This study used 1H-MRS to non-invasively measure lipid accretion in both liver and skeletal muscle in a large multi-ethnic cohort of healthy, exclusively prepubertal children, 7–9 years of age. These findings establish for the first time that many of the relations between ectopic fat and markers of the metabolic syndrome observed in adults are also present in healthy, young, non-diabetic children. Most noteworthy, we found that lipid accretion in liver and skeletal muscle is associated with fasting insulin and insulin resistance measured by HOMA. The relation between ectopic fat accumulation and insulin resistance, however, appears to be driven by increased total body and central adiposity. Our results suggest that excess adiposity (rather than maturation or puberty) promotes accumulation of lipid in liver and skeletal muscle, and that ectopic fat accumulation in both tissues may be important in the early pathogenesis of insulin resistance. To unravel the sequence of these complex mechanisms, including the inter-relation between abdominal fat, liver lipid accretion and insulin resistance, longitudinal studies in developing children are needed to delineate the time course of lipid accumulation in liver and within skeletal muscle in relation to insulin resistance.
The relation between total and abdominal adiposity and ectopic fat accumulation within skeletal muscle and liver in adults [
5,
8,
12] and within skeletal muscle in children [
19] and adolescents [
11] has previously been reported. The present study extends these findings to healthy, multi-ethnic, exclusively prepubertal children, and demonstrates that ectopic fat accumulation in both liver and skeletal muscle is greater in those children with increased adiposity. Liver lipid stores, in particular, were strongly correlated with total body and abdominal visceral fat independent of sex and race. This association between IHL and total, but not necessarily visceral, abdominal fat is intriguing given that the majority of the abdominal fat deposition in these children was as SAT (91% of total) rather than VAT (9% of total; ). Visceral and deep subcutaneous stores along with liver fat have been associated with metabolic derangements including insulin resistance in several studies [
8,
12,
14,
25], but it has proven difficult to evaluate the independent effect of these depots. The tight association between liver fat and VAT is thought to be due to increased VAT-driven NEFA flux to the liver via portal circulation. Although we demonstrate similar relations in this cross-sectional study, longitudinal studies in prepubertal children will help resolve the inter-relations between these variables and determine which depot is initially most deleterious for insulin resistance and its associated metabolic complications.
A strong association between liver fat accumulation, or hepatic steatosis, and insulin resistance was previously identified in adults [
8,
12,
14], adolescents [
4,
11,
13] and obese prepubertal children [
17]. The current study is the first to report such ectopic lipid accumulation in an ethnically diverse cohort of healthy primarily non-obese (73.9%) children prior to puberty. The current findings are in support of a pilot study from our group using a clinical 1.5 T system [
18] and the autopsy studies by Schwimmer and colleagues [
15], which provided evidence that lipid can accumulate in liver at a young age. In the classic report of Schwimmer et al. [
15], for example, autopsies of 742 deceased children were used to identify prevalence of fatty liver, which was 9.6% in children 2–19 years of age and 3.3% in those 5–9 years old. Clinical studies in severely obese children [
16,
17] demonstrated that the prevalence of fatty liver or steatosis may be as high as 36–52% in obese paediatric patients, depending on Tanner stage and degree of obesity. The current study, which non-invasively measured IHL accumulation, extends previous findings and demonstrates that IHL accumulation in a multi-ethnic cohort of healthy, exclusively prepubertal children (range 0.11–4.6%; mean 0.83%) was similar to that found in healthy overweight, insulin sensitive adults (range 0.04–7.8%; mean 0.78%) using the same methodology (E. Ravussin, unpublished observations) and that a greater accumulation of IHL was associated with insulin resistance, independent of sex and race.
We also found an association between IMCL, but not EMCL, and both fasting insulin and insulin resistance, as we had hypothesised. These results agree with the majority of studies in adults [
5,
6,
9,
10], and adolescents [
7] and one study in prepubertal boys [
19]. This observation is of particular interest because our cohort, which was randomly recruited from South Louisiana, was comprised of predominantly non-obese male and female children with obesity prevalence rates slightly greater than reports in US youth [
26]. In addition, children with a Tanner stage≥2 were excluded from enrolment, as were children with first degree relatives with diabetes. Furthermore, the range of IMCL in the soleus (0.13–1.86%) was lower than previously found in adults (0.1–3.5%) (E. Ravussin, unpublished observations). In two previous studies in 7–10 year old boys [
19] and 11–15 year old adolescents [
7], elevated total body fat and central adiposity were accompanied by higher IMCL [
7,
19] and EMCL [
7] depots. Our results in this exclusively prepubertal, healthy cohort of male and female children support these findings and suggest that IMCL and EMCL accumulate as a function of increasing obesity. Although EMCL also accumulated in association with increased adiposity, only IMCL appeared to be an important marker of elevated fasting insulin and insulin resistance in prepubertal youth, as in adults [
9,
10]. It is important to mention, however, that EMCL data are difficult to interpret because of the inhomogeneous storage of EMCL and methodological error (i.e. EMCL is susceptible to bulk magnetic susceptibility during assessment by MRS) [
27].
A final noteworthy finding from our study was the strong relation between liver lipid accretion (and to some extent muscle lipid accretion) and components of the metabolic or insulin resistance syndrome [
24]. In adults, the metabolic syndrome is defined as a cluster of metabolic abnormalities that predispose an individual to increased risk of cardiovascular disease and type 2 diabetes [
28]. In children, especially prior to puberty, this definition is less clear. Using recent criteria specific to prepubertal youth, our study found that only six children (9.7%) were positively diagnosed with the metabolic syndrome [
23,
24]. We also found that elevated IHL was significantly correlated with several accepted characteristics of this metabolic cluster [
28] including increased waist circumference, elevated systolic blood pressure and elevated fasting triacylglycerol concentration; but not with low HDL-cholesterol concentration, elevated fasting glucose concentration and/or elevated diastolic blood pressure. In addition to the standard characteristics, increased IHL was associated with increased total and LDL-cholesterol concentrations. Associations between increased liver fat accretion and many of these and other markers were previously reported in adolescent and obese children including elevated waist circumference [
17], elevated waist-to-hip ratio [
16], elevated fasting insulin [
13] and triacylglycerol concentrations [
13,
16,
17], and depressed HDL concentration [
13,
16,
17], as well high normal to elevated liver enzyme concentrations [
16,
17]. Nevertheless, the clustering of IHL with components of metabolic syndrome in healthy, primarily non-obese children prior to puberty is of clinical interest and may be used to help better define and detect metabolic syndrome in children under 10 years of age [
20].
Overall the results of this study contribute to our understanding of the pathogenesis of insulin resistance in children before puberty. They suggest that increasing adiposity promotes ectopic fat accumulation in liver, but to a lesser degree in skeletal muscle, and that fat accumulation in liver and skeletal muscle are equally associated with insulin resistance. While these results imply that ectopic fat accumulation may be important in the early pathogenesis of insulin resistance, longitudinal studies are needed to help determine the cause and effect relationship for this association. However, our findings in this multi-ethnic cohort of healthy male and female children prior to puberty have significant clinical relevance, as interventions aimed at reducing adiposity have the potential to prevent or decrease ectopic fat accumulation and, thus, delay the onset of insulin resistance and the consequent risk for development of type 2 diabetes.