]. Initial transient interactions between platelets and reactive surfaces my be essential for allowing a modulated response to injury, as commitment to irreversible adhesion after each initial contact could have adverse consequences, including tissue damage. In inflamed tissues, this function may mediate platelet contact with stimulated endothelial cells [
167], a surface onto which the only adhesive substrates may be membrane-bound VWF and P-selectin, which also mediates cell adhesion and rolling [
168]. The presence of additional structures signifying a serious lesion may be the required trigger for subsequent steps such as irreversible platelet adhesion and accumulation. The GP Ibα-mediated translocation velocity onto immobilized VWF is typically less than 2% of the free flow velocity of non-interacting platelets at the same distance from the luminal surface. This slow motion allows the establishment of additional bonds through receptors that belong mostly, but not necessarily, to the integrin superfamily. Such receptors, many of which depend on platelet activation to express function, typically have an intrinsically slower rate of bond formation but are capable of mediating stable interactions that lead to the definitive arrest of individual platelets and subsequent thrombus development. Notable in this regard is the role of the activated integrin αIIbβ3 and of collagen receptors. When VWF is bound to collagen, the transition from rolling to stable adhesion occurs more rapidly than on immobilized VWF alone and thrombus development occurs at higher shear rates than on collagen without VWF [
36]. Such considerations highlight the true synergistic function of the VWF-collagen complex.
An integrated view of VWF-mediated platelet adhesion and aggregation
The concept that the VWF-GP Ibα interaction cannot support long-lasting adhesion must be modified in view of the recently demonstrated ability of non-activated platelets to form aggregates that attach firmly to immobilized VWF under extremely high shear stress conditions () [
169]. Several unique features characterize this mechanism of platelet adhesion to extracellular surfaces and to one another, marking substantial differences with the process of single platelet rolling. Perhaps the most relevant distinction is that GP Ibα-mediated long-lasting adhesion and aggregation only occur above a threshold shear rate of ~10,000 s
−1, a feature that highlights its potential importance for pathological arterial thrombosis. Platelets that become firmly adherent to the surface are stretched considerably in the direction of flow, but whether this morphological change is the cause or consequence of adhesion under elevated shear stress remains to be established [
169]. Of note, a 3-D multi-scale computational model has been used to calculate the shear rate threshold required for measurable VWF-mediated platelet aggregation [
170,
171], and the zero efficiency of binding predicted for shear rates <8000 s
−1 is in remarkable agreement with experimental findings obtained independently [
169]. It is also noteworthy that, at the levels of shear stress required for VWF-mediated and activation-independent platelet aggregation (>400 dyne/cm
2 wall shear stress), the bond between VWF-A1 and GP Ibα exhibits the properties of a slip bond (the transition from catch to slip bond occurring at 10–20 dyne/cm
2 wall shear stress; see reference [
164]), thus should become less efficient with increasing shear stress. Experimental evidence is in contrast with such a conclusion [
169], indicating that mechanisms not directly dependent on the intrinsic biomechanical properties of single bonds (for example, regulation of the number of bonds formed) may play a key role in VWF and GP Ib-mediated platelet adhesion/aggregation. A second key distinction is that platelet adhesion and aggregation at pathologically elevated shear rates depends on soluble as well as surface-bound VWF, while single platelet adhesion and rolling require only immobilized VWF [
169]. A third and equally relevant feature is that GP Ibα-mediated and VWF-dependent firm platelet adhesion and aggregation occur without any requirement for platelet activation and integrin function. Such a statement should not be taken to indicate that activation has no influence on platelet thrombus formation at pathologically elevated shear rates, as it remains essential for the stability of aggregates [
13]. It is intuitive, however, that the ability of platelets to aggregate onto surfaces even before activation greatly favors the establishment of growing thrombi in a high shear rate environment, in which elevated tensile stress limits the efficiency of adhesive bonds and rapid flow reduces the concentration of agonists required for activation. Under challenging hydrodynamic conditions, therefore, platelet interactions with adhesive surfaces and with one another appear to be synergistic. Of note, ADAMTS-13 can cleave circulating VWF multimers while they mediate activation-independent inter-platelet cohesion under high shear stress, thus dispersing the aggregates [
149].